To be is to be contingent: nothing of which it can be said that "it is" can be alone and independent. But being is a member of paticca-samuppada as arising which contains ignorance. Being is only invertible by ignorance.

Destruction of ignorance destroys the illusion of being. When ignorance is no more, than consciousness no longer can attribute being (pahoti) at all. But that is not all for when consciousness is predicated of one who has no ignorance than it is no more indicatable (as it was indicated in M Sutta 22)

Nanamoli Thera
Showing posts with label Lachman. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Lachman. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

The Strange Death of James Webb

 

On the afternoon of May 8, 1980, after two years of a deep, paralyzing depression and at least one psychotic episode, the brilliant Scots historian of the occult James Webb put the barrel of his shotgun to his head and blew his brains out. He was thirty-four. In the 1970s Webb had made a name for him with his fascinating if skeptical histories of occultism, The Occult Underground (1974) and The Occult Establishment (1976). In 1980, The Harmonious Circle, Webb’s study of G. I. Gurdjieff, P. D. Ouspensky, and their followers had just been published, and Webb’s career was looking good. He was a regular contributor to Encounter and also to the encyclopedia Man, Myth, and Magic, and his performance at Trinity College, Cambridge, had been so stellar that a biennial James Webb Memorial Prize is awarded there in his honor.

Webb’s books combine a painstaking research into the occult and an ironic dismissal of it, the kind of know-it-all rationalism we might expect from a Cambridge graduate. But at the time of his suicide, Webb had changed his mind about the kinds of experiences he had chalked up to delusion, fantasy, and a post-Enlightenment craving for the irrational. In his last days, Webb was convinced that the nervous breakdown that cast him into suicidal madness had also revealed dimensions of reality that could only be called supernatural. He found himself “catapulted into a larger universe” filled with altered states of consciousness and profound visions of “cyclical time.”

The experience was not all revelation. Webb also showed the classic signs of paranoid schizophrenia. His publisher, he claimed, was persecuting him. Worse still, he was convinced that a certain group of French Freemasons had it in for him. Such remarks suggest Webb’s change of heart about the supernatural was nothing more than the pathetic result of his tragic breakdown. Yet the circumstances surrounding his death were unusual and raise the suspicion that the dividing line between madness and occult revelation may not be as clear cut as we suppose.

How and when Webb’s madness began are unclear; even as a schoolboy at Harrow he was considered brilliant but perhaps a little unstable. After his death, his widow—even more skeptical of the supernatural than he—refused to discuss the matter, preferring, understandably, to forget the tragic business. By most accounts Mary Webb was a no-nonsense, practical woman who loved her husband but had little insight into his brilliance and even less into his obsessions, and it is a fair guess that she may have felt that his interest in the occult was somehow responsible for his madness. That Webb married a woman with little of his intellectual spirit and less sensitivity to his experiences is one of the strange things about the affair. It does account, however, for his relationship with another woman, Joyce Collin-Smith. Many an unsympathetic wife has driven her husband into other arms, but in Webb’s case the attraction of the other woman wasn’t sexual but psychic.

Webb first encountered Joyce Collin-Smith in 1972. At the National Liberal Club in London, she gave a lecture to the Astrological Association on the life and work of her brother-in-law, Rodney Collin. Webb was interested in Rodney Collin because, as one of the main followers of Ouspensky, Collin would feature prominently in Webb’s book on Gurdjieff. Webb had come to the lecture intending to ask Joyce for an interview about her brother-in-law.

By the time she met Webb, Joyce Collin-Smith had run the gamut of spiritual teachers. In the 1950s she practiced the Gurdjieff “work” with Rodney Collin at his commune in the suburbs of Mexico City. Before this she had been involved with Dr. Frank Buchman, founder of Moral Rearmament. She was also a follower of Pak Subuh, the Indonesian mystic and founder of the Subud movement, which included J. G. Bennett among fellow “work” members. And, in the early days of the 1960s, she had been chauffeur and girl Friday to the Maharishi Mahesh Yogi before the Beatles discovered meditation and made the giggling guru a spiritual superstar. A former Fleet Street journalist, novelist, and officer in the Women’s Auxiliary Air Force, Joyce was old enough to be Webb’s mother; at the very least, she was an unusual candidate for spiritual adviser to a brainy twenty-six-year-old who found most of her pursuits pure hogwash.

And yet, at the very first meeting, Joyce knew Webb would play a large role in her life. She also knew he was fated for some strange destiny. As she recalled in her autobiography, Call No Man Master (1988), the minute she saw the tall, red-haired young man enter the auditorium, her “heart leapt.” It was not love at first sight; on the contrary, in Webb she recognized a sinister, terrifying figure from a repeated nightmare of her childhood. In her dreams, a tall, red-haired young schoolmaster asked her to fetch something from a forbidding tower. Frightened at entering the tower alone, she nevertheless obeyed. Halfway up, in a desolate, empty room, the schoolmaster, raving mad, charged in and threw himself at her. She woke up each night, sweating and terrified. Now, more than forty years later, the mad schoolmaster had come to her lecture.

Joyce watched as he took a seat in the last row. She then gave her lecture, speaking, she recalls, almost solely to him. At the end of her talk, as she spoke with some of the audience, Joyce half expected the “schoolmaster” to erupt into maniacal laughter. But when the shy, diffident young man approached and explained that he was writing a book on Gurdjieff and wanted to speak with her about her brother-in-law, she was surprised at his gentle, almost apologetic manner.

They developed an immediate rapport. In Joyce’s house in Sussex, they talked for hours about philosophy, religion, history, and her experiences with the occult. Precognitive dreams, visions, strange states of consciousness while practicing Transcendental Meditation and self-remembering, even communication with the dead. Webb was impressed. A brilliant scholar, his encounters with the occult had been strictly “armchair,” but it’s clear from Joyce’s account that he was also attracted to something else.

Webb’s family was well-off. Had he lived, Webb would have inherited a large estate at Blair Drummond, in Perthshire, Scotland. But relations with his family had soured over Mary. Class may have had something to do with it, but Webb’s mother and stepfather were certain she wasn’t right for him; when the couple did marry, it was against their wishes.

Estranged from his parents, finding little in common with Mary, Webb took refuge in his studies. His brilliance threw him far ahead of his contemporaries. Few could keep up with his discoveries; fewer still could speak intelligently about them. And now he had met someone who seemed to know all about the occult from the inside, someone who also took an immediate liking to him and gave him encouragement and approval. Joyce quickly became a kind of surrogate mother for Webb. He welcomed the ease and naturalness in her household, so different from the tension around his real parents. Later Joyce would claim that they had known each other in previous incarnations; this time they had met as a sort of mother and son.

Inevitably, Joyce compared their astrological charts; both were Capricorns with Leo rising. The points of contact among their stars suggested to Joyce that James could indeed have been her son—had she had one—and the association with the mad schoolmaster faded from her consciousness. Their rapport deepened; her affection for the young scholar grew. More and more, Joyce was reminded of her relationship with Rodney Collin, who, as we shall see, also died in mysterious circumstances. As their philosophical conversations continued, they began to experience a kind of telepathy; each knew the other’s thoughts before a word was spoken. Their rapid exchange developed into a kind of verbal shorthand. Repeatedly, Joyce felt a curious sensation of déjà vu. At one point, during tea on a summer afternoon, Webb asked Joyce for “another piece of cherry cake.” Immediately Joyce was reminded of another childhood dream, this one involving a Tibetan background, a fantasized “brother,” and cherries. Increasingly she felt that they were indeed “two beings who had incarnated within reach of each other many times in different roles.”

Several months later Joyce’s husband’s ill health forced her to sell their Sussex house, and they moved to a cottage in the New Forest. Money was scarce; she had to take what work she could find, mostly lecturing and doing horoscopes. Not long after, she got a call from “Jamie,” as she called Webb. He wanted to double-check some material for the Gurdjieff book. He and Mary had married recently and had just returned from a honeymoon in the Orient. Joyce was glad to hear from him, but thought he sounded strange, “rather low and glum,” unlike his usual cheerful self. Webb wanted to visit her, but Joyce put him off; her husband’s health would make things difficult. But she promised to ring him soon about lunching with him in London.

Something in Webb’s call made Joyce check his chart again. She saw the familiar qualities, “fiery, vigorous, and tenacious,” so much like her own. But there was something else. Webb’s stars indicated a depressive tendency, an inclination to withdraw deeper into himself as he got older. She didn’t know it at the time, but Webb had just done that. He had amassed an incredible library and spent more and more time alone, immersed in his research. Friends and literary acquaintances saw less and less of him. His marriage, too, seemed shaky. Webb worked well into the night, often falling asleep at his desk, amidst volumes of Jacob Boehme, Raymond Lully, and other occult philosophers. What had been an admirable dedication to work now seemed a full-fledged obsession. Joyce warned Jamie of the dangers but, like any good Faust, he ignored them.

The next time they spoke, Joyce felt certain something had happened. It was then that Webb told her of being persecuted by his publishers and raved about the French Freemasons. He was ill with flu, and Joyce urged him to relax. But Webb’s mental deterioration had begun. He didn’t ring again and, to her later regret, Joyce’s own affairs prevented her from telephoning him. The next time she heard from him, Webb had already plunged into madness.

“My life has just emerged from a nightmare,” Webb wrote some time later. “I had a full-scale nervous breakdown, with hallucinations, visions, and a fine repertoire of subjectively supernatural experiences. Hoist with my own petard, some would say.” The cool rationalism that called occultism a “flight from reason” seemed helpless before the kinds of experiences he had gone through. “Despite the undoubtedly hallucinatory nature of many of my experiences,” he wrote, “a residue remains which I simply have to take seriously.” He tried to fit what was happening to him into some system, calling on Gnostic notions of Aeons and Hindu kalpas. But the visions were too vivid and extraordinary to be neatly filed into some metaphysic. The gist of them had to do with time. The world had become a kind of Heraclitean flux. He had seen “molecules.”

