To be is to be contingent: nothing of which it can be said that "it is" can be alone and independent. But being is a member of paticca-samuppada as arising which contains ignorance. Being is only invertible by ignorance.

Destruction of ignorance destroys the illusion of being. When ignorance is no more, than consciousness no longer can attribute being (pahoti) at all. But that is not all for when consciousness is predicated of one who has no ignorance than it is no more indicatable (as it was indicated in M Sutta 22)

Nanamoli Thera

Saturday, April 19, 2025

The War on Terror - conversation with Christopher Bollyn


G&B: I’m Bonnie Faulkner. Today on Guns and Butter, Christopher Bollyn. Today’s show: “The War on Terror — The Plot to Rule the Middle East”.

Christopher Bollyn is an independent researcher, investigative journalist, and author. He spent three years traveling extensively throughout Europe and the Middle East. He studied Egyptian, Biblical Hebrew, and Norwegian, at the University of Oslo. He is a graduate of the University of California in history, with an emphasis on Israel-Palestine.

Along with research and writing, he has worked as an editor and translator. His travels and studies of German, Spanish, Norwegian, Swedish, Hebrew, and Arabic languages, have helped him analyze international politics and event.

He is the author of “Solving 9/11 — The Deception That Changed the World”, “Solving 9/11 — The Articles”, and “The War on Terror — The Plot to Rule the Middle East”. His newest book, out on September 11th, 2019, is “Solving 9/11 — The Articles Vol II

Christopher Bollyn, welcome!

Bollyn: Thank you. It’s nice to be with you.

G&B: You begin your book “The War on Terror — The Plot to Rule the Middle East” with a quote from then President George White Bush, one week after the attacks of September 11th. Quote:

“This crusade, this war on terrorism, is going to take a while.”

Unquote. At the same time Congress passed the “Authorization to Use Military Force”. What does this authorization to use military force authorize the President to do?

Bollyn: Well it’s an open-ended funding and authorization. Which allows the President to basically wage war against anybody he deems to have been involved in the terror attacks of 9/11, or to be harboring anybody who was involved in the terrorist attacks of 9/11. So it provides the money, and the political authorization, to wage war based on the President’s decision that that entity was involved in September 11.

G&B: And this authorization to use military force is not just against other countries, but organizations, and individuals, right?

Bollyn: Right. Anybody that he sees to have been in some way involved in the terror attacks of 9/11. And that could be also a country like Afghanistan, who they said was harboring the Al-Qaeda group that they said did 9/11. But this authorization has been abused since 2001, and under the “War on Terror”, under the guise of fighting the “War on Terror”, under that authorization, they’ve waged war in dozens of countries.

G&B: Now since the Constitution gives the right of declaring war, does this authorization take away that right from Congress? I mean, it basically hands it over to the President. It makes it his decision, isn’t that right?

Bollyn: Right. Yeah, it’s like an abdication of their responsibilities. That they have basically given him a rubber stamp that he can use to wage war wherever he sees fit. It’s his decision, and his decision alone, as to where he wants to wage war.

G&B: What is the significance of the US President stating that the terror attacks of 9/11 were, quote:

“An act of war.”?

Bollyn: Well that’s very important. They made that declaration already on the first day, on September 11th. That’s important, because it means that as an “act of war”, that the government will respond to it accordingly, using military force. And wage war against the people that they said did this, that committed this terrorist attack. And so the attack on the Pentagon was the one thing that allowed them to make that determination, because the Pentagon is, of course, an American military fortress. So, when you have a military attack on a military fortress it is a military, an act of war.

And so using that that logic it precluded the need for there to be any criminal investigation to determine who was really behind 9/11. So, it gave them an easy way out for those people who wanted to wage war in the first place!

G&B: Right. The ability to wage a war, because of these attacks, then negated the necessity to hold a criminal investigation, isn’t that what you’re saying?

Bollyn: Right! And then the authorization to use military force was passed a couple days after 9/11. So, based on that, George Bush was able to take the country to war less than a month after 9/11 happened, in Afghanistan, because everything was basically allowed. The authorization, the funding, and the logic.

G&B: You point out that the US has conducted major military operations in Afghanistan, Pakistan, Iraq, Somalia, Yemen, Libya, Syria, and the Philippines. Has any evidence been presented that any of these countries were involved in the terror attacks of September 11th?

Bollyn: No! Not even has evidence been presented to indict Osama bin Laden, for example. I mean, it’s a famous story about the FBI did not put Osama bin Laden on the most-wanted list for his involvement in 9/11. [He was listed wanted for other alleged crimes] Because they didn’t have evidence for that.

So the entire “War on Terror” is a war that is being fought under false premises. And the authorization to use military force is being abused! And they’ve spent something like seven trillion dollars on this war! This “War on Terror” that began in October 2001, has now gone on for over 18 years. And it’s the longest and most expensive war in US history.

G&B: General Wesley Clark in a presentation to the San Francisco Commonwealth Club, in 2007, said that there was a coup on 9/11, in the United States, “a policy coup”. What did General Clark mean by “a policy coup”?

Bollyn: Well, he said that:

“Some hard-nosed people took over the direction of American foreign policy and never bothered to inform the rest of us.”

And he pointed out that there were, in this memo that he had discovered, he had learned about when he went to the Pentagon a week, or so after 9/11, there were seven countries on this memo that the United States military was prepared to overthrow in the next five years. And those countries were Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Libya, Somalia, Sudan, and finishing off with Iran.

And that’s basically been the to-do list for the “War on Terror”. And yeah, that’s what they’ve done. And he discovered, he heard this memo and he was shocked that, … He had been the former chief of military in Europe during the Afghanistan war. He had just finished his service in Europe, and he knows policy. He knows what he’s talking about. He was running for President at the time. And he knows that this was a “policy coup” where what they call the “neo-cons”, the zionist neocons, people like Wolfowitz, had had dictated this policy. And this was being followed by the Pentagon.

G&B: How would you describe the Israeli “Yinon Plan” for the Middle East? Authored by Oded Yinon and translated in English by Israel Shahak. I believe this was written in 1982.

Bollyn: Right. It was published in 1982. Well in 1982, Oded Yinon — and he’s a strategist for the Likud Party — he was writing and serving under Ariel Sharon. He wrote this strategy for Israel in the 1980s. And it called for Israel to basically a wage war and to overthrow the Arab countries all across the region! All the Arab countries! And to break them up into ethnic statelets. Into, you know, along ethnic lines. It’s often called “balkanization”, and it resembles what was done to Yugoslavia.

So you take a large, secular, socialist, economy, if you will, and you break it up into small warring factions that don’t get along with each other. And this is exactly, … The Yinon Plan called for, on the Eastern Front, doing this first to Iraq and then Syria. Saying that Iraq was the main enemy, the largest, most formidable, enemy of Israel.

And the thing is that this is exactly what’s happened under the United States occupation of both Iraq and Syria.

And I saw in the news, just today, that Michael Pence is visiting Iraq, the Kurdish section of Iraq. So Iraq has been broken up into a Sunni section, a Shiite section, and a Kurdish section, in the north. And the same sort of thing is being done to Syria. And these were the first two targets for the Israeli plan known as the Yinon Plan. It was published in Hebrew, 1982

G&B: What are some of the drastic political and social changes that have been imposed on America and the world as a result of the 9/11 deception?

Bollyn: Well, it fundamentally changed the relationship between the citizen and the state. As you can see like in the United States when you go flying, traveling, you’re treated as a suspect, a terrorism suspect, even though you’re just a member of the traveling public. This can be on the trains, this could be on the planes. The way we’re treated when we go in through the security check.

And also there’s been a huge increase in the militarization of the police forces in America. This is partly due to the whole idea of preparing for, you know, the same sort of insurrection in the United States, as they have faced in Afghanistan and in Iraq. And also the fact that a lot of people that served in Iraq and Afghanistan, and the wars, have come back from the wars and gotten employed as police officers. So you have this whole militarization of America, the police. You see if everywhere you go. And that’s part of the, that’s the legacy of the “War on Terror”.

G&B: What exactly has the “War on Terror” brought us in terms of the rules of war, including torture. Now that never used to be allowed!

Bollyn: Right, right! They don’t call it “torture”, they call it “enhanced interrogation”. But yes, the rules have all been rewritten. So that we now have torture, as you say, we had big camps, you know, in Iraq, like Camp Bucca where people were tortured and abused systematically. And this was done, because they said that:

“There was a need to know what these people were up to.”

And so based on that, and the whole fear that they had imposed on the American public, people went along with it. They went along with this, thinking that these people that had done 9/11 were so evil, that anything would be, anything that could stop them, anything could hinder their evil plans, would be allowed. And like I said, America’s just become a very much a pro-war “anything goes” nation, after 9/11

G&B: How was the foe in the “War on Terror” created?

Bollyn: Well, that’s a very good question! You see the “War on Terror” is a very old doctrine. An Israeli doctrine, going back at least to the late 70s, when Menachem Begin — the arch terrorist of Israel history — when he became prime minister, he became prime minister in 70, 74, I think. His party came to leadership in 77. He was the Prime Minister then in 77.

Two years later he called a conference on “international terrorism” in Jerusalem, which was attended by something like 700 dignitaries from around the world. Owners of media, President George Bush’s father, George Herbert Walker Bush, who was running for President at a time. And they rolled out this doctrine in a three-day propaganda offensive in Jerusalem, called “The Jerusalem Conference on International Terrorism”. In which they said that:

“The new enemy of the West was terrorism, international terrorism.”

At the time they blamed it all on Russia. That Russia was behind this terrorism. And they said that what has to happen is that the Western militaries have to engage, you know, the terrorists in the Middle East. And those nations that are protecting them.

And so this was the doctrine. And this was the “War on Terror” doctrine, explained and laid out as the “new doctrine” for the West to follow. And what happened though, is that it didn’t go into effect immediately, because it required, of course, something like 9/11 to make the United States, you know, move it’s military operationally into the Middle East. So 9/11 was basically the spark plug, or the kick-start, that brought this “War on Terror” from 1979 into reality, into operation.

G&B: Of course, this “Jerusalem Conference on International Terrorism” that took place in 1979, and was arranged by then Israeli prime minister Menachem Begin, was extremely important and seminal in this whole “War on Terror”. And as you’ve mentioned, George HW Bush was in attendance. And he was running for President then. On the same subject, what is the “Jonathan Institute” and what was its purpose?

Bollyn: Right. Well the entity that hosted the conference was the Jonathan Institute. Jonathan is the first name of Jonathan Netanyahu. This is Benjamin Netanyahu’s older brother, who reportedly died, was killed, in the Israeli operation in Entebbe, Uganda, when there was a hijack planes have been taken there. And the Israeli covert force known as “Sayeret Matkal” went in and were able to release the hostages. But in the process of this rescue operation, Jonathan Netanyahu was killed.

So they named Institute after him. And so Menachem Begin was the organizer of the conference, he was the prime minister at the time. He was involved in Lebanon, you know, attacking Lebanon at the same time. And Benjamin Netanyahu, and his father, Benzion Netanyahu, were the conference hosts, if you will. They were the ones that organized it and got it arranged at their Institute. This isn’t an Institute that has any sort of address, physical address. It’s just an Institute. And it’s whole purpose was to promote the idea of the “War on Terror”.

G&B: You mentioned this operation at Entebbe, in Uganda. Wasn’t that a false flag? I mean, was that an actual hijacking, or was that staged?

Bollyn: Well, that’s a good question, you know. I don’t have enough information about the Entebbe operation, or, you know, other operations from that time period. People say the same thing about the Munich Massacre from the Olympics in 1972, it was, I think.

You know, and looking back today with our understanding of how Israeli false flag operations work, there’s a lot of question marks about, you know, these earlier operations. If they were staged, or, … But the thing is, that it’s very likely, and it’s not unreasonable that people think like that, because Israel has been doing false flag operations for a long time! They’ve been doing false flag operations since they became a state, and even before.

But the first false flag operation that that I know of the Israel did was in 1952, or 53. I think it’s called the Lavon Affair. And it was done in Egypt. And it was Israelis and some Egyptian jews, a cell, who were planting nitroglycerin bombs in British and American buildings, and libraries, and cultural centers, and theaters, and things like that.

And that was an operation that was discovered to be an Israeli false flag operation. It was meant to be blamed on the Islamic Brotherhood. But what happened is that the Egyptian police captured some of the agents, and they confessed.

G&B: In the same year as the Jerusalem Conference, veteran Israeli intelligence chief, Isser Harel, made a prediction. What was his prediction?

Bollyn: Yes, Isser Harel was the founder of the Israeli Mossad. He’s like the first real chief of the Mossad, and former head of the Shin Bet, which is Israel’s internal intelligence, like the FBI. And he said, he made a prediction to an American zionist, he predicted that Arabs would attack the tallest building in New York City. And that they would do this, because this is a symbol, you know, American fertility.

And yeah, that they would attack the tallest building in New York City. And he made that prediction in 1979.

And it was only reported after 9/11. It was reported by a guy named Michael Evans from Texas. He’s a jewish guy, who has a Christian evangelical operation called, “Jerusalem Prayers”, or something like that. But what he does is, he’s one of these Christian zionists who’s very pro-zionist. And he was very close with people like Menachem Begin, and Isser Harel.

