To be is to be contingent: nothing of which it can be said that "it is" can be alone and independent. But being is a member of paticca-samuppada as arising which contains ignorance. Being is only invertible by ignorance.

Destruction of ignorance destroys the illusion of being. When ignorance is no more, than consciousness no longer can attribute being (pahoti) at all. But that is not all for when consciousness is predicated of one who has no ignorance than it is no more indicatable (as it was indicated in M Sutta 22)

Nanamoli Thera

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

A Stink of Zen

 Convinced that he has found the non-path to true insight - Zen, like Tao, is a way of non-doing - Smith follows Ryder’s advice and signs on as a fire lookout on a Northwest mountain top. In real life, Kerouac did the same. In a tiny forest service cabin on Desolation Peak, part of the North Cascade mountain range that cuts through California, Oregon, Washington and British Columbia, Kerouac lived alone for sixty-three days. The idea was to get enlightened or at least have visions. The universe had other plans. A kind of lunacy without the Zen descended on Kerouac. Peering at the cold, snowbound expanse of silent rock, mute forest and humbling peaks, Kerouac felt he was looking at a mirror. What he saw was a void, otherwise known as Jack Kerouac. No booze, no drugs, no sex, no cars, stone cold sober, Kerouac had an unexpected encounter with himself. The unreadable tracts of spontaneous prose that make up Desolation Angels (1960) is one result of Kerouac’s unsuccessful attempt to capture strange forces. The ‘anything goes’ ethic of his Beat Zen philosophy, mirrored in his life, deteriorated, like Dean Moriarity, into an uninteresting babble. Sadly, Kerouac would soon follow.

A STINK OF ZEN

Zen started in China in the sixth century AD. Its founding father, the fierce-faced Bodhidharma, was an Indian monk who combined snarling aggressiveness with Marx Brothers inanity. Once so angry at himself for falling asleep while meditating, legend has it that in a rage Bodhidharma sliced off his eyelids. These fell to the ground and became the seeds of the first tea plant.

By the early sixties, Zen and another kind of ‘tea’, marijuana, which had reached the Beats via the jazz scene, had become the intellectual flavour of the month, its serious study introduced to English speakers through the works of the Japanese scholar Daisetz Teitaro Suzuki.k Suzuki’s Essays in Zen Buddhism (1927) and other works lent an academic respectability to ideas about satori, koans, and zazen that was as far from Kerouac’s naive ‘anything goes’ approach as possible. Yet Suzuki’s works, applauded by Western orientalists, were nearly unreadable, and clearly lacked the common touch. Some Western thinkers saw in them little more than a philosophical ‘yellow peril’. The title of a section of Arthur Koestler’s The Lotus and the Robot (1961), a study of India and Japan, says as much: ‘A Stink of Zen’.

Koestler, who would find Timothy Leary’s brand of mysticism equally ersatz, and who would by the end of the decade follow Huxley as a mainstream proponent of parapsychology,12 saw little in Zen and Suzuki besides obfuscation and fudgy morality. Highlighting Zen’s ethical relativism, Koestler quotes Suzuki’s remark that ‘Zen is . . . extremely flexible’ and ‘may be found wedded to anarchism or fascism, communism or democracy, atheism or idealism’.13 Beyond good and evil - and any other categories of the rational mind - Zen made no distinction between ‘this’ or ‘that’. In the words of Seng-Ts’an, the third Zen Patriarch, who lived in the sixth century AD, ‘The conflict between right and wrong / Is the sickness of the mind’. Koestler rightly points out that with statements like this, context is everything. To a Taoist monk, bemused at the neurotic fastidiousness of Confucian decorum, it suggests a cheerful unconcern with pedantic conventions. To a sixties mystic-hedonist, it meant ‘do what thou wilt’ or ‘everything is permitted’ or ‘there’s no such thing as right and wrong’, convenient slogans condoning an assortment of appetites. Charlie Manson often appealed to their wisdom. In a later work Koestler pointed out that Eugen Herrigel, whose Zen in the Art of Archery (1953) would become a New Age classic, had been a member of the Nazi party.14 The Nazis, of course, were partial to their own brands of lunacy, and were less than hung up about right and wrong.

The lotus of Koestler’s title is the blissed-out Indian mystic, high on nirvana; the robot is the highly trained, unreflective automaton that the practice of Zen seemed geared to produce. Koestler’s mordant wit was paradigmatic of the tack late Enlightenment man would take as the threat from the East encroached more and more upon Western soil, and a masochistic mea culpa ensued from Western lips that continues in today’s politically correct witch hunts. Increasingly, as the appeal of taut reason lessened, that of an easy, immediate intuition increased. Koestler and other champions of the mind found themselves in less and less demand.

One West Coast Zen lunatic, however, took argument with Kerouac’s brand of wild satori. One of the less loony characters to appear in The Dharma Bums is Arthur Whane. At a party at which people have decided to strip - one of Ginsberg’s less endearing antics-a smartly dressed Whane carries on a serious conversation about Buddhism without batting an eye at his two naked interlocutors. When asked what Buddhism meant to him he answered, ‘Buddhism is getting to know as many people as possible.’ Getting to know as many people as possible is something Alan Watts, on whom Kerouac based the prim Arthur Whane, certainly tried to do.

THE WISDOM OF IRRESPONSIBILITY

Born in Chislehurst, Kent, in 1915, Alan Watts (1915-1973) was, like Huxley, Heard and Isherwood, another British transplant to the Golden State. His journey to the East started early. In 1930, Edmond Holmes’s Creed of Buddha came into the fifteen-year-old Alan’s hands. In it was a pamphlet about Buddhism which mentioned a Buddhist Lodge in London. Alan wrote to the author, Christmas Humphreys, who turned out to be the director of the Lodge. An invitation was secured. Humphreys introduced him to the writings of D. T. Suzuki, and not long after Watts met the man himself.

When Watts met Suzuki, the Zen master was in his late sixties, a tiny man who wore pebble glasses and a bow tie. Suzuki exuded a air of Zen that was clear and unmistakable. His writing, however, was something else. Many readers found his books baffling, and orthodox Japanese scholars considered him a dilettante. Watts’s first act in his new life as Zen ambassador was to write a book, expounding Suzuki’s doctrine. In a month, the nineteen-year-old Alan produced the enthusiastic and highly derivative The Spirit of Zen (1935).

Over the years Watts fine-tuned his teaching. But all of his very popular and influential books share the same basic premise, the idea that there is no need to strive for enlightenment, because we are all already enlightened. This satori on the pointlessness of spiritual struggle seems to have guided Watts over several ethical hurdles with little strain.

One such was his marriage to the American Eleanor Everett, the first of three. They met at a meeting of the Buddhist Lodge in 1937, when Eleanor’s mother, the rich Chicago socialite Ruth Everett, gave a talk about her experiences in a Zen monastery in Kyoto. They had little in common, but Eleanor attracted Alan for several reasons, one of which was her eagerness to have a sexual adventure. But the real magnet was Ruth. Ruth Everett knew a great deal about Zen, and had great personal power, something Watts sensed as he talked with her at the lodge. She also had a lot of money. But she was unattainable as an erotic partner. That left Eleanor.

In 1938 Watts married an already pregnant eighteen-year-old Eleanor, and Ruth installed the couple in a huge Edwardian maisonette in Courtfield Gardens, decorated in opulent oriental style. Here Watts practised calligraphy, edited a Buddhist journal, prepared lectures on Zen, and thought about his next book. He also helped Eleanor spend her hefty allowance. Then a little man with a moustache threw a spanner in the works. In late 1938, as Eleanor approached term, she and Alan left Courtfield Gardens for Manhattan. A war with Hitler was inevitable, and Alan had no intention of fighting.

In New York, Alan took the next step on his path. Ruth had just begun studying with the Zen roshi Sokei-an-Sasaki at his small walk-up temple on 74th Street. After hearing his mother-in-law speak of the remarkable teacher, Watts went for a visit.

Watts referred to the practice of zazen scornfully as ‘sitting on your ass’. Now he was introduced to it by a master. Impressed by the older man’s style and simplicity of life, Watts asked to be his student. Sokei-an agreed. Sokei-an’s main method of teaching was sanzen, an interview during which the teacher would set the student a koan, rather as the Maharishi would dole out mantras later on.

Watts soon found his koans a bore. They produced no enlightenment, and after working away at one for several months, in a fit of frustration he shouted at his teacher that his interpretation was right. Sokei-an disagreed. That was the end of Watts’s stint as his student.

One koan, however, was becoming hard to ignore: how to make a living. Watts solved the problem by becoming an Episcopalian priest. Although his friends were stunned at this decision, the eloquent Watts argued that he wasn’t really abandoning Buddhism, as all paths led to the same goal, and what really mattered was that he celebrate the mystery that all religions embodied . . . The fact that by 1941 he was in danger of being drafted for the US armed service, and that as a minister he would be exempt, may have had something to do with it too. In 1944, Watts was ordained an Episcopalian priest in the Church of the Atonement, Evanston, Illinois.

Watts took to his ministry with gusto, and their home at Canterbury House became a location for wild parties. Watts once attached a petrol-soaked sanitary napkin to a helium balloon, lit it and sent it across Lake Michigan. The police and local radio stations received reports of a flying saucer. But Watts’s determination to fit into his suburban environment was doomed from the start. The reason was something that would occupy Watts from then on: sex.

In June, 1950, Eleanor wrote to her friend, Bishop Conk-ling, who had secured Watts’s entry into the church. Eleanor had fled to New York, taking the children to her mother, and had put herself under the care of a psychiatrist. She was also seeing a priest. Her reason, she told the Bishop, was that Alan was a sex maniac.

He masturbated daily, drew pornographic pictures, read pornography, and had a taste for ‘various tortures’ which he inflicted upon himself in order to achieve orgasm.15 But that wasn’t all. Watts, having confessed his appetites, asked Eleanor to beat him. She refused. He found himself looking to other women for satisfaction. In typical suburban fashion, this led to an affair with the babysitter, Dorothy de Witt, who would eventually become Watts’s second wife.

But Eleanor herself was no saint. When it became clear that Watts and Dorothy were sleeping together, Eleanor sought solace in a younger man, with whom she would have a son. When Eleanor announced that now she too had a lover, she expected Watts to act the jealous husband. But Watts was pleased with the development and suggested they live together in a ménage à quatre. By 1947, their daughter Joan was moved out of her room to make way for the new arrangement. When the affair blew up, Watts wrote one of his most famous books, the aptly named The Wisdom of Insecurity (1954).

In San Francisco Watts met an old London acquaintance, Frederic Spiegelberg. He asked Watts to join his American Academy of Asian Studies, whose aim, at least in Watts’s mind, became ‘the practical transformation of human consciousness’.16 Michael Murphy and Richard Price, the founders of Esalen, attended lectures, as did Gary Snyder. Another student, Lock McCorkle, went on to be a major figure in EST. Around this time Watts started broadcasting on a local Berkeley radio station, KPFA, and appeared on the educational television station KQED. He also took to wearing a kimono and fooling around with other women. Dorothy, meanwhile, expected another child.

In 1957 the Academy’s backer withdrew support and, at forty-two, Watts once again found himself jobless. Nevertheless, his reputation was growing. In the spring of 1958 he lectured at the C. G. Jung Institute in Zurich; during the trip he met Jung himself. One result was Watts’s influential Psychotherapy East and West (1961), in which he argues that the Hindu doctrine of maya did not refer to the illusory character of the sensual world - the traditional understanding - but pointed instead to the false constraints of society. Even if his argument didn’t hold water where Hinduism was concerned - its caste system was one of the most conservative social structures in history - it fitted in well with the anti-authoritarianism rising up among sixties youth.

But by this time the marriage to Dorothy was going down, and his relationship with his children - of whom there were now six - was practically non-existent. The comforts of Mill Valley, a suburb of San Francisco, where he now lived, began to grate. Goodly quantities of vodka helped; he was succumbing to the alcoholism that would eventually kill him in 1973. But as with so many other changes in his life, Watts needed a woman to act both as magnet and comforter. In 1959, while teaching in New York, he met one.

Mary Jane Yates - ‘Jano’, in Watts’s autobiography - was a student; they got to know one another over meals in Greenwich Village. Following the line of least resistance, they became lovers. Soon after Watts left Dorothy - who was again pregnant - his six children, and the hells of suburbia for his new lover. One of Watts’s books is entitled This is It. Maybe it was.