Webb’s letter was postmarked Durisdeer in Dumfrieshire. He and Mary had left London and had moved into a renovated old church. Joyce wrote back immediately. Webb replied at great length; he thought she had rebuffed him in his hour of need. His account of his breakdown was harrowing. He had been in and out of various hospitals, had been in the hands of several psychiatrists, was doped on Largactil (sold in the United States as Thorazine) and had only just escaped electroshock therapy. He had given up writing and was just barely keeping his sanity. Joyce berated herself for not responding sooner. She soon made up for this. During the next five months she and Webb exchanged a lengthy and extraordinary correspondence. Two or three times a week several pages of Webb’s increasingly wild account reached her door.

He wrote of a “shattering vision of the wheel of life.” He saw his previous incarnations. He became convinced that there is a “principle of consciousness which is not merely the result of a congeries of experience”—what Ouspensky had called the linga sharira, the “long body” that extends through countless lives. But the worst was that there seemed to be no stability. Things would not “stand still.” No sooner did he look at something than he saw its entire history, its present, past, and future. An oak was an acorn, then a rotting mass of mulch. Although he believed there was a way out, Webb shrank from the knowledge that we are all “imprisoned in the coils of cyclical time.”

Finally Joyce could offer something more than sympathy. She was familiar with these visions. During her time with the Maharishi, she had experienced the same phenomena, the result of too much Transcendental Meditation. It had brought her to the brink of suicide. She suggested exercises to keep his mind focused in time. These helped for a while, but increasingly Webb’s thoughts turned to death. He wrote to Joyce that “Rodney Collin was quite right about the importance of dying properly.” He also said that he had “revised my opinion about the manner of Ouspensky’s death.”

Strange deaths were indeed not uncommon among professors of Gurdjieff’s “work.” When Gurdjieff died in 1949, the doctor performing the autopsy declared that his internal organs were in such bad condition that he should have been dead years before; Gurdjieff had apparently willed himself to stay alive. Ouspensky’s death was even stranger. He was obsessed with time; his particular fascination was eternal recurrence, the notion that, with slight variations, our lives repeat, over and over. The only possibility of escape is in becoming more conscious. In his last days, a sick and dying Ouspensky visited various favorite sites, fixing them in his mind, in order to remember them in his next recurrence. Weird psychic phenomena occurred; in his efforts to die consciously, witnesses report that Ouspensky had become telepathic.

And when, on October 2, 1947, Ouspensky passed away, Rodney Collin, his closest disciple, locked himself in the room next to his master’s and did not emerge until a week later. He told his wife—and Joyce—that he had been in communication with Ouspensky the entire time. Nearly ten years later, on May 3, 1956, Collin himself would die after falling from a tower in Cusco, Peru. He was found in a position resembling the crucified Christ; earlier he had prayed that a crippled peasant boy be cured, and he had told his wife that he had offered God his body in exchange. There is some suspicion that he too had attempted to “die consciously.” Webb had written skeptically about the events around Ouspensky’s and Collin’s death. Now he had reason to change his mind.

Joyce considered the possibility that Jamie was going through some kind of self-inflicted initiatory process. She knew that their conversations had opened him to the reality of the occult. His armor of skeptical rationality had cracked; in his letters he spoke of curious precognitive dreams and of a kind of Gnostic personal myth. He had long fantasized that he was a member of a crew whose spaceship had crashed on an alien planet. Enslaved by the natives, they soon forgot their past. But occasionally a dim memory stirred, the crew members recognized each other, and they recalled their mission. “The tragedy,” he told her, “is infinitely far distant, the adventure infinitely long. And we are ageless, ageless.”

Had Webb been allowed to explore these intuitions, it’s possible he may have survived. But after several months of having him around the house, Mary forced him to take a job. They didn’t need the money. Understandably, she felt that some work might give her husband some ballast. But she really had no insight into his plight and little patience for his talk about the soul, later telling Joyce that she considered all that sort of thing “rubbish.” A copywriting job for an Edinburgh advertising agency was not quite what Webb needed. The uncongenial atmosphere had the opposite effect, throwing him deeper into alienation. His letters to Joyce became wilder. He was researching a book about esoteric movements in Scotland but he “couldn’t get the pattern of it anymore.” More and more, he believed, someone was after him because he knew too much,

Finally, Joyce decided she had to see him. By this time their telepathic link had increased. She had visions of him at his desk and could feel a pain in the back of his neck, a vulnerable spot he shared with both her and Rodney Collin. She could hear him crying at night and in her mind reached out to comfort him. Although she had never been there, she had images of the grounds around the house; later, after Webb’s death, she saw that these had been accurate. In a few weeks, she and her husband would go to Scotland for their holiday. She decided then to see Jamie.

It was too late. On the afternoon before their trip, Joyce heard Webb’s voice calling her name. “I’m coming,” she answered mentally. Then something like an enormous explosion went off in her head. At once she told her husband, “Something is wrong with Jamie.” He said it was her imagination. Incredibly, she didn’t telephone. When they arrived at their holiday cottage there was a message to ring Mary. At three o’clock the previous day, Webb had shot himself. Joyce later discovered the immediate cause was a domestic quarrel.

Visiting Webb’s parents, Joyce discovered the full extent of his madness. One night, he crouched before the fire at their estate, repeating the Lord’s Prayer over and over and muttering repeatedly, “What is it all about?” On another occasion, he ran out into the night in a state of hysteria. He waded waist-deep across a river to reach Dunblane Cathedral twelve miles away, where he banged furiously on the door. Oblivious to those around him, for a few weeks the “mad schoolmaster” was certifiably insane.

Inevitably, Joyce blamed herself for not seeing him sooner. Jamie had plunged into a dark night of the soul, and she hadn’t been there for him. Her sense of guilt, then, may account for what followed. She began to feel Webb’s presence. First he asked her to visit his mother. Then he wanted her to carry on his work. Two visits to a medium convinced her that some part of Jamie had survived. Material emerged unknown to her that later proved unsettlingly accurate. The voice told her that he “would come to her,” asking that she get his books from Mary, who “doesn’t understand them.” “Make a replica of me,” it said.

At first Joyce was thankful for these messages. But then she felt that something was “not right” about them. This was not the “whole” Jamie, merely bits and pieces of him. Jamie, or some part of him, didn’t know he was dead and wouldn’t “move on.” Joyce began to feel that she was being “taken over.” Eventually, a clergyman friend of spiritualist persuasion offered to say a requiem to help Webb relinquish his attachment to the world. Satisfied that the rite would not interfere with them finding each other in the next incarnation, Joyce agreed. As she and the clergyman read the prayers in the candle-lit chapel, she felt something lift up from her consciousness and take flight. Jamie had moved on.

There was one other curious phenomenon. During her first wave of grief, Joyce found herself crying aloud, “Why didn’t you help him?” In the depths of her anguish she heard a voice that said, “I did.” At the same time she saw a face, dark-haired, dark-eyed, with a deep, penetrating gaze. She thought it might have been Rudolf Steiner. At the time of his suicide, Webb had been commissioned to write a book about Steiner, a task that later went to Colin Wilson. Wilson remarked that if Webb’s earlier books were anything to go by, his book on Steiner would surely have been skeptical. Considering Webb’s strange and tragic death, had he survived, I wonder if Wilson would have been right.


Revolutionaries of the Soul

 Gary Lachman

Meister Eckhart and The Via Negativa

 

While Dante was creating perhaps the greatest initiatory work of the medieval via positiva, a German contemporary of his was laying the groundwork for perhaps the greatest medieval expression of the opposite path, the via negativa. As mentioned earlier, the esoteric and the mystic paths, though related, are not identical. The esotericist seeks the experience and knowledge of the intermediary planes that lie between the material world and the One; he is interested in the Imaginal World, and in the different levels of reality and consciousness it encompasses. The mystic has little interest in anything but union with the divine. Both ways are rooted in the Neoplatonic ladder of being, but while one is interested in mapping out each step of the way, the other wants to reach the top by the shortest route possible.

While Dante projected an entire cosmos in order to contain his beatific vision, the theologian and philosopher Meister Eckhart (1260?–1327?) worked to empty his consciousness of everything but the immediate presence of God. Eckhart’s focus on the direct and unimpeded experience of the divine exemplified the great wave of lay mysticism and spirituality that swept through the Rhineland in the fourteenth century and troubled an unstable church already challenged by the Cathars and Knights Templar. As the Mysteries of antiquity provided a more powerful emotional experience than the routine worship of the gods, so too the grassroots spirituality fed by Eckhart’s vision offered a more transformative form of devotion than the increasingly legalistic strictures of the church.

This independent spirituality attracted many followers and took different forms, such as the contemplative Friends of God, led by Eckhart’s followers, John Tauler (1300–1361) and Henry Suso (1295–1365), and the more antinomian Brethren of the Free Spirit. The church has never taken kindly to amateur spirituality, believing that such matters should be left in the hands of professionals, and it took steps to dampen what it called “enthusiasm” whenever it appeared. In 1311, the Brethren of the Free Spirit were declared heretical by Pope Clement V—who ordered the arrest of the Templars—and accordingly persecuted. The less rambunctious Friends of God were not persecuted; they in fact remained within the church and were a kind of response to the Dionysian revels of the Brethren of the Free Spirit, although the fact that they died out after only two generations may have saved them from the Brethren’s fate. Along with the Black Death and the Hundred Years’ War (1337–1453), the inability of the church to accommodate a more living spirituality was a factor adding to the turbulence and chaos of the late Middle Ages. The time was rife with a sense of imminent disaster and apocalypse. The end of the world, many believed, was coming. A century earlier, the Calabrian monk and mystic Joachim of Fiore (1135–1202) had prophesized that a new age of the Holy Spirit was on its way, following the ages of the Father and the Son. Mankind, Joachim said, would then achieve direct contact with God, and no longer have need for the church, a prediction the Brethren of the Free Spirit, who were followers of Joachim, had tried to make true. Rome was not happy with this, but Dante put Joachim in Paradise, and the fact that the beginning of the age of the Holy Spirit coincided with the purported year of Meister Eckhart’s birth, 1260, may not have been entirely the work of chance.

