To be is to be contingent: nothing of which it can be said that "it is" can be alone and independent. But being is a member of paticca-samuppada as arising which contains ignorance. Being is only invertible by ignorance.

Destruction of ignorance destroys the illusion of being. When ignorance is no more, than consciousness no longer can attribute being (pahoti) at all. But that is not all for when consciousness is predicated of one who has no ignorance than it is no more indicatable (as it was indicated in M Sutta 22)

Nanamoli Thera

Friday, November 20, 2026

Rogue Messiahs

 In June 2001, Wilson turned seventy. It was a relatively quiet year for him in terms of publications. But Rogue Messiahs had come out the year before. It was called The Devil’s Party in the UK; the title was taken from William Blake’s remark about his fellow poet John Milton, who was “of the Devil’s party, without knowing it,” something Wilson believed was true of his false messiahs. The Mail on Sunday gave the book a thumbs-up, and even the Times Literary Supplement (TLS) took notice, although their review, while on the whole positive, did point out some editorial problems.

One of Wilson’s main themes in the book is that the downfall of many bogus spiritual leaders is sex; they tend to become obsessed with it as an expression of their dominance over their flock. The careers of Jim Jones (Jamestown massacre), David Koresh (Waco massacre), and even less-murderous characters such as Aleister Crowley make this clear. Noting this, the TLS reviewer pointed out that, although Wilson had written about “the occult, magic, and other esoteric themes,” the “world of sex and violence . . . has clearly engaged him most closely.”8 While acknowledging that Wilson “writes entertainingly”—“his large cast of misguided aspirants to Messianic status . . . preach, plot, quarrel, rage, rape, break every law, suffer and die . . . across his colourful pages”— the reviewer assures us that this is not in “any way an academic offering. . . . Sharper editing” could have pruned some repetition, and he could have relied less heavily on anecdote. There was also the standard reflection that because Wilson’s interests range “across diverse fields,” allowing for a wide perspective, there is also an unfortunate tendency toward digression.9

This tendency toward digression does make for an at times choppy read, a handicap the book shares with The Atlantis Blueprint. Before publication several chapters dealing with contemporary French philosophy, which are fascinating in themselves but seem out of context with the rest of the book, found their way to the cutting room floor. They were later resurrected in Below the Iceberg and are engaging evidence that Wilson kept abreast of developments such as structuralism, deconstructionism, and postmodernism. As we might expect, he was critical of all three. He takes especial argument with the work of Michel Foucault, Roland Barthes, and Jacques Derrida, some of the biggest names in postexistentialism France. Sartre had died in 1980, but had been out of fashion for some time. In an obituary for the Evening News, Wilson remarked that while Sartre’s death may seem an “out-of-date sort of catastrophe,” he was nonetheless “one of the most exciting and brilliant figures in twentieth century literature.”10The link between Foucault and a mad messiah such as David Koresh may not be immediately clear, but in the end Wilson found that Foucault—a homosexual who had a taste for dark eroticism, S&M, and “sex with the stranger”—was as much a charlatan as Koresh; he was an “intellectual con-man” out to deceive his readers.11 Barthes was a “depressive romantic” whose attempt to write literary criticism as if it were phenomenology displayed his “philosophical ineptitude.”12 Derrida’s rejection of meaning in any text—something he shares with the other two—was “ultimately sterile.”13 Wilson’s rejection of Derrida, and his warranted exasperation with the fact that he was considered one of the most important intellectuals of the age, comes through in a brief account of deconstructionism, written for his son Rowan’s literature course at Oxford, also included in Below the Iceberg. Rowan had found Derrida’s work “gobbledegook”—“understandably,” Wilson sympathized—so his father explained it to him in plain English.14 What Rowan’s literature professor may have thought of this is unknown.

Yet even without the digressions into French philosophical fashions, Rogue Messiahs seems to suffer from a lack of a solid center. Its main argument is that false messiahs and their followers are made for each other. The messiahs are members of the dominant 5 percent on the lookout for ways to express their dominance. Their followers are individuals looking for some meaning beyond the triviality of everydayness. The bad guru needs the adoration of his flock; unlike the dominant .005 percent, he still relies on other people to feed his self-esteem, and, as Wilson’s often gruesome pages show, in some cases he will go to murderous lengths to secure it. Multiple killings surrounding Shoko Asahara, leader of the Japanese cult Aum Shinrikyo (Supreme Truth), and Jeffrey Lundgren, leader of a breakaway cult from the Church of Latter Day Saints—to mention only two examples—provide gory evidence of this. The follower, on the other hand, is too lazy to work toward his own salvation, and in exchange for a life in which all problems vanish in light of the teaching, he gives up his freedom. The complete control over his followers’ lives exhibited by Jim Jones and their masochistic acceptance of it are sad evidence of the level to which a powerful need for belief and belonging can reduce someone.

Yet Wilson argues that in both cases, positive drives are at work; the problem is that they can easily become warped. The false messiah is in search of an identity; the masochistic believer has a powerful “will to believe,” in William James’s phrase. “Human beings need to believe,” Wilson writes, “because belief leads to action and human beings are born with a need to act. . . . Without purpose, human beings feel only half-alive.”15 The problem is that this hunger for purpose can lead to some very strange altars.

Not all the messiahs Wilson looks at were monsters. He writes of Rudolf Steiner’s rise to European fame after World War I, and of Krishnamurti’s refusal to be a theosophical world avatar and subsequent career as a nonteacher of a nonteaching. Freud, Jung, and the spiritual writer Paul Brunton make important appearances. But in our time, many charismatic but frustrated individuals adopt the mantle of guru in order to bolster a fragile self-esteem. Their need to impress others inevitably draws them into a whirlpool of indulgence and self-destruction. Very few messiahs avoid the paranoia that seems part of their bargain with the Devil.

Yet in trying to account for the often delusional psychology of many of his murderous messiahs, Wilson enters territory which, fascinating in itself—like the axed chapters on Foucault and Co.—again seems somehow out of place. In his attempt to understand the messiah’s need to “transform reality,” Wilson looks at some remarkable case studies of delusional psychosis. He tells the strange story of the “three Christs of Ypsilanti,” in which a psychiatrist tried to free three individuals of their shared delusion that they were Christ by bringing them together. Milton Rokeach, the psychiatrist in question, believed that the collision with two competitors would shake each Christ’s awareness so that they would recognize that they were, indeed, mad.

It didn’t work, for two reasons. Wilson argues that people withdraw into a psychotic other reality in the first place because they find this one—our everyday reality—too difficult to cope with. To them it is threatening and frightening; it undermines their self-esteem. They are often inadequate characters, and the necessities and demands placed on them prove too much. Rather than collapse in complete breakdown and recognize themselves as a failure, their unconscious mind provides them with an alternate reality, which, while cutting them off from our shared reality, ensures that they won’t fracture entirely. In a way it is a variant of the dictum of H. G. Wells’s Mr. Polly: “if you don’t like your life you can change it.” For the three Christs of Ypsilanti it was rather, “if you don’t like your reality you can change it.” Too weak to change their lives, they left them for another, more amenable world. They had no reason to leave it to return to the one they had left behind.

The other reason why Rokeach’s experiment failed is that the unconscious mind, responsible for the alternate reality, is incredibly powerful. We have already seen some evidence of this throughout this book. Wilson relates the strange story of “Kirk Allen and the jet-propelled couch.” Kirk Allen (a pseudonym) was an actual rocket scientist who had developed the habit of taking imaginary journeys to the Mars of Edgar Rice Burroughs’s John Carter novels. It was when his interplanetary hops began to affect his work that he was recognized as a borderline psychotic and sent to a psychiatrist. Allen came to believe that his real life was on Mars, where he was a ruler, and that like John Mack’s Paul, he was an alien here on earth. Allen’s fantasies began after a series of emotional shocks—loss of a governess mother figure, seduction at twelve by her nymphomaniac replacement, and finally the sexual advances of a too-forward workmate. As he retreated from an abrasive and invasive world, his fantasies about his life on Mars went up a notch, and after an exceptionally uncomfortable episode, suddenly he was there. “He found himself sitting at his desk on Mars, dressed in the robes of his high office, then making his way to the secret room and consulting the photographs in the filing cabinet.”16 After that, Allen spent more and more time on Mars and less on planet Earth.

Wilson points out that Allen’s psychotic fantasy of being on Mars had the kind of reality that we sometimes find in very vivid dreams. He also argues that it is not that distant from the kind of inner journeys people such as Jung took when engaged in “active imagination” or Rudolf Steiner did when reading the Akashic Records. But where in the case of Allen and Rokeach’s three Christs, the unconscious mind’s ability to provide a substitute reality is detrimental, for individuals aiming to transform their lives creatively—that is, positively—it is a powerful tool. Wilson looks at the career of the poet W. B. Yeats as an example. Yeats began as a dreamy, world-rejecting romantic poet who, like Kirk Allen, found the real world much too inhospitable. Instead Yeats sang of fairies, spirits, and Celtic myths of old. His attitude can be seen in his poem “The Stolen Child,” in which fairies lure a child away to their magic lands because “the world’s more full of weeping than you can understand.”17 Yeats was what Wilson would call a typical romantic, withdrawing from a too difficult, demanding, ugly world and creating a more suitable substitute in its place. He complained of “all things uncomely and broken / all things worn out and old,” just as Ouspensky did on his return to this “wooden world” after his experiments with nitrous oxide.18 It was exactly this desire for fairy worlds and magic that led Yeats first to Theosophy and then to the Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn.

But Yeats was also a hardheaded Irishman and as he developed and matured his attitude toward reality became less defensive. He was less withdrawn and his poems took on a hardness and clarity that later earned him the Nobel Prize for literature. We can say that he began to attack reality, rather than flinch from it, to go on the offensive, to master life. Yeats never gave up his belief in magic, but rather than use his imagination to create an alternate reality he could retreat to, he used it to transform himself. As Wilson writes, Yeats’s Last Poems (1938–1939) “reveal a man who is completely adjusted to reality and who recognizes that his own sense of purpose is somehow connected to human evolution.” This is the “profane perfection of mankind” Yeats speaks of in “Under Ben Bulben.”19 Yeats, Wilson says, shows that “we are not faced with a bleak choice between self-deception and a reality that frightens and depresses us,” as Kirk Allen and Rokeach’s three Christs were frightened and depressed. The study of false messiahs, Wilson believes, teaches us that “the unconscious mind can transform reality without self-deception.”20Where does this transformation take place? In what Wilson calls “the second stream,” the current of imaginative and intellectual activity that runs parallel to the “primary stream” of ordinary, everyday life, a nod to the distinction H. G. Wells had made long ago.21 Most of the time the two streams are mixed and life is a burdensome muddle. But there are moments when they separate and, with the everyday demands quieted, the mind can “lift off” and soar into spheres of inner freedom, the kind of freedom Wilson had pursued for practically his whole life. It is difficult to achieve and fleeting—Wilson tells of reaching it one sleepless night in a Japanese hotel. It is not, he says, a “visitation,” but something that can be achieved “by direct effort.” There is no reason why these powers should respond only to self-delusion, he tells us. They are in fact presages of “the more highly controlled states of consciousness of which human beings are capable.”22

This was the real message of the book. But given its disjointed character, it’s not surprising if it was lost on some readers.