The seeds of the counterculture, planted by Huxley, Miller, the Beats, and Watts himself, were sprouting, and Watts for once found himself in an environment for which he was absolutely suited. Escaping the middle-class suburban trap, in 1961 he and Jano moved into an old ferry boat moored at Sausalito, across the Bay from San Francisco. It was a floating sixties version of Henry Miller’s Villa Seurat. In fact, Watts shared it with the artist Jean Varda, one of Miller’s pals from Big Sur. Other friends were around too: Gary Snyder, Kerouac, and new friends like Timothy Leary, who Watts visited in Harvard. By this time Alan had taken LSD, and would even write a book about it next year, The Joyous Cosmology (1962). Although he liked Leary, Watts shook his head at the mess he found in Leary’s household, amazed that any one who had experienced the mystical consciousness stimulated by LSD could live in such squalor. Oh well. Live and let live. Things were looking up. It was early yet - the summer of love was still a few years away. But the party was definitely getting started.

Turn Off Your Mind 

Gary Lachman


PINK FLOYD The Art-School Dance and the Hexagram Shuffle

 

You have a tendency, when things are going well for you, to interrupt the flow of events and to turn away from it negatively. When you have slipped back far enough you again reverse yourself and attempt to regain what you purposefully let go. This line is the line of self-defeatism – not in extremis, but the defeatism of constant backsliding, the defeatism of fear of climax, fear of contemplation, fear of attainment. You remain guiltless because the impulse does not stem from inhumane ideals and harms no one but yourself.

I CHING, Hexagram 24, ‘Returning’

Rob Chapman 

Psychodelia and Other Colours 


It begins appropriately enough with a song about leaving. Long before they signed a contract with EMI, Pink Floyd recorded one of Syd Barrett’s earliest compositions, ‘Lucy Leave’. Its melody and chord sequence are firmly in the tradition of the spasmodically paced R&B that produced the Pretty Things’ ‘Midnight to Six Man’ and ‘Buzz the Jerk’, the Who’s ‘The Good’s Gone’ and countless other mod songs that now genuflect to another beat. ‘The Good’s Gone’ is sung by Roger Daltrey in a flat, artless sneer that doesn’t sit comfortably within his range. Like Daltrey, Barrett sings ‘Lucy Leave’ as if he’s in an inappropriate register, as if he’s approximating the requirements of a beat-group vocalist, as if he hasn’t found his voice yet – which, of course, he hasn’t. To anyone hearing this unreleased item from the Pink Floyd’s juvenilia days it will be clear why no one wanted to sign the band, or even offer them gigs on a regular basis. The changes are ramshackle and tentative. The whole thing lacks proficiency and polish. And those lyrics – ‘Fall away from me, Lucy’ – have a faintly hallucinatory edge that is completely out of synch with the standard pop vernacular of the time. When he sings, ‘Mean, treat me and done me harm, Lucy,’ Barrett sounds like he’s parodying R&B. Which in a way he is. The madcap laughed even then.

Like Pete Townshend, Syd Barrett was landed with the role of providing lead and rhythm guitar for his group and frequently fluctuated between the two, fluctuation being the name of the game by 1966. Barrett was also fluctuating between his studies at Camberwell School of Art and the occasional gig with his band mates in the Pink Floyd Sound, as they still sometimes called themselves. Art remained his first love and most people who knew him at this time regarded him as a painter who dabbled in music. Barrett had been a diligent and committed artist since his school days in Cambridge, where he used to attend extra Saturday-morning classes and frequently bunked off school lessons and cross-country runs so that he could go home and paint. Pink Floyd only made the great conceptual leap from R&B also-rans to improvisatory doyens of the English psychedelic underground once Barrett started to apply painterly techniques and philosophies to his guitar-playing. Again, like Townshend, Barrett was one of the few art students willing to put these principles into practice, and arguably he was the only one who articulated a fully realised conceptual connection between art-school methodology and pop appliqué. The cutting up and collaging of found materials (predominantly fairy tales and Mother Goose rhymes) was his greatest gift to pop music and would become part of the very fabric of the English psychedelic sound.

You sense new ideas in the air, a new atmosphere, a new excitement. You are almost at the point of accepting them and enjoying them. You have been won over gradually as this creative force has slowly permeated society and gradually has touched and influenced people you know.

HEXAGRAM 24

The Cambridge social milieu that Syd Barrett grew up in was not dissimilar to the one in Canterbury at around the same time. These were the children of parents whose politics ranged from progressive liberal to communist, the offspring of doctors, biochemists, university lecturers, artists, sculptors. Striving to find their own creative voices Barrett and his friends staged Happenings, read beat poetry and listened to free jazz. They went to see French, Italian and Polish new wave films. They dug Bo Diddley, the Stones and the Beatles, and they smoked pot. And at some point during 1964/5 they all started taking acid. Like Canterbury, Cambridge was a musical backwater. For all its intellectual wealth nobody expected a famous pop group to emerge from such cloistered confines. That’s what London was there for, and London was only a train ride away – the centre of everything and yet a world apart.

What Cambridge did have was comedy. Culturally, the first manifestation of the swinging sixties wasn’t rock and roll; it wasn’t even Beatlemania and the beat-group boom. It was the satire movement, and the origins of that were emerging courtesy of the Cambridge Footlights Club, in the shape of Peter Cook, Jonathan Miller, Eleanor Bron, John Wells, John Bird. Barrett already had a keen sense of the absurd, which was galvanised by his discovery of Cook, Dudley Moore, Miller and Alan Bennett. ‘He adored Peter Cook very early on, and that’s when we were fifteen,’ remembers Barrett’s former girlfriend, Libby Gausden, ‘but he adored the Goons too, and he would not go out until they had been on. We all used to meet at the Mill pub on Sundays, and he wouldn’t leave the house until the Goons had finished.’

This embracing of the absurd was fully formed by the time Barrett left school in 1962. In his final year he played the part of Mrs Martin in a dramatic-society production of Eugene Ionesco’s The Bald Prima Donna. Being an all-boys school the two female parts in the production were played by males, who were distinguished from the real male characters by wearing pinafores – ‘Although Syd indicated that he would have been more than happy to drag up for the part,’ the production’s producer Peter Baker informed me. Described by Ionesco as an anti-play, The Bald Prima Donna was a satire on the English comedy of manners. Its sustained semantic attack on bourgeois convention sat well with Barrett’s own finely honed disregard for social niceties. Ionesco’s stage instruction required Mrs Martin to speak ‘in a drawling monotonous voice, rather sing song without light or shade’. Not dissimilar, then, to the distinctively flattened timbre that Barrett would adopt once he became a pop performer. He settled on this singing style fairly rapidly and never bothered to develop it; sometimes slightly startled, sometimes hovering on the edge of a sneer, always well-mannered, it served him well from ‘Lucy Leave’ to his own eventual leaving. Mrs Martin’s speeches were full of meaningless exclamations that displayed the futility of language. For a sixteen-year-old boy busy soaking up every last morsel of life’s absurdities this was rich source material indeed.

As part of the questing spirit that typified Barrett’s wider circle in the early 1960s, his school friends Andrew Rawlinson and Paul Charrier started to hitch down to London on Friday nights after school. They had little money and nowhere to sleep, so they stayed up all weekend on a diet of coffee, pills and sugar. ‘What we came across was the outskirts of normal life,’ remembers Rawlinson. ‘One of the places we found was a cafe in Cromwell Road that was frequented by transvestites. They used to emerge at about eleven at night. It was a place for outcasts really. We weren’t outcasts like them; we were schoolboys trying to find where the big time was. I liked those people. Most of them were pretty damaged, I have to say, because there wasn’t the supportive culture for them.’

Regaled with tales of nocturnal trannies and outcasts, Barrett and his friends created their own bohemian clique. They still felt green and provincial in terms of what was happening (or what they assumed was happening) elsewhere, but in their own little enclave of stoned gatherings, gigs, parties, readings, screenings and Happenings a group consciousness began to develop which forged an identity very different to what was going on in any other town or city at the time. Gradually pretty much everyone from Barrett’s wider social circle drifted down to London. His school friend Roger Waters commenced his architectural degree at the Regent Street Poly and told Barrett that if he ever moved down to town, they should think about getting a band together. Waters went ahead and started without him anyway, forming embryonic bands with embryonic names: Sigma 6, the Megadeaths, the Screaming Abdabs, the Abdabs, the Tea Set.

In many ways Barrett’s rechristening of the band remains his greatest legacy. All those earlier self-conscious efforts aligned themselves to specific tendencies that were emerging from the British counter-culture. Sigma 6 was derived from Alexander Trocchi’s manifesto for ‘the spontaneous university’. Megadeath evoked the H-bomb and the ever-present fear of obliteration. The Abdabs was a peculiarly English onomatopoeic term variously used to describe delirium tremens and shellshock. By 1964 its usage was more likely to suggest a college cabaret band who weren’t in the habit of taking themselves too seriously, which was pretty much the case. Almost all of these early band names were Waters’s suggestions; they sprung from the same verbal facility that gave us ‘Flapdoodle Dealing’, ‘Take Up Thy Stethoscope and Walk’, ‘Pow R. Toc H.’ and ‘Corporal Clegg had a wooden leg’. The one exception was the Tea Set, which was jazz slang for smoking pot, an activity that was distinctly infra dig as far as Waters was concerned. The Tea Set was both a knowing nudge to the hip life – Louis Armstrong referred to ‘tea’ all his life – and an appropriation of an advertising slogan from the time – ‘Join the Tea Set’. If you look at the cover of Time magazine’s famous ‘London: The Swinging City’ edition from 15 April 1966, the red bus in the centre of the picture, right next to Big Ben, carries the slogan on its side.

For a while the group used the names Tea Set and Pink Floyd interchangeably. Barrett’s former art-school contemporaries remember them playing college gigs under both billings. Cambridge friend Nigel Lesmoir-Gordon advised them to drop the Tea Set if they wanted to be taken seriously. ‘Steve Stollman [ESP label co-founder] was talking of having these Happenings at the Marquee on Sunday afternoons. I said, “Yeah, poetry and jazz.” It occurred to me that there was this band in Cambridge called the Tea Set who might be well suited. At that stage they were just beginning to be adventurous. Still doing the R&B stuff but starting to cut loose. I can’t remember if I phoned Syd Barrett or Roger Waters. I said, “Don’t call yourself the Tea Set. Call yourself by that other name, the Pink Floyd. It will sit much better.” Tea Set sounds like such a joke. I didn’t like it, too crass.’

As a name, Pink Floyd has endured far better than many of the other options available at the time. The Beatles’ monumental creativity rapidly outgrew a name that was based on a feeble pun, derived from Buddy Holly and the Crickets. Equally time-bound is the Rolling Stones, taken from a Muddy Waters number, and chosen in haste by Brian Jones when required to come up for a name for an imminent gig. The Beach Boys, the Kinks and the Yardbirds are also unmistakably of their era, even if their music transcends it. Pink Floyd, though, has a certain subtle neutrality about it, suggestive and meaningless at the same time. Barrett had found references to two South Carolina bluesmen – Pink Anderson and Floyd Council – on a record sleeve and had combined the two forenames. Devastatingly simple in one respect, it belies deeper, more complex thought processes. ‘Pink’ variously connotes Caucasian, femininity, nakedness. ‘Floyd’ suggests black, rootsy, earthy. Floyd was not an uncommon name among blues and R&B musicians – Floyd Dixon, Floyd Jones, etc.; Woody Guthrie had immortalised bank robber Pretty Boy Floyd in song; and the recently deposed heavyweight boxing champion of the world was called Floyd Patterson. You can hear Barrett, the pop-art aesthete, cogitating over the options, sifting them laterally. Pink Floyd. Pretty Blues. Blushing Purity. Feminised Authenticity. Naked Outlaws. White Blackness. It’s a name crafted out of intuitive juxtapositions. On one level it’s an oblique play on the ‘Can white men sing the blues?’ syndrome that would preoccupy an entire generation of pop musicians during the 1960s. On another it’s an indicator of Barrett’s art-school sensibilities, a blank-canvas name, a looks-good-on-a-poster name.

For most of 1965 and well into 1966 Pink Floyd played the same rudimentary R&B as everybody else, just another average white band on an overcrowded circuit. They rehearsed up at Hornsey Art College, where their landlord, Mike Leonard, ran his light-and-sound workshop. It was here that the group first got a taste of the possibilities of mixed media. In Leonard’s rehearsal space, performing in the flickering beam of his light and sound boxes, the group began to extemporise. They still performed their standard R&B repertoire when they played gigs, but in the light show they could stretch out into infinity. Barrett adapted his guitar style accordingly, sculpting with atonality, weaving new possibilities into old language. He stopped worrying about musical competence and technique and began applying painterly textures and colouration. Within a matter of months he had pretty much abandoned his fine-art apprenticeship and started painting with sound instead.

You contemplate taking a course that is contrary to your deepest principles. Your thoughts have not yet been transformed into action. Banish unprincipled ideas immediately before they obsess you to the point of forcing you to act on them. There is no need to feel guilty – yet.