Dante and Eckhart shared much in common; for one thing, the combination of mystical insight and intense intellectual hunger, although in each the expression of this union took different forms. Both also had trouble with the authorities. Dante, we know, was exiled. In his later life, Meister Eckhart was accused of heresy, tried, and was found guilty, although he died before receiving the verdict. He was accused of pantheistic tendencies; like Eriugena, he spoke of nature’s “manifest theophanies” and preached that there was no need to hear sermons, “for every creature is full of God and is a book” and that “God is present in a stone or a log; only they do not know it.”47 For such beliefs, he was posthumously found guilty of being “deceived by the father of lies,” and, like Socrates and Suhrawardi, of “sowing thorns and thistles among the faithful and even the simple folk” by the men who tried him.48 Yet Eckhart’s remarks are not strange or threatening to anyone with a sense of Schwaller de Lubicz’s “intelligence of the heart” or Bergson’s intuition or the “participatory” mode of consciousness associated with the right brain. Yet these subtle insights are invariably lost on those who view life literally.

In some sense we can say that the parallel positive and negative ways, rooted in Dionysius the Areopagite and embodied in Dante and Eckhart, reached a kind of culmination at this point, just as Europe was about to undergo the transformation that would eventually lead to the modern world. As Evelyn Underhill said in her classic work Mysticism, “These two giants stand side by side at the opening of the [fourteenth] century; perfect representations of the Teutonic and Latin instinct for transcendental reality.”49 For Teutonic and Latin, we can read via negativa and via positiva, a differentiation that would inform the Protestant Reformation in the sixteenth century and which would change the face of Europe.

Although supressed after his death and forgotten for centuries, Meister Eckhart’s work was rediscovered in the nineteenth century, mostly through the work of the German Romantic philosopher and Christian theosopher Franz von Baader (1765–1841), and he has since become a central figure in modern western mysticism. Some recent scholars suggest that Eckhart’s true lineage is within the German philosophical tradition, and wish to save him from the dubious world of New Age mysticism. Yet the German philosophical tradition itself contains many who were fellow travelers with mystics, so the differentiation is perhaps more academic than useful. In recent times, Eckhart has been enormously influential, and figures as disparate as the philosopher Martin Heidegger, the Zen scholar D. T. Suzuki, the contemporary spiritual teacher Eckhart Tolle, and the Christian priest and theologian Matthew Fox find common ground in their inheritance from Meister Eckhart.

A FAITHFUL HERETIC

Eckhart von Hochheim was born around 1260 in Tambach, a Thuringian village in northeast Germany near the town of Erfurt. Little is known of his childhood and family life; some accounts say he was the son of a knight, yet others dismiss this. It is possible he may have studied in Paris as a youth under the Aristotelian philosopher Siger of Brabant.50 What we do know is that at around sixteen, Eckhart entered the Dominican novitiate at Erfurt. In 1280, he was sent to the famous Dominican House of Studies, the Studium Generale, at Cologne, which was founded by Albertus Magnus. Eckhart was there for only a short time before Albertus Magnus died, but accounts say he met the great philosopher and theologian and was taught by some of his students, one of whom was Thomas Aquinas. Albertus Magnus brought the ideas of Plato, Aristotle, and Plotinus and the theology of Christianity, Islam, and Judaism into a creative synthesis, a version of the perennial philosophy; he was also, as mentioned, one of the first in the West to study alchemy. Eckhart absorbed this heady curriculum, which also included the work of Porphyry, Proclus, Augustine, Origen, Dionysius, and Eriugena. Although Albertus Magnus’s Neoplatonism was soon eclipsed by the scholasticism of his pupil Aquinas, the mystic spirituality he fostered had a powerful influence on the Christians of the Rhineland.

Eckhart proved a brilliant student and able administrator, and following his ordination as a priest in 1293, he went on to have a remarkable career in the church. In Paris, he worked as a lecturer and studied for his degree as master of theology. Between 1293 and 1302, when he was granted the degree, which was the highest academic honor at the time—and from which his title of “meister” comes—he was made prior of Erfurt and also vicar of Thuringia. Other titles came, including being made regent master at the St. Jacques Dominican House of Study, the First Provincial of Saxony, the vicar of Bohemia, as well as professor of theology. Eckhart is generally considered a mystic; if he was one, he was in the tradition of Emanuel Swedenborg and Rudolf Steiner, two other men deemed mystics who were also highly efficient organizers.

Eckhart was put in charge of reforming several of the Dominican Houses and he was also made responsible for the spiritual guidance of Dominican nuns and several women’s lay spiritual groups, such as the Beguines. These popular women’s groups reflect both the turn toward the feminine and the interest in independent spirituality common to the time; as one commentator remarked, they contributed to “one of the most spectacular upsurges of mystical spirituality in the history of Europe.”51 Not surprisingly, Clement V, who had suppressed the Templars and declared the Brethren of the Free Spirit heretical, suppressed the Beguines, and in 1310, the mystic Marguerite of Porete was burned at the stake for heresy in Paris. Among other things, she was accused of promoting the “heresy of the free spirit,” a charge laid against Eckhart as well. Marguerite, along with other women mystics, such as Hildegard of Bingen (1098–1179) and Mechthild of Magdeburg (1207–1294), a Beguine, was an influence on Meister Eckhart’s beliefs. Eckhart believed in an equality of the sexes and promoted a casual friendship between men and women, in contrast to the more sharply segregated policy of the church. He was also, as Albertus Magnus was, open to insights from other faiths, and was conversant with Jewish thinkers like Moses Maimonides and the Sufi saint Ibn ‘Arabi, among others. Much of what we know of Eckhart’s teachings comes to us from the many nuns and Beguines who memorized his sermons and wrote them down, although in their efforts to erase Eckhart’s work, the Inquisitors seized many of these accounts and destroyed them. Were it not for the efforts of these spiritual women, the little we have of Eckhart’s writings might have been even less.

What troubled the church was that Eckhart preached the same sort of union with God that the Sufi mystics sang of under the cover of a mysticism of the erotic. “God and I are one,” Eckhart told his congregation. “Through knowledge I take God into myself, through love I enter into God.”52 Other sayings make the same point. “The eye through which I see God is the same eye through which God sees me; my eye and God’s eye are one eye, one seeing, one knowing, one love.” “Our Lord says to every living soul ‘I became man for you. If you do not become God for me, you do me wrong.’”53 Probably the most well-known, as well as the most threatening from the church’s perspective, is “God needs me as much as I need him,” an insight that achieves the dual heresy of diminishing God’s omnipotence while emphasizing man’s importance.54 This sort of union with the divine has always been frowned upon by the church—understandably, as it subverts its authority, although Eckhart made a spirited defense of his faithfulness and orthodoxy and, as in the case of other heretics, much of what he says can be found in scripture.55 Yet as we’ve seen throughout this book, “dynamic” religion, meaning personal and experiential, does not get along well with the “static” variety, and it is usually the dynamic individuals who suffer from this dissonance.

According to Eckhart, the fundamental ground of all being is God—or, in Neoplatonic terms, the One—and through a process of letting go, of emptying ourselves of everything that stands in the way of recognizing and experiencing this—the via negativa—we can come to know God and to be One with Him. Or to be more precise, not to know God, which we cannot, as he is beyond knowledge, but to love him and to feel his love. This process of inner emptying is at the heart of the anonymous fourteenth-century mystical work The Cloud of Unknowing, whose title encapsulates the essence of the via negativa, and whose aptly unknown author was, like Eckhart, influenced by Dionysius the Areopagite. The aim of this work was to instruct a novice on the essentials of the contemplative life. Physical withdrawal, in the clichéd sense of retiring to a cave, is not essential. This work can and should be done in the midst of life. Eckhart himself said that if it was a choice between mystical rapture and giving a sick person soup, one should forget the rapture and get the soup. What was important, both for Eckhart and the unknown author of The Cloud of Unknowing, was “psychological withdrawal,” a letting go of attachments, possessions, relationships, and personal concerns. As the old Sufi saying has it, one should be in the world, but not of it. As the psychologist Ira Progoff remarked, “the aim of the work is to lead beyond all theological conceptions and doctrines, and beyond all attachments to religious objects and observances.”56 We should, the anonymous author tells us, learn to love God without his characteristics; love him not because he is good, loving, or merciful, but simply because he is (the similarity to the Neoplatonic conception seems fairly clear here). “It is good to think about the kindness of God, and to love Him and to praise Him for it, [but] it is far better to think about his naked being and to praise Him and love Him for Himself.”57As with Eckhart, this “ground” of “naked being” is the same as our own, and by losing one’s self in order to find it, one finds one’s “true self,” as it is. This is best achieved by getting rid of everything that can take our minds away from this. As Progoff writes, “Attachment to the symbolic forms and sacred figures of man’s religions can easily become an impediment in the ultimate quest of the spirit.”58 The philosopher Alfred North Whitehead said, “Religion is what the individual does with his solitariness,” an insight with which Eckhart and those that followed him would agree.59

Eckhart had different names for this process of getting rid of whatever comes between oneself and God, but probably the most well-known is Gelassenheit, a German word that does not have an exact English equivalent but can be understood as “detachment,” “releasement,” or simply “letting go.” It plays a central role in the philosophy of Martin Heidegger, whose concern with our “forgetfulness of being” is close to Eckhart’s own vision, with his attention to Istigkeit, or the sheer “is-ness” of things, and it is also used by Iain McGilchrist to characterize the right brain’s mode of letting things be as they are, as opposed to the left brain’s tendency to manipulate them into how it thinks they should be. The “dispassionate equanimity” related to the Greek notion of ataraxia (Chapter Three) comes close, but is too negative. We can see it as a positive letting-go in order to let things be as they are. “When a man’s heart grieves for nothing, then a man has the essence and the nature and the substance and the wisdom and the joy and all that God has,” Eckhart tells us. “Then the very being of the son of God is ours and in us we attain to the very essence of God,” he says of this kind of detachment.60 One cannot help but think of the Buddhist quieting of desire and of countless “dropouts” who quit the rat race in order to find a better life. “I have no money, no resources, no hopes; I am the happiest man alive,” Henry Miller declared at the start of his most famous work, Tropic of Cancer, an account of la vie bohème in the Paris of the 1930s.61 Eckhart might not have appreciated the book, but he would have agreed with Miller’s joy.

Yet while Eckhart and those who followed him continued on their solitary path toward the “dark brilliance” and “empty fullness” of the divine, the western mind was gearing up for a trip down the via positiva unlike any it had seen for some time.

