To be is to be contingent: nothing of which it can be said that "it is" can be alone and independent. But being is a member of paticca-samuppada as arising which contains ignorance. Being is only invertible by ignorance.

Destruction of ignorance destroys the illusion of being. When ignorance is no more, than consciousness no longer can attribute being (pahoti) at all. But that is not all for when consciousness is predicated of one who has no ignorance than it is no more indicatable (as it was indicated in M Sutta 22)

Nanamoli Thera
Showing posts with label transgender. Show all posts
Showing posts with label transgender. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 4, 2026

Transsexual cured by an exorcism?


In fact, there is a growing belief among some critics of the psychological establishment that psychoanalysis and contemporary psychology have failed. In his book The Psychological Society, for example, Martin L. Gross—one of psychology’s most acerbic critics—complains that “the psychological revolution has damaged the psychic fiber of individual man and woman” and has brainwashed us into thinking that we are sick and deluded. He posits that psychoanalysis is a religion more than a science. Gross came to this conclusion after making a detailed study of whether psychiatry and psychology have really helped improve the quality of our daily lives. He is far from alone in his views and was interviewed sympathetically in Human Behavior magazine after his book came out.

The following case is an example of the failure of psychiatry, a failure later corrected in a totally bizarre manner.

Dr. David H. Barlow and Dr. Gene G. Abel first met the patient whom they identify only as “John” in 1969. John was a clear case of lifelong gender dysphoria, even by the most conservative criteria. They were counseling him for sexual reassignment surgery at the time of his strange cure.

Gender dysphoria is the psychiatric term for what is commonly called transsexualism, the obsession that one has been born as the wrong sex. This behavioral disorder often leads to conduct that isn’t too socially acceptable, such as cross-dressing (transvestism) and seeking change-of-sex surgery. Surgery is, however, the only treatment that seems to resolve the conflicts that plague transsexuals. But even this treatment is not always successful; for some transsexuals are so confused about their identities that they will go back to role-playing their original gender, even though their surgery is irreversible. Psychotherapeutic forms of treatment seem useless, and there is only a single case in the literature that reports the cure of a transsexual. That cure consisted of months of work with the patient using behavior modification.

What causes gender dysphoria isn’t known, and theoretical explanations for the condition range from psychological causes to possible biological reasons. Extreme gender confusion in early childhood has been suggested as a cause, but an unidentified hormonal disorder could conceivably be a contributing factor also. (For example, girls born with congenital adrenal hyperplasm—a disorder in the adrenal glands—will grow up exhibiting masculine behavior.) Whatever the case, transsexualism is a long-lived problem that is resistent to change. For this reason the two psychiatrists at the University of Tennessee Medical School were stunned when John suddenly showed up one day completely cured— not by psychiatry or medicine but as the result of an exorcism!

The strange story began in 1952 when the patient was born. From early childhood John considered himself to be a girl. His gender confusion was probably the result of family problems. His mother and father, who raised their family in Tennessee, were thirty-two and forty-five years old respectively, and they didn’t get along very well. They finally separated when the boy was eight, by which time John’s transsexualism was already fairly ingrained. The couple were already the parents of two other children (a boy and a girl) before John came along, so he was the baby of the family. He was a pampered child, too, for his mother was very protective and wouldn’t let him engage in any rough-and-tumble boys’ play. She instead kept him at home, where he occupied his time—with his mother’s encouragement—cleaning and performing other household work.

When he was four years old, John began to imitate his mother openly by putting on makeup and dressing in his sister’s clothes. This behavior continued even after he started school, and he often made excuses to stay home to indulge his feminine fantasies. The only physical trauma John suffered during these early years came when he broke his leg when he was six. The broken leg didn’t bother him very much, but the cast he was forced to wear prevented him from cross-dressing, which he found a constant source of frustration.

John’s feminine traits and identification soon pervaded his entire life. He refused to participate in gym while at grammar school, while his growing effeminacy caused the other boys at school to make life miserable for him. His older brother often had to come to his defense.

John’s greatest personal satisfaction came when his mother took a job and he took over full responsibility as family housekeeper, a role he enjoyed immensely.

The next phase in John’s ever-increasing gender dysphoria came during adolescence. By this time he was going to high school, but was doing only passably well. His main preoccupation was still his family’s home, where he could engage in his favorite pastime, domestic work.

But when he was fifteen, something happened that permanently changed his life. He read a magazine article about transsexualism, learned about sexual reassignment surgery, and began corresponding with experts at Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore. Surgery seemed to be the obvious course of action for him, so he began to prepare for it. To achieve this goal, the teenager dropped out of school and began studying the literature on transsexualism. He became so versed on the subject that he successfully conned a physician into giving him estrogen by claiming that he needed it to treat a previously diagnosed endocrine disorder. His real purpose, of course, was to prepare himself physically for the change-of-sex surgery.

Soon the oral doses and injections took effect, and his body hair began to thin while his breasts enlarged. The estrogen also affected him psychologically, and he later reported that it made him feel more tranquil than he had ever felt before.
It is impossible to determine how far the young man would have gone with this self-therapy were it not for an automobile accident that disrupted his life in 1969. He was then sixteen. His use of estrogen was discovered by the doctors who treated him after the accident, and they informed his family about the situation. They were shocked by the revelation, as might be expected.

The disruption these revelations caused within John’s family can’t be overestimated, and seemed to exacerbate his previously disturbed relationship with his mother. She resolutely insisted that he seek psychiatric treatment, and she even threatened suicide should he refuse. John eventually gave in to his mother’s histrionics and committed himself to a state hospital, but there was nothing the therapists could do for him.