Gary Lachman 

Beyond the Robot 

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

The Dark Legacy of Carlos Castaneda


For fans of the literary con, it's been a great few years. Currently, we have Richard Gere starring as Clifford Irving in "The Hoax," a film about the '70s novelist who penned a faux autobiography of Howard Hughes. We've had the unmasking of James Frey, JT LeRoy/Laura Albert and Harvard's Kaavya Viswanathan, who plagiarized large chunks of her debut novel, forcing her publisher, Little, Brown and Co., to recall the book. Much has been written about the slippery boundaries between fiction and nonfiction, the publishing industry's responsibility for distinguishing between the two, and the potential damage to readers. There's been, however, hardly a mention of the 20th century's most successful literary trickster: Carlos Castaneda.

If this name draws a blank for readers under 30, all they have to do is ask their parents. Deemed by Time magazine the "Godfather of the New Age," Castaneda was the literary embodiment of the Woodstock era. His 12 books, supposedly based on meetings with a mysterious Indian shaman, don Juan, made the author, a graduate student in anthropology, a worldwide celebrity.

Admirers included John Lennon, William Burroughs, Federico Fellini and Jim Morrison.  Under don Juan's tutelage, Castaneda took peyote, talked to coyotes, turned into a crow, and learned how to fly. All this took place in what don Juan called "a separate reality." Castaneda, who died in 1998, was, from 1971 to 1982, one of the best-selling nonfiction authors in the country. During his lifetime, his books sold at least 10 million copies.

Castaneda was viewed by many as a compelling writer, and his early books received overwhelmingly positive reviews. Time called them "beautifully lucid" and remarked on a "narrative power unmatched in other anthropological studies." They were widely accepted as factual, and this contributed to their success. Richard Jennings, an attorney who became closely involved with Castaneda in the '90s, was studying at Stanford in the early '70s when he read the first two don Juan books. "I was a searcher," he recently told Salon. "I was looking for a real path to other worlds. I wasn't looking for metaphors." 

The books' status as serious anthropology went almost unchallenged for five years. Skepticism increased in 1972 after Joyce Carol Oates, in a letter to the New York Times, expressed bewilderment that a reviewer had accepted Castaneda's books as nonfiction. The next year, Time published a cover story revealing that Castaneda had lied extensively about his past. Over the next decade, several researchers, most prominently Richard de Mille, son of the legendary director, worked tirelessly to demonstrate that Castaneda's work was a hoax. 

In spite of this exhaustive debunking, the don Juan books still sell well. The University of California Press, which published Castaneda's first book, "The Teachings of Don Juan: A Yaqui Way of Knowledge," in 1968, steadily sells 7,500 copies a year. BookScan, a Nielsen company that tracks book sales, reports that three of Castaneda's most popular titles, "A Separate Reality," "Journey to Ixtlan" and "Tales of Power," sold a total of 10,000 copies in 2006. None of Castaneda's titles have ever gone out of print -- an impressive achievement for any author. 

Today, Simon and Schuster, Castaneda's main publisher, still classifies his books as nonfiction. It could be argued that this label doesn't matter since everyone now knows don Juan was a fictional creation. But everyone doesn't, and the trust that some readers have invested in these books leads to a darker story that has received almost no coverage in the mainstream press. 

Castaneda, who disappeared from the public view in 1973, began in the last decade of his life to organize a secretive group of devoted followers. His tools were his books and Tensegrity, a movement technique he claimed had been passed down by 25 generations of Toltec shamans. A corporation, Cleargreen, was set up to promote Tensegrity; it held workshops attended by thousands. Novelist and director Bruce Wagner, a member of Castaneda's inner circle, helped produce a series of instructional videos. Cleargreen continues to operate to this day, promoting Tensegrity and Castaneda's teachings through workshops in Southern California, Europe and Latin America. 

At the heart of Castaneda's movement was a group of intensely devoted women, all of whom were or had been his lovers. They were known as the witches, and two of them, Florinda Donner-Grau and Taisha Abelar, vanished the day after Castaneda's death, along with Cleargreen president Amalia Marquez and Tensegrity instructor Kylie Lundahl. A few weeks later, Patricia Partin, Castaneda's adopted daughter as well as his lover, also disappeared. In February 2006, a skeleton found in Death Valley, Calif., was identified through DNA analysis as Partin's. 

Some former Castaneda associates suspect the missing women committed suicide. They cite remarks the women made shortly before vanishing, and point to Castaneda's frequent discussion of suicide in private group meetings. Achieving transcendence through a death nobly chosen, they maintain, had long been central to his teachings.

He had an innocence “like Holy men, prophets and gurus”

Castaneda was born in 1925 and came to the United States in 1951 from Peru. He'd studied sculpture at the School of Fine Arts in Lima and hoped to make it as an artist in the United States. He worked a series of odd jobs and took classes at Los Angeles Community College in philosophy, literature and creative writing. Most who knew him then recall a brilliant, hilarious storyteller with mesmerizing brown eyes. He was short (some say 5-foot-2; others 5-foot-5) and self-conscious about having his picture taken. Along with his then wife Margaret Runyan (whose memoir, "A Magical Journey With Carlos Castaneda," he would later try to suppress) he became fascinated by the occult.

According to Runyan, she and Castaneda would hold long bull sessions, drinking wine with other students. One night a friend remarked that neither the Buddha nor Jesus ever wrote anything down. Their teachings had been recorded by disciples, who could have changed things or made them up.

"Carlos nodded, as if thinking carefully," wrote Runyan. Together, she and Castaneda conducted unsuccessful ESP experiments. Runyan worked for the phone company, and Castaneda's first attempt at a book was an uncompleted nonfiction manuscript titled "Dial Operator."  In 1959, Castaneda enrolled at UCLA, where he signed up for California ethnography with archaeology professor Clement Meighan. One of the assignments was to interview an Indian. He got an "A" for his paper, in which he spoke to an unnamed Native American about the ceremonial use of jimson weed. But Castaneda was broke and soon dropped out. He worked in a liquor store and drove a taxi. He began to disappear for days at a time, telling Runyan he was going to the desert. The couple separated, but soon afterward Castaneda adopted C.J., the son Runyan had had with another man. And, for seven years, he worked on the manuscript that was to become "The Teachings of Don Juan."

"The Teachings" begins with a young man named Carlos being introduced at an Arizona bus stop to don Juan, an old Yaqui Indian whom he's told "is very learned about plants." Carlos tries to persuade the reluctant don Juan to teach him about peyote. Eventually he relents, allowing Carlos to ingest the sacred cactus buds. Carlos sees a transparent black dog, which, don Juan later tells him, is Mescalito, a powerful supernatural being. His appearance is a sign that Carlos is "the chosen one" who's been picked to receive "the teachings."

"The Teachings" is largely a dialogue between don Juan, the master, and Carlos, the student, punctuated by the ingestion of carefully prepared mixtures of herbs and mushrooms. Carlos has strange experiences that, in spite of don Juan's admonitions, he continues to think of as hallucinations. In one instance, Carlos turns into a crow and flies. Afterward, an argument ensues: Is there such a thing as objective reality? Or is reality just perceptions and different, equally valid ways of describing them? Toward the book's end, Carlos again encounters Mescalito, whom he now accepts as real, not a hallucination. 

In "The Teachings," Castaneda tried to follow the conventions of anthropology by appending a 50-page "structural analysis." According to Runyan, his goal was to become a psychedelic scholar along the lines of Aldous Huxley. He'd become disillusioned with another hero, Timothy Leary, who supposedly mocked Castaneda when they met at a party, earning his lifelong enmity. In 1967, he took his manuscript to professor Meighan.

Castaneda was disappointed when Meighan told him it would work better as a trade book than as a scholarly monograph. But following Meighan's instructions, Castaneda took his manuscript to the University of California Press' office in Powell Library, where he showed it to Jim Quebec. The editor was impressed but had doubts about its authenticity. Inundated by good reports from the UCLA anthropology department, according to Runyan, Quebec was convinced and "The Teachings" was published in the spring of 1968. 

Runyan wrote that "the University of California Press, fully cognizant that a nation of drug-infatuated students was out there, moved it into California bookstores with a vengeance." Sales exceeded all expectations, and Quebec soon introduced Castaneda to Ned Brown, an agent whose clients included Jackie Collins. Brown then put Castaneda in touch with Michael Korda, Simon and Schuster's new editor in chief.

In his memoir, "Another Life," Korda recounts their first meeting. Korda was told to wait in a hotel parking lot. "A neat Volvo pulled up in front of me, and the driver waved me in," Korda writes. "He was a robust, broad-chested, muscular man, with a swarthy complexion, dark eyes, black curly hair cut short, and a grin as merry as Friar Tuck's ... I had seldom, if ever, liked anybody so much so quickly ... It wasn't so much what Castaneda had to say as his presence -- a kind of charm that was partly subtle intelligence, partly a real affection for people, and partly a kind of innocence, not of the naive kind but of the kind one likes to suppose saints, holy men, prophets and gurus have." The next morning, Korda set about buying the rights to "The Teachings." Under his new editor's guidance, Castaneda published his next three books in quick succession. In "A Separate Reality," published in 1971, Carlos returns to Mexico to give don Juan a copy of his new book. Don Juan declines the gift, suggesting he'd use it as toilet paper. A new cycle of apprenticeship begins, in which don Juan tries to teach Carlos how to "see." 

New characters appear, most importantly don Juan's friend and fellow sorcerer don Genaro. In "A Separate Reality" and the two books that follow, "Journey to Ixtlan" and "Tales of Power," numerous new concepts are introduced, including "becoming inaccessible," "erasing personal history" and "stopping the world." 