Gary Lachman 

The Secret Teachers of the Western World 

Jan Potocki

 

That sex and the East were linked to magic was not something to put off another Enlightenment occultist. To the eccentric Pole, Count Jan Potocki (1761–1815), the three were a positive attraction. Most English readers know Potocki as the author of The Manuscript Found in Saragossa, one of the strangest works of 19th century literature. Modelled on The Arabian Nights, The Saragossa Manuscript, as it is often called, is a weird farrago of stories within stories, with an overall supernatural bent. Over a period of 66 days, Alphonse van Worden, a young Walloon officer, recounts his adventures amidst gypsies, kabbalists, demons, corpses, astrologers, the Wandering Jew, secret societies and obliging oriental ladies. As Potocki’s single masterpiece, The Saragossa Manuscript alone would be sufficient evidence of its author’s eccentricities. Yet Potocki’s own life, as well as that of his great work, have a history far stranger than most fiction.

Born in one of Poland’s wealthiest aristocratic families, by the end of his life, Potocki had become something of a superman. A famed traveller, ethnologist, linguist and fantasist, Potocki combined Enlightenment rationalism with a Romantic appetite for the strange and uncanny. His many accomplishments include an ethnographic excursion to Mongolia (following journeys to Tunisia, Egypt, Turkey and Morocco), the first balloon flight over Warsaw, fluency in eight languages (including the secret patois of the Circassian nobleman), opening the first free reading room in Poland, a period of service with the Knights of Malta (including a sea battle against the Barbary pirates), and a quest for the original manuscript of the Arabian Nights. In between all of this, Potocki found time to devote himself to writing, as well as to a profound study of occultism. He also found himself embroiled in the mystical political intrigues that made Europe in the days before the Revolution a warren of secret societies and esoteric enclaves.

Among the many cities to which Cagliostro brought his Egyptian Rite was Warsaw, where he opened a lodge in 1780. By this time, a powerful splinter group had emerged within the Masonic fold. On 1 May 1776, Adam Weishaupt, a professor of canonical law at Ingoldstat University in Bavaria, gave birth to his brainchild: the Illuminati. Drunk with the elixir of Enlightenment rationalism, Weishaupt had a vision of a free, egalitarian Europe, rid of the tyranny of the monarchies and the Church. To achieve his end, Weishaupt inaugurated a secret society. He then became a Freemason, in order to appropriate the lodges’ vast network of contacts and hierarchies. His disciples quickly infiltrated most other lodges, which were already filled with members of various other secret secret societies. (The situation resembles somewhat the plot of Chesterton’s The Man Who was Thursday) Cagliostro, it is believed, was an early convert to Weishaupt’s cause, and it is possible that at least some of the activity of his Egyptian Rite initiations included drawing in potential new followers. It’s possible that Potocki was initiated into Cagliostro’s Warsaw lodge: it’s clear at any rate that he was a Mason. If so, and if Cagliostro was sifting his initiates for new recruits, then Potocki was certainly the kind of man he would target.

Two factors suggest this indeed may have been the case. One is Potocki’s passion for anything Islamic. Like William Beckford, an early reading of the Arabian Nights proved decisive; Potocki spoke fluent Arabic,, and after his visit to Constantinople, the Count often dressed in burnous and fez. This is significant, not only in the general sense of‘the East’ as a metaphor of mystery and exoticism, but in the more specific sense that, among the many eminent figures that Weishaupt claimed were initiates in the Illuminati, Mohammed figures largely. The fact that the prophet himself was a member of Weishaupt’s society would certainly have piqued the young Count’s interest.

Stronger evidence for a connection between Potocki and the Illuminati however is The Saragossa Manuscript itself. Throughout his life Potocki advocated an inconsistent array of political beliefs; but in the atmosphere of pre–Revolutionary Paris, like many others, he more than likely shared in the hope that a new Golden Age was about to dawn. An activist by nature, participation in a society dedicated to help bring this along would have appealed to him. Secret knowledge and scenes and motifs of initiation run through The Manuscript Found in Saragossa. One of its central figures, the Great Sheikh of the Gomelez family, is the head of a gigantic scheme that in many ways resembles the machinations of Weishaupt. Sentiments of tolerance, egalitarianism, universal brotherhood, and what we today would call multi–culturalism – all part of the Illuminati platform – are evident throughout the book. Other ‘evidence’ is the fact that Potocki set his adventure in Spain. With his formidable erudition, Potocki may have been aware of earlier, Spanish Illuminist sects, like the Alumbrados, or ‘Illuminated Ones’, who began in Guadalajara in the early 1500s. The Alumbrados believed in an “illumination by the Holy Spirit” and persisted until the Inquisition suppressed them in 1623, accusing them, among other things, of practising sexual perversion. He may also have been aware of another sect of ‘Illuminated Ones’, the Roshaniya, who flourished in Afghanistan also in the 1500s. Like Weishaupt’s Illuminati, the Roshaniya aimed at gaining political control by upsetting the status quo; for some authorities, there is a possible connection between the Roshaniya and another Islamic secret society, the 11th century Assassins. Here Potocki’s love of Islam would have forged a link.8All this is speculation. What’s net in doubt are the genuine occult themes that appear throughout The Saragossa Manuscript. I can only mention some of these. The gallows that the young Alphonse finds himself under after his night of passion with Emina and Zubeida suggest the Tarot trump of the Hanged Man, a symbol of spiritual death and initiation. The weird adventures and tales within tales, in which Alphonse is unsure whether he is awake, dreaming or under the influence of hashish, is a reminder of the ambiguous nature of reality. They take place within the lamina space between sleep and consciousness, the hypnagogic realm of magic and the paranormal. Several well known occult figures appear: Apollonius of Tyana, Knorr von Rosenroth, and Simon Magus. Several ‘doublings’ too: the Celestial Twins, invoked by the student kabbalist, suggest alchemical themes of integration as well as the esoteric notion of the doppelgänger or astral body. Many of the doublings are of a sexual nature, suggesting strange erotic practices. Alphonse’s encounter with Emina and Zubeida, whom he meets in a cellar, indicates the uncertain territory he is about to enter. These delightful but possibly dangerous twins are ‘subterraneans’, creatures of the underworld. They are also devotees of a strange, foreign faith.

One motif that Potocki shares with William Beckford, whose Vathek he would surely have known, is a stairway of 1,500 steps. In Beckford’s Arabian nightmare, the steps lead upward, to the top of Caliph Vathek’s hubristic tower. In Potocki, they lead down, into a cave and the underworld. Here Potocki alludes to the central secret society of European legend: the Rosicrucians. In Rosicrucian legend, Christian Rosenkruz, the mythical founder of the society, was buried in 1484, in a hidden tomb, after dying at the age of 106. In 1604, the tomb was said to have been discovered and, inside, his uncorrupted body lay in a seven–sided vault, lit by a powerful lamp. The Rosicrucians were hermeticists, kabbalists and alchemists; one of their tracts promise that anyone coming forth to join them would receive “more gold than both the Indies bring to the king of Spain.” The gold they meant, however, was not the vulgar metal, but a more spiritual kind. The cave Alphonse finds himself in is illuminated by many lamps; there he finds a massive vein of gold and the tools necessary to extract the precious metal. Each day he digs out a quantity equal to his own weight. The gold he extracts is surely Rosicrucian, and the fact that Christian Rosenkruz received his occult wisdom in Damascus would be another enticement for the Islamophile Potocki.

The count’s mystical proclivities, however, did not save him from a macabre fate. The collapse of the Illuminati, suppressed in 1785, along with the entire Masonic project, filled Potocki, as well as many of his contemporaries, with despair. The Revolution had turned into a charnel house, with the dictator Napoleon rising out of the slaughter. Personal scandal troubled him too; incest was mentioned in connection with his divorce from his second wife. Alone in his castle on his Podolia estate, ill health, boredom, melancholia and disillusionment led to morbid fantasies. The thought that he had become a werewolf obsessed him. Potocki is said to have taken the silver knob of a sugar bowl, filed this into a bullet, then had it blessed by his chaplain. Then, on 20 November 1815, he put the barrel of his pistol in his mouth and pulled the trigger. A sad end to a man whose brilliant masterpiece – full of tolerance, curiosity and a lively interest in the beliefs of other cultures – displays the best virtues of the occult Enlightenment.

A DARK MUSEA HISTORY OF THE OCCULT

GARY LACHMAN

A Taxonomy of Suicide

 

If there is a problem in writing a book about literary suicides, it certainly isn’t dearth of material. There, are course, the familiar names: Sylvia Plath, Virginia Woolf, Hemingway, Chatterton. These, I found, readily came to mind when I mentioned to friends that I was planning a book on writers who had killed themselves, or had tried to, or had written about suicide at some length and depth. But once I began to research in earnest and had moved past these well known figures, the field opened up considerably, and I found myself echoing that line from Eliot’s The Waste Land: “So many, I had not thought death had undone so many” – so many, that is, killed by their own hand.

At the risk of bludgeoning the reader into a stupor at the outset, let me support this remark with a list, not exhaustive, sadly, but certainly representative. So, in no particular order, and in addition to those mentioned above – who died by gas, drowning, gun shot and arsenic respectively – we have Gérard de Nerval (hanging), Cesare Pavese (barbiturates), Yukio Mishima (hari kari), Heinrich von Kleist (gun shot), Georg Trakl (cocaine overdose), L. H. Myers (barbiturates), Robert E. Howard (gun shot), Jan Potocki (gun shot), Paul Celan (drowning), Walter Benjamin (morphine overdose), Guy Debord (gun shot), Gilles Deleuze (fall), Otto Weininger (gun shot), Anne Sexton (carbon monoxide), Empedocles (volcano), James Webb (gun shot)1, Romain Gary (gun shot), Jack London (morphine overdose), Arthur Koestler (barbiturates), Ross Lockridge, Jr. (carbon monoxide), John Kennedy Toole (carbon monoxide), Geza Csath (poison), Stefan Zweig (barbiturates), Klaus Mann (sleeping pills), Thomas Lovell Beddoes (poison), Hart Crane (drowning), Primo Levi (fall), Harry Crosby (gun shot), Richard Brautigan (gun shot), Sadegh Hedayat (gas), Vachel Lindsay (poison), Hunter S. Thompson (gun shot), B.S. Johnson (slit wrists), Sarah Kane (hanging), Malcolm Lowry (sleeping pills), Eugene Marais (gun shot), Jerzy Kozinski (barbiturates and asphyxiation), Philipp Mainländer (hanging), Mário de Sá-Carneiro (strychnine), Egon Friedell (fall), Marina Tsvetaeva (hanging), Charlotte Perkins Gilman (chloroform), Eleanor Marx (prussic acid), Henry de Montherlant (cyanide and gun shot), Sara Teasdale (sleeping pills), Adalbert Stifter (slit throat), René Crevel (gas), William Seabrook (sleeping pills) – and I think with any luck you get the idea.