Since he was well in touch with reality and was not psychotic, he was merely formally diagnosed as a transsexual and discharged. This conveniently allowed John to go to work at a fast-food restaurant and once again plan for change-of-sex surgery. The hospital psychiatrists felt, however, that their patient could benefit from psychotherapy, and they encouraged him to see Dr. David H. Barlow at the University of Tennessee Medical School. (Dr. Barlow would later help bring the case to public attention. He is a renowned pioneer in the use of behavior modification techniques for the treatment of sexual disturbances.) This course of action didn’t strike John as unreasonable. He began taking estrogen again, but this time under the supervision of a private psychiatrist. He also went back to cross-dressing.

While personally satisfied with the way his life was going, the only teal problem still facing him was his mother’s possessiveness. He complained that she continually tried to smother him while at the same time she fercely rejected his transsexualism. To escape the situation, the young man—with his psychiatrist’s blessing—joined the Navy in 1972, but he was rejected for psychiatric reasons. His mother tried to take advantage of the circumstances and even tried to move into his apartment with him, much to his annoyance. The situation between John and his mother became so intolerable that finally he tried to commit suicide by overdosing on his medication.

This unsuccessful suicide attempt brought him back to the hospital and back to the attention of Dr. Barlow and his colleague Dr. Gene G. Abel, who had also previously worked extensively with transsexuals. They counseled the patient, agreed with him that surgery would probably resolve his gender dysphoria and began preparing him. This entailed giving him full therapeutic dosages of estrogen and electrolysis and subjecting him to a complete psychiatric examination for gender identity, gender role behavior, and sexual arousal patterns. These standard objective psychological tests, which are always given before change-of-sex surgery is seriously considered, were conducted by Drs. Barlow and Abel.

The results of every one of the tests were consistent with a diagnosis of transsexualism. Even the way John moved and walked was typically feminine, according to a test that the researchers used to check for masculine and feminine motor behavior. For all practical purposes, John was really a woman trapped in a man’s body. For this reason the therapists did not hesitate to continue recommending a change-of-sex operation.

The process leading up to this radical surgery is very slow, however. For two years the researchers kept continual tabs on John, repeatedly giving him tests for gender identity and masculine versus feminine motor behavior. The results consistently came up feminine, which constituted further evidence that change-of-sex surgery was warranted in his ease.

By this time John was living openly as a woman and was going by the name Judy. He successfully adapted to his new lifestyle, and no one who casually knew him realized he was a pre-op transsexual. His therapists even stated when they wrote up the case that he “was successfully wearing a bikini having progressed to bra size 38B.”

By the summer of 1973, John was ready for his change-of-sex operation, to which he was looking forward eagerly. Both of his therapists agreed that his adjustment would probably be successful and that he wouldn’t suffer later conflicts over his decision. They suggested that he have the surgery at a medical center in a nearby state, and he duly checked in.
Then came the shock. The therapists never received word back about the surgery, and several silent months passed before they heard from John again. When he resurfaced the following fall, he had been remarkably transformed.

“One day in late fall,” report Drs. Barlow and Abel, “a research assistant who had worked with the case came back from a half-finished lunch of fried chicken and shouted, ‘Judy is back at the restaurant, but she’s not Judy anymore, she’s John!’ Other reports quickly confirmed the report, and John was invited back to our offices for a session which occurred in early January of 1974. He entered the office in a three- piece business suit with polished shoes, neatly cut short hair, clipped fingernails, and consistently masculine motor behaviors.

Even to trained eyes, the only sign of his former feminine role was the almost complete absence of facial hair, which in view of his light complexion and in the context of his total masculinity would normally go unnoticed.” The story he told was as remarkable as his transformation. While he was working at the fast-food restaurant, he had grown very attached to his employer, who was a Christian fundamentalist. She refused to be judgmental about her employee’s transsexualism, but she did ask that he consult with a physician she knew in town before undergoing the final surgery. This physician was also a fundamentalist. Although John considered himself a Southern Baptist, neither he nor anyone else in his family was religious. But he went to see the doctor anyway as a favor to his boss. The doctor examined him and spoke with him for some time and even agreed that his change-of-sex adjustment would probably be good. He then told John that his real problem was possession by evil spirits! John was astounded by this announcement, even more when the physician asked if he could perform an exorcism. For some reason John agreed.
The exorcism lasted from two to three hours, and it involved prayer, the laying-on-of-hands, and exhortations against the evil spirits possessing the patient. John later explained to his therapists that he fainted several times during the ritual, but when the ordeal was over, the physician assured him that twenty-two spirits had been driven from his body.

(The physician later explained to Dr. Barlow that one of these entities had been female and was the cause of John’s problem.) The result of the exorcism was nothing short of amazing. When the ritual was over, John announced that it had worked! Now, for the first time in twenty years, he perceived himself as a man. His desire to cross-dress ceased instantly and he immediately went to a barbershop to have his hair cut short. This conversion to a totally masculine identity lasted for two weeks, during which time he lived back with his mother.

But then he began to feel his old tendencies returning, so he and his employer visited a fundamentalist faith healer at a public meeting in town. They were able to talk with her and she agreed to pray over John.

Once again he fainted dead away. He fainted again after regaining consciousness for a few moments, which ended the treatment. It was at this point that John realized that another miracle had transpired. While leaving the public platform where he had been treated, he saw that his breasts— fully formed from the estrogen treatment—had returned to normal. He had now fully returned to his male gender, although the effects of estrogen are long-lasting and his claim medically impossible. (While checking into the story, Dr. Barlow received confirmation of the “miracle” from the young man’s employer.) Even though they could plainly see that their former patient’s feminine characteristics had completely and mysteriously disappeared, Dr. Barlow and his colleagues were incredulous about their patient’s story and spent considerable effort in verifying it. The story consistently checked out. But to be sure of their personal observations, the therapists asked John to retake the same battery of psychological tests that they had used to diagnose him a transsexual. This time the test results all came out consistent with a masculine identity . . . which was a total reversal of the prior results he had given while being monitored over the previous two years. Even his gait and body movements were now firmly masculine, possibly for the first time in his life.