HEXAGRAM 24

Everyone threw the I Ching. Life became a game of chance and coincidence as adherents placed their faith in a recently revived oracle based on the Taoist wisdom of ancient China. The I Ching, the so-called Book of Changes, submitted action and interpretation to the casting of yarrow sticks or the throwing of coins. Meaningless actions were transformed into meaningful ritual. The I Ching became the stoner’s parlour game du jour. While the political wing of hippiedom subscribed to the rhetoric of revolution, the mystical wing aligned itself to old-time theosophists and Rosicrucians and all the other esotericists who preferred palm readings, séances and yarrow sticks to throwing bricks through embassy windows or hurling marbles under police horses.

During that fruitful period in the late summer and autumn of 1966, when the words just seemed to pour out of him in a torrent, Syd Barrett wrote most of the songs that would appear on the Pink Floyd’s debut LP, The Piper at the Gates of Dawn. Among them was a composition based on the I Ching called ‘Chapter 24’. Barrett lifted the words pretty much verbatim from the Fu Hexagram (‘The receptive earth above; the arousing thunder below’), which was chiefly concerned with the theme of ‘Return – The Turning Point’. The song appeared on Piper embellished with harmonium, bells and mellotron, and Barrett sang it in a choirboy voice that now seemed to owe far more to folk music and the English hymnal tradition than it did to R&B. The song’s ellipses were seamless. The Fu Hexagram’s ‘Return. Success. Going out and coming in without error’ became ‘Change. Return. Success. Going and coming without error.’ As Lennon had done with ‘Tomorrow Never Knows’, Barrett borrowed specific phrases word for word and collapsed others to suit the metre. But he didn’t get the technique from Lennon; he got it from an art-school apprenticeship, which by the time he wrote ‘Chapter 24’ he had all but aborted. ‘Action brings good fortune,’ he sings. He sounds full of belief.

Early in 1967, during what should have been the final year of his studies, Barrett went to see Robert Medley, the head of Camberwell art school, and told him that he was earning £200 a week from gigs with the Pink Floyd. Medley generously offered him a sabbatical, but Barrett never did go back. According to those who knew him well, the wrench was apparently enormous. His close friend Anna Murray, who had appeared along with Susie Gawler-Wright in the original 1966 24 Hours programme about LSD, had no doubt about where his true talents lay. ‘He was very carried away by the music and he liked performing, but at the time I thought he’d be better off as a painter,’ she told John Cavanagh. ‘His temperament suited it better. I was really surprised when he took off into the music so hugely. I felt he was swept up and it wasn’t necessarily his intention or his driving force. It wasn’t apparent to me that it was the most important thing in his life at all.’1

A month after Syd Barrett officially left art school Pink Floyd turned professional and signed a contract with EMI records for an advance of £5,000.Along with other people you are experiencing a change of fortune – a turn for the better that is occurring without anyone having willed it, planned it or arranged for it. It occurs completely on its own, in its own slow time, in its own quiet way. Very gradually you will find your life becoming more eventful.

HEXAGRAM 24

It became eventful very quickly. There was nothing gradual about it at all. One minute the Pink Floyd were playing gigs at the Notting Hill Free School to a coterie of the devoted, the next they were the darlings of the London underground, headlining full-scale freak-outs at the UFO club and extemporising the blues into vapour in the swirling maelstrom of Mark Boyle and John Marsh’s light shows. In January 1967 a German film crew from Bavarian Rundfunk filmed a one-hour documentary entitled Die Jungen Nachtwandler (‘The Young Nightcrawler’) inside UFO. Directed by Edmund Wolf, it featured a lengthy sequence that showed Pink Floyd performing an incredibly unshackled version of ‘Interstellar Overdrive’. With the band immersed in John Marsh’s light projections (Marsh is briefly glimpsed during the footage), Wolf intones, in German: ‘These people in their confusion try to experience a real community. Even here sometimes you can find a common pleasure – without any aggression. Something of a new quality of being together as people, that’s what all the young ones are searching for. Much more kindness, much less aggression, that’s what they are searching for. In all this confusion something really new will be born. That’s what I believe.’ Judging by the beatific looks on their faces, so do the blissed-out clubbers. They all seem to do what everyone did in the light show at that time: they choreograph themselves to its patterns, forming chemically enhanced dance shapes that merge with the pulsating blobs and drips of the light-show oils. The euphoria and oblivion on display as the camera plays across half-lit faces are testimony to the tidal wave that LSD was unleashing upon the London underground at the onset of 1967.

‘And yet it does not matter that he’s all in bits,’ says Aldous Huxley in The Doors of Perception, as he listens to madrigals by the late-Renaissance composer Carlo Gesualdo while high on mescaline and perhaps not fully perceiving that it is he, the listener, that is in bits. ‘The whole is disorganized. But each individual fragment is in order, is a representative of a Higher Order. The Higher Order prevails even in the disintegration. The totality is present even in the broken pieces.’2

That was Barrett in the early part of 1967. That was everyone.

You have sensed a change, a regeneration, a turn for the better in your situation. Your friends and colleagues have not felt it yet. Move with it freely and naturally, even though this will alienate you from others.

HEXAGRAM 24

Barrett went gung-ho for acid, and his intake was prodigious. Unlike his band mates, unlike the majority of musicians on the scene, in fact, whose tastes for stimulants rarely went beyond alcohol and the odd puff on a joint, Barrett enthusiastically endorsed the systematic disassembling of sense and psyche. Cambridge compatriot and Hipgnosis’s LP-sleeve designer Storm Thorgerson told me in 2012 about the time he and Barrett ingested some hideous chemical compound cut with plastic derivatives. As Thorgerson felt his entire system undergo creeping paralysis, ‘beginning with the legs and working its way upwards’, all he could remember was Barrett cackling with laughter as he embraced the void.

In such circumstances fame tended to be a hindrance, a bothersome intrusion into the more important business of trepanning your soul. When the Pink Floyd came to record their first LP, producer Norman Smith felt the full brunt of Barrett’s truculence and refusal. ‘Syd was pretty difficult,’ he conceded in a 2007 interview with Guitar World magazine. ‘What I mean by difficult is, they would be in the studio recording a particular number. I would bring them into the control room to listen to the playback. Syd was doing the singing, of course. And I would suggest perhaps a little phrasing alteration. Syd was nodding. Didn’t say anything, but he was nodding, like a “yes” nod. He seemed to be paying attention. I said, “OK, go back into the studio and we’ll do another take.” So they go back in the studio and Syd did exactly the same as he had done the previous take. So I thought, “I think I’m wasting my time here.” But I realized as time went on that Syd really and truly, in my opinion, didn’t get any pleasure out of recording. Syd’s thing was he would write these songs, he would go to an underground club or something of that nature and perform in front of these fans. And that really was his big thing.’

Smith was a product of the old school, versed in the EMI way of doing things. Barrett, equally methodical in his way, was versed in the spontaneous techniques of automatic writing and painterly abstraction. He baulked at the brain-sapping procedures of four-track recording, at the necessity of repetition. At school, performing in The Bald Prima Donna, he had tremendous sport with repetition, tilting at the absurdity of language until it surrendered its logic. In the college canteen, in stoned reverie with his friend, no two conversations were the same. In painting no two brush strokes were the same. Now he was being asked to play the same notes in the same order. Again and again and again.

‘I’m an old jazz man,’ said Smith. ‘I played in jazz groups before joining EMI. So that was my kind of music. I walked into UFO and the group came on. Well, their music didn’t mean very much to me at all. But they had this light show, which was very impressive. And I remember thinking to myself, “How can I get a light show onto disc?” I could see the following they had there and that they were extremely popular. So I thought, “Well, it looks as though we can sell some records here.”’ As well as nailing his commercial priorities to the mast, the Floyd’s producer was astute enough to realise that Barrett’s problem was insurmountable. How could he translate the thrill of immersion he felt at UFO into the clinical setting of Abbey Road studios? The more Barrett thought about it, the less he thought of it.

Down at UFO Mark Boyle provided the best of the light shows. He too had a fine-art practitioner’s sense of perfectionism and a disdain for those who sold themselves short. By the end of the decade Boyle had forsaken painting with light and had become a fully fledged conceptualist and installationist. In May 1970, in collaboration with his partner Joan Hills, he put together an exhibition called Journey to the Surface of the Earth, a ‘multi-sensual presentation of 1000 sites selected at random from the surface of the earth’. The exhibition was shown at the Gemeentemuseum Den Haag in Holland between 16 May and 12 July 1970, and in the programme catalogue Boyle wrote an extended polemic against the futility of ‘explanation’. Its similarity to Syd Barrett’s creative dilemma is startling. It anticipates and counterpoints Barrett’s own withdrawal from the centre of his quest.

The head is drenched with thoughts and images that supercede one another with such rapidity that writing and even speaking become intolerable except as a sort of recreational activity, or as a social constitutional of a kind that appals you more and more.

MARK BOYLE

At his creative peak Barrett revealed a seemingly effortless capacity for scrambling meaning and logic. It’s a rare lyrical gift, an instinctive freestyling approach to language that few songwriters possess. When he submitted himself to the obligations of the music industry – to pop-press interviews, for instance – he always sounded reined in and stilted by comparison. At the height of his fame he invariably came across either as polite, gauche or politely gauche. His formal and mannered responses reveal little of consequence about his art or himself. In Waters and Barrett’s famous TV encounter with the music critic Hans Keller, both men appear composed, but they exchange frequent quizzical and amused glances as Keller fires off another of his ‘Why precisely do you exist? Please explain’ enquiries. Of the two, Waters looks slightly less ill at ease, the more willing spokesman, a role he would rapidly grow into in direct proportion to his colleague’s withdrawal.

Barrett’s strangest interview encounter during this period was with American journalist Meatball Fulton, just after the release of The Piper at the Gates of Dawn in August 1967. In 2008 Fulton unearthed a rare and previously unheard tape of his meeting with Barrett and posted the full unedited audio on the Internet.3 Listening to it now is like eavesdropping on a conversation between two incapacitated stoners. Essentially it is an exercise in non-communication, but it speaks volumes about the times, and is revealing on several levels. Barrett is softly spoken to the point of inaudibility, and is as fluent as narcotic circumstances will allow. A minimally edited extract from his disjointed, rambling response to Fulton’s first question runs as follows:

‘Well, I’ll say, for example, painting at an art school. Or painting, say, in infant school. The initial desire to paint or initial first successes at painting arose, I think, out of a very genuine basic drive … and because family and social set-ups are channelled into success or otherwise and, through schools and suchlike, one gets different things … one comes across teachers and people like that, teaching and instruction … and I feel now that having left art school that there are a lot of things that I could do. A lot of things I see now, a lot of things went into me, into my head … changing and altering things. For instance, I made a painting the other day … and I could see and hear very clearly different instructions and different criticisms going into the picture, which were in fact criticisms that I could relate back to art school and teachers … So maybe this would be very valuable, this break. I don’t know, to try painting again after a break of going into pop music.’

Even in this slightly tidied-up form the hash haze of the room is palpable. Although, as any music journalist who has ever been faced with the task of contriving quotable utterances out of the rambling inconsequentialities of stoned rock stars will tell you, the extract is no more inarticulate than many that writers encounter on a regular basis. Pick your way through the hesitant and halting delivery, the repetition, the cul-de-sacs and convoluted thought processes, and moments of clarity do emerge. The entire rambling discourse can be boiled down to this: Barrett has been thinking about his art-school training and is now wondering how he can best apply that conceptual grounding to the next stage of his creative development. At the time of the interview, August 1967, the Pink Floyd are taking a short break from touring, citing Barrett’s ‘nervous exhaustion’ as the reason. Perhaps the most revealing aspect of this conversational fragment is that Barrett is clearly thinking about resuming painting again, ‘after a break of going into pop music’. He is still pondering the implications of having dropped his fine-art studies at Camberwell in favour of a pop career. What is not clear from the response is whether he is attempting to apply his theorising to painting alone or trying to facilitate further ways of making connections between his fine-art studies and his music. Either way, the fact that he is theorising at all, and attempting to articulate these thoughts from the depths of his stoned stupor to an equally stoned stranger, speaks volumes.