And so at the same time that they had this conference Isser Harel was putting into his mind, into mister Michael Evans mind, the idea that, … Well, it’s called “The Jerusalem Prayer Team”, that’s what it’s called. That Arabs were targetting the United States of America, and they would target the tallest building in New York City.

I call this “ideation”. This is putting hints out there, putting the idea out there, through people like the evangelist Minister. They did the same thing in movie form, television shows. They put the idea out there that Arabs are targetting the tallest buildings in New York City. So when it happens, the public is a short way for them to understand that this is simply reality, imitating art! You know, that this has been predicted, and it’s understood. And:

“Well, that’s what happened! Didn’t you see the movie?”

G&B: Yes! Could you talk about Mossad operative, Arnon Milchan, and the Hollywood films he’s produced?

Bollyn: Arnon Milchan is right in the middle of this current case with Benjamin Netanyahu. Because he’s the Hollywood producer who was also a senior Israeli agent. He was an agent in an operation called “Lakam”, LAKAM. [LAKAM is an acronym for Bureau of Scientific Relations, an Israeli intelligence agency that collected scientific and technical intelligence abroad.] And that is Israel’s top secret operation to get components for their nuclear program from the United States. And this guy was their number one agent.

And he was at the same time he was a Hollywood film producer. He made “Pretty Woman”, “JFK”, “Brazil”, “Fight Club”, you know, lots of movies he’s made.

And in his movies there’s often ideation of the 9/11 attacks. For example, there’s a movie he made called, … The first movie ever made was called “The Medusa Touch” in 1978. In which a passenger aircraft is flown into the Pan Am building. And that’s the climactic scene of the movie, I think. It’s one year before the conference [Jerusalem Conference], and it’s very telling.

When you understand that, when you see that he, Arnon Milchan, was Israel’s top Israeli agent! He’s close friends with Ezra Weitzman, the Defense Minister of Israel at the time. He’s very close friends of Shimon Peres. Shimon Peres is the guy who brought him in. Shimon Peres is of course, the Godfather of the whole Israeli arsenal, nuclear arsenal. And this man, Arnon Milchan, his operation was to get what they needed for the nuclear arsenal.

And he was caught red-handed! His operation was caught red-handed smuggling nuclear triggers, something like 800 of them, from the United States to Israel! And at that time his employee who was involved in this operation, was Benjamin Netanyahu.

Now, in the trial with Benjamin Netanyahu, the charges that are placed against Netanyahu, part of it is, because he was receiving bribes, or gifts, very expensive gifts from Arnon Milchan.

G&B: Now, what about the television pilot, “The Lone Gunman” that you write about in your book, was co-produced by Arnon Milchan and Rupert Murdoch.

Bollyn: Yeah, well they had a television company together. They have, or they had, “Regency Productions”, I think it’s called. And they’re very close as well. Murdoch is very close to Arnon Milchan. Milchan was his landlord, or vice versa, but in any case they’re business partners as well. They’re co-owners of this TV production company.

And in 2000, Murdoch’s company “New Regency” films I think it was called, they made this production called “The Lone Gunman”, in which something like the 9/11 attack, very similar, happens in the film. It’s only a half an hour film — it’s made for TV — in which a passenger aircraft is hijacked remotely using a kind of more sophisticated chip called “Octium chip”. And the plane is hijacked using the override, so that the pilots don’t even know it, because the plane is being flown on autopilot. And what happens is that the plane is flown, is being flown directly into the World Trade Center. And at the last minute the pilots are able to regain control and just narrowly miss avoid hitting the World Trade Center.

But this movie came out, and was aired on Fox TV, in March of 2001. Six months before 9/11 happened.

And this is the thing what we see with Milchan, and Milchan-Murdoch films, is that the idea, the “ideation” of 9/11 is shown time, after time, after time. And the idea of the “War on Terror” is another part of his films.

In the movie Brazil, the futuristic film Brazil, it’s a state where, like the United States is today, where the state is waging a constant war against terrorism. And in doing so, it’s, you know, it’s imposing itself a great deal on its own people.

G&B: Yes, in the film Brazil, there are terrorist attacks and bombings just randomly! I remember a scene where some people are having an elegant dinner, and all of a sudden a bomb blows out the wall!

Bollyn: Mm hmm.

G&B: But it’s just routine and the waiters rush in, and put up a screen between the diners and the blown out wall! And it’s all presented as if it’s just a day in the life!

Bollyn: Yeah. And if you remember that scene in the restaurant where the women are talking about the operations and the surgeries they can get, and the bomb goes off. Just before the bomb goes off, the woman, one of the young girls says, “Salt?”, and she raises a jar of salt to offer salt, and then the bomb goes off! That’s very interesting.

And then, as soon as the bomb goes off, the band brushes themselves off, and starts playing. And what song do they start playing? The Hava Nagila, the zionist national anthem! Hava Nagila!

G&B: Oh my god, I forgot about that detail!

Bollyn: Whose idea was that! And that’s just like Arnon Milchan making a joke out of the whole thing, you know. This movie was made in 1985, or 86, and it’s like it’s a very, very interesting choice of music.

G&B: Yeah, that’s very chilling! You’ve mentioned how Arnon Milchan was involved in the smuggling of nuclear triggers out of the United States to Israel. Could you talk about the theft of nuclear material and uranium from the United States by Israeli operatives? Who were they? And what was the timeframe in which these thefts were taking place?

Bollyn: Well, there was an operation, I think it was in the 70s, or early 80s, from Apollo Pennsylvania in which Isser Harel, his men, his main men, were then Zvi Malkin and Shalom [Avraham] Bendor and a very key player in this is a man named Rafi Eitan.

Rafi Eitan, this man, was the head of the LAKAM program at the time. He was the head of the operation to get the components for nuclear materials. And he sent these men, Shalom Bandor and Zvi Malkin. And Rafi Eitan himself was a member of this group. They went to Apollo Pennsylvania and arranged with this man who owned this company, New Mec, I think it’s called. The man’s name was Ben Shapiro. And he was American jew who was willing to help.

And what happened is that after they visited the plant Apollo, and met with Mr Shapiro, the plutonium was then sent in special cartons to Israel by LA freighters. And this was the smuggling of plutonium to Israel for their nuclear weapons.

And it’s interesting that this is discussed in the book about Robert Maxwell, “Israel’s Superspy” [Robert Maxwell, Israel’s Superspy (2003) ] because, you know, Rafi Eitan played a big role in all of this stuff. And it also involved the theft of the PROMIS software. [Prosecutors Management Information System] That came a little bit later. That came in the 80s. But when Rafi Eitan was able to steal the PROMIS software — this is the prosecutors information management system — it allowed them to adapt the software for spying and sell to countries all around the world. Which gave the super user — the Israelis — access to everything that was going on in the networks that had bought the software.

G&B: Right. And you mentioned Robert Maxwell in connection to this stolen PROMIS software. And I believe in that book, isn’t he’s selling this software to other countries?

Bollyn: Yeah! They used Maxwell as their main sales agent. And he sold it, you know, first places like Zimbabwe, and South Africa, and then to Jordan, and countries in the Middle East. And it got everywhere! It got to banks, and Swiss banks. And then they, this was the PROMIS, this was the modified PROMIS software.

So they got the PROMIS software from the Department of Justice. And he was — Rafi Eitan — was travelling in the United States under an alias. I think was named David Orr, or something like that. Dr. David Orr. So, he was using the identity of an Israeli man — a real doctor in Jerusalem — and travelling under his name.

And they got this software, and then they he adapted it. He brought it back to Israel and they adapted it for spying. So they put a microchip in there and they moved things around, so that this became an enterprise spyware. And this was in the 80s, this is like in 1984.

And then 83, 84, and then they kept developing this, the capacity of, the capabilities of the software into something called “pTech”. And pTech was the software that was running on all the American military computers and the federal computers on 9/11. And this was again, the spy software that was developed by Israel. And that was being used to monitor what happened at the FAA on 9/11. And it’s part of, it’s a very important aspect of the computer crime with 9/11.

G&B: Right. And you pointed out to me something I hadn’t thought of but that “pTech” probably is a shortened form of PROMIS technology, right?

Bollyn: Right. It stands to reason, because it’s the same sort of software. It’s enterprise software that gives you not only access to everything that’s going on in the network in real time, but it gives you surveillance, and the ability to intervene, to do something, to change something.

And this would explain, for example, why the American military was unable to respond effectively to the hijackings on 9/11, because planes were diverted, you know, communications were missed. So the attacks went on, unhindered.

G&B: And I think we might also mention, with regard to Robert Maxwell, that he is, of course, the father of Ghilane Maxwell, who’s been in the news lately, with regard to the Jeffrey Epstein scandal, right?

Bollyn: Right, right.! And in the Epstein scandal you see that one of the most conspicuous Israelis involved in that was Ehud Barak — the former head of Israeli military intelligence — was seen photographed coming in and out of the townhouse of Jeffrey Epstein. And he would stay at Jeffrey Epstein’s house, one of his houses, when he was in town.

So yeah, it’s an Israeli operation. You know, the Epstein thing was an Israeli operation. And it was used to control people of influence, politicians, and what-have-you. And if you look at the list of people who flew on the “Lolita Express”, or who stayed on Jeffrey Epstein’s island, it’s all the big shots. It’s all the top brass.

G&B: You write that when we examine the historical roots of the 9/11 atrocity and the “War on Terror”, we find more indications that 9/11 and the “War on Terror” both originate from the same source. What are some of the key events, beginning in 1977, that point to a common origin for both 9/11 and the “War on Terror”? Now, I know you’ve already mentioned a few of them, but what event occurred in 1977?

Bollyn: Well that’s when the Likud Party came to power. As I said, that’s when Menachem Begin came to power. And Menachem Begin is a unabashed, notorious, terrorist. He was involved in the bombing of the King David Hotel, back in 1946. He was involved in the Deir Yassin massacre. You know, when they mastered an entire village near Jerusalem, to put the fear into the Palestinians.

So when this man came to power, … You know, as Dr. Einstein wrote in 1948, Einstein warned the American jews and the American community, that if Menachem Begin ever comes to power, if his party ever comes to power — it was known as “Herut” at that time — these are terrorists and they will do terrible things!

And, you know, unfortunately the warnings of Albert Einstein were not heeded. But anybody who’s followed Israeli politics over the decades knows that the likes of Ariel Sharon, and Yitzhak Shamir, and Menachem Begin, these are people who came to power using terrorism! Terrorism is their modus operandi! So that when they came to power politically, in 1977, it would be no surprise, should be no surprise, that they immediately engaged in wars of aggression against Lebanon, for example. And they immediately began using terrorism.

There’s a book that came out “Rise and Kill First”, came out last year. And it’s written by an Israeli guy. It’s a discussion of, it’s a description of all of the, not all, but a lot of the Israeli assassinations over the years. And in this book they talk about, in 1979 Israeli military intelligence created a terrorist network in Lebanon, in which the Israelis themselves were putting car bombs, and donkey bombs, and truck bombs, which operated for four years! For four years, until 1983. And causing chaos and wars in Lebanon between various factions.

And, of course, remember 1983, what happened to the American barracks in Beirut. It was blown up by a truck bomb that the Mossad knew all about. So that was the beginning of the “War on Terror”.

And as I said, that they had the conference in 1979, in which they laid out the doctrine that the West should engage, you know, Islamic terrorism across the region, because it’s a struggle of the West.

And then in 1982, again, the Oded Yinon Plan came out, which called for the balkanization of all the Arab states. Well, how is little Israel go to balkanize all the states? Well, in order to do that they obviously had to get the Western militaries in there to do the hard lifting that required, they needed it to be done, in places like Iraq and Syria. That’s exactly what’s happened!

And so then, fast forward to, like, 9/11 happened. And that was as I said, the kick-start for the whole “War on Terror”! That Bibi Netanyahu had been pushing for decades!

If you remember, in the 80s Netanyahu came out with — after the first conference in Jerusalem — he came out with books about it. He came out with books in which he reprinted the speeches that were given, or the articles that were written about it.

And he promoted this “War on Terror”. And he wrote books like “Fighting Terrorism” and “How the West Can Win” [Terrorism: How the West Can Win]. And so he was pushing this, like, uphill all the way! And when I read those books about, you know how was this gonna happen, how does it come to fruition? Well 9/11 is how it happened!

So when 9/11 happened, they were able to kick-start the “War on Terror” that he’d been pushing for so long. So when he was asked by the New York Times on 9/11:

“What does this mean? What does what happened today mean for Israeli-American relations?”

And he said:

“It’s very good!”

He blurted it out!:

“It’s very good!”

He said [correcting himself]:

“Well, it’s not very good, but it’ll bring sympathy for Israeli position.”

Or something like that. So it’s like, you know, he couldn’t hold himself back! And then, all the interpretation that we got about the events of 9/11 came through, from him, and Ehud Barak.

Ehud Barack was in the BBC television studio in London shortly after the towers were struck. And he was calling for, … He blamed Osama bin Laden! He said that:

“Now is the time to start a concrete operational ‘War on Terror’.”

And that’s exactly what we got! And then as I said, then there was the memo in the Pentagon that was circulating at the highest levels, calling for the overthrow of seven countries in five years. And they took a little bit longer than five years, but that’s exactly what we’ve done. And now, of course, in the cross-hairs is Iran.

G&B: You address the question of which came first, the terror attacks of 9/11, or the “War on Terror”. How would you answer this question?