The two therapists followed John’s life for the next two and a half years to see if the cure would be permanent. It certainly seemed to be, for John’s transsexual tendencies never returned. By 1975 he was dating women but had not engaged in premarital sex because of his new-found religious beliefs. They learned that he still occasionally felt fleeting homosexual urges, but their former patient assured them that he was perfectly capable of banishing these from his mind when they arose. His adjustment to his masculine life seemed as perfect as it was inexplicable.

What is a psychiatrist to make of such a bizarre case? Does it prove the existence of spirit possession, or could the exorcism have produced some sort of psychological miracle akin to hypnotic suggestion?

It is clear from their report that neither Dr. Barlow nor Dr. Abel feels competent to explain why and how this unexpected cure came about. Writing in the Archives of Sexual Behavior in 1977, they noted that “what is important in this case is that no psychotherapeutic procedure of any kind with whatever element of suggestion or persuasion, has been effective for transsexualism, with the possible exception of behavior modification in one case. But even the most facile operant conditioner would be hard pressed to explain the sudden and massive behavioral change observed and objectively measured in this case.” They add that the one reported case of a patient cured through behavior modifi- cation responded only after months of treatment. That patient only learned to behave “masculinely” by practicing new behavioral strategies for walking and acting. The patient had to be carefully taught these strategies, while John’s cure had been instantaneous.

“What cannot be denied,” the two researchers conclude, “. . . is that a patient who was very clearly a transsexual, by the most conservative criteria, assumed a long-lasting masculine gender identity in a remarkably short time following an apparent exorcism.” Dr. Barlow was in a position to know, too, since he has personally specialized in the “cure” of gender dysphoria. He had invariably found that the process takes an extremely long time to complete.

No matter how one chooses to interpret this case, the fact remains that conventional psychiatry cannot explain why John grew up with the internal feelings that he was a woman and not a man, why counseling and therapy accomplished nothing by way of a cure, or how the young man accomplished a 100 percent change in behavior almost instantaneously.

THE INFINITE BOUNDARY A Psychic Look at Spirit Possession, Madness, and Multiple Personality
D. Scott Rogo

Sunday, August 11, 2024

The stories of detransitioners are the most dangerous for the gender-identity narrative

 The stories of detransitioners, which are the most dangerous for the gender-identity narrative, are also silenced. They find each other online: on Twitter, where they use the lizard emoji to signal their detrans status, or on the detrans subreddit (though as I write transactivists have taken it over by claiming that it was a hate forum). Seen from within gender-identity ideology, they are apostates. Some of the abuse I have seen heaped on them is truly shocking. They are accused of faking their stories to incite transphobia, or of being in the pay of the American evangelical Right. Or they are told that they screwed up, and should now shut up and stop causing trouble for ‘real’ trans people.

Irreversible Damage, a book about female detransitioners by journalist Abigail Shrier published in 2020, is the first time their stories have been widely heard. Shrier struggled to get the book published and advertised. The first publisher to consider buying it backed out after staff threatened a walk-out. Amazon refused to accept ads for it, and when a parents’ group started to crowdfund billboards advertising it, the crowdfunding platform pulled the plug after transactivists complained. (There is, however, clearly an appetite for a non-airbrushed take on paediatric transitioning. Shrier’s book has sold extremely well.)Many detransitioners find telling their story impossibly painful. It takes courage to speak truth that others do not want to hear – especially when you used to be one of those trying to shout the truth-tellers down. They often feel deep shame, says Lisa Marchiano, the Jungian therapist. Some I have spoken with recall with remorse their own attacks on people who spoke against paediatric transitioning. Others regret having encouraged others to transition when, with hindsight, they were all caught up in the same craze. Many feel like fools for being so sure they wanted something and then realising they were wrong.

Recovery requires them to forgive themselves. Just how hard that is depends in part on how far they went before desisting. Someone who took cross-sex hormones for a year or two may struggle to recover their footing in reality. But someone who regrets having their reproductive organs removed must process the worst sort of grief: that caused by an irreparable loss you eagerly brought upon yourself. Not only are they sterile, but they have lost body parts that matter for general health. A woman who has undergone hysterectomy is more likely to suffer a range of health problems, from heart disease to urinary incontinence. One without ovaries will have to take artificial oestrogen to stave off menopause. ‘Knowing you made a choice that really damaged your health, and you did it when you were barely twenty,’ says Marchiano: ‘that is a very difficult thing to come to terms with.’

Even as detransitioners and sceptical parents have to be sought out and befriended before they will tell their stories, gender-identity ideology’s most ardent adherents are given platforms everywhere. Susie Green, the chief executive of Mermaids, took her child to Thailand for sex-reassignment surgery at age sixteen – two years below the legal age in the UK. And yet Green is frequently asked to comment on stories with a trans angle. The careers of Jazz Jennings – and her parents – were launched in 2007, when Jazz was six and the family appeared in a documentary presented by Barbara Walters. The family have been on television ever since. Kai Shappley (the Texan child whose mother would not accept a gay son) is now an actor, and played a transgirl in the 2020 Netflix reboot of The Baby-Sitters Club.