During the interview Barrett talks, albeit obliquely, about assimilating ideas and channelling thought processes. Unfortunately, his inquisitor reduces these potentially fruitful areas of enquiry to hippie shibboleths: conditioned response, thought control, the system, the man. Barrett is unfailingly polite and responds to all questions with a surface diplomacy, but he becomes increasingly guarded and non-committal as the tape rolls on. After the initial exchanges he perceptibly begins to withdraw from the whole charade that is unfurling like so much hash smoke before him. When Fulton attempts to press his interviewee further on the issue of freeing oneself from ‘the system’, Barrett tries to bring the question back to the specifics of painting. ‘I finished a picture. I got through a lot of things. It’s quite enjoyable, you know, and … I would like to get hold of that and be able to assimilate the system as it comes in, rather than as it goes out.’ Again, gnomic though it seems, this is just a convoluted way of saying that he would like to be more methodical in his approach rather than simply relying on instincts. None of this registers with his interviewer, who changes tact and asks, ‘Do you ever feel when you see people that you could tell them something about themselves that they don’t already know? Or do you look at people that way? I feel you do, that you really sort of observe people. Do you?’ Barrett initially tries to distance himself from the thrust of the question. His disjointed, contradictory reply hints both at a reluctance to deal with the enquiry and a degree of embarrassment at being put on the spot in this way. His response also contains a revealing nugget or two about the limits of journalistic encounters like this one:

‘Nah. I think it’s something about … I certainly do get a feeling of what people are like and, really, the complication comes out in talking, but this only comes out at certain times because of a feeling that talking is, in fact, a far less valuable thing than … it’s almost superfluous to everything else, you know. But the same time, it’s a contradiction that the words and talking to people should be difficult in any way. One is hesitant to say, “No, I can’t say anything,” you know. And I know as well this is something that occurs only at times, other times it doesn’t … and it’s cool.’

Again, choice phrases leap out of the brain fug – ‘the complication comes out in talking’, talking ‘is superfluous to everything else’. And so it goes on. Inconsequentiality chases its own tail until all that can be heard is the tape machine whirring and the inhalation of ennui on an airless August day somewhere in London in the middle of the Summer of Love.

‘There’s so many different things that on different levels that I could say … maybe the most strange thing is … meeting you, very strange to meet you, well, it isn’t really strange, it’s not many people that … one can … interviewers and such like, and you come into that class. I mean generally it’s just sort of say hello and to get to say the questions and go again … I don’t know … I don’t know.’

‘I see you’re holding back,’ says Fulton.

‘No. Not at all! I understand. I think I learn a lot from you,’ says Barrett, trying to put his interrogator at ease. As he struggles to extricate himself from this Ionesco-esque theatre of absurdity he merely binds himself in more semantic knots. ‘I know I feel from you that … really, that I could say anything and do anything and you would still … I mean, you are recording it and that’s cool and … I know that applies to you, to me and you, ’cos really I assure you, you can do anything you want, but … if … I want to … if I wanted to say nothing or if I want to act in an extra-extraordinary way … then I feel that that too is justified.’

The voice trails away. Click. Someone pushes an off button. In more ways than one.

You are the pivot of the changes taking place. As you move in the new direction – contrary to accepted traditional ideas – everyone and everything will fall in behind you.

HEXAGRAM 24

Except they won’t. ‘Increasingly erratic’ is the phrase that writers love to use about this particular phase of Barrett’s disintegration: ‘His behaviour became increasingly erratic.’ It’s a tired, hackneyed expression right up there with ‘He let his imagination run riot,’ and it’s just as meaningless, or rather it’s so true it’s tautological. That’s what the imagination does, it runs riot. That’s what imagination is, a running riot. Oh, the futility of words. Barrett’s imagination had always run riot. It had been running riot since he was two. ‘You only have to read the lines / of scribbly black / and everything shines,’ as he sings in ‘Matilda Mother’. Ironically, the only time his imagination didn’t run riot was when he knuckled down to the disciplined procedures of his art and his writing. When he wrote pop songs and painted he adhered to the conventions of pop songs and painting. It was when he wasn’t being purposefully creative that his imagination ran riot. That’s when he became ‘increasingly erratic’. ‘Increasingly erratic’ was a loaded term. In context it meant too erratic to observe the procedures and obligations of the pop life (or, for that matter, the art life). Too erratic to toe the line. Touring. TV. Press. Promotion. Obligation. Be here now. Be there tomorrow. At some point during the summer of 1967 Syd Barrett crossed an invisible line. Improvisation in the context of a UFO performance was cherished and revered. Pete Townshend brings his mate Eric Clapton down just to check out what you are doing. Improvisation in the context of fucking up the career path and the well-rehearsed life your fellow band mates are carving out for themselves is irresponsible. Where are the boundaries? Where is the cliff edge and precipice? When you are self-medicating as often as Syd it becomes increasingly difficult to tell. And who is going to tell you anyway? ‘Do you ever feel when you see people that you could tell them something about themselves that they don’t already know?’ asked Meatball Fulton, dropping verbal pebbles down a deep well and waiting for an echo that never comes. And how can you possibly answer that question when you hardly know your own self, when you no longer even want a sense of self?

You don’t want any image, you want to be transparent, a projection almost seen on a cloud of cigarette smoke. And you know as you say it that all you’re doing is to make another kind of image, perhaps more suited to your circumstances than any other. You’re saying I am what I produce. I am a circuit of no importance. My anonymity is valuable to me.

MARK BOYLE

Barrett thrived in the light show. It appealed to his sense of anonymity. Immersed in the multicoloured displays of the liquid lenses and the celluloid wheels, adorned in dappled refractions, backlit by flickering shadows and silhouettes, reduced to a shape, an outline Barrett could shed his obligation to stagecraft and ego projection. Performing in the light show was like merging with your own canvas. The troubles began when there wasn’t a light show to hide in. When the Pink Floyd toured the ballrooms, they encountered another world. Barrett visibly wilted in the spotlight. Suddenly Hexagram 24 – earth above, thunder below – took on more ominous connotations.

Do not plunge into a new course – you will only find yourself thrashing helplessly about. What will happen has begun to happen. You sense it starting; as it proceeds you will sense its progress. Meanwhile, remain yourself. Practise only what you fully understand.

HEXAGRAM 24

The Pink Floyd go to America, and have to abandon the tour after only a handful of gigs. In November 1967 they embark upon one of the last of the old-school package tours around the UK with the Jimi Hendrix Experience, the Move, the Nice, Amen Corner, Eire Apparent and Outer Limits. Fifteen-minute sets for each band and thirty minutes for Hendrix, the headline act. Syd Barrett starts to go missing, sometimes while still on stage. On a couple of occasions Nice guitarist David O’List is drafted in as a replacement. No one really notices. No one really cares. It’s a package tour. Fifteen minutes of fame. Shove ’em on and shove ’em off again.

You would like to have a bitter image of yourself. But you’re not even bitter any longer. You have no ambitions. You’ve seen it all and you knew before you saw it that their Hilton Hotels and their Cadillacs were going to add up to precisely nothing. You’re an onion, and to find the inner, essential onion you strip away the layers protecting the centre, to discover that at the centre there are only more layers and beyond them a smell and a blur of tears.

HEXAGRAM 24

The English beat poet Spike Hawkins tells Barrett that he has unlocked so many doors. ‘Yes,’ replies Barrett. ‘But with cheap keys.’ Disillusion hardens like quick-setting cement. Required to come up with a new single Barrett writes ‘Vegetable Man’, a sardonic sneer at the whole process of pop fame. He delivers it in that flat, artless sneer, the one he reserves for all the songs that aren’t about gnomes and Emily and Puck and Pan. The lyrics will be misread for years as a lacerating treatise on his crumbling state of mind. He also writes ‘Scream Thy Last Scream’, a tale as dark and menacing as any Grimms’ fairy tale. Both songs are rejected as ‘uncommercial’.

A turn for the better has come and gone. You have let it pass you by … you believe you display backbone by resisting change, you mistake your fear for stubbornness. This attitude is disastrous. It denies the inevitable flow of change in the universe – a flow which will carry you along, if not buoyant and upright then tumbled headlong and willy-nilly. But the moment has passed. You can do nothing about it now. You must patiently wait for things again to resolve themselves.

HEXAGRAM 24

‘If not buoyant and upright then tumbled headlong and willy-nilly’ would be the shape of it for some time to come. On BBC Radio 1, on 31 December 1967, John Peel and Tommy Vance presented a three-hour end-of-year edition of TopGear. It was a stupendously rich celebration of all that was great and good about 1967. As well as featuring Syd Barrett’s last session with Pink Floyd there were live sessions by the Moody Blues, the Herd, the Alan Bown! and Eric Burdon and the Animals, all of whom performed four numbers apiece. The best of the year on vinyl was featured too. There were bulletins from the American underground like ‘I Can Take You to the Sun’ by the Misunderstood, ‘Porpoise Mouth’ by Country Joe and the Fish, ‘Castles Made of Sand’ by the Jimi Hendrix Experience, ‘Dropout Boogie’ by Captain Beefheart, ‘Pandora’s Golden Heebie Jeebies’ by the Association, ‘A Child’s Claim to Fame’ by Buffalo Springfield, ‘Fall on You’ by Moby Grape. There were all those English singles and LP tracks that had gone into making the great psychedelic spring, summer, autumn and winter of love: ‘Blue Jay Way’ by the Beatles, ‘Coloured Rain’ by Traffic, ‘Armenia City in the Sky’ by the Who, ‘Time Seller’ by the Spencer Davis Group, ‘Supernatural Fairy Tale’ by Art, ‘Fredereek Hernando’ by One in a Million. And in the midst of all these riches Syd Barrett’s absence hovers like light-show spectral shadows. He’s there on tape but his spirit is somewhere else. He sings ‘Scream the Last Scream’, ‘Vegetable Man’ and ‘Jugband Blues’; the latter would be the last of his compositions the Pink Floyd recorded. The last word he sings on a Pink Floyd LP is ‘joke’.

In his final months with the band there was an undoing of everything and a sense of unravelling. In need of reinforcements they brought in Barrett’s old Cambridge pal David Gilmour to bolster the sound and maybe, who knows, reignite a flagging spirit. Syd’s mate Dave, with whom he had swapped riffs in the tech college canteen, with whom he had busked in the south of France. The five-piece line-up did rejuvenate him briefly. He perked up for a gig or two, but then lapsed back into incommunicado. ‘His head did no thinking / his arms didn’t move,’ as he sang on ‘Scarecrow’. And then one day – hooray! – the band didn’t pick him up any more, reasoning that there was no one there any more to pick up anyway.

While Syd Barrett embarked upon a decade-long quest to impale himself upon ennui and indecision, Pink Floyd furnished his absence and his unfinished canvases with their own architectural ab-dabs and abstractions. Groups are often at their best when they don’t know what it is that they are doing, when the boundary markers are ill defined, when the goal is still beyond, when the dreams (or, in the Floyd’s case, the dystopias) are only half formed. It is also during this period, paradoxically enough, when they are at their most influential. The spacey imprecision that Pink Floyd hazily sketched out between 1968 and 1970 – impulses in progress, fleetingly captured and episodically rendered on ASaucerful of Secrets, Ummagumma, More and La Vallée and on their numerous radio sessions – influenced everything from the German space rock of Tangerine Dream to the ambient dance fusions of the Orb and beyond, influenced everything but Pink Floyd, in fact. Their best music during this transitional period is tentative, ethereal and unsullied. Its hauntingly wistful beauty encapsulates both where its founding spirits came from and what they were never entirely able to leave behind.

‘I really think that the architecture has a lot to do with it,’ reasons Barry Miles. ‘That’s why the Pink Floyd’s music is so slow and English and environmental. It’s the sound of Grantchester Meadows. It’s a very English upper-middle-class environment that is required to produce that. Canterbury is the only other place like that. Even Oxford has a metal-box factory and a ring of industry around it. It seemed to me that that was a very important element in the Pink Floyd – the fact that the three different leaders all came out of that same background, incredibly privileged, not just middle-class but very privileged in the sense of what they had access to. And the visual aspect too. I’m a great believer in the situationist idea that the actual geography and buildings and the built environment is of tremendous importance. Just growing up there and walking around those streets, going to the meadows and always being in the presence of medieval architecture. And the very slow pace of life in the sense that everything just continues. There’s the keeper of the fabric, and when he dies there’s another keeper of the fabric. These are just offices that get renewed.’

While the Pink Floyd assembled monuments of sound that reflected their architectural heritage, their original guiding spirit remained in Cambridge, abstract and listless, occasionally regathering thoughts that would never quite assemble themselves in the same way again. As in light show as in life.

You remember fragments of 50,000 experiences, and you suspect them, and you suspect the conscious and unconscious forces that keep dredging them up. They’re all part of the proper snobberies, the prejudices and preferences built in by your heredity and your upbringing. Most of all you suspect the way you formulate. And so finally you say there is this, there is this, there is this.

MARK BOYLE

Until in the end there isn’t even that.Notes

1 Cavanagh, John, The Piper at the Gates of Dawn (New York, Continuum, 2003), p. 52

2 Huxley, p. 30

3 www.sydbarrett.com/news/Irregular-Head_June10.pdf

12


Lovecraft and Crowley


In the late 1940s, Kenneth Grant, a student of magic, met Aleister Crowley during the Beast’s last days at Netherwood, an aptly named boarding house in Hastings, England. Here Crowley performed magick, drank gin and injected enough heroin each day to kill a room full of people. At seventy-one, with a wake of shattered lives and broken followers behind him, he was still a magus and still the Word of the Aeon. His income came mostly from a branch of his magical organization, the OTO (Ordo Templi Orientis), that had started up in California (see Chapter Nine).

