To be is to be contingent: nothing of which it can be said that "it is" can be alone and independent. But being is a member of paticca-samuppada as arising which contains ignorance. Being is only invertible by ignorance.

Destruction of ignorance destroys the illusion of being. When ignorance is no more, than consciousness no longer can attribute being (pahoti) at all. But that is not all for when consciousness is predicated of one who has no ignorance than it is no more indicatable (as it was indicated in M Sutta 22)

Nanamoli Thera

Thursday, March 12, 2020

Joubert - Of Philosophy, Metaphysics, Abstractions, Logic, Systems

[1] I,—WHENCE,—whither,—wherefore,—how?—there is the whole of philosophy: existence, origin, place, end, and means.

[2] As poetry is sometimes more philosophical even than philosophy, metaphysic is, by its nature, more poetical even than poetry.

[3] The mind takes pleasure in metaphysics because there it finds room; elsewhere, everything is too full. The mind needs a fantastic world in which it can move and wander; it delights less in the objects it meets with than in the space itself. It is thus that children love sand, and water, and all that is fluid or flexible, because they do with it what they will. 

[4] Practice is serious, but theory is recreation; there the soul finds gaiety and fresh youth, through the joys of the intelligence.

[5] What deceives us in morals is the excessive love of pleasure. What checks and hinders us in metaphysics is the love of certainty. 

[6] Metaphysics make the mind singularly firm; that is why, sometimes, nothing is so cruel as a metaphysician. 

[7] Religion is the only kind of metaphysic that the common people are able to understand and accept. 

[8] It is the devout who are the practical metaphysicians. 

[9] The true science of metaphysics consists not in the rendering abstract that which is sensible, but in rendering sensible that which is abstract; apparent that which is hidden; imaginable, if so it may be, that which is only intelligible; and intelligible finally, that which an ordinary attention fails to seize. [M.A.] 

[10] Distrust, in books on metaphysics, words which have not been able to get currency in the world, and are only calculated to form a special language. [M.A.] 

[11] Whatever may be said, metaphors are as essential to metaphysics as are abstract terms. When metaphors fail you, then, try abstract terms, and when abstract terms are at fault, try metaphor. Grasp the proof, and show it as best you can; there is the whole art and rule of the matter. 

[12] Before an abstract idea can become something of which the mind can form a picture, or even a conception, how much time is needed! How many touches and retouches are wanted to give substance to the shadow! 

[13] A choice of words that presents at first ideas with which you agree, and thus draws you on to admit others with which you would not have agreed, is an argument in disguise. It has the force and the power of a real argument, but is without its harsh, imperious, or repulsive quality. 

[14] There is in the mind a perpetual circulation of unconscious arguments. 

[15] Right reasoning has its own rules and physiognomy. Truth of conception has neither; but it is very superior to the other. 

[16] As soon as an argument attacks any universal practice or instinct, it may be difficult to refute, but it is certainly delusive. You may not be able to answer it; you must nonetheless be firm in resisting it. The wise man escapes from it by holding to the common opinion. 

Of Space, Time, Light, and Sound

[1] EVEN in eternity there is time; but it is not an earthly and worldly time, counted by the movement and succession of material bodies; it is a spiritual and incorruptible time, measured by the affections of spirits and by the succession of the thoughts which are their movements. It destroys nothing, it completes. Its changes are but improvements and developments. It consumes evil to make room for good, and effaces good for what is better. It provides God with His pageants, and will so provide Him for ever.

[2] Light is the shadow of God; all clearness is the shadow of light. 

[3] The first morning light rejoices us more than the hours that follow. It has really an essential character of mirth, wherewith it colours all our moods, without any effort of our own. 

[4] The fire, they say, makes company; that is because it makes thought. Physically, there is something peculiarly inspiring in the sight of fire. The attitude, the silence, the place, the kind of reverie into which we fall as we warm ourselves—all these combine to give the mind more steadiness and more activity. The hearth is a Pindus and the Muses are there. 

[5] The sound of the drum drives out thought; for that very reason is it the most military of instruments. 

[6] Without the song of the grasshopper as an accompaniment, the quiver of the sunlit air in great summer heat is like a dance without music. 

[7] We should not gather anything that grows in graveyards, and even the grass should have a sacred uselessness. 

[8] Places die like men, although they appear to last on. 

[9] Monuments are the links which unite one generation with another. Preserve what your fathers have seen. 

[10] Agriculture produces good sense, and good sense of an excellent kind. 

[11] In gardening we enjoy the purer and more delicate delights of husbandry. 

[12] I never like evergreen trees. There is something black in their green and cold in their shade, something dry, pointed and prickly in their leaves. As besides, they lose nothing and have nothing to fear, they seem to me without feeling, and therefore interest me little. 

[13] Carnivorous animals care not only for their prey, but for the chase. It is their game, their pastime, their pleasure. All, in fact, hunt gaily—laughingly—so to speak.
Translated by Katharine Lyttelton
[MA] Matthew Arnold]

No comments:

Post a Comment