This celebration of one group, and denigration and silencing of the other, surely has an impact on whether children seek to transition, and also on whether they eventually desist. Coming-out school assemblies, and teachers explaining how special and brave the trans child is, help lock children into trans identities they might otherwise have abandoned. (This is not to deny that trans children will face bullying. The two evils do not cancel out.)

When I spoke with Richard Green before his death, National Geographic had recently published an issue with transgender children on the cover. Green was certain that such publicity was a terrible idea. The ‘tremendous personal investment’ of both child and family in the trans identity would make desistance much harder, he said. The sceptical parents I have interviewed would love to be proved wrong; to see their transitioned child blossom. But parents who have turned their children into their public activism are all in. They can never allow themselves to entertain the possibility that setting their child on the path to trans adulthood might have been an error.

Child transition is an issue in an increasing number of divorce battles. Most do not come to public notice (I heard about the trend from medical professionals who have been called as expert witnesses). But in 2019 one was reported worldwide: that of a seven-year-old male child in Texas whose mother insisted she had a daughter named Luna, and father, that he had a son named James.

The case was a Rorschach test for America’s polarised media: which parent was the hero and which the villain depended on the politics of the outlet. The mother persuaded a court to grant her custody and order the father to dress the child in girl’s clothes and use female pronouns. Then the father gained joint custody, after providing evidence that the child showed no interest in presenting as a girl during custodial visits. The mother appealed, and won, and, at the time of going to press, the child is known as Luna, a girl whose father has no say in her care.

However this story plays out, its poisonous twists cannot be good for the child’s mental health or relationship with the warring parents. But it is cast in the shade by what happens in Canada, where gender-identity ideology is entrenched in law and the government grants itself sweeping powers to intrude on family life. There, parents may find that, set against their child’s, their opinions are irrelevant.

In 2013 the Jacksons (not their real name; a Canadian court order prohibits its publication) separated. Their daughter Max became distressed and depressed. In 2016, aged twelve, she was referred to the school counsellor. Unbeknownst to her parents at the time, she mentioned feeling a commonality with the transboy protagonist of a film she had seen online. The counsellor concluded that Max was trans, arranged for a change of name and pronouns in school records, and referred Max to a psychologist, who recommended testosterone and made a further referral to a paediatric endocrinologist.

A consent form was sent to the Jacksons; the father refused to sign. ‘I wasn’t even looking at the trans part of it,’ he says. What jumped out were the disclaimers: that this was an experimental treatment; that no one knew the long-term effects of taking cross-sex hormones so young; and that sterility was near-certain. He reasoned that his daughter could do as she chose when she reached eighteen. Until then, protecting her was his job.

But under British Columbia’s Infants Act, a child of any age has the right to medical treatment that is opposed by parents if the doctor thinks it is in the child’s best interests, and that the child is ‘mature enough’ to decide. In 2019, the supreme court of British Columbia ruled that Max could consent to medical transition independently of the father’s wishes (his ex-wife was no longer opposed). His refusal to refer to his child as a boy, and continued opposition to transition, were ruled ‘family violence’, and he was banned from speaking to the press. But after a period of silence he started to speak to media outlets, some of which named him and the doctors involved in the case. In March 2021 he was arrested, and a month later was sentenced to six months in prison for criminal contempt of court. ‘The initial bad actors are the teachers and school counsellors who secretly put young girls on the path to gender clinics,’ says Carey Linde, a lawyer who has represented the father in most of the hearings. ‘And then Canadian law allows doctors to provide experimental treatments without parents even knowing.’

You can judge how easy it is to find a doctor in Canada willing to certify that puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones are in a child’s best interests from the recording of an event at Vancouver Public Library in February 2019. In it, Wallace Wong, a child psychologist, can be heard saying that his paediatric gender clinic sees around five hundred children who are in public care. His caseload is around one thousand, he says, and his youngest client not yet three. He advises parents to accelerate children’s transition by exaggerating their gender dysphoria, and claiming that if transition is prevented, they will kill themselves. ‘Pull a stunt,’ he says. ‘Suicide, every time – they will give you what you need.’

*

The final harm to children I want to discuss concerns safeguarding. As the belief that biological sex is over-writeable by self-declared gender identity takes hold, institutions are abandoning the protocols set up to avoid a repeat of child-abuse scandals in the Catholic Church, Boy Scouts, residential homes, boarding schools and many other institutions. Guidelines written by trans lobby groups and adopted by schools, sporting federations, social clubs and so on mean that toilets, changing rooms and dormitories are now segregated according to the sex that children – and adults – say they are. Parents are left in the dark.

In 2018, Helen Watts was expelled from the UK Girl Guides for objecting to the organisation deciding to allow males to become members and group leaders, provided they identified as girls or women. The new rules say there is no need to inform girls or parents if males will be sharing sleeping accommodation or washing facilities. Watts wonders whether Girl Guides has considered the consequences for personal care (her questions have gone unanswered). ‘How would you, or your five-year-old, feel about her being cleaned up after a toileting accident by a male who identifies as a woman, and you’re not even supposed to know?’ she asks.

Watts also objects to leaders being told that conversations about gender identity can be confidential. ‘I understand the need for discretion and sensitivity,’ she says. ‘But that should apply just as much to the girls, whose interests Girl Guides is supposed to represent. Girl Guides is potentially putting teenage girls and boys in the same accommodation and not telling parents. All leaders have safeguarding training, and we learn never to agree to keep a secret. We’re keeping information from parents that might alter their decisions. It undermines trust, and builds a barrier between children and parents. It’s gaslighting on a massive scale.’