The OTO had a history going back to 1895, when it was started in Germany by an occultist, Karl Kellner. After Kellner died in 1905, Theodor Reuss became its head, and it was during Reuss’s leadership that Crowley became involved.

In 1912 Reuss contacted Crowley after reading his Book of Lies. In it Reuss realized that Crowley had revealed certain secrets known only to initiates of the OTO. Reuss asked Crowley how he had come across these secrets. Crowley replied he hadn’t; the secrets came from his own incorrigibly fertile brain. Reuss was impressed, recognized Crowley’s magical acumen, and suggested he start a London branch of the OTO. Never one to refuse a title, Crowley accepted and gradually began to dominate the society, eventually taking over its leadership in 1922. The secrets in question had to do with sex. The basis of the OTO was the insight that sex could be used for magical purposes. That Crowley should come upon this quite on his own isn’t surprising. He had been obsessed with sex ever since he bedded the family maid as a boy of fourteen. Tantric yoga, the basic idea behind the OTO, is the anti-ascetic strain of Tibetan Buddhism. It deals with the use of pleasure - sexual, sensual, drug-induced - for spiritual ends. Very popular by the mid-sixties, it is a steady seller in New Age bookshops today.

Crowley accepted Grant as a student and set about his magical training; one examination of Grant’s astral vision required his inhaling ether. His tutorial, however, was shortlived. In 1947, within a year of meeting the Great Beast, Crowley had died, and the inevitable factionalism that follows the demise of a cult leader had begun.

After Crowley’s death, Grant became head of one such OTO faction, the New Isis Lodge, which he founded in 1955 (see Chapter Nine). Following Crowley, he claimed that the OTO’s history went back to the medieval Knights Templar. More than this: following the usual occult practice, he pushed its history even further back, into the hazy mist of antiquity, and further still, into prehistory. In a series of books written over the last twenty-five years, Grant argued that Crowley’s magick, and the tantric practices it involves, are rooted in mankind’s earliest religious expression.5

Along with studying Crowley’s ‘magick’, Grant was also a devotee of weird fiction. Not surprisingly, Lovecraft was one of his favourite writers. That he should see a connection between the two seems natural. In The Book of the Law, the work that Crowley claimed was dictated to him by an extraterrestrial source in Cairo in 1904, and which proclaims the advent of a new Aeon or age, there’s a picture of the coming millennium that in all essentials lines up with Lovecraft’s version in ‘The Call of Cthulhu’. Crowley’s new age of ‘the crowned and conquering child’, should, he commented, ‘be marked by the collapse of humanitarianism’. Here’s a selection of what Aiwass, his Holy Guardian Angel responsible for his inspired work, has in mind:

Do what thou wilt shall be the whole of the law . . . Come forth, o children under the stars and take your fill of love ... These are the dead, these fellows; they feel not . . . the lords of the earth are our kinfolk . . . We have nothing with the outcast and unfit: let them die in their misery . . . Compassion is the vice of kings: stamp down the wretched & the weak: this is the law of the strong . . . lust, enjoy all things of sense and rapture . . . Pity not the fallen . . . strike hard and low, and to hell with them . . . be strong, then canst thou bear more joy. I am a god of War and of Vengeance . . . smite the peoples and none shall stand before you . . . Conquer! That is enough . . . Worship me with fire & blood; worship me with swords & with spears ... let blood flow to my name. Trample down the heathen ... I will give you of their flesh to eat! . . . damn them who pity. Kill and torture . . . I am the warrior Lord . . . I will bring you to victory and joy . . . ye shall delight to slay.6


When the Hell’s Angels at Altamont let loose their pool cues on a crowd of cowering hippies, they probably didn’t have Lovecraft or Crowley in mind. Nevertheless, they weren’t far removed from the liberated free-for-all that both had prophesied.

In 1970 Grant wrote an article for Man, Myth and Magic, ‘Dreaming Out of Space’.7 In it he argued that many of the Cthulhu Mythos stories were based on Lovecraft’s own fantastically vivid dreams. Two years later, when Lovecraft’s name was turning up in student-union soirées and cannabis-fuelled late-night metaphysics sessions, Grant published a book, The Magical Revival (1972), linking Lovecraft, Arthur Machen and other early twentieth century fantasists to Crowley’s new Aeon. Grant argued that their work had remarkable affinities with Crowley’s cult. ‘In the tales of Lovecraft’, Grant wrote, ‘the reader is plunged into a world of barbarous names and incomprehensible signs. Lovecraft was unacquainted with both the name and the work of Crowley, yet some of his fantasies reflect, however distortedly, the salient themes of Crowley’s Cult ...’8 Yet Lovecraft was in denial. In a chapter on the occult use of drugs, Grant writes, ‘Lovecraft seems not to have passed the final pylons of Initiation . . . at the last dreadful encounter, he invariably recoiled, resolved not to know what horror lay concealed behind the mask of his most critical incarnation. He ... feared to use drugs in case his nightmare-vision swept him beyond the point of no recall.’9 One wonders what the teetotal mechanistic-materialist Lovecraft would have thought of this.

Yet it has to be said that Grant does point to some remarkable similarities between Lovecraft’s work and Crowley’s. To Lovecraft’s Al Azif he compares Crowley’s Liber Al vel Legis, the Latin for The Book of the Law. Lovecraft’s ‘Great Old Ones’ are similar to ‘The Great Ones of the Night of Time’, who are part of rituals worked by the Golden Dawn. Lovecraft writes of the hidden city of ‘Kadath in the Cold Waste’; one of Crowley’s names for himself was ‘the Wanderer in the Waste’. And for Lovecraft’s ‘Cthulhu dreaming in R’lyeh’, Grant offers ‘The Primal Sleep of the Great Ones’.

There are several other comparisons in Grant’s book, yet there is one Lovecraft-Crowley link that Grant, as far as I can tell, doesn’t make. Lovecraft’s theme of a book so dark that knowledge of it brings madness and destruction seems borne out by the history of The Book of the Law. A study of Crowley’s life and that of his disciples shows that many of them ended up mad, destitute or prematurely dead; occasionally all three. Crowley, or Aiwass, himself warns that no commentary should be made of the book. Crowley didn’t heed that warning, and spent his life post 1904 doing little else. The reader can decide for himself what fortune this brought the Great Beast. As yet, no perfect commentary has appeared. As Grant writes, ‘It was Crowley’s belief that when the Book is finally published in strict accordance with the instructions given by Aiwass in its third chapter, it will effect the total destruction of civilization as we know it. So far, the instructions have been imperfectly executed, and the holocaust therefore incomplete.’10 Let us be grateful for small miracles.

Turn off your mind ...

Gary Lachman

Monday, November 16, 2026

In a broader sense all forms of alienation might be thought of as forms of self-estrangement

 Wish You Were . . . Connected

To be alienated is to be cut off, or estranged, from something or someone with which one should be connected. One can be alienated from other people, as when one fails to relate intimately to one’s family or friends, or when one cannot deal cordially and co-operatively with colleagues, or interact civilly with, or respond empathetically toward, other people in general. It can be a harmful failure to make contact, a troublesome inability to achieve closeness, a frustrating breakdown in communication. Since art is an attempt to communicate one’s ideas and feelings deeply and intensely, artists are often especially sensitive to this problem. Artists of all kinds must confront the danger that this special communication might at any point be thwarted by their alienation from their audience.

But not all alienation is social. Workers can become alienated from their work if they must perform boring, uncreative tasks at the direction of others. They can become alienated from the products of their work, as might assembly-line workers who install one tiny part of a car, in accordance with someone else’s design and production plans. Such workers are unlikely to see the finished product as having resulted from their personal creative effort. They may feel disconnected from the fruits of their labors (which they also, incidentally, do not own).

It’s plausible that modern life leads increasingly to our alienation from nature, as well. We spend more and more of our time in artificial environments (for example, in the car, at the office, on city streets, or locked up in our homes); and we are likely, wherever we are, to remain glued to television or computer screens, iPods, or to other electronic media or devices. If the rhythms of nature are drowned out by these distractions, it’s not a stretch to see that we can also become alienated from ourselves.

One who is alienated in this way may passively defer to others (such as parents, religious leaders, one’s peers, or society at large) on the fundamental questions of life that each of us, if we are to be autonomous, must decide for ourselves: What do I stand for? What are my values? How should I treat other people? What do I think is important? What are my priorities? What do I want to accomplish with my life? Confronting these questions allows one to emerge as a person, an individual with distinct talents, interests, and sensibilities—and not just an anonymous and interchangeable member of the public. Insofar as one submerges or never develops these distinctive traits, one loses sight of oneself, and becomes alienated from it.

Indeed, in a broader sense all forms of alienation might be thought of as forms of self-estrangement. The reason is that I can only be truly “alienated” from something that is (or should be) part of me. I am not alienated from the cobwebs in the corner of my basement, even though I feel no connection to them, for I can only be alienated from that to which I want to be connected, or should be connected. That’s why alienation involves disequilibrium, disturbance, and anxiety. It makes the world feel strange in ways that can sometimes be effectively expressed in music.

**

Time, Finitude, and Death

Time” on The Dark Side of the Moon begins quietly. But we suddenly hear the very loud chiming of clocks. The effect is startling and jarring, much like the first point that “Time” makes. Young people, especially, have no clue about how precious and scarce time is. They “fritter and waste the hours in an offhand way,” reasoning that they “are young and life is long and there is time to kill today.” Then life’s alarm clock sounds: “then one day you find ten years have got behind you / No one told you when to run, you missed the starting gun.” It also underscores the existentialists’ ideas about our “thrown” condition. We simply find ourselves already right up to our necks in the midst of a world that we did not create. Everyone, in that sense, has “missed the starting gun.”

Waters says that, following his mother’s advice, he spent his youth preparing for a life that he regarded as having not yet started—a life that was to start at some unspecified time in the future. The point was to get a good education so that he might be prepared, later, to have a family and a career, at which time his life would begin. He reports: “It came as a great shock to discover that I wasn’t preparing for anything—I was right in the middle of it, and always had been.”49Both lyrics and recollection suggest that part of the problem is our overly passive reliance on others, our refusal to think and act for ourselves. Just because “no one told [us] when to run,” that’s not a valid excuse for not embracing life authentically. Everyone, especially those that are “kicking around on a piece of ground in [their] home town” and “waiting for someone or something to show [them] the way,” should take a deep breath and “choose [their] own ground.” Waters confirms that a fundamental message of The Dark Side of the Moon is that “[i]t’s OK to engage in the difficult task of discovering your own identity[, a]nd it’s OK to think things out for yourself’.”50

The point is underscored in a familiar way for Pink Floyd—immediately after a provocative lyric, David Gilmour’s guitar soloing takes over. It gives listeners time, literally, to think about the ideas just presented and joins those ideas to richly emotive music. Gilmour begins this solo by sustaining its first note for seven beats, as if he were saying “listen to me; I have something important to say; I won’t be changing notes until I have your attention.” Once he does, the listener is likely to hear in Gilmour’s dark, moody, minor-key playing a restatement and intensification of the ideas conveyed by Waters’s lyrics. He gradually increases his speed and moves to the upper register of his instrument until the mood suddenly relaxes into the major seventh chords of the chorus. Now, Gilmour’s solo sounds no longer dark and menacing, but open, hopeful, even consoling (as if he were saying, “don’t feel bad; I missed the starting gun, too; everybody did”), an effect that is underscored by the soothing female voices that accompany it in the background.

One likely reason for why this and other of Gilmour’s solos work this way is that they are usually improvised, on the spot, in the studio. (This is true, for example, of all of his solos from The Dark Side of the Moon, including the one from “Time.”) One can hear this. These solos don’t sound canned or calculated, but rather strike the listener as free, spontaneous creations. He plays them “in the moment,” and allows his emotional response to the music over which he is soloing to come through.51

“Time” ends with the frightening line, “the time is gone, the song is over / Thought I’d something more to say.” You might think the song is speaking about itself as it winds down, but it’s speaking about you and all of us who, when we reach old age and recognize that we have little time left, will be disappointed at our meager accomplishments. We will recall with dismay and disappointment all of the things that we had hoped and dreamed and planned to do, but had never done, perhaps because we had foolishly assumed that “life is long and there is time to kill today.” We might instead recognize and confront our finitude, and take full advantage of the limited time available to us to make our lives meaningful and to ameliorate the hardships and the suffering that we share with others.