If we add to these the names of writers and thinkers who have either written extensively about suicide or in whose work or life suicide played a important role, the list swells to unwieldy proportions. Shakespeare, Goethe, Dostoyevsky, Tolstoy, Nietzsche, Schopenhauer, Camus, Hesse, Wittgenstein, Kafka, Montaigne, Flaubert, Villiers de I’Isle Adam, Mary Wollstonecraft, Jorge Luis Borges are only some of the names. Others come to mind too, and to be perfectly honest it’s difficult to decide who to include and who to leave out. So, for instance, at the end of his novel Auto-da-Fé, Elias Canetti’s protagonist, Peter Kien, sets his library aflame and burns himself to death. Clearly this is a literary suicide (a very literal literary one) and also a symbol of the western intellectual’s self-destruction. And the eccentric hero of Knut Hamsun’s novel Mysteries. He kills himself, this time by drowning. Include these or not?

Faced with this wealth of dark thoughts and saddening lives, I at first thought to compile an encyclopaedia, but I rejected this idea for two reasons. Encyclopaedia entries on most of these individuals exist already, and not only would I be repeating work already done, the structure of the book would require me to either standardize the space devoted to each case, and so lose a great deal of important material, or to have some very long entries and some very short ones. And this consideration led to my second reason. Some of the cases simply seemed more interesting than others. In some, as in the case of the Japanese novelist Yukio Mishima and the American poet manqué Harry Crosby, suicide, their self-destruction, seemed an inevitability, and not because of manic-depression or some other mental instability, but because of who they were, their self-image and their self-obsession. Death, for both Mishima and Crosby, was an idea not far from their minds, and it was something they looked forward to, but neither were particularly depressive characters, unlike, say, the poet Paul Celan or the novelist Richard Brautigan.

In other cases, more understandable and external reasons led to the individual taking his or her own life. Illness was the motive for the philosopher Gilles Deleuze and the short story writer Charlotte Perkins Gilman, incipient blindness for the novelist and dramatist Henry de Montherlant (who, incidentally, once considered writing a handbook on suicide), and escaping old age for the gonzo journalist Hunter S. Thompson. All of these people are interesting because of their life and work, and that they committed suicide sets them apart from most other people. But their suicide itself isn’t a focal point of their lives as it is, say, with the tragic French Romantic poet and writer Gérard de Nerval, who hung himself in a decrepit alley in Paris after battling years of madness and poverty, or the Austrian philosopher Otto Weininger, whose brilliant and extreme ideas about sex, race and genius led him to take his own life. In these and other cases, the suicide doesn’t seem something ‘tacked on’ to their lives, something that, given other circumstances, may not have happened. With de Nerval, Weininger, Mishima, Crosby and others, their self-inflicted deaths have, as I’ve said, an aura of inevitability. And while I am aware how romantic such considerations seem, I nevertheless find them difficult to ignore.

If he hadn’t shot himself, it’s doubtful that Harry Crosby would be remembered today solely on the strength of his poetry, or as something more than a rich literati groupie, hovering in the vicinity of Hemingway and others in Paris in the 1920s. Perhaps more than anything else, this says something about the power of suicide as a publicity stunt, an idea not limited to moderns, as is evidenced by the case of the Greek Cynic philosopher Proteus Peregrinus, who capped off a turbulent career by publicly cremating himself in the Olympic flame in AD 165. Lucian’s account of Peregrinus’ self-immolation, “On the Death of Peregrinus,” pictures him as an exhibitionist, eager for fame, and given that I am talking about him here, nearly two millennia later, he seems to have achieved some of it. But Crosby’s death, narcissistic, juvenile and murderous as it was (he took a lover with him, unwillingly by some accounts), it nevertheless remains, for all its stupidity, something more than a headline grabber. Ironically, it was the meaning of his life.

So, for some, we can say suicide presented itself as a practical solution to a pressing problem. For others, however, it had a deeper, more vital meaning.

Suicide and Depression

That writers and poets seem to be prone to suicide has not gone unnoticed. More times than not, the connecting link most often suggested is some form of manic-depression – or, put less medically, melancholy. “Why is it,” Aristotle asked, “that all men who are outstanding in philosophy, poetry or the arts are melancholic?” One answer to this question is “Are they?” One could, I think, produce a list of men (and women) outstanding in philosophy, poetry or the arts that are not melancholic, or at least no more melancholic than individuals less outstanding in these fields. One can be moved by Weltschmerz without being overwhelmed by it, and the list of writers and poets (and artists and composers) who didn’t kill themselves is longer than the one above. Yet, it is clear that in some way Aristotle is right. Painters and composers are also melancholic, and they kill themselves too, but the numbers of suicides in their group seem smaller than those among writers.

“That such a final, tragic, and awful thing as suicide,” writes Kay Redfield Jamison in Touched by Fire: Manic-Depressive Illness and the Artistic Temperament, “can exist in the midst of remarkable beauty is one of the vastly contradictory and paradoxical aspects of life and art.”2 Yet although, as she states, “recent research strongly suggests that, compared with the general population, writers and artists show a vastly disproportionate rate of manic-depressive illness,”3 one of the arguments of this book is that, as in the case of Mishima, Crosby and others, not all literary suicides are the product of depression. Or, to put it another way, to equate all thoughts of suicide (and the act itself) with symptoms of manic-depression (or some other pathological condition) strikes me as overly reductive.

It may be unfashionable to think so, but angst, it seems to me, is something more than a chemical imbalance. The poet Robert Lowell once remarked about his own recurring manic attacks, “It’s terrible […] to think that all I’ve suffered, and all the suffering I’ve caused, might have arisen from the lack of a little salt in my brain.”4 Lowell’s suffering was real, and I would not deny him his salt, but I want to argue that existential concerns about the value of life, and what we might call ‘aesthetic’ concerns about the freedom to leave it under one’s own steam, are not necessarily manifestations of a pathology. Indeed, the whole shift in thinking about our inner states from a philosophical or metaphysical point of view to a medical one (melancholy as a state of mind, as opposed to manic-depression as a pathological condition) is something I find troubling. Clearly, I’m not suggesting that people who benefit from anti-depressant drugs should cancel their prescriptions. Nor that in many, probably most cases of suicide, depression is the root cause. I am saying that the reflections on suicide of writers and thinkers like Camus, Hermann Hesse, Dostoyevsky and others, which we will discuss further on, are something more than the morbid thoughts produced by a pathological condition. When breaking off a course in psychotherapy, the poet Rilke, no stranger to thoughts about death, famously remarked that “if my devils leave me, my angels will too.” Rilke continued to be troubled by his devils, and he continued to write some of the most powerful poetry of the twentieth century. If I am here subscribing to the ‘tortured genius’ school of romanticism, I make no excuse for it.

As some have suggested, it may be irresponsible to think that the confusion, loneliness, despair and isolation experienced by many individuals of the ‘artistic temperament’ should not be lessened by the insights of psychopharmacology. The general feeling seems to be that if these can be eased, they should be. But consider this passage from Shaw’s John Bull’s Other Island, when the ‘melancholic’ priest Keegan, who sees the world as a “place of torment and penance” where we are sent to “expiate crimes committed in a former existence,” confronts the businessman Broadbent, who finds the world “rather a jolly place.”

KEEGAN. “You are satisfied?”

BROADBENT. As a reasonable man, yes. I see no evils in the world – except, of course natural ones – that cannot be remedied by freedom, self-government, and English institutions. I think so, not because I am an Englishman, but as a matter of common sense.

KEEGAN. You feel at home in the world, then?

BROADBENT. Of course. Don’t you?

KEEGAN. [from the very depth of his nature] No.

BROADBENT. [breezily] Try phosphorous pills. I always take them when my brain is overworked.5

It’s no coincidence that Colin Wilson, who himself came close to suicide in his teens, used this passage as the frontis-piece to The Outsider, his study of alienation, extreme mental states and the crisis of meaning in modern man. The Outsider, Wilson tells us, sees “too deep” and “too much” to feel “at home in the world,” and many of the writers and artists he discusses considered suicide as a real response to their alienation. The idea that their troubling reflections on life’s meaning could be excised through a pill seems a clear negation of those reflections’ value. Although it may be the case that his relations with people might have improved if he had, I somehow can’t regret that Kafka, who often thought about suicide, didn’t have the advantage of taking Prozac.

Yet, understandably, most attempts to grasp this link between writers and, as the philosopher William James, who entertained suicidal thoughts, phrased it, “the pistol, the dagger, and the bowl,”6 have centred on depression. A. Alvarez titled his study of suicide – to which this book is indebted – The Savage God, and speaks of the urge as manifested in Sylvia Plath as “not a swoon into death, an attempt to ‘cease upon the midnight with no pain’ ” but “something to be felt in the nerve-ends and fought against.”7 Alvarez writes of the “shabby, confused, agonized crisis which is the common reality of suicide,”8 and of course he is right. In the majority of cases, which are not literary, suicide is a dark cul-de-sac in a trapped, despairing life. But when considering literary suicides, depression, as common and as devastating as it is, does not, it seems to me, cover all the bases.