Such concerns have nothing to do with believing trans people are unusually likely to be predators. Safeguarding procedures need to cover everyone, no matter their gender identity. ‘I know of a Guide leader who had to bring her four-year-old son on a weekend camping trip, and there had to be rules for where he was to shower and sleep,’ says Watts. ‘Including male children along with female ones is a risk you have to assess and manage – unless they say the magic words, “I’m a girl.” ’

Child-safeguarding rules are largely about nipping problems in the bud and preventing honest mistakes. But they are also intended to prevent rare, catastrophic institutional failures. The history of institutional child-abuse has shown how predators can ‘groom’ people and organisations to accept behaviour that should have raised red flags. The only defence against such grooming is to apply child-safeguarding rules to everyone, always, with no exceptions, and to regard child safeguarding as an obligation of every adult. That is why I am writing the next few paragraphs, though I know from experience how ready people are to misinterpret and dismiss fears about harms to children as malicious mud-slinging.

Let me be clear: in what I am about to say there is an analogy, and it is not between transactivists and paedophiles, but between some transactivists and campaigners for gay rights post-1968 – who were naive, self-centred and blind to children’s welfare, and therefore easily manipulated by paedophiles. (The further reading section for this chapter lists copious sources for a claim that may seem inflammatory, but on which the historical record is crystal clear.) My point is that transactivism can be exploited by those who would harm children – not that trans people, or transactivists, want to harm children, or do not care if others do.In the late 1960s, some European liberals thought that breaking down sexual taboos was a task that had to be started young. In German kindergartens run along radical-left lines, teachers encouraged children to fondle them, view pornography and simulate sexual intercourse. Contemporaneous accounts show that parents often felt qualms, which they suppressed because of what they had been told about how children should naturally behave. What happened was child-abuse, though motivated by political conviction rather than sexual desire. But it did not take long before paedophiles saw their chance.

The leaders of the sexual revolution were men whose aims were to legalise homosexuality – and, in some cases, to smash the heterosexual family unit. Few if any wanted to endanger children; they simply did not give children enough thought. Left-wing organisations tolerated groups such as the UK’s Paedophile Information Exchange (PIE), which had links with the Labour Party and the civil-rights group now called Liberty. In Germany, a political organisation called the Study and Work Group on Paedophilia made remarkable advances. In 1980, a youth group affiliated with the liberal Free Democratic Party adopted pro-paedophilia positions, as did the Green Party, formed the same year.

Paedophiles gained such a hearing on the Left partly by persuading Leftists that their enemies’ enemies were automatically friends. In this case, the enemies were Conservatives, Catholics, evangelicals and fascists, all of whom opposed both gay activists and paedophiles. On the Left, that made speaking out about paedophile infiltration nearly impossible.

In 1979, Eileen Fairweather, a tyro journalist, was writing for Spare Rib, a feminist magazine. She was assigned to read the book Paedophilia: The Radical Case, which argued for lowering the age of consent to four. The author, Tom O’Carroll, was an early member of PIE who was later imprisoned for child-abuse. Fairweather recalls ‘anguished, earnest’ discussions about what to write. ‘I did draft something, arguing that the existing age of consent was not “patriarchal”, but protected children,’ she says. ‘But I never even dared show it to anyone.’ Paedophiles had so thoroughly infiltrated the gay movement by that time that if you dared criticise those calling for ‘child sexual liberation’ you were branded anti-gay. Fairweather says she sees ‘the same intimidation and paralysis of intelligence’ today, caused by the fear of being called transphobic.In the 1990s, Fairweather won press awards for her work uncovering paedophile rings in British children’s homes and schools. She became an acknowledged expert on how paedophiles exploit ‘institutional weaknesses and political correctness’. It is therefore concerning that gender-identity ideology raises red flags for her, in particular the advice to teachers to keep secrets from parents and discourage children from speaking up about concerns regarding sharing their private spaces with children of the opposite sex.

The worry is not, I repeat, that trans people are unusually likely to be child-abusers. Gay people aren’t, either, and yet their movement was infiltrated by those who were – with two baleful consequences. Children were harmed who could have been kept safe and, even today, homophobes conflate homosexuality and paedophilia. Anyone who cares for the welfare of either children or trans people should want to avoid history repeating itself.

Helen Joyce

Trans

Saturday, August 10, 2024

Helen Joyce - Trans

 This is a book about an idea, one that seems simple but has far-reaching consequences. The idea is that people should count as men or women according to how they feel and what they declare, instead of their biology. It’s called gender self-identification, and it is the central tenet of a fast-developing belief system which sees everyone as possessing a gender identity that may or may not match the body in which it is housed. When there is a mismatch, the person is ‘transgender’ – trans for short – and it is the identity, not the body, that should determine how everyone else sees and treats them.

The origins of this belief system date back almost a century, to when doctors first sought to give physical form to the yearnings of a handful of people who longed to change sex. For decades such ‘transsexuals’ were few and far between, the concern of a handful of maverick clinicians, who would provide hormones and surgeries to reshape their patients’ bodies to match their desires as closely as possible. Bureaucrats and governments treated them as exceptions, to be accommodated in society with varying degrees of competence and compassion.

But since the turn of the century, the exception has become the rule. National laws, company policies, school curricula, medical protocols, academic research and media style guides are being rewritten to privilege self-declared gender identity over biological sex. Facilities that used to be sex-separated, from toilets and changing rooms to homeless shelters and prisons, are switching to gender self-identification. Meanwhile more and more people are coming out as trans, usually without undergoing any sort of medical treatment. This book explains why this has happened, and how it happened so fast.