These thoughts harmonize with the famous argument of twentieth-century German existentialist philosopher Martin Heidegger that our refusal to face up to our own mortality—not just to acknowledge it in a vague, abstract, intellectual way, but rather to look it straight in the eye and feel it in one’s bones—creates the inauthenticity and triviality of our lives. With Heidegger, the two problems raised in “Time”—relying on others to “show you the way” and failing to recognize mortality—have the same solution. For if we were to come to grips with our finitude, we would not willingly and uncritically go along with norms of thought and behavior simply because they are widely accepted by others. If I genuinely face the fact that I have but one short life to live, I will want to make sure that it is indeed my life that I live, and not that of the public at large. I will not simply do as “one” does, or think as “they” do, but rather I will think for myself, and do what I think (in the light of my best critical judgment, and on the basis of careful thought, and with full cognizance of my own unique interests and talents) is best. Nor will I squander my precious time, which could be spent in significant conversation with others, or in the development of significant personal projects or interpersonal relationships, on idle gossip or sensationalistic trivia. For I could only do so if I suffered from the delusion that “life is long and there is time to kill today.”

**

We Don’t Need No Indoctrination

The Wall also contains Pink Floyd’s only #1 single, “Another Brick in the Wall (Part 2),” with its disturbing, but catchy refrain, sung by a children’s chorus: “We don’t need no education.” It’s not so much an attack on education per se as an attack (according to “The Happiest Days of Our Lives”) on “certain teachers” who torment their students with “derision” and ridicule. And it is an attack on education when it becomes indistinguishable from “thought control.” This occurs then students are simply told what to think, as opposed to being helped to learn how to think for themselves. (The fact that the children sing in unison, rather than in harmony, adds to the perception that they, as victims of thought control, all think alike.) Teachers whose main concern is simply to keep order, maintain a schedule, and get through the day, are well served by passive, docile students who, like the “Sheep” from Animals (“Meek and obedient you follow the leader”) are content to take orders, let others think for them, and grow into modern, alienated citizens who overpay for concert tickets because their local radio station tells them to.Another reason why indoctrination is widespread in education is the fact, well-known by those who wield power, that independent, critical thought is dangerous to their interests. People who think for themselves can’t be counted on to do your bidding, especially if your bidding is indefensible. Consider the difference between the teaching of arithmetic, on the one hand, and history or social studies, on the other. In arithmetic, it’s not enough for students merely to memorize the correct answers; rather, they must understand the logic of arithmetic for themselves, so that they can calculate answers for themselves to problems that have never been posed to them by their teachers.

But in history and social studies, teachers face enormous pressure to produce students who hold the “right” opinions, to adopt “patriotic” positions which justify, if not celebrate, they very status quo that Pink Floyd indicts in these albums, in which the alienating powers, privileges, and wealth enjoyed by society’s contemporary rulers (or chart-topping rock stars) are seen as important, legitimate and well-deserved.

The ugliness that results from this thwarting of independent critical thought and the substitution of indoctrination for it is well captured by Franz Kafka’s memorable aphorism: “Probably all education is but two things: first, parrying of the ignorant child’s impetuous assault on the truth; and second, gentle, imperceptible initiation of the humiliated children into the lie.”56

That’s why Pink Floyd’s message is one of resistance—resistance to the forces of indoctrination and conformity, as well as resistance to the artificial barriers that separate “us” from “them.” More specifically, the band urges us to resist those who would persuade us that money is more precious than time, that commerce is more important than creativity, that spectacle is more valuable than communication, and that competition is more important than empathy. Indeed, according to Pink Floyd one of the keys to coping successfully with the alienating pressures of modern life is the reversing of these value judgments.

But the most important key is simply to think for oneself. Don’t let others (even your favorite rock band!) decide for you what is true, valuable, and important. For if you think for yourself (and are not afraid to care), you have a chance to lead a richly meaningful life as an autonomous person. But if you don’t, you run the risk of ending up, like so many others, as just another brick in the wall, dragged down by the stone.


Dragged Down by the Stone: Pink Floyd, Alienation, and the Pressures of Life

DAVID DETMER

In 

Pink Floyd and Philosophy 

Russell Targ's Third Eye Spies

 FOREWORD

I was an Army psychic spy. Yes, really! For the military. A psychic spy. For nearly all of the seven years that I was a captain in the US Army, I was first trained and then used my extrasensory perceptual (ESP) abilities to project my consciousness to locations both foreign and domestic. These were abilities I never even knew I had before I was recruited to learn how to use them. Specifically, I am talking about what is known as “remote viewing,” or “RV” for short.

As Russell notes early in this book, the term “remote viewing” was coined by legendary New York artist and parapsychologist Ingo Swann. (Full disclosure: Swann taught me remote viewing, and I will be ever grateful, both to him and to the taxpayers who funded it.)

To be succinct: remote viewing is a skill that capitalizes on an aspect of consciousness we all possess. We have it simply by virtue of being human, and it allows us to experience, perceive, and describe people, places, and things that are hidden from us by distance, shielding, or even the past or (to some degree) the future. I often refer to this skill as a form of “disciplined clairvoyance.”

I was one of several military officers, enlisted soldiers, and government civilians who were taught to use this form of “disciplined clairvoyance” to spy out Soviet research facilities, advanced weapons, and scientific laboratories. We “looked” for hostages taken by Hezbollah in Lebanon, hunted narcotics traffickers off America's coasts, “observed” Chinese nuclear tests, “invaded” the Kremlin, and dug into emerging defense technology—both ours and the “other guy's.”

There were times, of course, when this psychic skill didn't work. On the other hand, there were many occasions when it absolutely worked—sometimes spectacularly. (Similar impressive results are presented in this book.) Given that skeptics laugh at the idea that ESP should ever work, the amount of concrete evidence we developed left us laughing last and best.

In large measure, I owe my career as a psychic spy to the author of this book, Russell Targ. Russ, along with his colleagues at the highly regarded California think tank SRI International had the courage to swim upstream against the tide of orthodox science. Their task was to fill a hole in our defenses that the US intelligence community could not itself plug. If they had not so successfully plugged that hole, I never would have had the opportunity to become a psychic spy.

In the 1960s and early 1970s, the Central Intelligence Agency fretted about massive Soviet military spending in fields that Western “experts” generally dismissed as “paranormal.” (To them, “paranormal” is a synonym for “fantasy.”) This worry led the CIA to physicist Hal Puthoff's laboratory door at SRI in the fall of 1972. The agents gave him a check for $50,000 as seed money and asked him to set up a program investigating the kinds of paranormal phenomena on which the Soviets already had a head start.

Russell, who had a long-standing interest in these topics, had recently become acquainted with Hal and, now that there was an actual “program” to join, he was invited to SRI to partner with Hal in creating what ultimately evolved into the Star Gate psychic spy program. Star Gate was run by the US government for the next twenty-three years, ending only with the conclusion of the Cold War. Thus history was made.

My task here is to briefly introduce you to this marvelous book, clarify the context, and set the stage for what follows.

When journalists write about the “CIA Star Gate Program,” they often start off confused, and it just gets worse from there. They think that because the Program has a singular name, it must have had a monolithic structure. But that is wrong. The first point to make is that the program only was called Star Gate late in its existence. Before that it was known under a variety of arcane titles, such as Scanate, Grill Flame, and Sun Streak, to name a few. The Star Gate moniker stuck because it was the last name by which the program was known.

It's best if you think of Star Gate as two parallel, yet connected efforts—two forking trunks of the same tree, if you will. The first trunk was Star Gate's research arm, created to investigate psychic phenomena, specifically remote viewing. Begun and home-based at SRI and helmed by Russell and Hal, this effort was funded under contract initially by the CIA and served as the foundation from which everything else developed.

After the CIA was forced to abandon the SRI program in 1975, the source of money and guidance switched to various Department of Defense (DoD) activities, starting with the Air Force, then the Army, and finally the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA). (Russell often mentions his great respect for Lieutenant General James Williams, under whom the longstanding relationship between DIA and remote viewing began.)

Ironically, the CIA never again “ran” the Star Gate Program. Though Star Gate is widely called the CIA's program, the agency's only additional role was to do away with it in June 1995. To those of us with ties to Star Gate, this was much like giving the beloved dog that you can no longer care for to a trusted neighbor, whose first act on taking ownership was to shoot it. Hard feelings? Yeah, maybe some.

Once established, the SRI effort (later moved to Science Applications International Corporation, or SAIC, under Dr. Ed May) was to make its findings available to its customer, the DoD, for use in the other branch of Star Gate, the military “psychic spy” unit. Some operational (that is, practical) work was done at SRI, but the majority of what Russell and his colleagues did there was scientific. It is largely those results and his experiences in helping generate them that Russ mines for our benefit in this book.

After a sojourn at Wright-Patterson Air Force Base under Air Force civilian analyst Dale Graff, the military branch of Star Gate came to rest at Fort George G. Meade, Maryland, in the late 1970s. It lived its life there through several incarnations (I won't bore you with the bureaucratic details).

First administered by the Army's Intelligence and Security Command, administrative ownership of the unit was passed to DIA headquarters at Bolling Air Force Base, District of Columbia, at the start of 1986, though the actual remote viewers stayed at Ft. Meade.

We Star Gate viewers performed over 2,500 intelligence collection missions for two dozen intelligence community and military agencies. Just some of the list includes the National Security Agency, the Joint Chiefs of Staff, the US Secret Service, the DEA, US Forces Korea, the Army's Intelligence Threat and Analysis Center, and the National Security Council. Our most prolific requestor, ironically, was the organization that in the end shut Star Gate down—the Central Intelligence Agency.

Until Congress transferred Star Gate to the CIA (leading, as mentioned, to the program's immediate demise), the DIA directed and funded the research at SRI (and later SAIC). This research significantly advanced remote viewing and other consciousness science. The world owes Russell and his colleagues a debt of gratitude for the profound insights from which we all may benefit.

Russell, though, had his own plans. Seeking a more relaxed climate for consciousness research than the often stifling classified security envelope government contracts demand, Russell left after ten years at SRI in 1982 and branched out into other activities. He has never looked back.

In my talks with him about this project, Russell often calls this a “remote viewing picture-book.” Director/producer Lance Mungia's successful documentary film Third Eye Spies, in which Russ plays the central role, gave Russ the idea for a companion book. And this book, itself now appropriately titled Third Eye Spies, serves as a canvass on which to assemble and add to the vignettes and interviews that emerged in the film.

Gathered here are remote viewing stories and images, some never before published, all brought together in a form more accessible than film can sometimes be. After all, even if the power is out, we can still pick up a book from the shelf anytime we want to refresh our memory or remind ourselves of something we loved in it. Try doing the same with a film.

Perhaps some of the most fascinating parts of Third Eye Spies (the book) are the chapters on precognition (in other words, “seeing” events or getting information from the future) and on how to actually launch a basic remote viewing experience for yourself. The latter is particularly helpful. Many folks want to try this skill, but have no idea where to begin. Russell provides friendly and—more importantly—easy guidance for people who have never tried remote viewing before and want to take their first steps. He gives you the basic secrets that he has successfully used over and over again in his many live workshops and appearances to help folks from Italian housewives to American businesspeople have their first empowering remote viewing experiences.

Russell now finds himself on the long end of life. One senses in him the urge many of us feel, once we realize we have unexpectedly become “chronologically challenged” by age, to document important things that didn't quite fit together in past tellings of our histories. This book is memorable for many reasons, and I invite you to give it the chance it deserves.

Paul H. Smith, PhD (Major, US Army, ret.)

Cedar City, Utah

April 2022

INTRODUCTION

I have been successfully teaching people how to get in touch with their psychic abilities for more than fifty years. This began in 1972 when I co-founded an extrasensory perception (ESP) research program at Stanford Research Institute. It was funded by the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA). We performed many fascinating double-blind experiments for the CIA, with very successful results. Among these, we described a hidden Russian weapons factory in Siberia and a failed Chinese atomic bomb test, located a downed Russian bomber in Africa, and located several kidnapped US officials. One was the ambassador to Iran during the Iran hostage crisis. Another was an American general kidnapped in Italy by the Red Brigades radical terrorist group. Early in the program, we even identified the ringleader of the Patty Hearst kidnapping, for which we received a commendation from the Berkeley Police Department.

This program was so successful that in 1978 the United States Army invited us to train six Army intelligence officers to create an Army psychic corps known as Project Star Gate. Star Gate provided useful secret and top-secret information to the military until 1995. One of my purposes here is to correct the misconception that psi, a more modern term for ESP, is weak and unreliable. On the contrary, in our laboratory experiments and classified operational tasks, psi was found to be surprisingly reliable, accurate, and useful. In this book, I will introduce you to the most successful and gifted remote viewers who participated in our program, many of whom had never done any psi-oriented work like this before.