A Taxonomy of Suicide

With this in mind, and thinking of how to structure this book, it struck me that I would have to do a ‘taxonomy’ or ‘phenomenology’ of suicide. Rather than look for some root cause, linking the different cases I had collected, I thought it better to simply describe and categorize them. There may not be an ‘essence’ shared by all the suicides in this book. There may not even be something like the notion of a ‘family resemblance’ a la Wittgenstein – who, incidentally, endured many a suicidal thought. But they do seem to fall into certain ‘types’. There is the Existential Suicide. There is also the Romantic Suicide. There is the Aesthetic Suicide, and, as I’ve been discussing, the Manic-Depressive or Melancholy Suicide. There is also the Political Suicide and the Surreal Suicide. Each of these will be looked at in some detail as we go on. There are also some sub-categories, like the Fame Suicide, mentioned above, and the strange category of Imitative Suicides. One striking example of this type is the case of Eleanor Marx, youngest daughter of Karl Marx, and translator of Flaubert’s Madame Bovary, which famously ends with the suicide of its heroine. Jilted by her socialist lover Edward Aveling, Eleanor was so impressed by Emma Bovary’s death that she ended her own life in the same way, by taking poison. The imitation was not exact, however. Emma ate arsenic, but in Eleanor’s case it was prussic acid.

Some cases are perhaps unique, and it might be a good idea to begin our survey by touching briefly on some of the different types of literary suicide that fall outside of the main categories mentioned above.

One such I might call the Fan Suicide. One disciple of Rousseau was so enamoured of his master that he blew his brains out at his grave; he is honoured with a tomb at Ermenonville, near Rousseau’s own.9 There is the philosophical suicide. The German Romantic playwright and short-story writer Heinrich von Kleist, who we will discuss in detail further on, may be the one case of a suicide over epistemological reasons; reading the philosopher Kant – not an enticing prospect for most of us – Kleist was led to blow his brains out. There is even a case of a suicide in the cause of literature. In Berlin in 1834, Charlotte Stieglitz stabbed herself to death, trusting her death would inspire her husband, the poet Heinrich Stieglitz, to greatness. Sadly, Heinrich remained a mediocre poet, and her sacrifice was in vain. Another example of the imitative type involves the Conan Doyle and Sherlock Holmes scholar Richard Lanceyln Green. There is the suspicion that he arranged his suicide to appear as a murder, in effect mimicking the plot of one of Doyle’s last Holmes stories, “The Problem of Thor Bridge.”

Methods of Suicide

Writers’ methods of ending their life can also be unique and deserve some classification. The eighteenth century Polish traveller, ethnologist and fabulist Jan Potocki, author of the strange work The Manuscript Found at Saragossa, was a student of the occult, a Freemason and a possible member of the secret society the Illuminati. In his last days, suffering from ill-health, family troubles and disillusionment with the outcome of the French Revolution, Potocki had come under the belief that he had become a werewolf, and he took steps to remedy this. Taking the silver knob of a sugar bowl, he filed this into a silver bullet, had this blessed by a priest, and then blew his brains out with it by shooting himself in the mouth. The French romantic poet Gérard de Nerval, mentioned earlier, was, like Potocki, a student of the occult; he is also famous for walking a lobster on a leash through the Palais-Royal in Paris. After two stays in an insane asylum and several bouts of madness, he finally hung himself with a filthy apron string he had carried for years and which he assured friends was really the Queen of Sheba’s garter.10

Other methods seem exceptional in their severity. The poet Vachel Lindsay killed himself by drinking Lysol, a powerful cleaning fluid. The playwright Sarah Kane, at twenty-eight enjoying success and a promising career, was found hanging in a bathroom in London’s King’s College Hospital. And after two unsuccessful attempts at taking his life, as well as enduring harrowing multiple courses of electro-convulsive therapy, which many believe only worsened his condition, Ernest Hemingway blew his brains out with a shotgun on the landing outside his wife’s bedroom door; she had to step over his remains in order to get down the stairs.

Reasons for Suicide: Failure and Success

Of the many reasons for suicide, it seems obvious that failure would be a common cause among writers. In the case of John Kennedy Toole this is true. Toole’s novel, A Confederacy of Dunces, was rejected by several publishers in the 1960s and this, combined with depression and possible confusion over his sexuality, led Toole to heavy drinking and eventually to gassing himself in his car. Toole’s mother, a domineering woman, had absolute faith in her son’s genius and after his death, she continued to hunt for a publisher for the book. Eventually, through the help of the novelist Walker Percy, Toole’s novel was finally published, to great success. In 1981 he was posthumously awarded the Pulitzer Prize, and A Confederacy of Dunces has since achieved ‘modern classic’ status.

Yet, success, too, is no defence against the literary suicide. In 1948, Raintree County by Ross Lockridge, Jr., an epic of the US Civil War, was published to wide acclaim and massive sales, the sort of response every writer secretly (and not so secretly) desires. The manuscript, which Lockridge had been working on while ostensibly doing a dissertation on Walt Whitman at Harvard University, weighed nearly twenty pounds, and was accepted by Houghton Mifflin almost on sight; he arrived at their offices carrying it in a battered suitcase. Prior to publication Life magazine ran an excerpt from it for a hefty sum. Lockridge also won an enormous prize offered by MGM Studios, as well as a movie contract (the film was eventually released in 1957 starring Elizabeth Taylor and Montgomery Clift, and seen as another Gone With the Wind) and it was the main selection of the Book-of-the-Month Club. Yet, two months after publication, and a day before Raintree County was announced as No.1 on the national best-seller list, Lockridge killed himself in the same way as John Kennedy Toole would twenty years later, by carbon monoxide poisoning. Lockridge too was suffering from severe depression, some of which was rooted in the anxiety such massive success often brings: the pressure of living up to the acclaim, the challenge, basically, of the second book.

The Unsuccessful Suicide

There are still other categories of literary suicide. One is the Ambiguous Suicide; another is the case of writers who attempted suicide, or were about to and, for one reason or another, were stopped, which I might call the Aborted Suicide. One of these, Mary Wollstonecraft, we will look at in some detail further on. Goethe, who is held responsible for a spate of copy-cat romantic suicides, and who will also be explored in detail further on, has the eponymous hero of his drama Faust stopped from killing himself by hearing the church bells on Easter Sunday.

One case in which a book, or at least a pamphlet, prevented a writer from killing himself is that of the Prague occultist and novelist Gustav Meyrink. Torn between the demands of his life as a sober financier, and the pleasures of being Prague’s most extravagant dandy, Meyrink was at the brink of suicide when a pamphlet was pushed under his door. It was an advertisement for a book on occultism. Meyrink read the signs and decided not to end his life; when his Expressionist novel The Golem appeared some years later, it was a bestseller. The French short story writer and novelist Guy de Maupassant seemed to presage his own suicide attempt in his story “The Horla,” in which the hero’s mind is increasingly dominated by a strange extra-dimensional creature, and he is eventually led to kill himself. Many see this eerie tale as a vision of Maupassant’s own incipient madness, brought on by syphilis. His hero’s suicide, however, was wish-fulfilment. Maupassant attempted to avoid the fate of his brother, who also went mad, by committing suicide, but was prevented by his servant.11Another unsuccessful suicide was the Lithuanian poet, novelist, esoteric philosopher and diplomat O.V. de Lubicz Milosz, a writer little known in the English speaking world, although his reputation in his adopted country of France is secure. Milosz began his writing career as a symbolist and decadent, and at eighteen, was one of the habitués at the Kalissaya, the first American bar in Paris, where he was often in the group of would-be geniuses surrounding Oscar Wilde. Sitting at a table with George Moore, Ernest Lajeunesse and the poet Moréas, Wilde once remarked to a friend “This is Moréas, the poet.” Seeing Milosz come in he continued “and that is Milosz – poetry itself.” Milosz (who was the uncle of the Nobel Prize winner Czeslaw Milosz) was a devotee of Poe, Lamartine, Baudelaire, Novalis, Byron and Hölderlin, and he took part in café discussions at the Kalissaya and at another poetic watering hole, the Napolitaine. Yet, in spite of his decadent pose, Milosz was unhappy with notions of ‘art for art’s sake’, and in a letter to his friend Christian Gauss, admitted to being “horribly sad … with a sadness that nothing can vanquish.” “This life,” he told Gauss, “is horribly empty with its anxious loneliness surrounded by the idiots of the Napolitaine and the Kalissaya …”12 This loneliness increased and eventually led Milosz to a suicide attempt. As he told Gauss in another letter, on 1 January 1901, “towards eleven o’clock in the evening – with perfect calm, a cigarette at my lips – the human soul is, after all, a strange thing – I shot myself in the region of the heart with a revolver.”13 He botched the job, but his doctors didn’t think he’d survive. Unexpectedly he did, and Milosz was sufficiently moved by the experience to cast off his aesthetic garb and turn himself into a philosophical poet of a highly metaphysical and spiritual character.

Another suicidal failure was the poet Charles Baudelaire, one of Milosz’s heroes. In 1845, Baudelaire’s extravagantly decadent tastes had depleted the inheritance he received from his father, who died when Baudelaire was six. His domineering mother and strict step-father took steps to curb the young aesthete’s expenditure, effectively impounding the funds, and doling out to him a small allowance. This humiliation, combined with his masochistic dependency on the illiterate, coarse and frequently drunk mulatto woman Jeanne Duvall, led Baudelaire to despair, and he tried to escape his fate by stabbing himself. Like O.V. de Lubicz Milosz, he bungled the job, which we can assume only added to his humiliation. The crisis however had a beneficial result; out of it Baudelaire’s first published writing, the Salon of 1845, was met with approval, and established him as a respected, if not well-paid, critic.14

Another failed suicide, a somewhat tragic-comic and colossal one, was William Cowper, whose account of his fruitless attempts to end his life are too long to quote here but can be found in the Suicidal Miscellany at the end of the book.

Suicide, or Not?

The writer Graham Greene presents us with a case that could be considered either a failed attempt or an ambiguous one, but in my opinion, and Greene’s, doesn’t qualify as a suicide attempt at all. In “The Revolver in the Corner Cupboard,” Greene relates how he relieved his teenage boredom by playing Russian Roulette on Berkenstead Common. In his late teens Greene suffered from an acute case of ennui. He writes that “For years it seemed to me I could take no aesthetic interest in any visual thing at all: staring at a sight that others assured me was beautiful, I would feel nothing.”15 Here Greene echoes the ahedonia of an earlier, sometimes suicidal poet, Samuel Taylor Coleridge. In “Dejection: An Ode,” Coleridge writes:Yon crescent Moon, as fixed as if it grew

In its own cloudless, starless lake of blue;

I see them all so excellently fair,

I see, not feel, how beautiful they are!