Bollyn: Which came first, 9/11, or the “War on Terror”?

G&B: Yes.

Bollyn: Yeah, well as I said, before 9/11 happened on September 11th 2001. But the “War on Terror” doctrine preceded it by, what, 22 years at least. So, it’s like, they laid out that the whole idea of the “War on Terror”. They laid out the logic, they laid out the propaganda for it, before they achieved it. And in order to achieve it they had to get, of course, the United States military into the region. So that’s what 9/11 was all about.

And as you saw, it was all done like on a greased slide. They had the authorization to use military force, they had declared it an “act of war”, they had the Pentagon attack. So it was a foregone conclusion that the United States military would respond. And it was all prepared in advance! It was all very carefully laid out, so that it was a given, it was a given, that after 9/11, United States would go into the Middle East and start waging war.

And it started in Afghanistan and then they pushed for Iraq. And this is all part of the doctrine of the “Project for a New American Century”. That paper that came out one year before 9/11, in which they called for a complete change in the American military policy and foreign policy. They should become the policemen of the world, that the United States should should occupy Iraq — whether Saddam Hussein is on the throne, or not — simply, because it’s too important of a country to be left to its own.

And this was all discussed in the lead-up to the election in 2000, when George Bush won. And it was, … They knew that if George Bush won, and with Ariel Sharon winning in Israel, that it was a pretty clear, you know, pretty clear that there would be a war coming out of this constellation of hard-line people.

It’s very similar to what happened in 1982 when you had Ronald Reagan and Menachem Begin in power. An ideologue like Reagan, and an ideologue like Bush, with a Likud politician like Ariel Sharon, you’re going to get conflict.

G&B: Who was Ali Mohammed, and what role did he play in creating the enemy to be fought in the “War on Terror”?

Bollyn: Well, Ali Mohammed was the first trainer for Osama bin Laden.

And what happened is that when the, of course, when the Soviet, the Red Army conquered Afghanistan there was this Mujahideen force that was dislocated into Pakistan. Afghans who were fighting against the Red Army for Afghanistan. And what happened is the United States — this is part of the Charlie Wilson story — congressman Charlie Wilson from Texas, he and the Saudi Arabians, and the Pakistanis, agreed to put up the money.

And what happened is that the Israelis under Ehud Barak — again — when Ehud Barak was head of military intelligence in 83, 84 and 85, I think it was, he began providing the weapons and the training for the Mujahideen, who were training in Pakistan, and then going back into Afghanistan and fighting.

And so what he did is, he took the weapons off the battlefield from Lebanon in 82, and transferred them to Pakistan. And the Pakistani government was aware that this was being done by Israel. It was secret and everything, but if they allowed it to go on, …

And one of the trainers who was training these Arabs, these Afghan Arabs they are called — people like Osama bin Laden — was a man called Ali Mohammed, who happens to be a Hebrew speaking agent, supposedly from Egypt, probably an Egyptian jew, or something. I don’t know. But he spoke Hebrew. And he learned Hebrew probably from being the trainer with the Israeli intelligence working in Pakistan. But this is the man who trained and set up all these operations that were done in the name of Osama bin Laden.

So he set up other operations as well, like the shooting in New York of Maher Kahana, and things like that.

Ali Mohammed then, was then finally arrested. And he had been trained in America, as well. He was then put in a federal penitentiary, a federal prison, and then he disappeared from the federal prison without a trace!

Kind of like what happened to Jeffrey Epstein.

G&B: What has your research revealed about the origins of the terrorist videos?

Bollyn: Well the terrorist videos, you know, they all have come to us from one source. And that source is SITE Intelligence Group. And recently there’s a couple more branches, derivatives of that group, but SITE Intelligence Group is a propaganda, … I call it a propaganda tool of the Israeli state.

It’s based in Maryland. Bethesda, Maryland. It’s run by an Iraqi jewish woman named Rita Katz. And these videos would be provided from her SITE Intelligence Group to the media, and the subscribers. And there was one of the videos back in, I know 2009, or something, about Osama bin Laden. And in that case she had sent this video, of a beheading, maybe it was a beheading video. She had sent this video out to several people in the administration, high up people in the government. And before it had been released [by ISIL]. And she told them:

“Don’t tell anybody had this video until it’s been released by the, …”

All Qaeda, or ISIL, whatever it was. But somehow it leaked. And so it became known that she had this video. This Israeli woman had this video and had released it to the media, before it had even been released by the people who were the terrorists!

So you have to say:

“Well how did this woman have the video before it’s even been released by the Arab terrorists?”

And this is the thing, is that in order to keep the “War on Terror” going, and to steer this monster, they have to occasionally do things, or bring out information or, you know, “interpret” what’s going on in the Middle East for the Americans.

And just like 9/11, how 9/11 was “interpreted”, it was interpreted for the United States government, for the military, by Ehud Barak. It’s the same thing what Rita Katz and SITE intelligence is doing, they are interpreting the Middle East for us.

And so what’s amazing is these groups like ISIS, and ISIL, and Al Qaeda, who can make all these flashy videos, and do all these things, are unable to actually reach the Western media themselves, directly. It always goes through this Israeli bottleneck, if you will.

And it’s interesting that you asked about what General Wesley Clark said about this policy coup. And he had said that when this happened, when 9/11 happened, he said that:

“We did not have American understanding of it.”

9/11, he’s talking about. And what he means to say is that, we didn’t, our understanding of 9/11 did not come from America, American sources, from American intelligence. It came to our understanding, it came from Israel. Israel interpreted 9/11 for us! And that’s the case all throughout the whole saga.

The whole deception of 9/11, you know, 9/11 was done in order to achieve a certain agenda. And that agenda was the “War on Terror”.

Now the “War on Terror” and the attacks the United States has done against the Arab states, makes no sense! It makes no sense for Osama bin Laden to do something like that. He didn’t do this big sophisticated attack, because he hates America liberties and freedoms!

It was done for a much more, much bigger reason.

And that reason was to start the “War on Terror”.

And the “War on Terror” is an Israeli construct. So that the sophistication of 9/11, and the end result of 9/11, strongly indicate that this is an Israeli, or a zionist operation, from A to Z!

And look at the actual memorial, the Ground Zero Memorial, in New York City. It was also designed and built by an Israeli! It was built by the former ambassador, Israeli ambassador’s son, Arad. Michael Arad.

G&B: Yes, with regard to the 9/11 memorial in New York City, I finally saw it a few years ago. And it’s very, very, dark! I was quite shocked by it!

It’s, a lot of, … I believe the museum is actually underground. And the waterfalls, there are these waterfalls that go down into the ground. In the shape of the footprints of the Twin Towers. But it’s very, it’s black looking! And then there’s this bizarre, huge white, it looks like the skeleton of  a dinosaur, or something! I mean, the wrong thing is really weird!

Bollyn: Yeah. And the guy that, … The architect who built it, the young fella, who was not hardly known, he’s a friend of Mayor Bloomberg. He’s also a very close friend of the Netanyahu family. He’s a friend, he’s a personal friend of Netanyahu’s son.

So it’s like the entire, you know, operation from the planning, and preparation, setting up the prediction, the “ideation” of the actual event, then the foisting of the deception, foisting the false narrative on the American public and the world, and then the actual control of the legacy, …

We’re talking about the memorial, you talk about the legacy, you’re talking about the place where, you know, school buses come every day. Dozens of school buses coming every day. And kids are taken off the bus and led through this place, and they’re basically taught the false narrative, they’re indoctrinated into the false narrative of what happened on 9/11! That 9/11 was done by these, you know, fanatical, Arab, Muslims.

And that’s why we are where we are today in the “War on Terror”.

And see, that’s why this book, the “War on Terror” is so important, because I wrote, … It’s a very small book. It’s only about 160 pages long, 170 many pages, because it’s very important for the public to understand that the “War on Terror” is a big fraud!

And the fraud of the “War on Terror” is related to the deception we’ve been told about 9/11. Like this book is really meant for the reader who already understands that we’ve been deceived about 9/11, and who did it. And the “War on Terror” book explains why we have been deceived, and who’s behind the deception.

G&B: You write that the real radicals are, in fact, the traitors in the political, and media arenas, who have pushed the lies about 9/11, and the “War on Terror”, since September 2001, as opposed to those who do real research on these events.

Bollyn: Right! Well, my chapter two of the book. It says:

“9/11 truth is anything but radical.”

And that stands to reason. A radical is somebody who calls for, like radical change in a political situation, and that’s what we got. A conservative is a person who says:

“Well let’s go slow, make incremental, small changes. Let’s not change everything overnight.”

But what happened with 9/11, of course, is that before there was any investigation into what happened on 9/11, the United Sates was waging war in Afghanistan! And the authorization to wage, you know, the authorization to use military force we were talking about, was passed.

And so this longest war in American history was started before there was even any investigation!

And when people call for a new investigation, they have to understand that there hasn’t been an investigation of 9/11! 9/11 remains an unsolved crime. Hence the title of my book “Solving 9/11”. It’s an unsolved crime in which the evidence was actually confiscated, and destroyed, rather than then analyzed.

So there’s been no criminal investigation, and there’s been no trial!

So it’s a very, very bizarre thing! And it says a lot about the, … I don’t know how to say this, … It’s how America has gotten so hijacked by a small group of people who control the media! And they’ve hijacked our nation for decades now, into this “War on Terror”! And it’s a war against the American people.

So it’s really important that they wake up and understand that if we want to preserve any kind of freedom in America, we have to understand how we’ve been duped into the “War on Terror”.

G&B: Have the multiple trillions of dollars spent to wage the global “War on Terror” been borrowed at interest?

Bollyn: Well yeah! It’s all borrowed money! Trump said a couple months ago, a few months ago, he said that:

“It’s seven trillion dollars.”

And what have we gotten for it? Nothing! Nothing!

Well, we’ve got a lot worse than that! We’ve gotten a big debt! A seven trillion dollars, plus the interest on that. And that debt is just growing all the time. But the actual cost of the war, including that future debt payments, and treatment for the wounded vets, and what have you, is about seven trillion dollars. It’s an incredible amount of money!

And so that’s why, you know, you look around America you see the homeless people, the situation with the infrastructure, the general demise of our nation. And you say:

“Couldn’t that money have been better spent, here at home, rather than waging mindless, senseless, wars against people who have nothing to do with 9/11, in distant countries?”

G&B: How is treason defined in the US Constitution? And how would treason apply to those who engaged in what the US government termed “an act of war”?”

Bollyn: Yeah, well, treason is, … Part of the treason argument is that by levying war against the United States government, by levying war against the American people, and the nation, … And anybody who supports that in any way — it says in the dictionary, about treason and the Constitution — is culpable of the same crime. So that would include people even in the media, who have willfully fed the deception.

You see it was an act of deception. It’s an ongoing, active, deception!

We have now for 18 years, this deception about 9/11 being presented in the media, whenever it’s discussed.

And so there’s been no investigation by the media. The media has been complicit in this deception against American people. And that means that they are responsible also for the crime of treason, because they are supporting, they are aiding, they are aiding and abetting in helping those who levied war against United States of America!

G&B: What effect have the 9/11 wars had on Syria?

Bollyn: Well Syria is just the latest. I don’t know if it’s the latest, there might be more going on in other places, but Syria is the second one of those countries that Yinon Plan [Oded Yinon] called for an Eastern Front. It said, first take out Iraq, breakdown the central government, the military, and balkanize the country.

Then the next country was Syria. In Syria, that’s what they’ve been doing.

And in Syria, of course, they used these self-created terrorist groups called ISIS and ISIL. And there’s a whole host of them. And these are the people that McCain was seen going over to. Senator McCain was seen meeting with them! And one of the people is thought to be, that he’s meeting with, is Al-Baghdadi, the one who they said they killed a couple weeks ago.

But he’s meeting with these people, these terrorists who ran these militias, these gangs, that were waging war against the government of Syria. So again, the target is to take down the central government of Syria, remove the regime of Bashar Al-Assad — which was elected after all — and replacing it with a broken up country! With, you know, one ethnic group here, one there, one there, one there! And they’ve succeeded in doing that.

And what they’ve really succeeded in doing is, the United States is occupying the eastern third of the country from the Euphrates River to the east, and that’s where the oil is. And now Trump is saying that we’re gonna use this war on terrorism to secure, or to maintain, control over Syria’s oil. And he says we’re doing this to keep the oil away from ISIS, ISIL. I don’t know.

One thing they’re trying to keep it away from, they’re definitely trying to keep it away from the Syrian government, because it’s the Syrian government who needs the oil, more than anybody.

G&B: Christopher Bollyn, thank you very much!

Bollyn: Well thank you Bonnie. It’s been a pleasure.

Source →


Wednesday, April 16, 2025

Do We Really Need School?

 I don’t mean education, just forced schooling: six classes a day, five days a week, nine months a year, for twelve years. Is this deadly routine really necessary? And if so, for what? Don’t hide behind reading, writing, and arithmetic as a rationale, because 2 million happy homeschoolers have surely put that banal justification to rest. Even if they hadn’t, a considerable number of well-known Americans never went through the twelve-year wringer our kids currently go through, and they turned out all right. George Washington, Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson, Abraham Lincoln? Someone taught them, to be sure, but they were not products of a school system, and not one of them was ever “graduated” from a secondary school. Throughout most of American history, kids generally didn’t go to high school, yet the unschooled rose to be admirals, like Farragut; inventors, like Edison; captains of industry, like Carnegie and Rockefeller; writers, like Melville and Twain and Conrad; and even scholars, like Margaret Mead. In fact, until pretty recently people who reached the age of thirteen weren’t looked upon as children at all. Ariel Durant, who co-wrote an enormous, and very good, multivolume history of the world with her husband Will, was happily married at fifteen, and who could reasonably claim Ariel Durant was an uneducated person? Unschooled, perhaps, but not uneducated.