Remote viewing is the ability to mentally experience and describe distant or unseen people, places, events, and objects from the past or present or future. The proof for ESP is so strong it would be statistically unreasonable to deny it. In data from laboratories all over the world, we see that the accuracy and reliability of remote viewing is not in any way degraded by distance. It is no more difficult to describe Soviet Siberia than it is to describe a park across the street. Similarly, it is no harder to describe an event hours or days in the future, than it is to describe a present-time event. For example, we were able to successfully forecast changes in the silver commodity market nine times in a row, earning us and our investor a quarter million dollars. So, the future can be known.

The world around us may look finite, but fifty years of research into psychic abilities and verified out-of-body experiences have convinced me that our awareness is limitless in space and time, and therefore we are also limitless. This is the basic finding from our two decades of remote viewing research at Stanford Research Institute (SRI). Through my work in this area, I have taught thousands of people all over the world how to get in touch with the part of themselves that is psychic. I hope this remote viewing “picture book” will help you do the same.

Remote viewing teaches that you are not just a physical body—not just meat and potatoes. Who we are is indestructible, timeless awareness and not what you see in the morning mirror. If you think that who you are is what you see in the mirror, then you are in for a lot of unnecessary suffering. I would say that the meaning of life is to experience our primordial timeless awareness and to teach that. I hope to give you an experience of that in this book.

Sunday, November 15, 2026

History of the Conquest of Mexico - Introduction

 The year 1859 saw the death of the two most famous historians in the English-speaking world. One was Lord Macaulay. The other was William Hickling Prescott, a Boston gentleman-scholar who had first come to the attention of Anglo–American readers with his History of the Reign of Ferdinand and Isabella (1838), but sealed his reputation with his History of the Conquest of Mexico (1843), and its companion volume, The History of the Conquest of Peru (1847). On a visit to the British Isles in 1850 he was everywhere fêted, and Disraeli, on being introduced to Prescott, opened the conversation by asking: ‘Pray, are you related to the great American author – the author of the Spanish Histories?’ ‘I squeezed his arm’, recorded Prescott, ‘telling him that I could not answer for the greatness, but I was the man himself.’1 Prescott’s response was characteristically modest. His fame as‘the author of the Spanish Histories’, while gratifying, seems to have come to him as something of a surprise. ‘Spanish Histories’ did not, on the face of it, seem destined to be best-sellers in the Anglo–American world, and Prescott was well aware of his own limitations as a historian, although he also knew his strengths. But there was something improbable about the way in which this wealthy Bostonian, who might have passed his life in the city’s literary circles as no more than a cultivated dilettante, discovered both his vocation and his subject, and went on to achieve international renown. 

 Born in 1796, the son of a judge who had made a fortune at the Massachusetts Bar, he seemed destined to study in his father’s footsteps and become a successful lawyer.2 An accident during his second year at Harvard, however, changed the course of his life. He was struck in the left eye by a crust of bread thrown by a fellow student in the dining hall, and lost the use of it. Not long afterwards, an attack of rheumatic fever weakened his other eye and specialists in England, whom he consulted after recuperating in the Azores, told him that there was no chance of effecting a permanent cure. While he could still read, although with difficulty, he was forced to abandon the prospect of a legal career. This does not seem to have greatly dismayed him, and he continued on his European travels in France and Italy. It was apparently the reading of Gibbon’s autobiography that gave him the idea of becoming a historian, but his poor eyesight would make it difficult for him to read and write without human and mechanical assistance. When he returned home to Boston in 1817 he had with him a ‘noctograph’, a frame with brass wires which guided him along the lines as he wrote with a stylus on carbon paper, to which a sheet of ordinary paper was clamped. This device, which he used throughout his life, enabled him to write without having to read the words he had written – a task that fell to his unfortunate secretaries. 

 Marrying in 1820, his first task, if he were to turn himself into a scholar and a historian, was to broaden and deepen his reading, and extend his proficiency in classical and modern languages. But German Gothic print proved too much for his weak eyesight, and in 1824 he decided to learn Spanish as a substitute for German.3 On 13 February 1825 he records the event in the notebooks, or ‘Literary Memoranda’, in which he would make periodic entries throughout his life: ‘I began the study of Spanish December 1, 1824. I have written daily exercises; studied thoroughly Jossé’s Grammar;’ and he follows with a list of the works of Spanish literature he had been reading, including Don Quijote, and the history of the conquest of Mexico by the seventeenth-century Spanish historian, Antonio de Solís y Rivadaneyra.4 The entry in the notebooks is characteristic of the man. Making light of his physical difficulty, and struggling against what he believed to be a natural disposition to indolence, he would pursue a rigid self-discipline, spurred on by his determination to live up to the high moral principles inculcated by his Boston background and his Unitarian upbringing. 

 The effect of his immersion in Spanish literature was to draw him away from his first intention of working on Italian literature and history, and to shift to Spain instead. This led him, in 1826, to choose as a suitable topic for study the relatively unfamiliar Spain of the late fifteenth century and the joint reigns of Ferdinand and Isabella. He began ordering books from Spain, and built up a network of friends and correspondents who, for the rest of his life, would supply him with transcripts of documents from the Spanish archives. When books and transcripts arrived in Boston he would summarize them on his noctograph, and then carefully digest his notes, committing as much as possible of what he had read to his memory. This became so good that he learnt to compose whole chapters in his mind before committing them in their final form to his noctograph. The History of the Reign of Ferdinand and Isabella took ten years to complete, but when it was published at the end of 1837, it was an instant success. Even Prescott’s close friends were amazed by the narrative and literary skills displayed in the History, which secured him an international reputation as it found rapidly growing numbers of readers on both sides of the Atlantic. 

 An account of the conquest of Mexico by Hernán Cortés and his fellow conquistadores would have seemed the natural choice for a new project, as the logical continuation of the story of Spain’s rise to greatness under Ferdinand and Isabella. But for some time Prescott, always drawn by literary history, toyed with the notion of writing a life of Molière, and he acquired from France all the books he needed for the task. The extraordinary success of his Ferdinand and Isabella, however, encouraged him, in his own words, to ‘go on with another subject, which seemed to be a natural continuation of the last, which had the superior advantage of relating to my own quarter of the globe and for which I now possessed eminent advantages for procuring original, unpublished material from Spain… Should I be so fortunate as to obtain them, it will give a new and most authentic basis to the history of a series of brilliant adventures, which, from their relation to my own country cannot fail, thus recommended, to have sufficient interest… Should I get the materials from Spain, I may produce a work of permanent value.’5

 Prescott’s choice of words in explaining his decision to write the History of the Conquest of Mexico is revealing. He was attracted to the prospect of continuing what he had already accomplished in his Ferdinand and Isabella, the narration of ‘a series of brilliant adventures’. Such narration would reveal the human spirit at its most noble and indomitable, and emphasize the vital role played by men and women of character in the onward march of history. This was a theme that would be dear not only to Prescott but to the Boston historians of a slightly younger generation, John Lothrop Motley (1814–77), the author of The Rise of the Dutch Republic, and Francis Parkman (1823–93), the great chronicler of the struggle between France and Britain for the domination of North America.6

 Equally revealing was Prescott’s insistence on the importance of a work that would have ‘sufficient interest’. The interest, in this instance, would come not only from the character of the personalities involved, and above all that of Cortés himself, but also from the circumstance that the book would be dealing with the history of the western hemisphere, and thus impinge on the history of the future United States, a young republic that would invade Mexico, a still younger republic, three years after the publication of Prescott’s Conquest. The interest was enhanced, too, by the fact that the story involved a ‘grand theme’. The creation and fall of empires, the origins of nations, the progress of liberty and the advance of civilization all provided the kind of ‘grand theme’ that Prescott and his fellow Boston historians considered essential for the writing of great history.7 Finally, the use of original sources would confer permanent value, rather than mere ephemeral success, on a book that might otherwise be no more than a retelling, however brilliant, of a relatively familiar story. 

 In reality, an account of the Spanish conquest of Mexico proved to be ideally suited both to Prescott’s idea of history and to his particular gifts. He was heir to the great historical tradition of the eighteenth century, that of Gibbon and William Robertson, the Scottish historian whose History of America (1777) was one of the most famous historical works of its age, and whose shadow hovered above Prescott as he wrote. Like Gibbon and Robertson he regarded history as a branch of letters and, like them, he saw himself as an exponent of ‘philosophic history’, which combined factual accuracy and narrative skill with a determination to discover the underlying causes of events from the standpoint of a society that conceived of history in terms of the continuing improvement of manners and morals, and the progressive advance of civilization, towards the felicitous state it had attained in eighteenth-century Europe.8

 But if Prescott was the self-conscious heir of the eighteenth century, he was also a member of the generation that experienced the full force of the Romantic movement of the early nineteenth. Romantic historians tended to see the past in terms of great men – of heroic individuals who embodied the spirit of their nation. Daring deeds and sheer force of character enabled these heroes to overcome one obstacle after another as they led their people on the treacherous but upward path that would eventually lead the human race to the full and universal enjoyment of political and spiritual liberty. Romantic history, however, demanded not only the assertion of great moral principles, but also a powerful visual imagination and the capacity to depict historical events with a literary skill that would enable readers to visualize the scene and experience the emotions of the moment as if they were physically present. Not for nothing was Sir Walter Scott the presiding literary genius of this generation. 

 Prescott had already displayed this skill in his Ferdinand and Isabella, and the Spanish conquest of Mexico offered him an even greater opportunity for deploying it to the full. In the figure of Cortés he had a hero, who, for all his defects, accomplished a feat that seemed little short of miraculous in overthrowing the mighty Aztec empire with no more than a handful of men. While Cortés symbolized all the energy, confidence and daring of the Spanish people at their moment of greatness, Montezuma, hesitant and pusillanimous, faced him as the representative of a civilization that, in spite of important achievements, was plainly inferior to that of Spain. The story itself was packed with drama – with heroic marches, fiercely contested battles and displays of courage and treachery in equal measure – and had as its backdrop the exotic landscapes of Mexico, with its jungles and volcanoes, and the lake city of Tenochtitlan shimmering in the sunlight. With such a story, and such a setting, Prescott could hardly fail, and he knew it. 

 All that he needed was sufficient documentary material to give his account the freshness and originality it demanded. By the end of April 1839 he had what he wanted. The President of the Spanish Royal Academy of History, Martín Fernández de Navarrete, not only gave the copyists employed by Prescott full access to the many manuscripts it housed, but also generously offered him transcripts from his own extensive collection. Prescott noted in his Literary Memoranda the recent receipt of ‘one large parcel of letters of the MSS., amounting in all to 2500 pp., and consisting of letters of Cortés and the principal actors in his drama, and of other notices and records, hitherto unpublished… Thus, the doubt as to the acquisition of the materials essential to the success of my undertaking is dispelled.’9 By July he had worked out the ground-plan of the book, but the long introductory section on Aztec civilization – the part that now looks most dated – took him two years of study and writing, and it was not until the summer of 1841 that he was able to embark on the theme that really excited him, the drama of Cortés’s march into the interior and the extraordinary succession of events that followed. The last pages were written in July 1843, exactly as he had planned.10 The book was published a few months later, and took the United States and Europe by storm. 

 Why was the Conquest of Mexico such an instant and immediate success, and why does it continue to be read more than a century and a half after its original publication? Prescott himself, in contemplating the work he had in mind before setting pen to paper, provides a clue to the answer. ‘The true way of conceiving the subject’, he wrote, ‘is, not as a philosophical theme, but as an epic in prose, a romance of chivalry… which, while it combines all the picturesque features of the romantic school, is borne onwards on a tide of destiny, like that which broods over the fictions of the Grecian poets; – for surely there is nothing in the compass of Grecian epic or tragic fable, in which the resistless march of destiny is more discernible, than in the sad fortunes of the dynasty of Montezuma. – It is, without doubt, the most poetic subject every offered to the pen of the historian.’11

An epic in prose. Once he had set the scene, Prescott realized that his readers would be carried along by the sheer excitement of a drama that he could present as unfolding with all the inevitability of a Greek tragedy. As he saw it, it was ‘the resistless march of destiny’ that gave the overthrow of Montezuma’s empire its inevitability, and the source of this inevitability was to be found in the character of Aztec civilization itself. The written sources available to him for the study of this civilization were limited, and Mexican archaeology at the time of his writing was still in its infancy. As a result, the picture he could paint of pre-Colombian Mexico was bound to be superficial. While well aware of the achievements of the Aztecs, and impressed by Spanish accounts of Tenochtitlan and the great temple-pyramid – the teocalli – at its centre, he could write of Montezuma as having ‘the rude intellect of a barbarian’.12 Even if the emperor’s subjects were no longer savages, they were at best ‘semi-civilized’.13 ‘The Aztec’, he wrote,‘had plainly reached that middle station, as far above the rude races of the New World as it was below the cultivated communities of the Old.’14 This inferiority to the ‘cultivated communities’ of the Old World meant that, with the arrival of the Spaniards, Montezuma and his empire were doomed from the start.  That sense of doom pervades Prescott’s account of the conquest, giving the story the air of tragic inevitability that he was so anxious to convey to his readers, and that continues to haunt every subsequent retelling of it. Providence tends to play an active part in Prescott’s narrative, but underlying his sense of the role of Providence and destiny lay the conviction of the progressive march of civilization that was characteristic of eighteenth- and nineteenth-century views about the nature of the historical process. If he conceded some important aspects of civilization to the Mexicans, not least in ‘astronomical science’, which he described as being ‘so disproportioned to their progress in other walks of civilization’15 , he noted as indicators of their lack of civility their ‘bigotry’ and ‘superstition’, and the ‘revolting usages’16 of their priests, including human sacrifice. In this, Montezuma was a faithful representative of the Aztec people, as Prescott makes plain in his verdict on the emperor: ‘If we cannot refuse our contempt for the pusillanimity of the Aztec monarch, it should be mitigated by the consideration, that his pusillanimity sprung from his superstition, and that superstition in the savage is the substitute for religious principle in the civilised man.’17 All the more curious, then, that Montezuma’s equally superstitious subjects should have displayed such courage and endurance as they fought to save Tenochtitlan. 