There are also displays of magic. Don Genaro is at one moment standing next to Carlos; at the next, he's on top of a mountain. Don Juan uses unseen powers to help Carlos start his stalled car. And he tries to show him how to be a warrior -- a being who, like an enlightened Buddhist, has eliminated the ego, but who, in a more Nietzschean vein, knows he's superior to regular humans, who lead wasted, pointless lives. Don Juan also tries to teach Carlos how to enter the world of dreams, the "separate reality," also referred to as the "nagual," a Spanish word taken from the Aztecs. (Later, Castaneda would shift the word's meaning, making it stand not only for the separate reality but also for a shaman, like don Juan and, eventually, Castaneda himself.) 

In "Journey to Ixtlan," Carlos starts a new round of apprenticeship. Don Juan tells him they'll no longer use drugs. These were only necessary when Carlos was a beginner. Many consider "Ixtlan," which served as Castaneda's Ph.D. thesis at UCLA, his most beautiful book. It also made him a millionaire. At the book's conclusion, Carlos talks to a luminous coyote. But he isn't yet ready to enter the nagual. Finally, at the end of "Tales of Power," don Juan and don Genaro take Carlos to the edge of a cliff. If he has the courage to leap, he'll at last be a full-fledged sorcerer. This time Carlos doesn't turn back. He jumps into the abyss.

- - - - - - - - - - - - 

All four books were lavishly praised. Michael Murphy, a founder of Esalen, remarked that the "essential lessons don Juan has to teach are the timeless ones that have been taught by the great sages of India." There were raves in the New York Times, Harper's and the Saturday Review. "Castaneda's meeting with Don Juan," wrote Time's Robert Hughes, "now seems one of the most fortunate literary encounters since Boswell was introduced to Dr.
Johnson." 

In 1972, anthropologist Paul Riesman reviewed Castaneda's first three books in the New York Times Book Review, writing that "Castaneda makes it clear that the teachings of don Juan do tell us something of how the world really is." Riesman's article ran in place of a review the Times had initially commissioned from Weston La Barre, one of the foremost authorities on Native American peyote ceremonies. In his unpublished article, La Barre denounced Castaneda's writing as "pseudo-profound deeply vulgar pseudo-ethnography." 

Contacted recently, Roger Jellinek, the editor who commissioned both reviews, explained his decision. "The Weston La Barre review, as I recall, was not so much a review as a furious ad hominem diatribe intended to suppress, not debate, the book," he wrote via e-mail. "By then I knew enough about Castaneda, from discussions with Edmund Carpenter, the anthropologist who first put me on to Castaneda, and from my reading of renowned shamanism scholar Mircea Eliade in support of my own review of Castaneda in the daily New York Times, to feel strongly that 'The Teachings of Don Juan' deserved more than a personal put-down. Hence the second commission to Paul Riesman, son of Harvard sociologist David Riesman, and a brilliant rising anthropologist. Incidentally, in all my eight years at the NYTBR, that's the only occasion I can recall of a review being commissioned twice." 

Riesman's glowing review was soon followed by Oates' letter to the editor, in which she argued that the books were obvious works of fiction. Then, in 1973, Time correspondent Sandra Burton found that Castaneda had lied about his military service, his father's occupation, his age and his nation of birth (Peru not Brazil). 

No one contributed more to Castaneda's debunking than Richard de Mille. De Mille, who held a Ph.D. in psychology from USC, was something of a freelance intellectual. In a recent interview, he remarked that because he wasn't associated with a university, he could tell the story straight. "People in the academy wouldn't do it," he remarked. "They'd be embarrassing the establishment." Specifically the UCLA professors who, according to de Mille, knew it was a hoax from the start. But a hoax that, he said, supported their theories, which de Mille summed up succinctly: "Reality doesn't exist. It's all what people say to each other." 

In de Mille's first exposé, "Castaneda's Journey," which appeared in 1976, he pointed to numerous internal contradictions in Castaneda's field reports and the absence of convincing details. "During nine years of collecting plants and hunting animals with don Juan, Carlos learns not one Indian name for any plant or animal," De Mille wrote. The books were also filled with implausible details. For example, while "incessantly sauntering across the sands in seasons when ... harsh conditions keep prudent persons away, Carlos and don Juan go quite unmolested by pests that normally torment desert hikers."

De Mille also uncovered numerous instances of plagiarism. "When don Juan opens his mouth," he wrote, "the words of particular writers come out." His 1980 compilation, "The Don Juan Papers," includes a 47-page glossary of quotations from don Juan and their sources, ranging from Wittgenstein and C.S. Lewis to papers in obscure anthropology journals. 

In one example, de Mille first quotes a passage by a mystic, Yogi Ramacharaka: "The Human Aura is seen by the psychic observer as a luminous cloud, egg-shaped, streaked by fine lines like stiff bristles standing out in all directions." In "A Separate Reality," a "man looks like a human egg of circulating fibers. And his arms and legs are like luminous bristles bursting out in all directions." The accumulation of such instances leads de Mille to conclude that "Carlos's adventures originated not in the Sonoran desert but in the library at UCLA." De Mille convinced many previously sympathetic readers that don Juan did not exist. Perhaps the most glaring evidence was that the Yaqui don't use peyote, and don Juan was supposedly a Yaqui shaman teaching a "Yaqui way of knowledge." Even the New York Times came around, declaring that de Mille's research "should satisfy anyone still in doubt." 

Some anthropologists have disagreed with de Mille on certain points. J.T. Fikes, author of "Carlos Castaneda, Academic Opportunism and the Psychedelic Sixties," believes Castaneda did have some contact with Native Americans. But he's an even fiercer critic than de Mille, condemning Castaneda for the effect his stories have had on Native peoples. Following the publication of "The Teachings," thousands of pilgrims descended on Yaqui territory. When they discovered that the Yaqui don't use peyote, but that the Huichol people do, they headed to the Huichol homeland in Southern Mexico, where, according to Fikes, they caused serious disruption. Fikes recounts with outrage the story of one Huichol elder being murdered by a stoned gringo.

Among anthropologists, there's no longer a debate. Professor William W. Kelly, chairman of Yale's anthropology department, told me, "I doubt you'll find an anthropologist of my generation who regards Castaneda as anything but a clever con man. It was a hoax, and surely don Juan never existed as anything like the figure of his books. Perhaps to many it is an amusing footnote to the gullibility of naive scholars, although to me it remains a disturbing and unforgivable breach of ethics."

He and his witches maintained a tight veil of secrecy 

After 1973, the year of the Time exposé, Castaneda never again responded publicly to criticism. Instead, he went into seclusion, at least as far as the press was concerned (he still went to Hollywood parties). Claiming he was complying with don Juan's instruction to become "inaccessible," he no longer allowed himself to be photographed, and (in the same year the existence of the Nixon tapes was made public) he decided that recordings of any sort were forbidden. He also severed ties to his past; after attending C.J.'s junior high graduation and promising to take him to Europe, he soon banished his ex-wife and son. 

And he made don Juan disappear. When "The Second Ring of Power" was published in 1977, readers learned that sometime between the leap into the abyss at the end of "Tales of Power" and the start of the new book, don Juan had vanished, evanescing into a ball of light and entering the nagual. His seclusion also helped Castaneda, now in his late 40s, conceal the alternative family he was starting to form. The key members were three young women: Regine Thal, Maryann Simko and Kathleen "Chickie" Pohlman, whom Castaneda had met while he was still active at UCLA. Simko was pursuing a Ph.D. in anthropology and was known around campus as Castaneda's girlfriend. Through her, Castaneda met Thal, another anthropology Ph.D. candidate and Simko's friend from karate class. How Pohlman entered the picture remains unclear.

In 1973, Castaneda purchased a compound on the aptly named Pandora Avenue in Westwood. The women, soon to be known both in his group and in his books as "the witches," moved in. They eventually came to sport identical short, dyed blond haircuts similar to those later worn by the Heaven's Gate cult. They also said they'd studied with don Juan.

In keeping with the philosophy of "erasing personal history," they changed their names: Simko became Taisha Abelar; Thal, Florinda Donner-Grau. Donner-Grau is remembered by many as Castaneda's equal in intelligence and charisma. Nicknamed "the hummingbird" because of her ceaseless energy, she was born in Venezuela to German parents and claimed to have done research on the Yanomami Indians. Pohlman was given a somewhat less glamorous alias: Carol Tiggs. Donner-Grau and Abelar eventually published their own books on sorcery. 

The witches, along with Castaneda, maintained a tight veil of secrecy. They used numerous aliases and didn't allow themselves to be photographed. Followers were told constantly changing stories about their backgrounds.
Only after Castaneda's death did the real facts about their lives begin to emerge. This is largely due to the work of three of his ex-followers. 

In the early '90s, Richard Jennings, a Columbia Law graduate, was living in Los Angeles. He was the executive director of Hollywood Supports, a nonprofit group organized to fight discrimination against people with HIV. He'd previously been the executive director of GLAAD, the Gay and Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation. After reading an article in Details magazine by Bruce Wagner about a meeting with Castaneda, he became intrigued. By looking on the Internet, he found his way to one of the semi-secret workshops being held around Los Angeles. He was soon invited to participate in Castaneda's Sunday sessions, exclusive classes for select followers, where Jennings kept copious notes. From 1995 to 1998 he was deeply involved in the group, sometimes advising on legal matters. After Castaneda's death, he started a Web site, Sustained Action, for which he compiled meticulously researched chronologies, dating from 1947 to 1999, of the lives of Patricia Partin and the witches. 

Another former insider is Amy Wallace, author of 13 books of fiction and nonfiction, including the best-selling "Book of Lists," which she co-authored with her brother David Wallechinksy and their father, novelist Irving Wallace, also a client of Korda's. (Amy Wallace has contributed to Salon.) She first met Castaneda in 1973, while she was still in high school. Her parents took her to a dinner party held by agent Ned Brown. Castaneda was there with Abelar, who then went under the name Anna-Marie Carter. They talked with Wallace about her boarding school. Many years later, Wallace became one of Castaneda's numerous lovers, an experience recounted in her memoir, "Sorcerer's Apprentice." Wallace now lives in East Los Angeles, where she's working on a novel about punk rock. 