We have been taught (that is, schooled) in this country to think “success” is synonymous with, or at least dependent upon, “schooling,” but historically that isn’t true in either an intellectual or a financial sense. And plenty of people throughout the world today find ways to educate themselves without resorting to a system of compulsory secondary schools that all too often resemble prisons. Why, then, do Americans confuse education with just such a system? What exactly is the purpose of our public schools?

Mass schooling of a compulsory nature really got its teeth into the United States between 1905 and 1915, though it was conceived of much earlier and pushed for throughout most of the nineteenth century. The reason given for this enormous upheaval of family life and cultural traditions was, roughly speaking, threefold:

1. To make good people.

2. To make good citizens.

3. To make each person his or her personal best.

These goals are still trotted out on a regular basis, and most of us accept them in one form or another as a decent definition of public education’s mission, however short schools actually fall in achieving them. But we are dead wrong. Compounding our error is the fact that the national literature holds numerous and surprisingly consistent statements of compulsory schooling’s true purpose. We have, for example, the great H. L. Mencken, who wrote in The American Mercury for April 1924 that the aim of public education is not

...to fill the young of the species with knowledge and awaken their intelligence.... Nothing could be further from the truth. The aim...is simply to reduce as many individuals as possible to the same safe level, to breed and train a standardized citizenry, to put down dissent and originality. That is its aim in the United States... and that is its aim everywhere else.

Because of Mencken’s reputation as a satirist, we might be tempted to dismiss this passage as hyperbolic sarcasm. His article, however, goes on to trace the template for our own educational system back to the now vanished, though never to be forgotten, military state of Prussia. And although he was certainly aware of the irony that we had recently been at war with Germany, the heir to Prussian thought and culture, Mencken was being perfectly serious here. Our educational system really is Prussian in origin, and that really is cause for concern.

The odd fact of a Prussian provenance for our schools pops up again and again once you know to look for it. William James alluded to it many times at the turn of the century. Orestes Brownson, the hero of Christopher Lasch’s 1991 book, The True and Only Heaven, was publicly denouncing the Prussianization of American schools back in the 1840s. Horace Mann’s “Seventh Annual Report” to the Massachusetts Board of Education in 1843 is essentially a paean to the land of Frederick the Great and a call for its schooling to be brought here. That Prussian culture loomed large in America is hardly surprising, given our early association with that utopian state. A Prussian served as Washington’s aide during the Revolutionary War, and so many German-speaking people had settled here by 1795 that Congress considered publishing a German-language edition of the federal laws. But what shocks is that we should so eagerly have adopted one of the very worst aspects of Prussian culture: an educational system deliberately designed to produce mediocre intellects, to hamstring the inner life, to deny students appreciable leadership skills, and to ensure docile and incomplete citizens—all in order to render the populace “manageable.”

IT WAS FROM James Bryant Conant—president of Harvard for twenty years, WWI poison-gas specialist, WWII executive of the atomic-bomb project, high commissioner of the American zone in Germany after WWII, and truly one of the most influential figures of the twentieth century—that I first got wind of the real purposes of American schooling. Without Conant, we would probably not have the same style and degree of standardized testing that we enjoy today, nor would we be blessed with gargantuan high schools that warehouse 2,000 to 4,000 students at a time, like the famous Columbine High School in Littleton, Colorado. Shortly after I retired from teaching, I picked up Conant’s 1959 book-length essay, The Child, the Parent and the State, and was more than a little intrigued to see him mention in passing that the modern schools we attend were the result of a “revolution” engineered between 1905 and 1930. A revolution? He declines to elaborate, but he does direct the curious and the uninformed to Alexander Inglis’s 1918 book, Principles of Secondary Education, in which “one saw this revolution through the eyes of a revolutionary.”

Inglis, for whom an honor lecture in education at Harvard is named, makes it perfectly clear that compulsory schooling on this continent was intended to be just what it had been for Prussia in the 1820s: a fifth column into the burgeoning democratic movement that threatened to give the peasants and the proletarians a voice at the bargaining table. Modern, industrialized, compulsory schooling was to make a sort of surgical intervention into the prospective unity of these underclasses. Divide children by subject, by age-grading, by constant rankings on tests, and by many other more subtle means, and it was unlikely that the ignorant mass of mankind, separated in childhood, would ever reintegrate into a dangerous whole.

Inglis breaks down the purpose—the actual purpose—of modern schooling into six basic functions, any one of which is enough to curl the hair of those innocent enough to believe the three traditional goals of education listed earlier:

1. The adjustive or adaptive function. Schools are to establish fixed habits of reaction to authority. This, of course, precludes critical judgment completely. It also pretty much destroys the idea that useful or interesting material should be taught, because you can’t test for reflexive obedience until you know whether you can make kids learn, and do, foolish and boring things.

2. The integrating function. This might well be called “the conformity function,” because its intention is to make children as alike as possible. People who conform are predictable, and this is of great use to those who wish to harness and manipulate a large labor force.

3. The diagnostic and directive function. School is meant to determine each student’s proper social role. This is done by logging evidence mathematically and anecdotally on cumulative records. As in “your permanent record.” Yes, you do have one.

4. The differentiating function. Once their social role has been “diagnosed,” children are to be sorted by role and trained only so far as their destination in the social machine merits—and not one step further. So much for making kids their personal best.

5. The selective function. This refers not to human choice at all but to Darwin’s theory of natural selection as applied to what he called “the favored races.” In short, the idea is to help things along by consciously attempting to improve the breeding stock. Schools are meant to tag the unfit—with poor grades, remedial placement, and other punishments—clearly enough that their peers will accept them as inferior and effectively bar them from the reproductive sweepstakes. That’s what all those little humiliations from first grade onward were intended to do: wash the dirt down the drain.

6. The propaedeutic function. The societal system implied by these rules will require an elite group of caretakers. To that end, a small fraction of the kids will quietly be taught how to manage this continuing project, how to watch over and control a population deliberately dumbed down and declawed in order that government might proceed unchallenged and corporations might never want for obedient labor.

That, unfortunately, is the purpose of mandatory public education in this country. And lest you consider Inglis an isolated crank with a rather too cynical take on the educational enterprise, you should know he was hardly alone in championing these ideas. Conant himself, building on the ideas of Horace Mann and others, campaigned tirelessly for an American school system designed along the same lines. Men like George Peabody, who funded the cause of mandatory schooling throughout the South, surely understood that the Prussian system was useful in creating not only a harmless electorate and a servile labor force but also a virtual herd of mindless consumers. In time a great number of industrial titans came to recognize the enormous profits to be had by cultivating and tending just such a herd via public education, among them Andrew Carnegie and John D. Rockefeller.

There you have it. Now you know. We don’t need Karl Marx’s conception of a grand warfare between the classes to see that it is in the interest of complex management, economic or political, to dumb people down, to demoralize them, to divide them from one another, and to discard them if they don’t conform. Class may frame the proposition, as when Woodrow Wilson, then president of Princeton University, said the following to the New York City School Teachers Association in 1909: “We want one class of persons to have a liberal education, and we want another class of persons, a very much larger class, of necessity, in every society, to forgo the privileges of a liberal education and fit themselves to perform specific difficult manual tasks.” But the motives behind the disgusting decisions that bring about these ends need not be class-based at all. They can stem purely from fear, or from the by-now familiar belief that “efficiency” is the paramount virtue, rather than love, liberty, laughter, or hope. Above all, they can stem from simple greed.

There were vast fortunes to be made, after all, in an economy based on mass production and organized to favor the large corporation rather than the small business or the family farm. But mass production required mass consumption, and at the turn of the twentieth century, most Americans considered it both unnatural and unwise to buy things they didn’t actually need. Mandatory schooling was a godsend on that count. School didn’t have to train kids in any direct sense to think they should consume nonstop, because it did something even better: it encouraged them not to think at all. And that left them sitting ducks for another great invention of the modern era—marketing.

Now, you needn’t have studied marketing to know that there are two groups of people who can always be convinced to consume more than they need to: addicts and children. School has done a pretty good job of turning our children into addicts, but a spectacular job of turning our children into children. Again, this is no accident. Theorists from Plato to Rousseau to our own Dr. Inglis knew that if children could be cloistered with other children, stripped of responsibility and independence, encouraged to develop only the trivializing emotions of greed, envy, jealousy, and fear, they would grow older but never truly grow up. In the 1934 edition of his once well-known book Public Education in the United States, Ellwood P. Cubberley detailed and praised the way the strategy of successive school enlargements had extended childhood by two to six years already, and forced schooling was at that point still quite new. This same Cubberley was an intimate colleague of Dr. Inglis: both were in charge of textbook publishing divisions at Houghton Mifflin—Cubberley as chief of elementary school texts; Inglis of secondary school texts. Cubberley was dean of Stanford’s influential School of Education as well, a friendly correspondent of Conant at Harvard. He had written in his book Public School Administration (1922) that “our schools are...factories in which the raw products (children) are to be shaped and fashioned...And that is the business of the school to build its pupils according to the specifications laid down.”

It’s perfectly obvious from our society today what those specifications were. Maturity has by now been banished from nearly every aspect of our lives. Easy divorce laws have removed the need to work at relationships; easy credit has removed the need for fiscal self-control; easy entertainment has removed the need to learn to entertain oneself; easy answers have removed the need to ask questions. We have become a nation of children, happy to surrender our judgments and our wills to political exhortations and commercial blandishments that would insult actual adults. We buy televisions, and then we buy the things we see on the television. We buy $150 sneakers whether we need them or not, and when they fall apart too soon, we buy another pair. We drive SUVs and believe the lie that they constitute a kind of life insurance, even when we’re upside down in them. And, worst of all, we don’t bat an eye when Ari Fleischer tells us to “be careful what you say,” even if we remember having been told somewhere back in school that America is the land of the free. We simply buy that one, too. Our schooling, as intended, has seen to it.

Now for the good news. Once you understand the logic behind modern schooling, its tricks and traps are fairly easy to avoid. School trains children to be employees and consumers; teach your own to be leaders and adventurers. School trains children to obey reflexively; teach your own to think critically and independently. Well-schooled kids have a low threshold for boredom; help your own to develop an inner life so that they’ll never be bored. Urge them to take on the serious material, the grown-up material, in history, literature, philosophy, music, art, economics, theology—all the stuff schoolteachers know well enough to avoid. Challenge your kids with plenty of solitude so that they can learn to enjoy their own company, to conduct inner dialogues. Well-schooled people are conditioned to dread being alone; they seek constant companionship through the TV, the computer, the cell phone, and through shallow friendships quickly acquired, quickly abandoned. Your children should have a more important life, and they can.

First, though, wake up to what our schools really are: laboratories of experimentation on young minds, drill centers for the habits and attitudes that corporate society demands. Mandatory education serves children only incidentally; its real purpose is to turn them into servants. Don’t let your own have their childhoods extended, not even for a day. If David Farragut could take command of a captured British warship as a preteen, if Ben Franklin could apprentice himself to a printer at the same age (then put himself through a course of study that would choke a Yale senior today), there’s no telling what your own kids could do. After a long life, and thirty years in the public school trenches, I’ve concluded that genius is as common as dirt. We suppress genius because we haven’t yet figured out how to manage a population of educated men and women. The solution, I think, is simple and glorious. Let them manage themselves.

John Taylor Gatto 

Dumbing Us DownA

Smartphone

 

In the early days of the telephone, this new technology had an aura of fate-like power about it. Its resounding ringing was like an order to which one had to submit. In his Berlin Childhood around 1900, Benjamin describes how, as a child, he was helplessly at the mercy of the apparatus:

At that time, the telephone still hung – an outcast settled carelessly between the dirty-linen hamper and the gasometer – in a corner of the back hallway, where its ringing served to multiply the terrors of the Berlin household. When, having mastered my senses with great effort, I arrived to quell the uproar after prolonged fumbling through the gloomy corridor, I tore off the two receivers, which were heavy as dumbbells, thrust my head between them, and was inexorably delivered over to the voice that now sounded. There was nothing to allay the violence with which it pierced me. Powerless, I suffered, seeing that it obliterated my consciousness of time, my firm resolve, my sense of duty. And just as the medium obeys the voice that takes possession of him from beyond the grave, I submitted to the first proposal that came my way through the telephone.1The medium is the message. The resounding telephone in the dark corridor, with receivers as heavy as dumbbells, prefigures the message and lends it something of the uncanny. The noises of the first telephone conversations were ‘nocturnal noises’.2 The mobile phones we carry around in our pockets today do not possess the heavy weight of fate. They are handy and light; we literally have a grip on them. Fate is that alien power that immobilizes us. A message, as the voice of fate, does not leave us much room to manoeuvre. The mobility of the smartphone is enough to give us a feeling of freedom. No one is terrorized by its ringing. The smartphone does not force us into a helpless passivity. No one is delivered over to the voice of another.