Developments in academia played a central role. Feminists used to use the word ‘gender’, and some still do, to denote the societal framing of female people as inferior and subordinate to male ones. Roughly, sex is a biological category, and gender a historical category; sex is why women are oppressed, and gender is how women are oppressed.But in the 1990s the word was borrowed to signify a discourse – or, in the words of Judith Butler, the doyenne of gender studies and queer theory, ‘an imitation for which there is no original’. And so in these academic fields, which developed on American campuses out of 1960s French postmodernism, a man or woman came to mean someone who performed manhood or womanhood, which were sets of stereotypes – matters of self-presentation, such as clothing and hairstyle, and behaviours, such as choice of hobbies and career – that were meaningful simply because they were performed over and over again. In the past decade, even the tenuous link with objective reality provided by those stereotypes has been severed. In the simplistic version of the new creed that has hardened into social-justice orthodoxy, gender is no longer even something that is performed. It is innate and ineffable: something like a sexed soul.

When the only people who identified out of their sex were the tiny number of post-operative transsexuals, they had little impact on others. But the gender identity that is posited by today’s ideology is entirely subjective, and the group of trans people is far larger. It includes part-time cross-dressers and even people who present as a typical member of their sex, but identify to the contrary – or declare a novel identity, such as non-binary or gender-fluid. What is being demanded is no longer flexibility, but a redefinition of what it means for anyone to be a man or woman – a total rewrite of societal rules.

Gender self-identification is often described as this generation’s civil-rights battle. And it is promoted by some of the same organisations that fought for women’s suffrage, desegregation in the American South and gay marriage. But demanding that self-declared gender identity be allowed to override sex is not, as with genuine civil-rights movements, about extending privileges unjustly hoarded by a favoured group to a marginalised one.

In no society – anywhere, ever – have people been oblivious to the sex of those around them, and certainly not in situations involving nakedness or physical contact. And in all societies – everywhere, always – the overwhelming majority of violence, sexual assault and harassment suffered by female people has been perpetrated by male ones. Single-sex spaces exist for these reasons, not to prop up privilege or pander to prejudice. And it is logically impossible to admit people of one sex to spaces intended for the other while keeping them single-sex. All this is so obvious that it is remarkable to have to say it – and until a few years ago, when gender self-identification started to catch on, there would have been no need.

Most people are in the dark about what is being demanded by transactivists. They understand the call for ‘trans rights’ to mean compassionate concessions that enable a suffering minority to live full lives, in safety and dignity. I, alongside every critic of gender-identity ideology I have spoken to for this book, am right behind this. Most, including me, also favour bodily autonomy for adults. A liberal, secular society can accommodate many subjective belief systems, even mutually contradictory ones. What it must never do is impose one group’s beliefs on everyone else.

The other belief systems accommodated in modern democracies are, by and large, held privately. You can subscribe to the doctrine of reincarnation or resurrection alongside fellow believers, or on your own. Gender self-identification, however, is a demand for validation by others. The label is a misnomer. It is actually about requiring others to identify you as a member of the sex you proclaim. Since evolution has equipped humans with the ability to recognise other people’s sex, almost instantaneously and with exquisite accuracy, very few trans people ‘pass’ as their desired sex. And so to see them as that sex, everyone else must discount what their senses are telling them.

Underlying my objections to gender self-identification is a scientific fact: that biological sex has an objective basis lacked by other socially salient categories, such as race and nationality. Sexual dimorphism – the two sexes, male and female – first appeared on Earth 1.2 billion years ago. Mammals – animals like humans that grow their young inside them, rather than laying eggs – date back 210 million years. In all that time, no mammal has ever changed sex (some non-mammals can, for example crocodiles and clownfish). Men and women have therefore evolved under differing selection pressures for an extremely long time, and these have shaped male and female bodies and psyches in ways that matter profoundly for health and happiness. The distinction between the sexes is not likely to be at all amenable to social engineering, no matter how much some people want it to be.

*

This is not a book about trans people. I will present the scientific research into what causes gender dysphoria and cross-sex identification. But I will not seek to balance stories of those for whom transition has been a success, and those for whom it has been a failure. Whether or not transition makes people happier is an important question for individuals and clinicians, especially when it involves irreversible hormonal or surgical interventions. But it is irrelevant to evaluating the truth of gender-identity ideology, and to whether self-declared gender should replace sex across society. To draw another analogy, whether a religion makes its believers happy is irrelevant to the question of whether its god exists, or whether everyone else should be compelled to pay it lip service.

This is, rather, a book about transactivism. It is a story of policy and institutional capture; of charitable foundations controlled by billionaires joining forces with activist groups to pump money into lobbying behind the scenes for legal change. They have won over big political parties, notably America’s Democrats, and big businesses, including tech giants. They are backed, too, by academics in gender studies, queer theory and allied fields, and by the pharmaceutical and health-care industries, which have woken up to the fortunes to be made from ‘gender-affirmative’ medicine.

This powerful new lobby far outnumbers the trans people it claims to speak for. And it serves their interests very poorly. Its ideological focus means it seeks to silence anyone who does not support gender self-identification – which includes many post-operative transsexuals, who are under no illusion as to how much bodies matter. It also ignores other possible solutions to problems faced by trans people – research into the causes and treatment of gender dysphoria, for instance, or adding unisex facilities alongside single-sex ones. Its overreach is likely to provoke a backlash that will harm ordinary trans people, who simply want safety and social acceptance. When the general public finally realises what is being demanded, the blame may not land with the activists, where it belongs.