Gaby Geuter, an author and former travel agent, had been a workshop attendee who hoped to join the inner circle. In 1996 she realized she was being shut out. In an effort to find out the truth about the guru who'd rejected her, she, along with her husband, Greg Mamishian, began to shadow Castaneda. In her book "Filming Castaneda," she recounts how, from a car parked near his compound, they secretly videotaped the group's comings and goings. Were it not for Geuter there'd be no post-1973 photographic record of Castaneda, who, as he aged, seemed to have retained his impish charm as well as a full head of silver hair. They also went through his trash, discovering a treasure trove of documents, including marriage certificates, letters and credit card receipts that would later provide clues to the group's history and its behavior during Castaneda's final days.

During the late '70s and early '80s, Jennings believes the group probably numbered no more than two dozen. Members, mostly women, came and went. At the time, a pivotal event was the defection of Carol Tiggs, who was, according to Wallace, always the most ambivalent witch. Soon after joining, she tried to break away. She attended California Acupuncture College, married a fellow student and lived in Pacific Palisades. Eventually, Wallace says, Castaneda lured her back. 

Castaneda had a different version. In his 1981 bestseller, "The Eagle's Gift," he described how Tiggs vanished into the "second attention," one of his terms for infinity. Eventually she reappeared through a space time portal in New Mexico. She then made her way to L.A., where they were joyously reunited when he found her on Santa Monica Boulevard. In homage to her 10 years in another dimension, she was now known as the "nagual woman." 

Wallace believes this was an incentive to get Tiggs to rejoin. According to Wallace and Jennings, one of the witches' tasks was to recruit new members. Melissa Ward, a Los Angeles area caterer, was involved in the group from 1993 to 1994. "Frequently they recruited at lectures," she told me. Among the goals, she said, was to find "women with a combination of brains and beauty and vulnerability." Initiation into the inner family often involved sleeping with Castaneda, who, the witches claimed in public appearances, was celibate.

In "Sorcerer's Apprentice," Wallace provides a detailed picture of her own seduction. Because of her father's friendship with Castaneda, her case was unusual. Over the years, he'd stop by the Wallace home. When Irving died in 1990, Amy was living in Berkeley, Calif. Soon after, Castaneda called and told her that her father had appeared to him in a dream and said he was trapped in the Wallace's house, and needed Amy and Carlos to free him. 

Wallace, suitably skeptical, came down to L.A. and the seduction began in earnest. She recounts how she soon found herself in bed with Castaneda. He told her he hadn't had sex for 20 years. When Wallace later worried she might have gotten pregnant (they'd used no birth control), Castaneda leapt from the bed, shouting, "Me make you pregnant? Impossible! The nagual's sperm isn't human ... Don't let any of the nagual's sperm out, nena. It will burn away your humanness." He didn't mention the vasectomy he'd had years before. 

The courtship continued for several weeks. Castaneda told her they were "energetically married." One afternoon, he took her to the sorcerer's compound. As they were leaving, Wallace looked at a street sign so she could remember the location. Castaneda furiously berated her: A warrior wouldn't have looked. He ordered her to return to Berkeley. She did. When she called, he refused to speak to her. 

The witches, however, did, instructing Wallace on the sorceric steps necessary to return. She had to let go of her attachments. Wallace got rid of her cats. This didn't cut it. Castaneda, she wrote, got on the phone and called her an egotistical, spoiled Jew. He ordered her to get a job at McDonald's. Instead, Wallace waitressed at a bed and breakfast. Six months later she was allowed back. 

Aspiring warriors, say Jennings, Wallace and Ward, were urged to cut off all contact with their past lives, as don Juan had instructed Carlos to do, and as Castaneda had done by cutting off his wife and adopted son. "He was telling us how to get out of family obligations," Jennings told me. "Being in one-on-one relationships would hold you back from the path. Castaneda was telling us how to get out of commitments with family, down to small points like how to avoid hugging your parents directly." Jennings estimates that during his four years with the group, between 75 and 100 people were told to cut off their families. He doesn't know how many did.

For some initiates, the separation was brutal and final. According to Wallace, acolytes were told to tell their families, "I send you to hell." Both Wallace and Jennings tell of one young woman who, in the group's early years, had been ordered by Castaneda to hit her mother, a Holocaust survivor. Many years later, Wallace told me, the woman "cried about it. She'd done it because she thought he was so psychic he could tell if she didn't." Wallace also describes how, when one young man's parents died soon after being cut off, Castaneda singled him out for praise, remarking, "When you really do it, don Juan told me, they die instantly, as if you were squashing a flea -- and that's all they are, fleas." 

Before entering the innermost circle, at least some followers were led into a position of emotional and financial dependence. Ward remembers a woman named Peggy who was instructed to quit her job. She was told she'd then be given cash to get a phone-less apartment, where she would wait to hear from Castaneda or the witches. Peggy fled before this happened. But Ward said this was a common practice with women about to be brought into the family's core. 

Valerie Kadium, a librarian, who from 1995 to 1996 took part in the Sunday sessions, recalls one participant who, after several meetings, decided to commit himself fully to the group. He went to Vermont to shut down his business, but on returning to L.A., he was told he could no longer participate; he was "too late." He'd failed to grasp the "cubic centimeter of chance" that, said Kadium, Castaneda often spoke of. Jennings had to quit his job with Hollywood Supports; his work required him to interact with the media, but this was impossible: Sorcerers couldn't have their pictures taken. 

But there were rewards. "I was totally affected by these people," Jennings told me. "I felt like I'd found a family. I felt like I'd found a path." Kadium recalls the first time she saw Tensegrity instructor Kylie Lundahl onstage -- she saw an aura around her, an apricot glow. Remembering her early days with the group, she remarked, "There was such a sweetness about it. I had such high hopes. I wanted to feel the world more deeply -- and I did." 

Although she was later devastated when Castaneda banished her from the Sunday sessions, telling her "the spirits spit you out," she eventually recovered, and now remembers this as the most exciting time of her life.
According to all who knew him, Castaneda wasn't only mesmerizing, he also had a great sense of humor. "One of the reasons I was involved was the idea that I was in this fascinating, on the edge, avant garde, extraordinary group of beings," Wallace said. "Life was always exciting. We were free from the tedium of the world." 

And because, as Jennings puts it, Castaneda was a "control freak," followers were often freed from the anxiety of decision-making. Some had more independence, but even Wallace and Bruce Wagner, both of whom were given a certain leeway, were sometimes, according to Wallace, required to have their writing vetted by Donner-Grau. Jennings and Wallace also report that Castaneda directed the inner circle's sex lives in great detail. 

The most difficult part, Wallace believes, was that you never knew where you stood. "He'd pick someone, crown them, and was as capable of kicking them out in 48 hours as keeping them 10 years. You never knew. So there was always trepidation, a lot of jealousy." Sometimes initiates were banished for obscure spiritual offenses, such as drinking cappuccino (which Castaneda himself guzzled in great quantities). They'd no longer be invited to the compound. Phone calls wouldn't be returned. Having been allowed for a time into a secret, magical family, they'd be abruptly cut off. For some, Wallace believes, this pattern was highly traumatic. "In a weird way," she said, "the worst thing that can happen is when you're loved and loved and then abused and abused, and there are no rules, and the rules keep changing, and you can never do right, but then all of a sudden they're kissing you. That's the most crazy-making behavioral modification there is. And that's what Carlos specialized in; he was not stupid.”

“We were all supposed to go together, “make the leap”

Whether disciples were allowed to stay or forced to leave seems often to have depended on the whims of a woman known as the Blue Scout. Trying to describe her power, Ward recalled a "Twilight Zone" episode in which a little boy could look at people and make them die. "So everyone treated him with kid gloves," she said, "and that's how it was with the Blue Scout." She was born Patricia Partin and grew up in LaVerne, Calif., where, according to Jennings, her father had been in an accident that left him with permanent brain damage. Partin dropped out of Bonita High her junior year. She became a waitress, and, at 19, married an aspiring filmmaker, Mark Silliphant, who introduced her to Castaneda in 1978. Within weeks of their marriage she left Silliphant and went to live with Castaneda. She paid one last visit to her mother; in keeping with the nagual's instructions, she refused to be in a family photograph. For the rest of her life, she never spoke to her mother again. 

Castaneda renamed Partin Nury Alexander. She was also "Claude" as well as the Blue Scout. She soon emerged as one of his favorites (Castaneda officially adopted her in 1995). Followers were told he'd conceived her with Tiggs in the nagual. He said she had a very rare energy; she was "barely human" -- high praise from Castaneda. Partin, a perpetual student at UCLA and an inveterate shopper at Neiman Marcus, was infantilized. In later years, new followers would be assigned the task of playing dolls with her. 

In the late '80s, perhaps because book sales had slowed, or perhaps because he no longer feared media scrutiny, Castaneda sought to expand. Jennings believes he may have been driven by a desire to please Partin. Geuter confirms that Castaneda told followers that the Blue Scout had talked him into starting Cleargreen. But she also suggests another motivation. "He was thinking about what he wanted for the rest of his life," Geuter told me. "He always talked about 'going for the golden clasp.' He wanted to finish with something spectacular." 

Castaneda investigated the possibility of incorporating as a religion, as L. Ron Hubbard had done with Scientology. Instead, he chose to develop Tensegrity, which, Jennings believes, was to be the means through which the new faith would spread. Tensegrity is a movement technique that seems to combine elements of a rigid version of tai chi and modern dance. In all likelihood the inspiration came from karate devotees Donner-Grau and Abelar, and from his years of lessons with martial arts instructor Howard Lee. Documents found by Geuter show him discussing a project called "Kung Fu Sorcery" with Lee as early as 1988. The more elegant "Tensegrity" was lifted from Buckminster Fuller, for whom it referred to a structural synergy between tension and compression. Castaneda seems to have just liked the sound of it. 

A major player in promoting Tensegrity was Wagner, whose fifth novel, "The Chrysanthemum Palace," was a finalist for the Pen/Faulkner prize (his sixth, "Memorial," was recently released by Simon and Schuster). Wagner hadn't yet published his first novel when he approached Castaneda in 1988 with the hope of filming the don Juan books. Within a few years, according to Jennings and Wallace, he became part of the inner circle. He was given the sorceric name Lorenzo Drake -- Enzo for short. As the group began to emerge from the shadows, holding seminars in high school auditoriums and on college campuses, Wagner, tall, bald and usually dressed in black, would, according to Geuter and Wallace, act as a sort of bouncer, removing those who asked unwanted questions. (Wagner declined requests for an interview.) In 1995 Wagner, who'd previously been wed to Rebecca De Mornay, married Tiggs. That same year his novel "I'm Losing You" was chosen by the New York Times as a notable book of the year. John Updike, in the New Yorker, proclaimed that Wagner "writes like a wizard." 