Coleridge himself considered suicide in his early years, when, as his biographer Richard Holmes relates, he lived a kind of double-life at Cambridge, alternating “wild expenditure on books, drinking, violin lessons, theatre and whoring” with “fits of suicidal gloom and remorse.” “He abandoned himself to a whirl of drunken socializing, alternating with grim solitary resolutions to shoot himself as the final solution to bad debts, unrequited love and academic disgrace.”16 Coleridge’s older brother Francis had in fact committed suicide and the influence of Goethe’s The Sorrows of Young Werther, which we will discuss further on, probably had something to do with these thoughts of self-annihilation.

Graham Greene, however, hit upon an effective means of dissipating his boredom. Discovering a revolver among his brother’s things, Greene decided to try his hand at Russian Roulette, having read of Russian soldiers entertaining themselves in this way during long and dreary campaigns. Greene found some bullets and, loading one into a chamber, spun the revolver behind his back. Taking the pistol to the Common, he put the barrel to his temple and slowly pulled the trigger. He writes: “There was a minute click, and looking down at the chamber I could see that the charge had moved into place. I was out by one. I remember an extraordinary sense of jubilation. It was as if a light had been turned on … and I felt that life contained an infinite number of possibilities.”17 Greene continued the practice, finding a “craving” for its effects. Eventually, however, the kick of not blowing his brains out wore off, and he stopped.

Greene makes clear that his dangerous game, however, had nothing to do with suicide, although Kay Redfield Jamison counts him among her manic-depressives.18Greene writes, “… this was not suicide, whatever a coroner’s jury might have said of it: it was a gamble with six chances to one against an inquest … The discovery that it was possible to enjoy again the visible world by risking its total loss (my italics) was one I was bound to make sooner or later.” And to insure that his possible death would not be taken as intentional, Greene wrote a verse and left it on his desk, which included the line “I press the trigger of a revolver I already know to be empty.”19Ambiguous Suicides

Of other ambiguous or border-line suicides, the proto-surrealist Arthur Cravan is a good candidate. Cravan was a contemporary of Alfred Jarry, creator of the Ubu plays, and rivalled him in his eccentricities, combining a career in boxing – he once went six rounds with Jack Johnson – with aggressive, Dadaesque poetry. It is generally believed that Cravan committed suicide, throwing himself into the sea during a voyage from Mexico to Valparaiso to meet his wife, the poet Mina Loy; but an article by Charles Nicholl in the London Review of Books undermines this account, and suggests that he simply lost control of his less than seaworthy craft and sank; the voyage would in any case be demanding for even a highly competent sailor.20 Like many surrealists, Cravan however had a predilection for suicide, and once filled a Parisian hall with his announcement that he would kill himself in public. But when the hall was full, he promptly accused his audience of crass voyeurism and treated them to a lecture on entropy instead. (One suspects many wished he would have stuck with the advertised entertainment.) Cravan’s aesthetic ‘terrorist’ tactics would later be a major influence on the Situationist Guy Debord, who would commit suicide in 1994, shooting himself through the heart at his farm house in the Auvergne. Debord claimed that he wanted to see “whether one could live with the responsibility of committing an act of supreme transgression,” and his biographer Andrew Hussey spoke of his “supreme and sovereign act of self-destruction.”21 This is a refrain that will accompany many who choose what we can call the Aesthetic suicide. The problem with this and with all notions of ‘transgression’, is that there are no acts of “supreme transgression.” The other usual candidate for an act of “supreme transgression,” murder, has its own drawbacks, but, as we shall see, in the case of some aesthetic suicides, like that of Jacques Vaché, these were apparently negligible.

Another ambiguous case is that of the novelist Malcolm Lowry, best known for his masterpiece Under The Volcano, an hallucinatory account of the last twelve hours in the life of Geoffrey Firmin, an alcoholic ex-British Consul, drinking himself to death in Mexico. The action of the novel takes place on the Day of the Dead, and the book is saturated in occult and mystical symbolism, much of it taken from the Tarot; one card with great meaning for Lowry was the Hanged Man. Firmin tempts certain death by frequenting a low tavern, the Farolito, and at the end of the novel is killed there by local fascists and Nazi supporters. Lowry’s own life, filled with alcoholism, broken marriages, poverty and failure, seems a long, drawn out descent into a personal hell, and at the end of it, the official assessment was ‘death by misadventure.’ Yet there is some suspicion of suicide. The cause of death was asphyxiation – Lowry choked on his own vomit after a terrific binge. Yet a bottle that had contained twenty sodium amytal sleeping pills was found empty nearby. Lowry had been battling his addiction for years with little success and may have simply given up. But as his biographer Gordon Bowker suggests in Pursued by Furies: A Life of Malcolm Lowry, there is the possibility of foul play; it is possible that Lowry’s second wife, Majorie Bonner, with whom he had quarrelled ferociously on the night of his death, had given Lowry the sleeping pills while he was in a drunken stupor.22Another borderline case is the novelist Jack London. Associated with clean cut rugged boys’ adventure tales like The Call of the Wild and White Fang, London had a dark side, an obsession with pushing himself to the limits, a kind of ‘supersize’ philosophy of life. His capacity for food and drink was enormous and would in the end kill him, although it is possible that the overdose of morphine which capped off his hedonistic career was intentional. Although London could say that, “After having come through all of the game of life, and of youth, at my present mature age of thirty-nine years I am firmly and solemnly convinced that the game is worth the candle …”23 he would also keep a loaded revolver in his desk, ready to use against himself at any time.24

Addicted to morphine and opium, London was a phenomenal drinker and was one of the first major writers to publicly confess to his alcoholism; his “alcoholic memoir” John Barleycorn shocked the readers of his adventure tales and in puritanical America, turned many against him. In his passion for excess, it is easy to see a subliminal death-wish, a desire to pass beyond the limits of the self. London admitted to once almost drinking himself to death in a binge, and on another occasion, as he relates in John Barleycorn, he drunkenly stumbled into San Francisco Bay and “some maundering fancy of going out with the tide suddenly obsessed me.” London drifted for hours with the intention of letting himself drown, but sobered up in the end and was saved by fishermen. The hero of his semi-autobiographical novel Martin Eden kills himself, and in The Little Lady of the Big House the heroine, suffering from a mortal and inoperable gunshot wound, is helped by her doctor to end the pain by taking her own life.

London may have killed himself or he may have died from the uremia that was killing him anyway (his kidneys were failing and filling his system with the waste product urea). Other suggested causes are a heart attack, a stroke, or an accidental overdose of morphine. Whatever may have killed him, like Ross Lockridge Jr. (and a cadre of rock stars), success, which he had a great deal of, was no fun for London. “Success – I despised it,” he wrote, and one wonders if the collapse of ventures like the palatial Wolf House, his schooner the Snark, and his huge Beauty Ranch – all expensive enterprises that proved dismal failures – were brought about by an unconscious wish for annihilation. London’s childhood with a depressive, unhinged mother – who lived with an astrologer and spiritualist after London’s father deserted her – his early years working at a canning factory, and his frequent need to adapt to difficult environments made him in many ways a survivor. His own social views were very much in line with Social Darwinism. Yet, as one of his biographers suggests, they also came at a cost. “Jack never developed a robust sense of self, and he would enter adulthood with little self-esteem.”25 Although driven by an urge to better himself (he was a determined autodidact) and in every way a self-made man, London was plagued by what he called White Logic: “the messenger of truth beyond truth, the antithesis of life, cruel and bleak as interstellar space, pulseless and frozen as absolute zero, dazzling with the frost of irrefragable logic and unforgettable fact.” For all his worldly success – he was, at one point, the highest paid writer in America – London never really felt good about himself. Possessed of a Nietzschean belief in the superman, he was also prone to a cosmic pessimism, a fatalism that prevented him from adjusting his behaviour when faced with the results of his superhuman excess. When the tide of drugs, alcohol, and a failing body started carrying him out to the cosmic sea, he may in the end have just let himself go.

The Slow Suicide

London’s case raises the question of writers who may be seen as indulging in a slow drink or drug-filled suicide. That writers often have an unhealthy fondness for the bottle or drugs is well known. The Beat novelist Jack Kerouac is a case in point. After the initial success of books like On The Road and The Dharma Bums, Kerouac retreated into an increasingly esoteric prose style and an alcoholic solitude, effectively drinking himself to death while living with his mother; he died at forty-seven in 1969. Another is the decadent poet Ernst Dowson, a devotee of absinthe, opium, hashish, alcohol and other inebriants. Dowson, a friend of Arthur Symons, Yeats and others of the ‘Tragic Generation’, is described by one writer as “living almost hermit-like in a ramshackle house where he drank absinthe and took opiates in abundance.”26 He died at thirty-two of consumption, drink and overall self-abuse. Dowson’s poetry is filled with images and metaphors of ennui, world-weariness, decline and early death; perhaps his best known poem is “They Are Not Long,” with its cheery admonition that “They are not long/The days of wine and roses/ Out of a misty dream/Our path emerges for a while then closes/” In another poem, “A Last Word,” he wishes to go to “the Hollow Lands” where there is, “Freedom to all from love and fear and lust/Twine our torn hands/O pray the earth enfold/Our life-sick hearts and turn them into dust.” Dowson may not have had the strength to commit suicide, and his world-weariness may have been something of a pose, one adopted by many of his peers, but he did nothing to halt his sure drift into non-existence. Yet if we allowed his case and that of Kerouac’s (and sadly many others) to count as suicides, this book would grow unmanageable, and so I think we must leave them out.27Fake Suicides

Some writers have a kind of ‘double’ relationship to suicide. The Portuguese poet Fernando Pessoa didn’t commit suicide, but one of his ‘heteronyms’ did. Heteronym was the title Pessoa gave to the various literary alter-egos he created throughout his career; more than a pseudonym, Pessoa’s heteronyms – he had dozens – were actual complete other identities, with histories, psychologies, and literary styles all their own. One of these, the Baron of Teive, author of a work entitled The Education of A Stoic, is led to suicide through strictly logical reasoning. Believing in the “impossibility of producing superior art,” and deciding to kill himself after burning all of his works, the Baron works on one final piece of writing, a manuscript which will explain why it is impossible to capture in writing the literary works he imagines in his brain. As so often happens with Pessoa, this work, too, is only fragmentary, a literal testament to the impossibility of literature. The Baron has “reached the height of emptiness, the plenitude of nothing at all.” What leads him to suicide is “the same kind of urge that makes one go to bed early.”28 As Heinrich von Kleist had discovered (as we shall see), Teive sees that “the rational conduct of life is impossible. Intelligence provides no guiding rule,”29 and like Kleist, he concludes that there is only one option, suicide. “I feel I have attained the full use of my reason,” Teive writes, and so “that’s why I’m going to kill myself.”30 And after burning all of his previous fragments, he does.