The constant typing and swiping on the smartphone is an almost liturgical gesture, and it has a substantive impact on our relation to the world. I swipe away the information that does not interest me. I zoom in on the content that I like. I have the world firmly in my grip. The world has to accord with my desires. In this way, the smartphone amplifies self-referentiality. Through all my swiping, I submit the world to my needs. The world appears to me under the digital illusion of total availability.

According to Roland Barthes, the sense of touch ‘is the most demystifying of all senses, unlike sight, which is the most magical’.3The truly beautiful cannot be touched. It demands distance. Faced with the sublime, we stand back in awe. When praying, we fold our hands. The sense of touch destroys distance. It knows no astonishment. It demystifies, de-auratizes and renders profane what is touched. The touchscreen sublates the negativity of the other, of the unavailable. It generalizes the haptic compulsion to make everything available. In the age of the smartphone, even the sense of sight succumbs to haptic compulsion, and loses its magic. It loses the capacity for astonishment. The distance-destroying, consuming way of seeing approximates the sense of touch. It desecrates the world. To this way of seeing, the world appears only in the form of availability. For the frantically typing index finger, everything is consumable. The index finger that orders commodities or food necessarily transfers its consumerist habitus to other areas. Everything it touches takes on the form of a commodity. On Tinder, it degrades the other, who becomes a sexual object. Deprived of his or her otherness, the other becomes consumable.

In digital communication, the other is increasingly absent. Smartphones allow us to retreat into bubbles that screen us off from the other. Digital communications rarely involve salutations; the other is not explicitly addressed. We prefer to write a text message rather than ring someone up, because in writing we are less exposed to the other. Thus, the other as a voice disappears.

Communication with a smartphone is disembodied and without a gaze. Community has a bodily dimension. Because of its lack of corporeality, digital communication weakens community. The gaze stabilizes community. Digitalization makes the other as gaze disappear. The absence of the gaze is partly responsible for the loss of empathy in the digital age. When a parent stares at a smartphone, the infant is deprived of the gaze. The gaze of the mother, in particular, provides an infant with stability, self-affirmation and community. The gaze builds primordial trust. Without the gaze, a disturbed relationship to self and others develops.

What makes a smartphone different from a conventional mobile phone is that it is not just a telephone but, primarily, a medium for transmitting images and information. The world only becomes fully available and consumable once it is reified into an image:

‘Picture’ means … that which sounds in the colloquial expression to be ‘in the picture’ about something…. To ‘put oneself in the picture’ about something means: to place the being itself before one just as things are with it, and, as so placed, to keep it permanently before one.4

The smartphone places the world: it takes hold of it by placing [herstellen] it in front of us in the form of an image. The camera and the screen are the central elements of the smartphone because they intensify the becoming-image of the world. Digital images transform the world into available information. The smartphone is a ‘Ge-Stell’, enframing, in Heidegger’s sense: a Gestell, the essence of technology, unites in itself all forms of placing [Stellens] that make available, such as ordering [Bestellen], presenting [Vorstellen] or producing [Herstellen]. The next step in the process of civilization goes beyond the becoming-image of the world. It consists of the production of the world out of images, the production, that is, of a hyper-real reality.

The world consists of things as objects. The word ‘object’ is derived from the Latin verb obicere, which means ‘set against’, ‘throw against’ or ‘oppose’. The negativity of resistance is inherent in it. An object is something that turns against me, that opposes and resists me. Digital objects lack the negativity of obicere. I do not experience them as resistance. The smartphone is smart because it deprives reality of its character as resistant. Even the smooth surface of the smartphone conveys the sense of a lack of resistance. On its smooth touchscreen, everything seems tame [handzahm] and obliging. Everything is available at the tip of one’s fingers. The smartphone’s smooth surface is a digital flatterer that blandishes the hand and thus constantly elicits ‘likes’ from us. Digital media may be effective in overcoming the resistance of space and time, but it is precisely the negativity of resistance that constitutes experience. The smart environment of digital non-resistance impoverishes world and experience.

The smartphone is the main informaton of our time. It not only makes many things superfluous but also dereifies the world by reducing it to information. The material aspect of the smartphone recedes, and information takes its place; the materiality of the smartphone is not perceived in its own right. Smartphones do not really differ in their appearance. We look through them into the infosphere. An analogue watch also provides us with information regarding time, but it is not an informaton; it is a thing, even an adornment. Its material aspect is central to it.

A society that is dominated by information and informatons is unadorned. Adornment [Schmuck] originally meant splendid attire. Non-things are naked. The decorative and the ornamental are characteristic of things. They are life’s way of telling us that life is about more than mere functioning. In the baroque age, the ornamental was theatrum dei, the theatre of the gods. If we submit life fully to functionality and information, we drive the divine out of life. The smartphone is a symbol of our time. The smartphone is not embellished in any way. It is dominated by the smooth and straight. Even the communication that takes place via smartphones lacks the magic of beautiful forms. It is dominated by a straightforwardness that finds its best expression in affects. The smartphone also intensifies hypercommunication: everything is levelled out, abraded and ultimately made to conform [gleichgeschaltet]. We may live in a ‘society of singularities’, but paradoxically the singular, the incomparable, is hardly to be found.

We present our smartphones everywhere, and even delegate our perception to these apparatuses. We perceive reality through the filter of the screen. The digital window dilutes reality into information that we register. There is no physical contact with reality. Reality is deprived of its presence. We no longer perceive the material vibrations of reality. Perception is disembodied. The smartphone de-realizes the world.

Things do not spy on us. This is why we trust them. The smartphone, by contrast, is not only an informaton but also a very efficient informant that keeps its user under constant surveillance. Anyone familiar with its internal algorithmic life will rightly feel tracked by it. We are controlled and programmed by it. It is not we who use the smartphone; the smartphone uses us. The real actor is the smartphone. We are at the mercy of this digital informant, beneath the surface of which various actors steer and distract us.

The emancipatory aspects of the smartphone are not all there is to it. There is no fundamental difference between being reachable at all times and being enslaved. The smartphone is a mobile labour camp in which we voluntarily intern ourselves. The smartphone is also a pornophone: we voluntarily expose ourselves. The smartphone functions like a mobile confessional box. It is the continuation of the ‘sacral rule of the confessional box’ in another form.5Every form of rule has its own devotional objects. The theologian Ernst Troeltsch speaks of ‘devotional objects that fascinate the imagination of the people’.6 These objects stabilize rule by making it habitual and anchoring it in the body. In German, devot also means submissive. Smartphones have established themselves as the devotional objects of the neoliberal regime. As apparatuses that serve the purpose of submission, they resemble the rosary, which is just as mobile and handy. The like is the digital amen. By clicking on the like button, we submit ourselves to the context of rule.

Platforms like Facebook or Google are our new feudal lords. We tirelessly work their land and produce the valuable data that they exploit. We feel free, although we are completely exploited and controlled. In a system that exploits freedom, there is no resistance. Once it coincides with freedom, rule becomes total.

At the end of her The Age of Surveillance Capitalism, Shoshana Zuboff invokes collective resistance, pointing to the fall of the Berlin Wall:

The Berlin Wall fell for many reasons, but above all it was because the people of East Berlin said, ‘No more!’ We too can be the authors of many ‘great and beautiful’ new facts that reclaim the digital future as humanity’s home. No more! Let this be our declaration.7The communist system that represses freedom differs fundamentally from the neoliberal surveillance capitalism that exploits freedom. We are too intoxicated by our digital drugs, by communication, to raise the voice of resistance and cry ‘No more!’. There is simply no place here for any romantic notion of revolution. The conceptual artist Jenny Holzer’s remark ‘Protect Me From What I Want’ expressed a truth that Zuboff apparently failed to appreciate.

The neoliberal regime is itself smart. Smart power does not operate through orders or prohibitions. It does not make us docile; it makes us dependent and addicted. Instead of breaking our wills, it serves our needs. It wants to be liked. It is permissive rather than repressive. It does not condemn us to silence. Rather, we are constantly asked to share our opinions, preferences, needs and desires – even to tell the stories of our lives. Smart power conceals its intention to rule by coming across as friendly, smart. The subject is not even aware of its submission. It believes that it is free. Capitalism culminates in the capitalism of the like. Because it is permissive, it need not fear resistance or revolution.

Our almost symbiotic relationship with our smartphones has led some to suggest that they represent transitional objects, the term coined by the psychoanalyst Donald Winnicott to refer to those things that secure an infant’s safe passage towards reality. Only with the help of transitional objects can the infant create a play area, an ‘intermediate area’,8 in which it ‘relaxes as in a secure and uncontested resting place’.9 Transitional objects build a bridge to reality, to the other, to what escapes the fantasy of omnipotence. Young infants will grasp at the corner of a blanket or cushion, to put it in their mouth or to stroke. Later, they grasp a complete object, such as a doll or cuddly toy. Transitional objects have an existential function. They give the child a feeling of security. They take away the fear of being alone. They create trust and a feeling of being sheltered. Transitional objects allow children to slowly grow into the world. They are the first things of the world which stabilize the life of the infant.

A child has a very intense, deep relationship with the transitional object. The object must be neither modified nor washed. Nothing is allowed to interrupt the experience of closeness. The child panics if it loses the beloved object. The child possesses the transitional object, but to a certain extent it also has a life of its own. It appears as an independent, personal counterpart to the child. Transitional objects open up a dialogical space in which the child can encounter the other.

We react with uncontrollable panic when we lose our smartphones. We have intimate relationships with them. We do not like to give them to other people. Can the smartphone therefore be understood as a transitional object, a digital teddy bear? The fact that the smartphone is a narcissistic object suggests not. A transitional object represents the other. The child speaks to it, cuddles it, as if it were another person. No one cuddles a smartphone. No one perceives it as an independent counterpart. Unlike a transitional object, it is not something close to our heart; it is not irreplaceable. We regularly buy new smartphones.

The way the child plays with the transitional object is analogous to later creative activities, for instance in the arts. It opens up a free space. The child, as though in a dream, takes the position of the transitional object; it gives free rein to its fantasies. The child imbues the transitional object with symbolic value. The object becomes the vessel in which the child’s dreams are concentrated. The smartphone, by contrast, floods us with stimuli and represses our imagination. Transitional objects are poor in stimuli and therefore intensify and structure attention. The flood of stimuli that comes from the smartphone fragments our attention. Where the transitional object stabilizes the psyche, the smartphone destabilizes it.

Transitional objects create a relationship with the other. Our relationship with the smartphone, by contrast, is narcissistic. The smartphone is similar in many ways to a so-called ‘autistic object’. We could also call it a narcissistic object. Transitional objects are soft. The child snuggles up to them. When doing so, it feels not itself but the other. Autistic objects are hard: ‘The hardness of the object allows the child, when manipulating and pressing the object, to feel not so much the object but itself.’10 Autistic objects lack the dimension of the other. They do not fuel our fantasying. Our dealings with them are repetitive, not creative. Repetitiveness and compulsion characterize our relationship to the smartphone.

Like transitional objects, autistic objects are a substitute for the absent person, but they reify this person into an object. They take away the person’s otherness:

Autistic objects are the most extreme example of objects taking the place of human beings, even of serving the purpose of avoiding the imponderables and always possible separations that are an inevitable part of relations with autonomously acting human beings. To put it even more radically: they make it possible not to perceive others as independent human beings at all.11

The similarity between smartphones and autistic objects is obvious. Unlike the transitional object, the smartphone is hard; it is not a digital teddy bear. Rather, it is a narcissistic, autistic object through which we feel, most of all, ourselves. It thus also destroys empathy. We use the smartphone to retreat into a narcissistic sphere in which we are protected against the imponderables pertaining to the other. The smartphone puts the other at our disposal by reifying the other into an object. It turns the you into an it. The disappearance of the other is the ontological reason why the smartphone makes us lonely. We communicate so compulsively, so excessively, because we are lonely and empty. But hypercommunication is not fulfilling. Because it lacks the presence of the other, it only deepens the loneliness.

 Notes

1. Walter Benjamin, Berlin Childhood around 1900, Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press, 2006, pp. 49f.

2. Ibid., p. 48.

3. Roland Barthes, Mythologies, New York: Farrar, Straus & Giroux, 1972, p. 90.

4. Martin Heidegger, ‘The Age of the World Picture’, in Off the Beaten Track, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2002, p. 67 (emph. B.-Ch. H.).

5. Ernst Troeltsch, ‘Epochen und Typen der Sozialphilosophie des Christentums’, in Gesammelte Schriften, vol. 4: Aufsätze zur Geistesgeschichte und Religionssoziologie, Tübingen: Mohr, 1925, pp. 122–55; here: p. 134.

6. Ibid., p. 135.

7. Shoshana Zuboff, The Age of Surveillance Capitalism: The Fight for a Human Future at the New Frontier of Power, London: Profile Books, 2019, p. 525.

8. Donald Winnicott, Playing and Reality, London: Routledge, 1991, p. 2.

9. Tilmann Habermas, Geliebte Objekte: Symbole und Instrumente der Identitätsbildung, Berlin and New York: De Gruyter, 1996, p. 325.

10. Ibid., p. 336.

11. Ibid., p. 337.

Non-things

Upheaval in the Lifeworld

Byung-Chul Han

Positive Nihilism - Confrontation with Heidegger

 

There is an abyss of the finite.1 It is temporality.