 In writing of Aztec superstition – exemplified by the faith placed by Montezuma in oracles and prophecies, and his supposed identification of Cortés with the returning god Quetzalcoatl18 – Prescott was confronted by something of a dilemma. In the eyes of nineteenth-century Anglo– Americans, Spanish civilization was itself a byword for bigotry and superstition. It was the Protestant world, not the Catholic, that was in the vanguard of human progress, and the image of Spain was indelibly tarnished by the Black Legend of Spanish cruelty and fanaticism.19 Prescott, as a historian of Spain who was also a convinced Protestant, naturally had to face up in his work to the question of Spanish religion. He confronted it head-on in the pen-portrait of Cortés with which the Conquest concludes: ‘One trait more remains to be noticed in the character of this remarkable man: that is, his bigotry, the failing of the age, – for, surely, it should be termed only a failing… We should throw ourselves back (it cannot be too often repeated) into the age; the age of the Crusades. For every Spanish cavalier, however sordid and selfish might be his private motives, felt himself to be the soldier of the Cross… To the more rational spirit of the present day, it may seem difficult to reconcile gross deviations from morals with such devotion to the cause of religion. But the religion taught in that day was one of form and elaborate ceremony… In a worship that is addressed too exclusively to the senses, it is often the case that morality becomes divorced from religion…’20 In other words, Cortés and his fellow Spaniards were motivated by true religion, even if in that religion, in its Roman Catholic version, could now be seen as defective. No such concession was made to the superstitious Montezuma and his fellow Aztecs. 

 The scales were thus tilted against the Aztecs from the start, and continued to be so as the drama unfolded. While Prescott allowed the Aztecs, with the exception of their emperor, to be highly courageous, as befitted a people still not far removed from savagery, he was inclined to attribute to their methods of warfare such characteristics as deceit, duplicity and treachery, while glossing over the fact that the Spaniards could be tarred with just the same brush.21 Cortés is all too often accorded the benefit of the doubt, as in the fateful decision to take Montezuma into custody. Prescott expresses his own doubts about the morality of the ‘kidnapping of a friendly sovereign’, but then goes on to argue that ‘to view the matter differently, we must take the position of the Conquerors, and assume with them the original right of conquest. Regarded from this point of view, many difficulties vanish. If conquest were a duty, whatever was necessary to effect it was right also. Right and expedient become convertible terms…’22 Explaining can all too easily drift into explaining away. 

 Prescott was inevitably largely dependent on his Spanish sources, in particular Cortés’s own ‘Letters of Relation’23 and Bernal Díaz’s wonderful eyewitness chronicle of the conquest.24 But while well aware of the need to scrutinize these sources carefully, he also needed, for the purposes of his drama, to present Cortés as endowed with the qualities of the hero. ‘Cortés’, he writes, ‘was not a vulgar conqueror.’ Rather, ‘he was a knight-errant, in the literal sense of the word.’25 The story of the conquest of Mexico for Prescott is the story of the triumph of bold ambition, and of astute and intelligent leadership that amounted to genius. Cortés, like a true knight-errant, set forth on a mission that lesser men would have regarded as impossible, but by sheer courage and force of personality he vanquished all the odds. He was seen at his greatest at the moment of disaster, the noche triste of his forced retreat from Tenochtitlan: ‘Circumstances so appalling as would have paralysed a common mind, only stimulated his to higher action, and drew forth all its resources. He combined what is most rare, singular coolness and constancy of purpose, with a spirit of enterprise that might well be called romantic.’26

 By concentrating attention on Cortés and his qualities as a leader, Prescott was able to give the story of the conquest a dramatic unity. He does not neglect the band of men under Cortés’s command, men who ‘bore hearts stout and courageous as ever beat in human bosoms’27 , nor does he ignore the part played by Cortés’s Indian allies in his ultimate success, but over and over again at the moments of crisis it is Cortés who saves the day through his bravery and resourcefulness. This gives the seven books of The Conquest of Mexico an architectural unity that was one of the reasons for its success. Inevitably a feeling for the structure of the narrative is lost when it is not read in its entirety, but something of it can be glimpsed from the selections from books 3 to 5 included in this volume, most notably the episode of Cortés’s defeat of the expedition sent to overthrow him under the command of the perfect anti-hero, the lax and arrogant Pánfilo de Narváez, and the searing account of the retreat from Tenochtitlan. At that point the Spaniards appeared to have lost everything, but in the book which follows, and which is not included here, the indomitable Cortés again rises to the occasion, lays siege to the Aztec capital, and finally ensures the overthrow of the Aztec empire and the conquest of Mexico for Spain. 

 In both these episodes Prescott’s narrative style is displayed at its best, so perfectly paced that even today’s readers, conditioned by fast-paced drama and powerful visual imagery, are still likely to be gripped by the excitement of the story. Inevitably, here as elsewhere, Victorian turns of phrase tend at times to make his prose appear overblown, just as it can also lapse into the stately. In some respects, indeed, The Conquest of Mexico is not unlike a Victorian pageant, with one tableau succeeding another against an exotic backdrop. Cortés’s army, for instance, is described as descending towards ‘the broad plains of the tierra caliente, spread out like a boundless ocean of verdure below them.’28 It is another perfect tableau. Even if Prescott’s forests have a tendency to be ‘verdant’ rather than green, he can summon up sights and sounds in ways that still resonate with a modern reader. For all the occasional grandiloquence of his style, he remains a master both of the formal set-piece and of dramatic movement. 

 Inevitably, in style and conception The Conquest of Mexico remains very much of its age, and this has naturally diminished its usefulness as a historical source as the years have passed. The Spanish texts on which Prescott was dependent remain as fundamental to the story in our day as in his, but are nowadays read with a rather more critical eye than that with which he tended to appraise them. His idealization of Cortés as the quintessential hero prevented him from appreciating the complexity of his character, and made him a one-dimensional figure. It is now generally appreciated that Cortés’s letters are self-serving documents that cannot be taken at their face value, and sometimes come closer to fiction than to historical fact.29 Full of admiration for his hero, Prescott was inclined to dismiss criticisms of Cortés as mere slanders by his enemies, but extensive use of the documents produced during the course of the judicial inquiry into his activities and preserved in Seville’s Archive of the Indies, has made possible the more nuanced portrait presented in Hugh Thomas’s The Conquest of Mexico, the closest modern approximation to Prescott’s grand narrative.30

 It is, however, on the Mexican rather than the Spanish side of the story that the picture painted by Prescott has been most dramatically transformed. The reasons for this are various. Archaeology has transformed our knowledge of pre-conquest Mexico. Intensive work has been done on the interpretation of Mexican pictographs31 , and on the texts of indigenous Nahuatl accounts of the conquest.32 Above all, a profound change in Western attitudes towards the non-Western world occurred in the course of the twentieth century, as colonial empires collapsed and former colonial peoples began to claim their places in the sun. With these changes, the condescending view of non-Western civilizations that informed the approach of Prescott and his contemporaries lost its hold, and it became deeply unfashionable to see history as the story of the slow but steady progress of the human race towards the level of ‘civilization’ achieved by the West. As part of this process of re-evaluation, historians set out to recover ‘the vision of the vanquished’33 , and to reconstruct the histories of ‘peoples without history’34 , victims not only of imperial domination but also of the lack of written records. 

 The Aztecs have been among the beneficiaries of this process, and in recent years ethnographers and historians have made ambitious efforts to see their civilization in its own terms, rather than filtered through the distorting lens held up by their conquerors.35 The same holds true of the history of the conquest itself, as historians try to tease out an indigenous version of events from contemporary or near-contemporary indigenous accounts, many of them collected by the Spanish friar Bernardino de Sahagún and preserved in Book XII of the Florentine Codex.36 But while a sympathetic reading of these and other sources may have brought us closer than Prescott to an understanding of indigenous perceptions of the conquest, the whole exercise remains problematic. How far can we rely on the memories of people trying to make sense of what had happened two or three decades after the event, and many of them still traumatized by the collapse of the world they had known or dimly remembered? Even where the oral tradition remained unbroken and memories were reasonably accurate, can we be sure that these Christian converts transmitted the information in unvarnished form to the friars who recorded their words, rather than conforming it to the expectations of their religious mentors? Equally, how far did the friars themselves really understand and accurately record what their Nahua informants were telling them? 

 These and similar questions about the reliability of the available evidence have bedevilled all attempts, from Prescott’s time to our own, to solve some of the difficult problems that face every historian or would-be historian of the conquest. Prescott, for instance, found in the account of the omens preceding the arrival of the Spaniards, and also in the story of the expected return of Quetzalcoatl to reclaim the land from which he had long ago been driven, an explanation of Montezuma’s strange passivity in the face of Cortés and his men: ‘He felt as if the destinies which had so long brooded over the royal line of Mexico were to be accomplished, and the sceptre was to pass away from his house for ever.’37 Montezuma’s assumed identification of Cortés with Quetzalcoatl has been a staple element of the story from Prescott’s day to our own, but it has also come to be contested as a post-conquest fabrication.38 Equally, the omens have been shown to possess suspicious affinities with the omens and prodigies recorded by classical authors like Plutarch, Lucan and Josephus.39 If the Quetzalcoatl myth and the story of the omens are no more than retrospective attempts to make sense of the extraordinary succession of events, Prescott’s doom-laden interpretation of Montezuma’s behaviour loses much of its credibility. 

 In spite of the advance of knowledge about the belief systems of the Aztecs and their cyclical concept of history, it seems unlikely that the mystery of the Quetzalcoatl story will ever be solved. The evidence is simply too thin. The same remains true of another of the great mysteries of the conquest: the true cause of Montezuma’s death. Was he killed by stones thrown by his own rebellious subjects, as the account commonly goes, or was he put to death by the Spaniards, as one or two alternative sources suggest? Or did he perhaps die ‘as much under the anguish of a wounded spirit, as under disease’, as Prescott was inclined to believe?40 Again it is highly improbable that the truth will ever be known. 

 Although Prescott was well aware of the problems of evidence, the history of the conquest of Mexico remains far more complex than he imagined it. For him, it was the story of the overthrow of an empire that was doomed to defeat by the superiority, spiritual as well as material, of the European civilization that brought about its downfall. He could look on the defeated with admiration for their bravery and with a real sense of compassion, but the comment in his Literary Memoranda as he wrote up the noche triste tells its own story: ‘It did not cost me as much to kill Montezuma – as it did Isabella, tho’ I rather love the barbarian.’41 The future belonged to the white races of the north, and the moral and spiritual inferiority of the Aztecs inevitably consigned them to the dust-heap of history. 

 Yet, for all its limitations, Prescott’s History of the Conquest of Mexico still casts its spell. He may have made his mistakes, but he sifted the evidence carefully, and much of his narrative has stood the test of time. Although he idealized Cortés, he appreciated, as some of his successors have not, that the conquest of Mexico was not simply a foreign conquest, but also a Mexican civil war. ‘The Aztec monarchy’, he wrote, ‘fell by the hands of its own subjects, under the direction of European sagacity and science.’42 Later historians have naturally brought further evidence into play, and in particular have achieved a greater understanding of the civilization that was overthrown between 1519 and 1521. But they have not come much nearer to solving the mysteries that baffled Prescott; and, while necessarily complicating the story in their pursuit of a closer approximation to the truth, they have deprived it of something of the epic character with which he endowed it. When it came to providing a narrative of Cortés’s conquest of Mexico the very weaknesses of Prescott – his idealization of the self-reliant individual, his Bostonian assumptions and prejudices, his predilection for vivid romance – turned out to be his greatest source of strength. By reducing the story to an epic drama with poetic and melancholy overtones, he made it unforgettable for generations of readers. 

J. H. Elliott