In the early '90s, to promote Tensegrity, Castaneda set up Cleargreen, which operated out of the offices of "Rugrats" producer and Castaneda agent (and part-time sorcerer) Tracy Kramer, a friend of Wagner's from Beverly Hills High. Although Castaneda wasn't a shareholder, according to Geuter, "he determined every detail of the operation." Jennings and Wallace confirm that Castaneda had complete control of Cleargreen. (Cleargreen did not respond to numerous inquiries from Salon.) The company's official president was Amalia Marquez (sorceric name Talia Bey), a young businesswoman who, after reading Castaneda's books, had moved from Puerto Rico to Los Angeles in order to follow him. 

At Tensegrity seminars, women dressed in black, the "chacmools," demonstrated moves for the audience. Castaneda and the witches would speak and answer questions. Seminars cost up to $1,200, and as many as 800 would attend. Participants could buy T-shirts that read "Self Importance Kills -- Do Tensegrity." The movements were meant to promote health as well as help practitioners progress as warriors. Illness was seen as a sign of weakness. Wallace recalls the case of Tycho, the Orange Scout (supposedly the Blue Scout's sister). "She had ulcerative colitis," Wallace told me. "She was trying to keep it a secret because if Carlos knew you were sick he'd punish you. If you went for medical care, he'd kick you out." Once Tycho's illness was discovered, Wallace said, Tycho was expelled from the group.

- - - - - - - - - - - - 

If Castaneda's early books drew on Buddhism and phenomenology, his later work seemed more indebted to science fiction. But throughout, there was a preoccupation with meeting death like a warrior. In the '90s, Castaneda told his followers that, like don Juan, he wouldn't die -- he'd burn from within, turn into a ball of light, and ascend to the heavens. 

In the summer of 1997, he was diagnosed with liver cancer. Because sorcerers weren't supposed to get sick, his illness remained a tightly guarded secret. While the witches desperately pursued traditional and alternative treatments, the workshops continued as if nothing was wrong (although Castaneda often wasn't there). One of the witches, Abelar, flew to Florida to inspect yachts. Geuter, in notes taken at the time, wondered, "Why are they buying a boat? ... Maybe Carlos wants to leave with his group, and disappear unnoticed in the wide-open oceans." 

No boats were purchased. Castaneda continued to decline. He became increasingly frail, his eyes yellow and jaundiced. He rarely left the compound. According to Wallace, Tiggs told her the witches had purchased guns. While the nagual lay bedridden with a morphine drip, watching war videos, the inner circle burned his papers. A grieving Abelar had begun to drink. "I'm not in any danger of becoming an alcoholic now," she told Wallace. "Because I'm leaving, so -- it's too late." Wallace writes: "She was telling me, in her way, that she planned to die."

Wallace also recalls a conversation with Lundahl, the star of the Tensegrity videos and one of the women who disappeared: "If I don't go with him, I'll do what I have to do," Wallace says Lundahl told her. "It's too late for you and me to remain in the world -- I think you know exactly what I mean."

In April 1998, Geuter filmed the inner circle packing up the house. The next week, at age 72, Castaneda died. He was cremated at the Culver City mortuary. No one knows what became of his ashes. Within days, Donner-Grau, Abelar, Partin, Lundahl and Marquez had their phones disconnected and vanished. A few weeks later, Partin's red Ford Escort was found abandoned in Death Valley's Panamint Dunes. 

Even within the inner circle, few knew that Castaneda was dead. Rumors spread. Many were in despair: The nagual hadn't "burned from within." Jennings didn't learn until two weeks later, when Tiggs called to tell him Castaneda was "gone." The witches, she said, were "elsewhere." 

In a proposal for a biography of Castaneda, a project Jennings eventually chose not to pursue, he writes that Tiggs "also told me she was supposed to have 'gone with them,' but 'a non-decision decision' kept me here." Meanwhile, the workshops continued. "Carol also banned mourning within Cleargreen," Jennings writes, "so its members hid their grief, often drowning it in alcohol or drugs." Wallace, too, recalls a lot of drug use: "I don't know if they tried to OD so much as to 'get there.' Get to Carlos." Jennings himself drove to the desert and thought about committing suicide. 

The media didn't learn of Castaneda's death for two months. When the news became public, Cleargreen members stopped answering their phones. They soon placed a statement, which Jennings says was written by Wagner, on their Web site: "For don Juan, the warrior was a being ... who embarks, when the time comes, on a definitive journey of awareness, 'crossing over to total freedom' ... warriors can keep their awareness, which is ordinarily relinquished, at the moment of dying. At the moment of crossing, the body in its entirety is kindled with knowledge ... Carlos Castaneda left the world the same way that his teacher, don Juan Matus did: with full awareness." 

Many obituaries had a curious tone; the writers seemed uncertain whether to call Castaneda a fraud. Some expressed a kind of nostalgia for an author whose work had meant so much to so many in their youth. Korda refused comment. De Mille, in an interview with filmmaker Ralph Torjan, expressed a certain admiration. "He was the perfect hoaxer," he told Torjan, "because he never admitted anything."

  Jennings, Wallace and Geuter believe the missing women likely committed suicide. Wallace told me about a phone call to Donner-Grau's parents not long after the women disappeared. Donner-Grau had been one of the few allowed to maintain contact with her family. "They were weeping," Wallace said, "because there was no goodbye. They didn't know what had happened. This was after decades of being in touch with them." 

Castaneda's will, executed three days before his death, leaves everything to an entity known as the Eagle's Trust. According to Jennings, who obtained a copy of the trust agreement, the missing women have a considerable amount of money due to them. Deborah Drooz, the executor of Castaneda's estate, said she has had no contact with the women. She added that she believes they are still alive.

Jennings believes Castaneda knew they were planning to kill themselves. "He used to talk about suicide all the time, even for minor things," Jennings told me. He added that Partin was once sent to identify abandoned mines in the desert, which could be used as potential suicide sites. (There's an abandoned mine not far from where her remains were found.) "He regularly told us he was our only hope," Jennings said. "We were all supposed to go together, 'make the leap,' whatever that meant." What did Jennings think it meant? "I didn't know fully," he said. "He'd describe it in different ways. So would the witches. It seemed to be what they were living for, something we were being promised." 

The promise may have been based on the final scene in "Tales of Power," in which Carlos leaps from a cliff into the nagual. The scene is later retold in varying versions. In his 1984 book, "The Fire From Within," Castaneda wrote:
"I didn't die at the bottom of that gorge -- and neither did the other apprentices who had jumped at an earlier time -- because we never reached it; all of us, under the impact of such a tremendous and incomprehensible act as jumping to our deaths, moved our assemblage points and assembled other worlds." 

Did Castaneda really believe this? Wallace thinks so. "He became more and more hypnotized by his own reveries," she told me. "I firmly believe Carlos brainwashed himself." Did the witches? Geuter put it this way: "Florinda, Taisha and the Blue Scout knew it was a fantasy structure. But when you have thousands of eyes looking back at you, you begin to believe in the fantasy. These women never had to answer to the real world. Carlos had snatched them when they were very young." 

Wallace isn't sure what the women believed. Because open discussion of Castaneda's teachings was forbidden, it was impossible to know what anyone really thought. However, she told me, after living so long with Castaneda, the women may have felt they had no choice. "You've cut off all your ties," she said. "Now you're going to go back after all these decades? Who are you going to go be with? And you feel that you're not one of the common herd anymore. That's why they killed themselves." 

On its Web site, Cleargreen maintains that the women didn't "depart." However, "for the moment they are not going to appear personally at the workshops because they want this dream to take wings." 

Remarkably, there seems to have been no investigation into at least three of the disappearances. Except for Donner-Grau, they'd all been estranged from their families for years. For months after they vanished, none of the other families knew what had happened. And so, according to Geuter, no one reported them missing. Salon attempted to locate the three missing women, relying on public records and phone calls to their previous residences, but discovered no current trace of them. The Los Angeles Police Department and the FBI confirm that there's been no official inquiry into the disappearances of Donner-Grau, Abelar and Lundahl. 

There is, however, a file open in the Marquez case. This is due to the tireless efforts of Luis Marquez, who told Salon that he first tried to report his sister missing in 1999. But the LAPD, he said, repeatedly ignored him. A year later, he and his sister Carmen wrote a letter to the missing-persons unit; again, no response. According to Marquez, it wasn't until Partin's remains were identified that the LAPD opened a file on Amalia. "To this day," he told me, "they still refuse to ask any questions or visit Cleargreen." His own attempts to get information from Cleargreen have been fruitless. According to Marquez, all he's been told is that the women are "traveling." Detective Lydia Dillard, assigned to the Marquez case, said that because this is an open investigation, she couldn't confirm whether anyone from Cleargreen had been interviewed. 

In 2002, a Taos, N. M., woman, Janice Emery, a Castaneda follower and workshop attendee, jumped to her death in the Rio Grande gorge. According to the Santa Fe New Mexican, Emery had a head injury brought on by cancer. One of Emery's friends told the newspaper that Emery "wanted to be with Castaneda's people." Said another: "I think she was really thinking she could fly off." A year later, a skeleton was discovered near the site of Partin's abandoned Ford. The Inyo County sheriff's department suspected it was hers. But, due to its desiccated condition, a positive identification couldn't be made until February 2006, when new DNA technology became available. 

Wallace recalls how Castaneda had told Partin that "if you ever need to rise to infinity, take your little red car and drive it as fast as you can into the desert and you will ascend." And, Wallace believes, "that's exactly what she did: She took her little red car, drove it into the desert, didn't ascend, got out, wandered around and fainted from dehydration." 

Partin's death and the disappearance of the other women isn't Castaneda's entire legacy. He's been acknowledged as an important influence by figures ranging from Deepak Chopra to George Lucas. Without a doubt, Castaneda opened the doors of perception for numerous readers, and many workshop attendees found the experience deeply meaningful. There are those who testify to the benefits of Tensegrity. And even some of those who are critical of Castaneda find his teachings useful. "He was a conduit. I wanted answers to the big questions. He helped me," Geuter said. But for five of his closest companions, his teachings -- and his insistence on their literal truth -- may have cost them their lives. 