There is a beyond of reason and unreason. It is the human psyche. The abyss of conscious being, it determines the character of civilization where sufficient power has accrued to it.

The twentieth century was governed by psychopaths. They collapsed the boundaries of moral reason and refuted Kant’s analysis of consciousness.

There is no a priori of pure or practical reason. There is only the possibility of reconsidering, over and again, the harm wrought by the psyche in free fall.

One means of educating the psyche is penal law in all its dimensions, religious ones included.

But who shall punish whom? One man’s virtue is another man’s crime. Thus Hitler could feel unwaveringly, as he wiped out entire populations, the starry sky above him and the moral law within him, as stipulated by Kant; and how should one oppose the remedies of civilization to the ego-mania, the murderous appetites of such outright psycho-paths as Stalin or Pol Pot?2 And is civilization not a misleading concept in any case?

At least, when it attempts to assert an a priori of practical reason.

To begin, civilization comprises all determinants of human life in common.3 This is not to say it is accordingly inclined toward the preservation of life. Civilization consists primar-ily in an unequal distribution of power, within which the beyond of reason and unreason—the incalculability of the psyche—strives for self-assertion.

It is true that man may step past his own nature, and that of others, through the act of thinking, but freedom of thought is a fata morgana of consciousness, which must be integrated through a higher form of responsibility.4 Where the individual possesses little power, he is compelled to be modest. But this modesty abates to the extent that power is accrued.

It is true that civilization knows its golden ages as well, when attempts are made to instill the psyche with good and extirpate evil. Yet even where it appears successful, the education of the psyche is, and remains, an impossibility.

The psyche is resistant to any form of relativization. It responds exclusively to its own attunement.5 This marks the point at which it eludes calculation, and it is necessary, in order to examine it, to refer to the Dasein in terms of its absolute selfhood, the unique and nonrecurring I that I am, which remains unresolved with relation to this classification.6 The I as absolute selfhood possesses, apart from itself, the objectivity of the world, along with those aspects of itself that must be considered objective. What it does not.possess, apart from itself, and what permits its Dasein to become an experienceable reality, is the transcendent stepping-over of the objectivity of the world.7 This stepping-over is indispensable for the existence of the subject, but what the subject aims to arrive at and must arrive at remains something outside itself, something that the self, for the sake of which this stepping-over is under-taken, does not constitute.

In this way, the objectivity of the world remains eternally estranged from, even menacingly unattainable to, the I— transcendent, in a word. It can adduce no grounds whatsoever for its self-centeredness, and the unease, the endless irritation this state of affairs gives rise to, is registered by the psyche as though by a seismograph and becomes manifest in the subject’s particular mode of being attuned.8 Consciousness errs constantly with regard to clarity of perspective, to the temporal hue proper to present, past, and future. Even if the individual is capable of recognizing the horizon of his possibilities, he may, at the behest of his psychological constitution, ignore, overestimate, or reframe what he has recognized, and may do so with explicit recourse to reason, which remains in any case subject to the individual’s own conceptual world.

The psyche allows itself neither to be sublimated nor rendered objective by means of education. It is immune to reason and indeed manipulates the intellect, if it proves necessary, to legitimize abnormal inclinations. It reacts like a perpetuum mobile, affording the ego necessary validation, and can only be compelled to discipline itself according to a predetermined moral law where the ego is constrained by society. Supposing that it is itself not in a position to enact moral laws in the world.

In the Roman Empire, Caligula or Domitian were able to position their own psyche as the measure of all things with impunity; and the philosophy of history errs when it affirms that the psyche is subject to modification by history. In the twentieth century, following the abolition of the corporate state, well after the Enlightenment had strived for the ethical sublimation of the human psychological structure, a small group was able to break free from this societal discipline, and it was certainly not mere chance that setting aside their respective ideologies, Hitler and Stalin, Mao and Pol Pot, were indistinguishable with regard to one intention: they committed mass murder, and with.a resoluteness that Heidegger could have considered impossible.9 What goes for the abnormality of evil goes as well for the abnormality of good. There are only Epicurians, some coarse, some refined. Christ was the most refined of all. This well-known phrase from Büchner’s play Danton’s Death shows how indifferently, how archetypally, the psyche inhabits its sphere of activity, and how right Schopenhauer was to attribute the origin of ethics to that rarest but most precious of all manifestations of the psyche—namely compassion.

But where shall we seek out the metaphysics of the psyche, and why is it illusory when Heidegger attempts to derive the possibility of the conduct of life exclusively from the structure of a self-referential ontology? In its everydayness, Dasein is still delivered over, despite all effort of thought, to the incalculability of psychological forces, and even here, a glimpse at literature might offer some clarity.10 Shakespeare’s play Othello portrays jealousy culminating in intrigue, but does not clarify why a man would kill his wife, whom he loves above all else. Further, Othello makes no attempt to cast doubt on the intrigue against Desdemona. Yet precisely here, where good sense or the scientific impulse toward the empirical would be marshaled to explain why Othello behaves in this way and not in another, is where the free fall, the incalculability of the psyche, begins.

It is thoroughly conceivable that Othello, precisely because he loves Desdemona beyond all measure, may compound his love through these suspicions of infidelity, and that imagining the unimaginable, he will persevere for the sole purpose of augmenting his love for Desdemona. And this would indeed be the endless loop of jealousy, how something incompossible—namely love and the betrayal thereof—in lieu of submitting to the justifications of reason, progresses into catastrophe.

Knowledge always refers in the last instance to death, and it is here that the hunger for transcendence lurks, because the meaninglessness of our existence demands sublimation.
We disappear into the darkness of history. The facticity of conscious being changes nothing in this regard.

All else is compulsion to the experience of Being: from childhood, we are imprinted with the urge to enworld ourselves. The child wishes to grow up in order to better adapt the world to himself.11 Here, the naive illusion prevails that imprisonment or constraint within the housing of the self is something to be overcome. Childish, unevolved consciousness is not yet aware that the world merely reflects itself in the monadic Dasein. All else is indivisibility between self and world, is touch and metabolism. Without the assistance of all that I am not, my Dasein cannot realize itself.

That which I am not is a precondition of that which I am.

Consciousness struggles against this insight, or more precisely: the self only appears in consciousness as a fata morgana, and the fullness of the representational world is grounded therein.12 The knowable world appears endless. But man’s representational world is more endless than the perceptible world.

Man may step over his nature by means of thought. But he cannot change it or leave it behind.

The systematization of this point is and remains the work of thought. In general, consciousness enriches actuality through the adduction of thought-related characteristics.

Hence the mere consideration of an objectively given state of affairs itself becomes a state of affairs.13 Through illusion, in other words, consciousness may create for itself its own, objectively indemonstrable world, and in this undemonstrability, consciousness itself becomes free.

The will to change the world ends in a false promise. Man can only change the world in thought.

Freedom is an offer that is most often turned down.

Habits are established beyond good and evil, and are therefore difficult to alter.

There exists not only the will to happiness but also the will to lived delusion.14 Both are species-specific, and for two thousand years, they have left their mark on the history of culture.

Whoever wishes to make a change, must create meaning.

There is only the present, the moment in which Being realizes itself. Past and future are projections of consciousness.

Sartre’s notion of the past as the nothingness of Being proves nothing. Save that we may hold fast to elapsed Being in memory.15 The same is true for the concept of the future. The fact that we are constrained to consider our present Being as reproducible does not make the future a reality. The future is and remains a projection.

The present is fleeting being-in-the-world. It is always already past.

Of late, one calls for a spirituality without God, which casts aside the I-phenomenon as an illusion.16 But who then should spiritualize?

The transitory I is thoroughly disparaged as irrelevant, for the eternity of Being is opposed to it. And now it is supposed to redeem itself through insight into its own nullity.17 The all-one supervenes upon the one.18 A notion already put forth by Schopenhauer. But what benefit could such an idea yield?

Whether negligible or not, I too belong to the totality of beings.19 My problem lies solely in the constant process of self-generation that characterizes this totality.

A question, then: Does my existence possess a substantial nature, or is it merely a matter of form?

And who decides whether the totality of beings is not like-wise a matter of contingency?

Form arises by chance. But where does chance begin? And is there some sort of necessity that remains superordinate to chance?

What was there before the Big Bang: Being or nothingness?

Or something else, a beyond to which Being and nothing-ness belong as transitory forms?

Is it possible then that beings might affirm themselves not as something necessary but simply as an attribute of chance?

That they will someday come to an end, like every chance event, and that nothing substantial, but only the formal as a quality, may be attributed to the all-one or the one?

All that may arise, deserves its own demise.20 These words tear down the barrier between finite and infinite, outlining the logic of form, according to which the totality of beings can conjure up no further meaning.

If this is so, I myself am a chance event within chance as a whole, distinguished only by time, which gives rise to formal distinctions.

Which dies out faster, fire or smoke? Fire could not answer this question, according to the logic of succession.

Again, with respect to the problematic of the I: Heidegger writes somewhere in Being and Time that the average Dasein, thus the existential structure of its individuation, takes itself to be absolute.21 What is it that is false there? Every I is nonrecurring, hence the absolute would already be qualitatively substantiated for the individual Dasein.

But the qualitatively substantiated absolute is unquantifiable. What counts for me does not count for the others.

I am what others are not. I am (for myself) the absoluteness of the absolute—a tautology, an impossible state of affairs—and so my unfungibility, the nonrecurring nature of my existential structure, are relegated to the realm of the bewildering.

A fact that philosophy ignores: Hegel, to the extent that he posits the I-phenomenon as a fragmentary reason, which merges into reason as a whole (whatever that may mean), Schopenhauer, to the extent that he defines absolute subjective experience as illusion.22 Kant speaks contemptuously of the I in the diminutive, and Heidegger demands that man not cling to his fragile little I.23 All this betrays the arrogance of quantification. Thus it is also becomes clear why Heidegger has no acquaintance with existential despair.

In its stead, he asserts resoluteness, through which Dasein is to work off its groundless thrownness as debt.24 Curious, this sort of transcendental glossing-over: as if a compulsion toward the conferral of meaning must automatically follow from the experience of meaninglessness.25

Heidegger demands the possible from the experience of the impossible. But for him, the possible is only ever the potentiation of the Dasein.26 In this way, he impoverishes his self-understanding. He idealizes the experience of the impossible and thus ignores the impossible in the possible, and with it the grounds for despair as well as freedom of self-abnegation.

Heidegger’s spirituality is attunement. It is a felt experience of nothingness. As when the whole of being slips away from Dasein and it experiences, through this slippage, the complete indifference of all beings, itself included. It then experiences the possibility of authentic selfhood, but this is a selfhood without a representational world.27 Heidegger favors life-projection.28 He sorts the possibilities that conduce one to it according to their profitability. For him, Dasein is ever concerned to cleave to life, to the extent that such is possible.29 He ignores all the work of sublimation Dasein must carry out if this life-projection fails to succeed.

Heidegger never sets his sights on the merely represented world, but rather on the extant, known, recognizable one.

For him, all sublimation, including the ethical sort, is null and void, especially when it must be achieved not through the experience of being as a whole but through the constraints of psychopathology.

But Heidegger’s philosophy of existence remains the most valid delineation of conscious Being, so that it therefore seems inevitable to delve deeper into the Being-and-time-structure he has elaborated.

1. Abyss, Abgrund.

2. Lange’s phrase “den gestirnten Himmel über sich und das Sittengesetz in sich” is a modified quote from the conclusion of the Critique of Practical Reason: “Zwei Dinge erfüllen das Gemüt mit immer neuer und zunehmender Bewunderung und Ehrfurcht, je öfter und anhaltender sich das Nachdenken damit beschäftigt: Der bestirnte Himmel über mir, und das moralische Gesetz in mir.” In English: “Two things fill the spirit with ever new and increasing admiration and awe, the more often and steadily we reflect on them: the starry sky above me and the moral law within me.”

3. Life in common, Zusammenleben. While this term appears sporadically in Heidegger’s writings, the more germane point of comparison may be his remarks on Zusammengehörigkeit in Identität und Differenz, volume 11 of the Gesamtausgabe.

4. Step past, übersteigen.

5. Attunement, Befindlichkeit. This term runs through much of Heidegger’s work from before Being and Time into the 1940s and after. I have followed Joan Stambaugh in translating it as “attunement.” Other translations include “affectedness,” “disposedness,” and “sofindingness.”


6. Selfhood, Selbstheit. Unique and non-recurring, Einmalig, literally “occurring only once.” The word occurs numerous times in the Gesamtausgabe. See Tracy Colony, “The Death of God and the Life of Being: Heidegger’s Confrontation with Nietzsche,” in Interpreting Heidegger: Critical Essays, ed. Daniel O. Dahlstrom (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011), 197–216; Krzysztof Ziarek, Language after Heidegger (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2013), 39.

7. Reality, Wirklichkeit.

8. Mode of being attuned, Gestimmtheit.

9. Resoluteness, Entschlossenheit.

10. Everydayness, Alltäglichkeit. Delivered over, Ausgeliefert 11. Experience of Being, Seinserfahrung. Enworld, Verweltlichen. Customarily translated as “secularize,” this second term appears in Edmund Husserl, Eugen Fink, and Ludwig Binswanger as the process by which transcendental subjectivity embodies itself as a human subject in the world of history, time, and nature.