One place I expect to see a backlash soon is in women’s sports. Their entire purpose is to enable fair competition, since the physical differences between the sexes give males an overwhelming athletic advantage, and competing separately is the only way that exceptional females can get their due. Allowing males to identify as women for the purposes of entry to women’s competitions makes no more sense than allowing heavyweights to box as flyweights, or able-bodied athletes to enter the Paralympics, or adults to compete as under-eighteens. And yet, under pressure from transactivists, almost every sporting authority right up to the International Olympic Committee has moved to gender self-identification.

The sight of stronger, heavier, faster males easily beating the world’s best female athletes is sure to outrage deep-seated intuitions about fair play – once it comes to wider notice. As this book went to press, it was unclear where that would happen first, but clear that it would happen soon.

A handful of males were expected to compete in women’s events at the Tokyo Olympics, postponed in 2020 – and, judging from recent regional competitions, to place far better than they used to when competing as men. Meanwhile, duelling lawsuits are heading towards America’s Supreme Court, seeking on the one hand to block states from allowing male athletes to compete as women, and on the other to force states to do so.

Another backlash is imminent in paediatric gender medicine. Until recently, hardly any children presented at gender clinics, but in the past decade the number has soared. Every one of the dozen or so studies of children with gender dysphoria – discomfort and misery caused by one’s biological sex – has found that most grow out of it, as long as they are supported in their gender non-conformity and not encouraged in a cross-sex identification. Many of these ‘desisters’ are destined to grow up gay: there is copious evidence of a strong link between early gender non-conformity and adult homosexuality.

But as gender clinics have come under activists’ sway, the treatment they offer has taken an ideological turn. Instead of advising parents to watch and wait with sympathy and kindness, they now work on the assumption that childhood gender dysphoria destines someone to trans adulthood. They recommend immediate ‘social transition’ – a change of name, pronouns and presentation – followed successively by drugs to block puberty, cross-sex hormones and surgery, often while the patient is still in their teens. This treatment pathway is a fast track to sexual dysfunction and sterility in adulthood.

In the past few years a new group of trans-identifying minors has emerged: teenage girls. Until very recently, this demographic was almost never seen at gender clinics: now it predominates worldwide. And again these girls are fast-tracked to hormones and surgery, even though there is no evidence that these will help – and good reason to think they will not. This is the demographic most prone to social contagions, from the outbreaks of hysterical laughter and fainting that have been documented in girls’ schools and convents throughout history, to the eating disorders and self-harm that sometimes sweep through friendship groups in the present day. Now another is under way, this time spread by social-justice warriors on social media alongside the medical profession and schools, which have added gender-identity ideology to the curriculum.

Early signs suggest that the number of children appearing at gender clinics is levelling off in Sweden, where clinicians have started to become concerned about the uncritical promotion of trans identification across society. And in late 2020, an English court ordered the country’s sole paediatric gender clinic to seek judicial approval before offering children puberty-blocking drugs. These, it ruled, were part of a treatment pathway leading to irreversible harms that very few under-sixteens could possibly have the maturity to understand and consent to. But in the United States, where regulation is light and the health-care lobby is powerful, clinicians are abandoning even the last vestiges of caution. This story will end in shattered lives – and lawsuits.

I know that I will be called unkind, and worse, for writing this book. Some of what I say is bound to be perceived as deeply hurtful by some: that it is rare to be able to pass as a member of the opposite sex, especially if you are male; that the feeling of being a member of the opposite sex, no matter how deep and sincere, cannot change other people’s instinctive perceptions; that such a feeling does not constitute licence to use facilities or services intended for the sex that you are not; that children who suffer distress at their sex are ill-served by being told that they can change it.

My intention is not to be unkind to trans people, but to prevent greater unkindness. As gender self-identification is written into laws around the world, the collateral damage is mounting. Males who raped and murdered women are gaining transfers to women’s prisons. Women have lost their jobs for saying that male and female are objective, socially significant categories. I think it is deeply unkind to force female athletes to compete against males, and a scandal to sterilise children. These things are happening partly because of an admirable, but poorly thought-out, sense of compassion for trans people. This compassion is, not coincidentally, mostly demanded of women, who are socialised to put their own needs last and punished more severely than men when they refuse to comply.

What first intrigued me about gender-identity ideology was the circularity of its core mantra, ‘transwomen are women’, which raises and leaves unanswered the question of what, then, the word ‘woman’ means. What led me to think further was the vilification of anyone who questioned it. Philosophers, who freely debate such thorny topics as whether it is moral to kill disabled babies or remove kidneys from unwilling people for donation, have, with few exceptions, been cowed into silence regarding the consequences of redefining ‘man’ and ‘woman’. Journalists, who pride themselves on ferreting out the stories that someone, somewhere doesn’t want them to print, have taken one look at paediatric transitioning, males winning women’s sporting competitions and women being sacked for talking about the reality of biological sex – and, again with just a few exceptions, turned tail.

What finally pushed me to write this book, however, was meeting some of gender-identity ideology’s most poignant victims. They are detransitioners: people who took hormonal and sometimes surgical steps towards transition, only to realise that they had made a catastrophic mistake. At the inaugural meeting of the Detransition Advocacy Network, a British self-help group, in Manchester in late 2019, I met some in person. When I heard their stories, I knew I had to amplify them.

Some of those I have spoken with, at that meeting and since, are young lesbians who had previously decided that their gender non-conformity meant they were really men. Others are young gay men whose parents preferred to see their effeminate small boys as ‘girls trapped in boys’ bodies’, rather than as probable future homosexuals. The share with traits suggestive of an autistic-spectrum disorder is much higher than in the general population. These traits include dissociative feelings, which can be misinterpreted as gender dysphoria, and rigid thinking, which can lead someone to conclude that deviating from sex stereotypes makes a person trans. Young women with eating disorders are over-represented. And not a few were simply miserable teenagers seeking in transition a community and validation.