Long after Castaneda had been discredited in academia, Korda continued to insist on his authenticity. In 2000, he wrote: "I have never doubted for a moment the truth of his stories about don Juan." Castaneda's books have been profitable for Simon and Schuster, and according to Korda, were for many years one of the props on which the publisher rested. Castaneda might have achieved some level of success if his books had been presented, as James Redfield's "Celestine Prophecy" is, as allegorical fiction. But Castaneda always insisted he'd made nothing up. "If he hadn't presented his stories as fact," Wallace told me, "it's unlikely the cult would exist. As nonfiction, it became impossibly more dangerous." 

To this day, Simon and Schuster stands by Korda's position. When asked whether, in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary, the publisher still regarded Castaneda's books as nonfiction, Adam Rothenberg, the vice president for corporate communication, replied that Simon and Schuster "will continue to publish Castaneda as we always have." Tensegrity classes are still held around the world. Workshops were recently conducted in Mexico City and Hanover, Germany. Wagner's videos are still available from Cleargreen. According to the terms of Castaneda's will, book royalties still help support a core group of acolytes. On Simon and Schuster's Web site, Castaneda is still described as an anthropologist. No mention is made of his fiction.

Robert Marshall – Salon.com April 12, 2007

www.salon.com/books/feature/2007/04/12/castaneda/index.html

The Strange Death of James Webb

 

On the afternoon of May 8, 1980, after two years of a deep, paralyzing depression and at least one psychotic episode, the brilliant Scots historian of the occult James Webb put the barrel of his shotgun to his head and blew his brains out. He was thirty-four. In the 1970s Webb had made a name for him with his fascinating if skeptical histories of occultism, The Occult Underground (1974) and The Occult Establishment (1976). In 1980, The Harmonious Circle, Webb’s study of G. I. Gurdjieff, P. D. Ouspensky, and their followers had just been published, and Webb’s career was looking good. He was a regular contributor to Encounter and also to the encyclopedia Man, Myth, and Magic, and his performance at Trinity College, Cambridge, had been so stellar that a biennial James Webb Memorial Prize is awarded there in his honor.

Webb’s books combine a painstaking research into the occult and an ironic dismissal of it, the kind of know-it-all rationalism we might expect from a Cambridge graduate. But at the time of his suicide, Webb had changed his mind about the kinds of experiences he had chalked up to delusion, fantasy, and a post-Enlightenment craving for the irrational. In his last days, Webb was convinced that the nervous breakdown that cast him into suicidal madness had also revealed dimensions of reality that could only be called supernatural. He found himself “catapulted into a larger universe” filled with altered states of consciousness and profound visions of “cyclical time.”

The experience was not all revelation. Webb also showed the classic signs of paranoid schizophrenia. His publisher, he claimed, was persecuting him. Worse still, he was convinced that a certain group of French Freemasons had it in for him. Such remarks suggest Webb’s change of heart about the supernatural was nothing more than the pathetic result of his tragic breakdown. Yet the circumstances surrounding his death were unusual and raise the suspicion that the dividing line between madness and occult revelation may not be as clear cut as we suppose.

How and when Webb’s madness began are unclear; even as a schoolboy at Harrow he was considered brilliant but perhaps a little unstable. After his death, his widow—even more skeptical of the supernatural than he—refused to discuss the matter, preferring, understandably, to forget the tragic business. By most accounts Mary Webb was a no-nonsense, practical woman who loved her husband but had little insight into his brilliance and even less into his obsessions, and it is a fair guess that she may have felt that his interest in the occult was somehow responsible for his madness. That Webb married a woman with little of his intellectual spirit and less sensitivity to his experiences is one of the strange things about the affair. It does account, however, for his relationship with another woman, Joyce Collin-Smith. Many an unsympathetic wife has driven her husband into other arms, but in Webb’s case the attraction of the other woman wasn’t sexual but psychic.

Webb first encountered Joyce Collin-Smith in 1972. At the National Liberal Club in London, she gave a lecture to the Astrological Association on the life and work of her brother-in-law, Rodney Collin. Webb was interested in Rodney Collin because, as one of the main followers of Ouspensky, Collin would feature prominently in Webb’s book on Gurdjieff. Webb had come to the lecture intending to ask Joyce for an interview about her brother-in-law.

By the time she met Webb, Joyce Collin-Smith had run the gamut of spiritual teachers. In the 1950s she practiced the Gurdjieff “work” with Rodney Collin at his commune in the suburbs of Mexico City. Before this she had been involved with Dr. Frank Buchman, founder of Moral Rearmament. She was also a follower of Pak Subuh, the Indonesian mystic and founder of the Subud movement, which included J. G. Bennett among fellow “work” members. And, in the early days of the 1960s, she had been chauffeur and girl Friday to the Maharishi Mahesh Yogi before the Beatles discovered meditation and made the giggling guru a spiritual superstar. A former Fleet Street journalist, novelist, and officer in the Women’s Auxiliary Air Force, Joyce was old enough to be Webb’s mother; at the very least, she was an unusual candidate for spiritual adviser to a brainy twenty-six-year-old who found most of her pursuits pure hogwash.

And yet, at the very first meeting, Joyce knew Webb would play a large role in her life. She also knew he was fated for some strange destiny. As she recalled in her autobiography, Call No Man Master (1988), the minute she saw the tall, red-haired young man enter the auditorium, her “heart leapt.” It was not love at first sight; on the contrary, in Webb she recognized a sinister, terrifying figure from a repeated nightmare of her childhood. In her dreams, a tall, red-haired young schoolmaster asked her to fetch something from a forbidding tower. Frightened at entering the tower alone, she nevertheless obeyed. Halfway up, in a desolate, empty room, the schoolmaster, raving mad, charged in and threw himself at her. She woke up each night, sweating and terrified. Now, more than forty years later, the mad schoolmaster had come to her lecture.

Joyce watched as he took a seat in the last row. She then gave her lecture, speaking, she recalls, almost solely to him. At the end of her talk, as she spoke with some of the audience, Joyce half expected the “schoolmaster” to erupt into maniacal laughter. But when the shy, diffident young man approached and explained that he was writing a book on Gurdjieff and wanted to speak with her about her brother-in-law, she was surprised at his gentle, almost apologetic manner.

They developed an immediate rapport. In Joyce’s house in Sussex, they talked for hours about philosophy, religion, history, and her experiences with the occult. Precognitive dreams, visions, strange states of consciousness while practicing Transcendental Meditation and self-remembering, even communication with the dead. Webb was impressed. A brilliant scholar, his encounters with the occult had been strictly “armchair,” but it’s clear from Joyce’s account that he was also attracted to something else.

Webb’s family was well-off. Had he lived, Webb would have inherited a large estate at Blair Drummond, in Perthshire, Scotland. But relations with his family had soured over Mary. Class may have had something to do with it, but Webb’s mother and stepfather were certain she wasn’t right for him; when the couple did marry, it was against their wishes.

Estranged from his parents, finding little in common with Mary, Webb took refuge in his studies. His brilliance threw him far ahead of his contemporaries. Few could keep up with his discoveries; fewer still could speak intelligently about them. And now he had met someone who seemed to know all about the occult from the inside, someone who also took an immediate liking to him and gave him encouragement and approval. Joyce quickly became a kind of surrogate mother for Webb. He welcomed the ease and naturalness in her household, so different from the tension around his real parents. Later Joyce would claim that they had known each other in previous incarnations; this time they had met as a sort of mother and son.

Inevitably, Joyce compared their astrological charts; both were Capricorns with Leo rising. The points of contact among their stars suggested to Joyce that James could indeed have been her son—had she had one—and the association with the mad schoolmaster faded from her consciousness. Their rapport deepened; her affection for the young scholar grew. More and more, Joyce was reminded of her relationship with Rodney Collin, who, as we shall see, also died in mysterious circumstances. As their philosophical conversations continued, they began to experience a kind of telepathy; each knew the other’s thoughts before a word was spoken. Their rapid exchange developed into a kind of verbal shorthand. Repeatedly, Joyce felt a curious sensation of déjà vu. At one point, during tea on a summer afternoon, Webb asked Joyce for “another piece of cherry cake.” Immediately Joyce was reminded of another childhood dream, this one involving a Tibetan background, a fantasized “brother,” and cherries. Increasingly she felt that they were indeed “two beings who had incarnated within reach of each other many times in different roles.”

Several months later Joyce’s husband’s ill health forced her to sell their Sussex house, and they moved to a cottage in the New Forest. Money was scarce; she had to take what work she could find, mostly lecturing and doing horoscopes. Not long after, she got a call from “Jamie,” as she called Webb. He wanted to double-check some material for the Gurdjieff book. He and Mary had married recently and had just returned from a honeymoon in the Orient. Joyce was glad to hear from him, but thought he sounded strange, “rather low and glum,” unlike his usual cheerful self. Webb wanted to visit her, but Joyce put him off; her husband’s health would make things difficult. But she promised to ring him soon about lunching with him in London.

Something in Webb’s call made Joyce check his chart again. She saw the familiar qualities, “fiery, vigorous, and tenacious,” so much like her own. But there was something else. Webb’s stars indicated a depressive tendency, an inclination to withdraw deeper into himself as he got older. She didn’t know it at the time, but Webb had just done that. He had amassed an incredible library and spent more and more time alone, immersed in his research. Friends and literary acquaintances saw less and less of him. His marriage, too, seemed shaky. Webb worked well into the night, often falling asleep at his desk, amidst volumes of Jacob Boehme, Raymond Lully, and other occult philosophers. What had been an admirable dedication to work now seemed a full-fledged obsession. Joyce warned Jamie of the dangers but, like any good Faust, he ignored them.

The next time they spoke, Joyce felt certain something had happened. It was then that Webb told her of being persecuted by his publishers and raved about the French Freemasons. He was ill with flu, and Joyce urged him to relax. But Webb’s mental deterioration had begun. He didn’t ring again and, to her later regret, Joyce’s own affairs prevented her from telephoning him. The next time she heard from him, Webb had already plunged into madness.

“My life has just emerged from a nightmare,” Webb wrote some time later. “I had a full-scale nervous breakdown, with hallucinations, visions, and a fine repertoire of subjectively supernatural experiences. Hoist with my own petard, some would say.” The cool rationalism that called occultism a “flight from reason” seemed helpless before the kinds of experiences he had gone through. “Despite the undoubtedly hallucinatory nature of many of my experiences,” he wrote, “a residue remains which I simply have to take seriously.” He tried to fit what was happening to him into some system, calling on Gnostic notions of Aeons and Hindu kalpas. But the visions were too vivid and extraordinary to be neatly filed into some metaphysic. The gist of them had to do with time. The world had become a kind of Heraclitean flux. He had seen “molecules.”