12. Representational world, Vorstellungswelt.

13. State of affairs, Sachverhalt.

14. Lived delusion, Lebenslüge, literally “life-lie.” Though the term dates back at least to the beginning of the nineteenth century, it is closely associated with Henrik Ibsen’s aphorism from The Wild Duck: “Rob the average man of his life-illusion, and you rob him of his happiness at the same stroke.”

15. Nothingness of Being, Nichts am Sein, the German equivalent of Sartre’s néant d’être in Being and Nothingness: “la liberté n’est pas un être: elle est l’être de l’homme, c’est à dire son néant d’être.” In English: “Freedom is not a being: it is the being of man, that is, his nothingness of being.”

16. I-phenomenon, Ich-Phänomen. See Edmund Husserl, Introduction to Logic and Theory of Knowledge: Lectures 1906/07, trans. Claire Oritz Hill (New York: Springer, 2008).

17. Nullity, Nichtigkeit.

18. The all-one, Das All-eine. Also translated as “the universal one.” The term appears in the work of Karl Robert Eduard von Hartmann, Friedrich Wilhelm Joseph Schelling, and others. All-one and alone are paranomastic in both German and English.

19. Totality of beings, Seiende. A nominalization of the present participle of Sein, “to be,” Seiende is most often translated as “beings,” and occasionally as “entities.” Here I have opted to translate Sein as “Being,” capitalized, and Seiende as “being” or “beings,” depending on whether the employment of a plural not present in the original German seemed to me to distort the meaning in the phrase in question.

20. From Johann Wolfgang von Goethe’s Faust: “alles was entsteht, ist wert, daß es zugrunde geht.”

21. Individuation, Vereinzelung.

22. Illusion, Täuschung.

23. Fragile little I, Ichlein. In Gesamtausgabe 29–30, Grundbe-griffe der Metaphysik, 8. William McNeill and Nicholas Walker have translated this as “frail little ego” in Martin Heidegger, Fundamental Concepts of Metaphysics (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1995).

24. Groundless, Grundlos; thrownness, Geworfenheit; debt, Schuld. The two senses of this last term in German, “debt” and “guilt,” are significant for Heidegger’s analysis of the relationship between thrownness and the call of conscience, and I have used both here.

25. Conferral of meaning, Sinngebung.

26. Potentiation, Ermöglichung.

27. Authentic, eigentlich; selfhood, Selbstsein. Often the latter is rendered more precisely, but less elegantly, as “being-a- self.”

28. Life projection, Lebensentwurf. Though this particular term is not to be found in Heidegger’s work, Entwurf and entwerfen, respectively “projection” and “to project,” are basic concepts throughout his writings. Michael Inwood, in an illuminating entry in A Heidegger Dictionary (Oxford: Blackwell, 1999), writes: “An Entwurf in Heidegger’s sense is not a particular plan or project; it is what makes any plan or project possible.”

29. Concerned, in der Sorge.

Positive Nihilism
My Confrontation with Heidegger
Hartmud Lange


Tuesday, April 15, 2025

The 5G theory in covid mystification

 

  Wuhan was China’s rollout city for 5G, the 5th generation mobile network that, unlike previous wireless networks, will operate through millions of “small cells” that transmit over short distances. Another major hypothesis circulating in alternative media has been that 5G was the primary cause of the COVID-19 pandemic. YouTube has systematically deleted videos making this assertion. From one perspective, this may validate the videos, given YouTube’s record of draconian censorship. On the other hand, there are responsible people in alternative media who argue against, or at least question, a 5G role. For example, activist and blogger Derrick Broze, an opponent of 5G, was interviewed on the Corbett Report. Broze did not see 5G as causing the COVID-19 crisis; he pointed out, for example, that he had lived in Houston, an America rollout city for 5G, and no one started having COVID-19 when 5G began there.1 (However, as 5G operates at widely varying frequencies, and since the initial U.S. rollout was “soft,” one could question if this was done so there would be no public alarm and the “frog could be boiled.”)

Also, I received an email in April 2020 from 5G Crisis, a leading anti-5G activism website which I subscribe to. While affirming that harm from EMF (electromagnetic field) waves is undeniably well-documented, they asked subscribers to refrain from saying 5G was causing the pandemic— that there was no hard, evidence-based science for this, and that the assertion was causing ridicule of 5G opponents, making their work harder.

Nevertheless, there are responsible scholars who see a possible correlation between COVID and 5G. In February 2020, Dr. Ronald Kostoff of the Georgia Institute of Technology published a 1086-page paper on EMF dangers, The Largest Unethical Medical Experiment in Human History? Appendix 5—starting on page 648—is “Potential Impact of Wireless Radiation Exposure on the Opioid Crisis and the Coronavirus Pandemic.” He questions if EMFs contributed to the pandemic by weakening the immune system.

Magda Havas, PhD, did a study showing that, in U.S. states with 5G, both the infection and death rates for COVID-19 were about double that of states without 5G.3 Others who see a 5G link with COVID-19 include Thomas Cowan, MD, and Robert O. Young, PhD, both of whom YouTube has heavily censored. Cowan calls attention to the work of Arthur Firstenberg, whose book The Invisible Rainbow points out that past pandemics—in 1889 (Russian Flu), 1918 (Spanish Flu), 1957 (Asian Flu), and 1968 (Hong Kong Flu) — each corresponded with new electric/electromagnetic rollouts: electric power lines, radio, radar and satellites. He believes that the impact of these on the ionosphere—the Earth’s electrical envelope—had negative ramifications for human health. Our nervous systems are, after all, largely electrical; and our bodies themselves, at the most basic level, consist of electrons, protons and neutrons. Firstenberg’s book is well-researched and deserves a hearing. If he’s right, then 5G’s introduction, like previous rollouts, might indeed play a role in the current pandemic.

Shigeaki Hakusui, president of the Harmonix Corporation, wrote an article in 2001 on wireless radiation which states: “At the millimeter wave frequency of 60 GHz, the absorption is very high, with 98 percent of the transmitted energy absorbed by atmospheric oxygen.”4 Here is a graphic from that article:

  5G operates at frequencies as low as 450 megahertz, but can go to well above 60 gigahertz.5 (1 gigahertz is a thousand times stronger than 1 megahertz.) One of the strangest things about the Wuhan outbreak: residents, who appeared healthy and were engaged in routine activities, were photographed suddenly dropping dead. This has led some to ask if they were unable to process oxygen due to directed electromagnetic blasts from Wuhan’s network of approximately 10,000 5G antennas. As Scientists for Wired Technology has noted:

 The Department of Defense has developed a RF-EMR crowd-control weapon called the Active Denial System (ADS). The ADS works by firing a high-powered beam of 95 GHz waves at people—that is, a millimeter wavelength weapon—similar to millimeter waves being used for new 5G installations.6During a Congressional hearing, representatives from the telecommunications industry admitted to Connecticut Senator Richard Blumenthal that no safety testing has ever been done on 5G. The exchange went viral and can be watched at (for example) “US Senator Blumenthal Raises Concerns on 5G Wireless Technology Health Risks at Senate Hearing,” Environmental Health Trust channel,

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ekNC0J3xx1w.

This complete lack of safety testing for 5G is rather shocking, given the abundant evidence of physical harm from the less intense 4G and Wi-Fi, a matter I addressed in an interview with wireless educator Cece Doucette.1  Peer-reviewed scientific studies have linked wireless radiation to cancer, DNA damage, heart irregularities, lowered sperm counts, and many other health issues. For anyone looking for an introduction to wireless dangers, I recommend downloading the film Generation Zapped, winner of the Best Documentary at the 2018 D.C. Independent Film Festival; it includes compelling testimony from leading world scientists, doctors, and public health experts, as well as victims.

 NOTES

 1. “Fact Checking the 5G/Coronavirus Hypothesis,” The Corbett Report, March 6, 2020, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cszlsGiD1-E.

2. Ronald Kostoff, The Largest Unethical Medical Experiment in Human History, https://smartech.gatech.edu/bitstream/handle/1853/62452/LARGEST_UNETHICAL_ MEDICAL_EXPERIMENT_FINAL.pdf?sequence=4&isAllowe.

3. Magda Havas, “Is There an Association Between Covid-19 Cases/Deaths and 5G in the United States?” April 22, 2020, https://magdahavas.com/5g-and-mm-waves/is-there-an-association-between-covid-19-cases-deaths-and-5g-in-the-united-states/.

4. Shigeaki Hakusui, “Fixed Wireless Communications at 60GHz Unique Oxygen Absorption Properties,” RF Globalnet, April 10, 2001, https://www.rfglobalnet.com/doc/fixed-wireless-communications-at-60ghz-unique-0001.

5. “What Frequency Spectrum Will 5G Technology Use and How Does This Compare to 4G?” Arrow, February 15, 2019, https://www.arrow.com/en/research-and-events/articles/what-frequency-spectrum-will-5g-technology-use-and-how-does-this-compare-to-4g.

6. “5G Will Use the Same Frequencies as Pain-Inflicting Military Weapon,” Scientists for Wired Technology, Feb 27, 2018, https://scientists4wiredtech.com/2019/02/5g-will-use-the-same-frequencies-as-pain-inflicting-military- weapon/. 1 7. “James Perloff Interviews Wireless Educator Cece Doucette about the Health Risks of Wi-Fi, the Coming 5G, and What People Can Do to Protect Themselves and Their Communities,”JamesPerloff.com, December 18, 2018, https://jamesperloff.com/2018/12/18/james-perloff-interviews-wireless-educator-cece-doucette-about-the-health-risks-of-wi-fi-the-coming-5g-and-what-people-can-do-to-protect-themselves-and-their-communities/.

 Covid-19 AND THE AGENDAS TO COME RED-PILLED

James Perloff

Monday, April 14, 2025

Porn

 

Porn is a matter of bare life on display. The antagonist of eros, it annihilates even sexuality. In this respect, it is more effective than morality: “Sexuality does not fade into sublimation, repression and morality, but fades much more surely into the more sexual than sex: porn.”1 Pornography derives its appeal from the “anticipation of dead sex in living sexuality.”2 What is obscene about pornography is not an excess of sex, but the fact that it contains no sex at all. Today, sexuality is not threatened by that “pure reason” which puritanically avoids sex as something “dirty,”3 but by pornography. Porn is not sex in virtual space. Today, even real sex is turning into porn.

The pornographication of the world is unfolding as the profanation of the world. Porn profanes the erotic. Agamben’s “In Praise of Profanation” fails to recognize this social process. “Profanation” means using things that have been set aside for the gods through consecration (sacrare) and stand removed from regular contact. It involves practicing “a special form of negligence”4 with respect to what has been set apart in this manner. Hereby, Agamben adopts the thesis of secularization, assuming that every instance of setting-apart has an authentically religious core. In this light, the museum represents a secularized form of the temple — here, too, objects are placed at a remove and made unavailable for use. Likewise, Agamben considers tourism a secularized version of pilgrimage: pious journeys from holy site to holy site correspond, today, to sightseers’ restless trips through a world that has become one big museum.

Agamben places profanation alongside secularization. What has been made to stand apart should be made available for use again. However, the examples of profanation he provides range from the tenuous to the outlandish:


What could it mean to “profane defecation”? Certainly not to regain a supposed naturalness, or simply to enjoy it as a perverse transgression (which is still better than nothing). Rather, it is a matter of archaeologically arriving at defecation as a field of polar tensions between nature and culture, private and public, singular and common. That is: to learn a new use for feces, just as babies tried to do in their way, before repression and separation intervened.5


Sade’s libertine consuming a woman’s excrement practices eroticism as transgression, in Bataille’s sense. But how can defecation be profaned beyond the threshold of transgression and renaturalization? Agamben’s “profanation” is meant to suspend the repression that a theological (or moral) dispositive has cast over things. The example he finds in nature is a cat playing:


The cat who plays with a ball of yarn as if it were a mouse —just as the child plays with ancient religious symbols or objects that once belonged to the economic sphere— knowingly uses the characteristic behaviors of predatory activity… in vain. These behaviors are not effaced, but, thanks to the substitution of the yarn for the mouse…, deactivated and thus opened up for a new, possible use.6


Agamben sees compulsion or constraint behind every purpose; the profanation he proposes would liberate things into “means without ends.”

Agamben’s thesis of secularization blinds him to the particularity of a phenomenon that can no longer be traced back to religious practice and even stands opposed to it. It may well be that in a museum objects stand “at a remove,” as they do in a temple. However, musealization and exhibition are precisely what destroy their cult value and replace it with exhibition value. Likewise, tourism and pilgrimage stand in opposition to each other. Tourism creates “nonsites,” whereas pilgrimage is tied to places. According to Heidegger, the quality that makes human dwelling (Wohnen) possible is the “divine.” Such sites are constituted by history, memory, and identity. These same features are missing in the “non-sites” of tourism, where people pass by instead of lingering and spending time. Likewise, Agamben seeks to understand nakedness beyond the dispositive of theology — that is, “beyond the prestige of grace and the chimeras of corrupt nature.”7 He claims that exhibition offers an excellent opportunity to profane nudity:


It is this brazen-faced indifference that fashion models, porn stars, and others whose profession it is to show themselves must learn to acquire: they show nothing but the showing itself (that is, one’s own absolute mediality). In this way, the face is loaded until it bursts with exhibition-value. Yet, precisely through this nullification of expressivity, eroticism penetrates where it could have no place: the human face. […] Shown as a pure means beyond any concrete expressivity, it becomes available for a new use, a new form of erotic communication.8


However, nudity that is displayed without secrecy or expression approaches pornographic bareness. What is more, the pornographic face says nothing. It has no expressivity or mystery: “From one figure to the other, from seduction to love, then to desire, sexuality, finally to pure and simple porno; the farther you go, the closer you come to the lesser secret, the smaller enigma.”9 In contrast, the erotic is never free of secrecy. Contra Agamben, a face loaded with exhibition-value to the point of bursting promises no “new collective use of sexuality.”10 Indeed, exhibition destroys any and all possibilities for erotic communication. A naked face without mystery or expression —reduced simply to being on display— is obscene and pornographic. Capitalism is aggravating the pornographication of society by making everything a commodity and putting it on display. Knowing no other use for sexuality, it profanes eros — into porn. On this score, Agamben’s “profanation” amounts to just so much profanity.