Detransitioners speak of trauma from experimental drugs and surgeries, of having been manipulated and deceived by adults, and of being abandoned by friends when they detransitioned. I have seen them abused and defamed on social media, accused of being transphobes and liars, and of trying to stop genuine trans people getting the treatments they need. In fact, most are simply urging caution, and have no desire to stop others living as they wish. Their most obvious wounds are physical: mastectomies; castration; bodies shaped by cross-sex hormones. But the mental wounds go deeper. They bought into an ideology that is incoherent and constantly shifting, and where the slightest deviation is ferociously punished. They were led to believe that parents who expressed concern about the impact of powerful drugs on developing minds and bodies were hateful bigots, and that the only conceivable alternative to transition was suicide.

Ideas have consequences, and one of the consequences of the idea of gender self-identification is that children are being manipulated and damaged. Once you have seen that, it is hard to look away. The detransitioners I know have suffered greatly. They and their counterparts around the world seem to have settled on the lizard emoji as an informal mascot online: a talisman of rejuvenation, recovery and renewal. Their motive for speaking out is to save other young people from suffering as they did. That is also my motive for writing this book.

1

Sunday, April 28, 2024

Mutilating Children Could Have Been Avoided


The sexual left is blamed for the mutilation of children in the name of trangenderism. But the estalishment right allowed it to happen.

The conservative political class may finally be waking up to the realization that mutilating children is a little more serious consequence of transgenderist ideology than is admitting men to feminist bastions like women’s sports. Tucker Carlson has contributed to this awareness. But the interview he just held with the creator of a new film on this hideous practice covers up more than it reveals.

Carlson and filmmaker Robby Starbuck are appropriately outraged that children should be systematically abused in this way. But government policies and government officials, captured by radical sexual ideologues, have been the main driver of child abuse for decades, while both liberals and conservatives ignored it. I published articles clearly demonstrating this in the respected conservative news magazine Human Events back in 2002 and 2006, and in my books of 2007 and 2017 and my pieces were based on evidence provided by other investigators and scholars well before that.¹

Briefly, the argument is this: It is undeniable that child abuse overwhelmingly takes place in single-parent homes. Almost all physical child abuse (which is most of it) is perpetrated by single mothers (or in foster care after the children are removed from the mothers). Virtually all sexual abuse is by the mothers’ lovers. Mothers in intact families also account for very little. Biological fathers are responsible for a miniscule proportion and serve as the children’s principal protectors.

Yet trumped-up accusations of child abuse have long been used to rationalize separating children from their fathers through divorce/custody proceedings and creating the very single-parent homes where most abuse occurs. Family court judges, terrified of feminist social workers (and skillful at creating additional business for themselves), readily grant their requests to endanger children.

As I wrote previously:

Seldom does public policy stand in such direct defiance of undisputed truths, to the point where the cause of the problem -- separating children from their fathers -- is presented as the solution, and the solution -- allowing children to grow up with their fathers -- is depicted as the problem. If you want to encourage child abuse, remove the fathers. … Appalling as it sounds, the conclusion is inescapable that we have created a huge army of officials with a vested interest in child abuse.

Conservatives may finally be willing to criticize the transgenderists for the latest outrage, but they are still too frightened to challenge the feminists who started it all: both sexual ideology itself and using other people’s children as political weapons. Had they had the courage to do so decades ago, we might have avoided all this.² But then neutering conservatives, and rendering them cowardly sissies, is another achievement of the feminists.

As a coda to this, Tucker Carlson recently intereviewed a father who found himself helpless as his former wife and feminist judges started physically “changing the sex” of his young son. Again, Carlson was appropriately outraged. But here is what I posted on X (Twitter) in response:

https://twitter.com/DrSBaskerville/status/1784189991976865856

This [too] could have been avoided. As I posted recently (https://twitter.com/DrSBaskerville/status/1782147106423140573…), child abuse -- including some hideous child abuse -- has long been taking place almost entirely in the homes of single mothers. Yet only now that it involves transgender ideology do conservatives start expressing outrage about it. Where were they all these decades, when children were being taken away from their fathers and subject to abuse every bit as horrifying as this? And why are they not expressing any outrage or desire to reform the divorce machinery itself, which is the first weapon that enables all the horrors like this one? It is no accident that this man's son is suffering this at the hands of his "ex-wife". It is certainly why she become his ex-wife, so that she would be "liberated" to do things like this. This is all thoroughly documented in my book, Taken Into Custody (https://stephenbaskerville.com/taken-into-custody…). I realize that Carlson worked for Fox News, who would have dismissed him earlier if he had investigated this properly. But now he is free. My new book will argue that professional conservatives deliberately allow and even encourage harm to come to ordinary people in order that they can express outrage about it and benefit politically. I would like to think this is not true of Carlson. His commentaries are full of little asides indicating that he wants to expose things like this. So what is he waiting for?

1
Stephen Baskerville, “The Truth About Child Abuse,” Human Events, vol. 58, no. 16, 29 April 2002, p. 14; “How the Government Creates Child Abuse,” Human Events Online, 13 April 2006. You can find extensive documentation in my books, Taken Into Custody (2007), chap. 4, and The New Politics of Sex (2017), pp, 193-206.

2
I have not seen a breakdown of how many children undergoing “sex change” procedures are the children of broken homes, but it is almost certainly huge. Even if it is not, the point is the same, because failing to confront feminist extremism is what led to transgenderism. That would make a good project for a graduate student.

If you liked this post from Stephen Baskerville's Newsletter, please share it.

More of my work can be found at www.StephenBaskerville.com.