Webb’s letter was postmarked Durisdeer in Dumfrieshire. He and Mary had left London and had moved into a renovated old church. Joyce wrote back immediately. Webb replied at great length; he thought she had rebuffed him in his hour of need. His account of his breakdown was harrowing. He had been in and out of various hospitals, had been in the hands of several psychiatrists, was doped on Largactil (sold in the United States as Thorazine) and had only just escaped electroshock therapy. He had given up writing and was just barely keeping his sanity. Joyce berated herself for not responding sooner. She soon made up for this. During the next five months she and Webb exchanged a lengthy and extraordinary correspondence. Two or three times a week several pages of Webb’s increasingly wild account reached her door.

He wrote of a “shattering vision of the wheel of life.” He saw his previous incarnations. He became convinced that there is a “principle of consciousness which is not merely the result of a congeries of experience”—what Ouspensky had called the linga sharira, the “long body” that extends through countless lives. But the worst was that there seemed to be no stability. Things would not “stand still.” No sooner did he look at something than he saw its entire history, its present, past, and future. An oak was an acorn, then a rotting mass of mulch. Although he believed there was a way out, Webb shrank from the knowledge that we are all “imprisoned in the coils of cyclical time.”

Finally Joyce could offer something more than sympathy. She was familiar with these visions. During her time with the Maharishi, she had experienced the same phenomena, the result of too much Transcendental Meditation. It had brought her to the brink of suicide. She suggested exercises to keep his mind focused in time. These helped for a while, but increasingly Webb’s thoughts turned to death. He wrote to Joyce that “Rodney Collin was quite right about the importance of dying properly.” He also said that he had “revised my opinion about the manner of Ouspensky’s death.”

Strange deaths were indeed not uncommon among professors of Gurdjieff’s “work.” When Gurdjieff died in 1949, the doctor performing the autopsy declared that his internal organs were in such bad condition that he should have been dead years before; Gurdjieff had apparently willed himself to stay alive. Ouspensky’s death was even stranger. He was obsessed with time; his particular fascination was eternal recurrence, the notion that, with slight variations, our lives repeat, over and over. The only possibility of escape is in becoming more conscious. In his last days, a sick and dying Ouspensky visited various favorite sites, fixing them in his mind, in order to remember them in his next recurrence. Weird psychic phenomena occurred; in his efforts to die consciously, witnesses report that Ouspensky had become telepathic.

And when, on October 2, 1947, Ouspensky passed away, Rodney Collin, his closest disciple, locked himself in the room next to his master’s and did not emerge until a week later. He told his wife—and Joyce—that he had been in communication with Ouspensky the entire time. Nearly ten years later, on May 3, 1956, Collin himself would die after falling from a tower in Cusco, Peru. He was found in a position resembling the crucified Christ; earlier he had prayed that a crippled peasant boy be cured, and he had told his wife that he had offered God his body in exchange. There is some suspicion that he too had attempted to “die consciously.” Webb had written skeptically about the events around Ouspensky’s and Collin’s death. Now he had reason to change his mind.

Joyce considered the possibility that Jamie was going through some kind of self-inflicted initiatory process. She knew that their conversations had opened him to the reality of the occult. His armor of skeptical rationality had cracked; in his letters he spoke of curious precognitive dreams and of a kind of Gnostic personal myth. He had long fantasized that he was a member of a crew whose spaceship had crashed on an alien planet. Enslaved by the natives, they soon forgot their past. But occasionally a dim memory stirred, the crew members recognized each other, and they recalled their mission. “The tragedy,” he told her, “is infinitely far distant, the adventure infinitely long. And we are ageless, ageless.”

Had Webb been allowed to explore these intuitions, it’s possible he may have survived. But after several months of having him around the house, Mary forced him to take a job. They didn’t need the money. Understandably, she felt that some work might give her husband some ballast. But she really had no insight into his plight and little patience for his talk about the soul, later telling Joyce that she considered all that sort of thing “rubbish.” A copywriting job for an Edinburgh advertising agency was not quite what Webb needed. The uncongenial atmosphere had the opposite effect, throwing him deeper into alienation. His letters to Joyce became wilder. He was researching a book about esoteric movements in Scotland but he “couldn’t get the pattern of it anymore.” More and more, he believed, someone was after him because he knew too much,

Finally, Joyce decided she had to see him. By this time their telepathic link had increased. She had visions of him at his desk and could feel a pain in the back of his neck, a vulnerable spot he shared with both her and Rodney Collin. She could hear him crying at night and in her mind reached out to comfort him. Although she had never been there, she had images of the grounds around the house; later, after Webb’s death, she saw that these had been accurate. In a few weeks, she and her husband would go to Scotland for their holiday. She decided then to see Jamie.

It was too late. On the afternoon before their trip, Joyce heard Webb’s voice calling her name. “I’m coming,” she answered mentally. Then something like an enormous explosion went off in her head. At once she told her husband, “Something is wrong with Jamie.” He said it was her imagination. Incredibly, she didn’t telephone. When they arrived at their holiday cottage there was a message to ring Mary. At three o’clock the previous day, Webb had shot himself. Joyce later discovered the immediate cause was a domestic quarrel.

Visiting Webb’s parents, Joyce discovered the full extent of his madness. One night, he crouched before the fire at their estate, repeating the Lord’s Prayer over and over and muttering repeatedly, “What is it all about?” On another occasion, he ran out into the night in a state of hysteria. He waded waist-deep across a river to reach Dunblane Cathedral twelve miles away, where he banged furiously on the door. Oblivious to those around him, for a few weeks the “mad schoolmaster” was certifiably insane.

Inevitably, Joyce blamed herself for not seeing him sooner. Jamie had plunged into a dark night of the soul, and she hadn’t been there for him. Her sense of guilt, then, may account for what followed. She began to feel Webb’s presence. First he asked her to visit his mother. Then he wanted her to carry on his work. Two visits to a medium convinced her that some part of Jamie had survived. Material emerged unknown to her that later proved unsettlingly accurate. The voice told her that he “would come to her,” asking that she get his books from Mary, who “doesn’t understand them.” “Make a replica of me,” it said.

At first Joyce was thankful for these messages. But then she felt that something was “not right” about them. This was not the “whole” Jamie, merely bits and pieces of him. Jamie, or some part of him, didn’t know he was dead and wouldn’t “move on.” Joyce began to feel that she was being “taken over.” Eventually, a clergyman friend of spiritualist persuasion offered to say a requiem to help Webb relinquish his attachment to the world. Satisfied that the rite would not interfere with them finding each other in the next incarnation, Joyce agreed. As she and the clergyman read the prayers in the candle-lit chapel, she felt something lift up from her consciousness and take flight. Jamie had moved on.

There was one other curious phenomenon. During her first wave of grief, Joyce found herself crying aloud, “Why didn’t you help him?” In the depths of her anguish she heard a voice that said, “I did.” At the same time she saw a face, dark-haired, dark-eyed, with a deep, penetrating gaze. She thought it might have been Rudolf Steiner. At the time of his suicide, Webb had been commissioned to write a book about Steiner, a task that later went to Colin Wilson. Wilson remarked that if Webb’s earlier books were anything to go by, his book on Steiner would surely have been skeptical. Considering Webb’s strange and tragic death, had he survived, I wonder if Wilson would have been right.


Revolutionaries of the Soul

 Gary Lachman

Meister Eckhart and The Via Negativa

 

While Dante was creating perhaps the greatest initiatory work of the medieval via positiva, a German contemporary of his was laying the groundwork for perhaps the greatest medieval expression of the opposite path, the via negativa. As mentioned earlier, the esoteric and the mystic paths, though related, are not identical. The esotericist seeks the experience and knowledge of the intermediary planes that lie between the material world and the One; he is interested in the Imaginal World, and in the different levels of reality and consciousness it encompasses. The mystic has little interest in anything but union with the divine. Both ways are rooted in the Neoplatonic ladder of being, but while one is interested in mapping out each step of the way, the other wants to reach the top by the shortest route possible.

While Dante projected an entire cosmos in order to contain his beatific vision, the theologian and philosopher Meister Eckhart (1260?–1327?) worked to empty his consciousness of everything but the immediate presence of God. Eckhart’s focus on the direct and unimpeded experience of the divine exemplified the great wave of lay mysticism and spirituality that swept through the Rhineland in the fourteenth century and troubled an unstable church already challenged by the Cathars and Knights Templar. As the Mysteries of antiquity provided a more powerful emotional experience than the routine worship of the gods, so too the grassroots spirituality fed by Eckhart’s vision offered a more transformative form of devotion than the increasingly legalistic strictures of the church.

This independent spirituality attracted many followers and took different forms, such as the contemplative Friends of God, led by Eckhart’s followers, John Tauler (1300–1361) and Henry Suso (1295–1365), and the more antinomian Brethren of the Free Spirit. The church has never taken kindly to amateur spirituality, believing that such matters should be left in the hands of professionals, and it took steps to dampen what it called “enthusiasm” whenever it appeared. In 1311, the Brethren of the Free Spirit were declared heretical by Pope Clement V—who ordered the arrest of the Templars—and accordingly persecuted. The less rambunctious Friends of God were not persecuted; they in fact remained within the church and were a kind of response to the Dionysian revels of the Brethren of the Free Spirit, although the fact that they died out after only two generations may have saved them from the Brethren’s fate. Along with the Black Death and the Hundred Years’ War (1337–1453), the inability of the church to accommodate a more living spirituality was a factor adding to the turbulence and chaos of the late Middle Ages. The time was rife with a sense of imminent disaster and apocalypse. The end of the world, many believed, was coming. A century earlier, the Calabrian monk and mystic Joachim of Fiore (1135–1202) had prophesized that a new age of the Holy Spirit was on its way, following the ages of the Father and the Son. Mankind, Joachim said, would then achieve direct contact with God, and no longer have need for the church, a prediction the Brethren of the Free Spirit, who were followers of Joachim, had tried to make true. Rome was not happy with this, but Dante put Joachim in Paradise, and the fact that the beginning of the age of the Holy Spirit coincided with the purported year of Meister Eckhart’s birth, 1260, may not have been entirely the work of chance.