This profanation is unfolding as deritualization and desacralization. Today, ritual spaces and actions are disappearing. The world is becoming more naked and more obscene. Bataille’s conception of “holy eroticism” still included ritualized communication: festivals and ceremonial games providing particularized sites, places at a remove. Today, love —inasmuch as it is supposed to amount only to warmth, intimacy, and pleasant arousal— points to the destruction of sacred eros. By the same token, pornography is eliminating erotic seduction, which toys with scenic illusion and deceptive appearances. Indeed, Baudrillard sets seduction in opposition to love: “Ritual is in the realm of seduction. Love is born from the destruction of ritual forms, from their liberation. Its energy is an energy of the dissolution of these forms.”11 Pornography completes the deritualization of love. Agamben’s profanation even promotes the deritualization and pornographication of the world in that it suspects ritual spaces of constituting compulsive forms of sequestration.

1. Jean Baudrillard, Fatal Strategies, trans. Phil Beitchmann (Los Angeles: Semiotext[e], 2008), 30.

2. Ibid., 53.

3. See Robert Pfaller, Das schmutzige Heilige und die reine Vernunft (Frankfurt am Main: Fischer, 2008).

4. Giorgio Agamben, Profanations, trans. Jeff Fort (New York: Zone, 2007), 75.

5. Ibid., 86.

6. Ibid., 85.

7. Giorgio Agamben, Nudities, trans. David Kishik and Stefan Pedatella (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2010), 57.

8. Agamben, Profanations, 90.

9. Baudrillard, Fatal Strategies, 137–138.

10. Agamben, Profanations, 91.

11. Ibid., 133.

The agony of eros 

 Byung-Chul Han

A Digital Apocalypse

 The Outer World of the Inner World

When we sit in front of a screen, our body stays outside. Mentally, we are behind the screen—up on the data cloud, out in data space. Viewed from this perspective, the world of things appears bizarre, slow, and refractory—somehow odd. Mentally, we occupy a fluid, digital realm, but our body inhabits a world where the treachery of the object, a certain physical objectionability, prevails. This state of affairs has consequences. Our inner thoughts, which are already fluid, are shifting more and more to the digital sphere. Photos, posts, messages, blogs, and emails are now what convey our sense of being, not our bodies. As such, inwardness no longer occupies the core of our physical existence; it has been outsourced into the cloud. Indeed, the body itself is increasingly being transferred into the sphere of data by way of its various functions. Blood pressure information, blood sugar levels, urine concentration, fertility calculations, and cybersex are moving physical sensation—once considered the inalienable core of individuality—into the realm of data. What’s left?

When interiority abandons the body as a site of residence and wanders off into data space, it becomes what it always already was: virtual. After all, the world within is where desires are administrated. Proper management is called virtue, virtus. It involves mastering and moderating appetites: not repression so much as tactical and strategic deployment, an economy of restraint and targeted release. But it takes some room to restrain desires and still keep them alive: it takes the inner world. Inasmuch as interiority shifts to data space, where it can be more readily administrated—and especially by third parties (which is why institutions have always sought to gain power over it)—the body is set free. Now, the body no longer stands as the fortress of interiority. It has become the projection surface for the soul. Since the inner world is drifting off into the realm of data, the body is turning into the site where relics of psychic space manifest themselves. Tattoos and piercings—tribal designs, spiderwebs, mythological animals, souvenirs, snakes, dragons, ornamental patterns, and so on—fill up the junk room of the psyche and spill outside, onto the body. In a certain sense, this represents an act of resistance: if the inner world is becoming commensurate with data, at least the body can avoid the same fate. That said, such practices amount to weak, apotropaic magic against the ghosts of interiority now inhabiting the data dimension. In fact, the ghosts of the machine are haunting the body and making it, aesthetically and functionally, into another machine. Cosmetic operations, body shaping, and fitness regimes serve to smooth out unsightly remainders of the past. The body is being pulled to pieces.

Such optimization measures represent administrative actions now that the body has been fired from the position of safeguarding interiority. Once it is no longer governed by inner forces—once it has been liberated from the soul—the body can be reformatted as a product: smooth surfaces, ideal proportions, compatible features, and customized design. Indeed, it turns into a surface where the digital machine writes its code. The body becomes writing, a digital medium; it no longer expresses individuality so much as the potentiality of x’s alterity evacuated to the power of n. Alter ego: the real me.

Adam and Eve

To the extent that the individual collapses when personal boundaries dissolve and stretch out into the realm of infinite possibility (xn), it becomes necessary to compensate for the lack that results. A fitting match is required: the Other as a prosthesis for one’s own self—a means of achieving narcissistic self-control. Here, online dating services enter the equation. They both contribute to, and operate by means of, interiority drifting off into the realm of data. By comparing profiles, dating sites claim to determine romantic and spiritual kinship between people (in other words, the compatibility of their inner worlds). But in fact, the actual purpose involves transferring the logic of shopping and commodity aesthetics to human relations. As a customer, the user may benefit from greater selection, but as an object of desire she or he also has to apply the laws of the market to him- or herself.

Insofar as one measures oneself according to a social imago (that is, the images of femininity and masculinity conveyed by Hollywood and advertising), one is obliged to “pimp” one’s own vita as much as possible and adjust the image to a desirable role model. As such, tinkering with one’s profile represents a form of self-fashioning like devising an artificial surrogate (an avatar). For anyone who signs up with a supposedly serious agency—say, one that caters to academics and financially robust elites—it proves impossible to avoid describing one’s personality in terms of patterns, drawing up a catalog of qualities and features, and following schematic logic when assessing oneself and others. When the inner world is cataloged and inventoried like this, a kind of database psychology emerges. Now, inwardness amounts to a seal of approval or a price tag.

Thus, it is no accident that there are dating services like Adopte un Mec or Shop a Man, which make commodity aesthetics—the experience of shopping—the rule of the game. There are top-shelf models and dead weight; market value is determined on the basis of customers’ voting behavior. Indeed, the object of desire is no longer obscure at all; instead, it dissolves into a statistical quantity (which can, in turn, function as a second-order attractor, fueling both desirability and self-promotion). Another response—which is just as unsurprising—involves applications like Tinder and BangWithFriends. Here, virtualization assumes even greater dimensions: a swipe on the touchscreen does away with the laborious matter of psychology altogether. Decisions occur quickly. If interest is “reciprocated,” further contact can be made. Formerly, such encounters meant running the risk of rejection (and corresponding embarrassment). The trick of these applications is to make a match only after both parties have demonstrated interest. In a certain way, risk-free assignations give rise to behavior that would not occur in the real world.

Whatever law dating sites obey, they establish forms of communication corresponding to database logic (x = xn). Because human beings are finite and have a determinate sex, they cannot fulfill a complete range of possibilities. In this sense, the individual is x ≠ xn. Under such conditions, it proves impossible to content oneself with just one other person. A series is required: xn. In consequence, generalized suspicion comes to haunt any and every contact—one is all but obliged to view one’s counterpart as a kind of serial offender. But doing so only amplifies one’s own feelings of psychological inadequacy. The result is second-order shame, which follows not from bodily exposure so much as from a sense of failure to live up to a media image. Coming up short in the digital dimension amounts to a kind of nakedness. It’s embarrassing that the unconscious of the machine has not achieved fuller realization—that one’s actual body rejects its power to shape and mold.

Strokes

Durex, the condom company, has developed an application that allows partners to stimulate each other without touching; designed for foreplay, it uses special underwear to transform swiping and touching motions on a smartphone into strokes and tickles on the skin. A Japanese manufacturer has created his and hers masturbation robots: dildos and linings simulate sexually aroused organs in the most straightforward way; the robots can be operated by remote control (at least in terms of penetration speed) or perform preprogrammed functions. In the wake of the hype about virtual reality prompted by Oculus Rift, countless clips have surfaced that advertise the device by promising the illusion of coupling with the man or woman of one’s dreams. There are now data gloves and data suits; it won’t take long before they’re put together and used for virtual sex. If the chaste assumption still prevails that all this will redound to the benefit of people in long-distance relationships, surely the real appeal is the prospect of being able to sleep with just about anyone (xn). Nor is it difficult to foresee programs offering trysts of different shapes and kinds. There might be preprogrammed “tracks” combining various forms of sexual stimulation into erotic hits. Petting, pillow talk, different modes of kissing and penetration, squabbles, and reconciliation would turn up the heat like musical phrases, riffs, and bridges.

This is all quite banal. But insofar as such technology gathers and processes data in order to improve services and functions—insofar as the information flows into a mainstream and, in due dialectical course, into subcultural deviations—it will literally be possible to sleep with the whole world. Here, x = xn and xn = x means a universal orgasm. “Was it good for you?” might not be the real question. Maybe the postcoital issue will be different: Save, Save as, Cancel. And once the experience has been stored, push a button: Play again.Borderliners

“The human being is a creature of distance,” said Heidegger. As an unrefined natural product, the individual cannot realize all the possibilities she or he embodies. In consequence, this inherently defective entity has the task of making the best use of the possibilities that do arise. Becoming human is a Bildungsroman. But what, exactly, do these possibilities consist of? Once upon a time, the horizon of immediate experience set the limit for what we could know. But ever since the world has become estranged—made distant, placed at a remove—the realm of possibility has exploded. It is not simply that prostheses now enable us to reach beyond our sensory apparatus (for instance, when a scanning tunneling microscope lets us see how atoms interact). Additionally, digitization allows for telepresence and global action incorporating the storehouse of empirical knowledge. Whatever you want …

For that matter: if we are able to enhance memory and performance, why shouldn’t we? Why, if the body’s appearance is no longer a matter of fate, should we shrink from applying surgical measures of augmentation or insurance? As celebrities demonstrate in exemplary fashion, the possibilities are so vast that it’s easy enough to succumb to an infinitesimal delirium (x = xn). If we can be everywhere, why be anywhere at all? If sex partners or life partners are on sale, why have just one? And since we can be whatever we want, there’s no need to be anything in particular. As a result, awareness of one’s own limitations becomes all but synonymous with a sense of personal nullity. The imago flashing on the horizon of our dreams lies so far away that it assumes negative form: a psychological antipode sucking out what little is left of a devitalized husk.

Wherever the ego is a void (or, to use a tautology, a crossed-out x), the individual hopes for salvation by plunging into relationships that promise to reconstitute him or her as x. But borderline personality disorder (BPD) occurs when the digital system short-circuits. Perceiving him- or herself to be null and void, the sufferer seeks redemption through the One. Then, as soon as the One appears, it is experienced as an attack on the sufferer’s realm of potential and rejected. From this perspective, BPD is the signature malady of our digital age: what happens when the formula fails. It represents the sole taboo still standing in the computerized world. Borderliners show us that bare presence (x = 1) offers nothing self-evident or reassuring; instead, it means experiencing the self as having been annihilated, a flat zero (x = 0). In response, they seek to make the systems of others crash (0 = 1).

Death by Selfie

The classical self-portrait was soul-searching. Artists set out to find the shadow behind the persona. In contrast, the selfie represents an act of self-forgetting: it perceives the shadow but tries to banish it behind the membrane formed by the image. That’s why there are selfies at the Louvre with the Mona Lisa in the background, selfies with somebody threatening to jump off a bridge, and selfies at Auschwitz. The selfie proves that one has managed to survive the impositions of selfhood and singularity, after all. Hence all the smiling—even when there’s not really anything to be happy about. The selfie doesn’t say “I.” It says “Me, too!” For this reason alone, it doesn’t actually connect with classical self-portraits. It’s not one’s own gaze, but a foreign stare that governs the scene. Selfies are a call for attention; shooting them signals the wish to be taken in and made part of a community. I’m there—Germany, the World Cup, with the Pope! The selfie is skin protecting digital existence from the body. The case of a Polish couple in Portugal shows just how far it can go: taking a selfie on a cliff, they plummeted to their deaths. To be sure, this was an unusual event, a misfortune, but lives are risked all the time for the sake of a better upload. Warnings are disregarded in order to ascend to the digital heavens. In fact, a better picture might result from avoiding all scenery—not showing any backdrop at all. The sea seamlessly fusing with the skies—pure, undifferentiated space—is perfect for selfies. The picture turns into a pure sign, an act where the self can yield to oblivion. Me, too!—in the limpid, digital cosmos.

All and Nothing

A Digital Apocalypse

Martin Burckhard &tDirk Höfer