Dante and Eckhart shared much in common; for one thing, the combination of mystical insight and intense intellectual hunger, although in each the expression of this union took different forms. Both also had trouble with the authorities. Dante, we know, was exiled. In his later life, Meister Eckhart was accused of heresy, tried, and was found guilty, although he died before receiving the verdict. He was accused of pantheistic tendencies; like Eriugena, he spoke of nature’s “manifest theophanies” and preached that there was no need to hear sermons, “for every creature is full of God and is a book” and that “God is present in a stone or a log; only they do not know it.”47 For such beliefs, he was posthumously found guilty of being “deceived by the father of lies,” and, like Socrates and Suhrawardi, of “sowing thorns and thistles among the faithful and even the simple folk” by the men who tried him.48 Yet Eckhart’s remarks are not strange or threatening to anyone with a sense of Schwaller de Lubicz’s “intelligence of the heart” or Bergson’s intuition or the “participatory” mode of consciousness associated with the right brain. Yet these subtle insights are invariably lost on those who view life literally.

In some sense we can say that the parallel positive and negative ways, rooted in Dionysius the Areopagite and embodied in Dante and Eckhart, reached a kind of culmination at this point, just as Europe was about to undergo the transformation that would eventually lead to the modern world. As Evelyn Underhill said in her classic work Mysticism, “These two giants stand side by side at the opening of the [fourteenth] century; perfect representations of the Teutonic and Latin instinct for transcendental reality.”49 For Teutonic and Latin, we can read via negativa and via positiva, a differentiation that would inform the Protestant Reformation in the sixteenth century and which would change the face of Europe.

Although supressed after his death and forgotten for centuries, Meister Eckhart’s work was rediscovered in the nineteenth century, mostly through the work of the German Romantic philosopher and Christian theosopher Franz von Baader (1765–1841), and he has since become a central figure in modern western mysticism. Some recent scholars suggest that Eckhart’s true lineage is within the German philosophical tradition, and wish to save him from the dubious world of New Age mysticism. Yet the German philosophical tradition itself contains many who were fellow travelers with mystics, so the differentiation is perhaps more academic than useful. In recent times, Eckhart has been enormously influential, and figures as disparate as the philosopher Martin Heidegger, the Zen scholar D. T. Suzuki, the contemporary spiritual teacher Eckhart Tolle, and the Christian priest and theologian Matthew Fox find common ground in their inheritance from Meister Eckhart.

A FAITHFUL HERETIC

Eckhart von Hochheim was born around 1260 in Tambach, a Thuringian village in northeast Germany near the town of Erfurt. Little is known of his childhood and family life; some accounts say he was the son of a knight, yet others dismiss this. It is possible he may have studied in Paris as a youth under the Aristotelian philosopher Siger of Brabant.50 What we do know is that at around sixteen, Eckhart entered the Dominican novitiate at Erfurt. In 1280, he was sent to the famous Dominican House of Studies, the Studium Generale, at Cologne, which was founded by Albertus Magnus. Eckhart was there for only a short time before Albertus Magnus died, but accounts say he met the great philosopher and theologian and was taught by some of his students, one of whom was Thomas Aquinas. Albertus Magnus brought the ideas of Plato, Aristotle, and Plotinus and the theology of Christianity, Islam, and Judaism into a creative synthesis, a version of the perennial philosophy; he was also, as mentioned, one of the first in the West to study alchemy. Eckhart absorbed this heady curriculum, which also included the work of Porphyry, Proclus, Augustine, Origen, Dionysius, and Eriugena. Although Albertus Magnus’s Neoplatonism was soon eclipsed by the scholasticism of his pupil Aquinas, the mystic spirituality he fostered had a powerful influence on the Christians of the Rhineland.

Eckhart proved a brilliant student and able administrator, and following his ordination as a priest in 1293, he went on to have a remarkable career in the church. In Paris, he worked as a lecturer and studied for his degree as master of theology. Between 1293 and 1302, when he was granted the degree, which was the highest academic honor at the time—and from which his title of “meister” comes—he was made prior of Erfurt and also vicar of Thuringia. Other titles came, including being made regent master at the St. Jacques Dominican House of Study, the First Provincial of Saxony, the vicar of Bohemia, as well as professor of theology. Eckhart is generally considered a mystic; if he was one, he was in the tradition of Emanuel Swedenborg and Rudolf Steiner, two other men deemed mystics who were also highly efficient organizers.

Eckhart was put in charge of reforming several of the Dominican Houses and he was also made responsible for the spiritual guidance of Dominican nuns and several women’s lay spiritual groups, such as the Beguines. These popular women’s groups reflect both the turn toward the feminine and the interest in independent spirituality common to the time; as one commentator remarked, they contributed to “one of the most spectacular upsurges of mystical spirituality in the history of Europe.”51 Not surprisingly, Clement V, who had suppressed the Templars and declared the Brethren of the Free Spirit heretical, suppressed the Beguines, and in 1310, the mystic Marguerite of Porete was burned at the stake for heresy in Paris. Among other things, she was accused of promoting the “heresy of the free spirit,” a charge laid against Eckhart as well. Marguerite, along with other women mystics, such as Hildegard of Bingen (1098–1179) and Mechthild of Magdeburg (1207–1294), a Beguine, was an influence on Meister Eckhart’s beliefs. Eckhart believed in an equality of the sexes and promoted a casual friendship between men and women, in contrast to the more sharply segregated policy of the church. He was also, as Albertus Magnus was, open to insights from other faiths, and was conversant with Jewish thinkers like Moses Maimonides and the Sufi saint Ibn ‘Arabi, among others. Much of what we know of Eckhart’s teachings comes to us from the many nuns and Beguines who memorized his sermons and wrote them down, although in their efforts to erase Eckhart’s work, the Inquisitors seized many of these accounts and destroyed them. Were it not for the efforts of these spiritual women, the little we have of Eckhart’s writings might have been even less.

What troubled the church was that Eckhart preached the same sort of union with God that the Sufi mystics sang of under the cover of a mysticism of the erotic. “God and I are one,” Eckhart told his congregation. “Through knowledge I take God into myself, through love I enter into God.”52 Other sayings make the same point. “The eye through which I see God is the same eye through which God sees me; my eye and God’s eye are one eye, one seeing, one knowing, one love.” “Our Lord says to every living soul ‘I became man for you. If you do not become God for me, you do me wrong.’”53 Probably the most well-known, as well as the most threatening from the church’s perspective, is “God needs me as much as I need him,” an insight that achieves the dual heresy of diminishing God’s omnipotence while emphasizing man’s importance.54 This sort of union with the divine has always been frowned upon by the church—understandably, as it subverts its authority, although Eckhart made a spirited defense of his faithfulness and orthodoxy and, as in the case of other heretics, much of what he says can be found in scripture.55 Yet as we’ve seen throughout this book, “dynamic” religion, meaning personal and experiential, does not get along well with the “static” variety, and it is usually the dynamic individuals who suffer from this dissonance.

According to Eckhart, the fundamental ground of all being is God—or, in Neoplatonic terms, the One—and through a process of letting go, of emptying ourselves of everything that stands in the way of recognizing and experiencing this—the via negativa—we can come to know God and to be One with Him. Or to be more precise, not to know God, which we cannot, as he is beyond knowledge, but to love him and to feel his love. This process of inner emptying is at the heart of the anonymous fourteenth-century mystical work The Cloud of Unknowing, whose title encapsulates the essence of the via negativa, and whose aptly unknown author was, like Eckhart, influenced by Dionysius the Areopagite. The aim of this work was to instruct a novice on the essentials of the contemplative life. Physical withdrawal, in the clichéd sense of retiring to a cave, is not essential. This work can and should be done in the midst of life. Eckhart himself said that if it was a choice between mystical rapture and giving a sick person soup, one should forget the rapture and get the soup. What was important, both for Eckhart and the unknown author of The Cloud of Unknowing, was “psychological withdrawal,” a letting go of attachments, possessions, relationships, and personal concerns. As the old Sufi saying has it, one should be in the world, but not of it. As the psychologist Ira Progoff remarked, “the aim of the work is to lead beyond all theological conceptions and doctrines, and beyond all attachments to religious objects and observances.”56 We should, the anonymous author tells us, learn to love God without his characteristics; love him not because he is good, loving, or merciful, but simply because he is (the similarity to the Neoplatonic conception seems fairly clear here). “It is good to think about the kindness of God, and to love Him and to praise Him for it, [but] it is far better to think about his naked being and to praise Him and love Him for Himself.”57As with Eckhart, this “ground” of “naked being” is the same as our own, and by losing one’s self in order to find it, one finds one’s “true self,” as it is. This is best achieved by getting rid of everything that can take our minds away from this. As Progoff writes, “Attachment to the symbolic forms and sacred figures of man’s religions can easily become an impediment in the ultimate quest of the spirit.”58 The philosopher Alfred North Whitehead said, “Religion is what the individual does with his solitariness,” an insight with which Eckhart and those that followed him would agree.59

Eckhart had different names for this process of getting rid of whatever comes between oneself and God, but probably the most well-known is Gelassenheit, a German word that does not have an exact English equivalent but can be understood as “detachment,” “releasement,” or simply “letting go.” It plays a central role in the philosophy of Martin Heidegger, whose concern with our “forgetfulness of being” is close to Eckhart’s own vision, with his attention to Istigkeit, or the sheer “is-ness” of things, and it is also used by Iain McGilchrist to characterize the right brain’s mode of letting things be as they are, as opposed to the left brain’s tendency to manipulate them into how it thinks they should be. The “dispassionate equanimity” related to the Greek notion of ataraxia (Chapter Three) comes close, but is too negative. We can see it as a positive letting-go in order to let things be as they are. “When a man’s heart grieves for nothing, then a man has the essence and the nature and the substance and the wisdom and the joy and all that God has,” Eckhart tells us. “Then the very being of the son of God is ours and in us we attain to the very essence of God,” he says of this kind of detachment.60 One cannot help but think of the Buddhist quieting of desire and of countless “dropouts” who quit the rat race in order to find a better life. “I have no money, no resources, no hopes; I am the happiest man alive,” Henry Miller declared at the start of his most famous work, Tropic of Cancer, an account of la vie bohème in the Paris of the 1930s.61 Eckhart might not have appreciated the book, but he would have agreed with Miller’s joy.

Yet while Eckhart and those who followed him continued on their solitary path toward the “dark brilliance” and “empty fullness” of the divine, the western mind was gearing up for a trip down the via positiva unlike any it had seen for some time.

Gary Lachman 

The Secret Teachers of the Western World