Another of Pessoa’s heteronyms, Bernardo Soares, the author of the best known (in the English speaking world) of Pessoa’s works, The Book of Disquietude – although to call this enormous collection of fragments a ‘work’ is misleading – considers suicide as well. But, as is usual with Pessoa, his take on it is paradoxical. Pessoa/Soares writes: “The active life has always struck me as the least comfortable of suicides.”31 If that is the case, then Pessoa’s own life, which, aside from his considerable literary activity was far from active, may be seen as a long avoidance of this particular method of doing yourself in: he spent nearly all of his life in Lisbon, practically in the same neighbourhood, had few friends and probably died a virgin. Yet anyone who reads The Book of Disquietude can’t help but recognize its deep world rejection and unrelenting ennui, and, like myself, may feel that suicide was never far from Pessoa’s mind. It’s understandable then that he would find the idea of helping another poet fake his own suicide attractive. The poet in question, however, is more well known in his other guise as a magician, occultist and drug addict.

Pessoa came into contact with the notorious Aleister Crowley through their mutual interest in astrology, and on a visit to Lisbon, during which the Great Beast quarrelled with his current Scarlet Woman – his magical concubine – Crowley coaxed Pessoa into helping him with his prank.32 Leaving a forlorn lover’s note at a treacherous rock formation on the coast west of Lisbon, known as the Boca do Inferno – the Mouth of Hell – Crowley created the impression that he had ended it all by leaping into the sea. Pessoa explained to the Lisbon press the various occult symbols that accompanied the note and even offered the fact that he had seen Crowley’s ghost the day after his disappearance. In reality, Crowley had left Portugal via Spain, and he enjoyed reading the reports of his death in the newspapers; among his other addictions, getting his name in the press was high on the list. Eventually, though, he tired of the ruse and ‘miraculously’ appeared at an exhibition of his paintings in Berlin, once again getting his name in print.33 Pessoa, however, had a still more significant link to suicide. In 1916, his great friend and collaborator in Lisbon on the avant-garde magazine Orpheu, the writer Mário de Sá Carneiro, author of the novel Lucio’s Confession, committed suicide in Paris by swallowing five bottles of strychnine. He was only twenty-five, but like Dowson and others, was addicted to alcohol and opium.

Sá Carneiro’s case suggests another category, which unfortunately I do not have the space to explore here: cities of suicide. Although all big cities have their share of suicides, there is something about Paris that gives the idea a romantic, poetic attraction. Along with Paul Celan, de Nerval, Gilles Deleuze, Sadegh Hedayat and others, Sá Carneiro seems to have taken seriously Rilke’s remark about Paris, in The Notebooks of Malte Laurids Brigge: “So this is where people come to live; I would have thought it is a city to die in.”

Agents of Suicide

Another category of suicides are writers who, while not committing suicide themselves, led others to it. The case of Goethe and The Sorrows of Young Werther will be considered at length further on, and in any case, in that instance, it was Goethe’s work, not the man himself, who was responsible. Here I am talking about the writer himself. It may be stretching it to include Freud in this category, but it’s not unusual today for Freud to be seen as more of a literary than a scientific or even a medical figure; and the fact that he was, say, compared to Jung, an exceptionally eloquent writer, helps.

As books like Paul Roazen’s Freud and his Followers makes clear, the circle of Freud’s disciples was like a secret society; Freud even handed out rings to his elect, a sign of the follower’s acceptance into the esoteric clique. The flip side of this honour was Freud’s wrath toward apostates. At the start of the courtship, the dogmatic and dictatorial Freud would allow new members a certain freedom of thought; but this was only, as one writer put it, “so that the ultimate triumph of the psychoanalytic doctrine would be the more complete.” If it became clear to Freud that the newcomer had reservations, however slight and reasonable, about his theories – specifically the sexual basis of neuroses – then “there was a ritual of excommunication,” and the unbeliever was “solemnly anathematised and placed on a list of ‘prohibited persons’.”34 Jung himself, who Freud considered the heir to his doctrine, eventually broke with the master, and the experience was so devastating for Jung that it led to something like a psychotic episode. Jung survived and went on to start his own school of analysis; others were not so strong. One of these was Victor Tausk.

Tausk was a brilliant individual who basically accepted Freud’s vision; his problem was that he was too brilliant, and his independence of mind, even when still working within the Freudian framework, troubled Freud. Freud wanted followers, but he didn’t want ones capable of thinking for themselves. Freud’s ire turned toward Tausk when Tausk came to the defence of the Viennese satirist Karl Kraus, who, wary of Freud’s ideas, made the perceptive remark that, “Psychoanalysis is the disease for which it claims to be the cure.” Kraus also criticized Freud’s attempt to reduce the genius of men like Dostoyevsky and Leonardo to manifestations of penis envy. Eventually the true believers fought back, claiming that Kraus’ own attacks on the tabloid press of the time were an expression of his penis envy. Tausk would have none of it and simply remarked that the shallow Viennese press was worthy of Kraus’ attack. This was enough for Freud, and when Tausk, who was going through some difficult times, asked Freud for help – specifically to psychoanalyse him – he refused. Freud subjected Tausk to petty humiliations, suggesting that he submit to analysis with one of Freud’s students instead, and rebuffed any attempts to regain their former intimacy. Tausk plummeted. Soon after the rejection, he wrote a letter to Freud and one to his mistress, tied a curtain cord around his neck, and shot himself in the head, strangling himself as he fell back from the blast.

Another disciple to receive the Freud treatment was Herbert Silberer “the most potentially brilliant and original of Freud’s followers.”35 Silberer made important observations about the strange half-dream state called hypnagogia, and in his book Problems of Mysticism and Its Symbols (1917), he explored the relation between unconscious imagery and alchemy years before Jung did.36 Although Silberer held Freud in high esteem, he also found much of value in Jung’s work. Silberer politely questioned Freud’s belief that the sexual theory offered a complete interpretation of alchemical symbolism, and suggested that this could also be seen ‘anagogically’, as an expression of a religious or mystical impulse, as ‘instinctive’ as the sexual one. He believed that his basic admiration for Freud would compensate for any differences of opinion. Freud disagreed, and cast the heretic into the outer darkness. When Silberer, increasingly puzzled by Freud’s rejection, offered to call on him, Freud wrote back: “As the result of the observations and impressions of recent years I no longer desire personal contact with you.” Silberer was shattered. A few years later, unable to throw off a sense of worthlessness, he hung himself from the window bars in his home. There must have been a touch of the morbid in Silberer. When he hung himself, he arranged a light so that when his wife came home the first thing she saw would be him.

Another writer surrounded by suicides is the Russian decadent Valery Briusov, author of the remarkable occult novel The Fiery Angel, the basis of Prokofiev’s opera of the same name. Briusov was the magus of Russian Symbolism; as novelist, poet, editor and critic, in the early twentieth century, he was a supremely important figure in the literary cliques of St. Petersburg and Moscow. Like Paris and London, pre-revolutionary Russia was caught up in a obsession with the occult. Satanism and diabolism in particular fascinated the Russian avant-garde, and one expression of this were the several ‘suicide clubs’ that sprang up among the intelligentsia. Briusov dominated the scene and gathered a coterie of followers. Highly disciplined and cautious, Briusov was attracted to wilder, more ecstatic types, one of whom, the precocious poet Alexander Dobrolyubov, was thrown out of high school at seventeen for preaching suicide to young female students, apparently with some success.

Another character who attracted Briusov was the novelist Andrei Bely, author of the modernist occult novel Petersburg. Bely, a highly labile and poetic character, was an infant terrible of Russian Symbolism. At first attracted to each other, Briusov and Bely soon developed a feud. Bely believed Briusov was trying to hypnotize him, and an occult war sprang up between them. This became the basis of Briusov’s The Fiery Angel. At the centre of the novel was the erotic triangle between Briusov, Bely, and the poetess Nina Petrovskaya.37

Nina loved Bely, but he spurned her for the wife of the poet Aleksandr Blok. She turned to Briusov for help; Briusov had a reputation as a magician and she hoped he could cast a spell to win Bely’s affection. When this failed she became Briusov’s lover, plunging into a seven year long sadomasochistic relationship, involving drugs, madness and suicide pacts. But after using Nina as a model for his novel, Briusov lost interest in her and dropped her. Crushed, she left Moscow and later committed suicide in Paris, joining the ranks of Sá Carneiro, Paul Celan and others. Another poet Briusov got involved with after Nina also committed suicide was Nadechda Lvova. According to the poet V.F. Khodasevic, Briusov encouraged Nadechda’s suicidal feelings, and presented her with a pistol that Nina had once turned on Briusov himself. When Briusov ended their affair, she shot herself with it. Still another poet, the twenty-one year old Victor Gofman, was advised by Briusov to kill himself as well; he, too, apparently took the master up on this suggestion.

One last possible agent of suicide. At the time of writing, BBC 4 presented a remarkable documentary about the ‘anthropologist’ and drug-guru Carlos Castaneda. Much of it was familiar to me; having written about Castaneda in my Turn Off Your Mind: The Mystic Sixties and the Dark Side of the Age of Aquarius, I was aware that most likely Castaneda had pretty much invented the whole of his adventures with the Yaqui brujo Don Juan, depicted in a series of bestselling books. What I didn’t know was that in the last years of his life, Castaneda had gathered a group of female followers with whom he apparently shared an esoteric teaching concerning a kind of cosmic resurrection after death, something along the lines of the Heaven’s Gate cult.38 Castaneda himself died of liver cancer in 1998, a shock to many of his followers who had accepted his own teaching that he would not die, but ‘ascend’ to some higher sphere. His death was kept secret for some time and was, as they say, shrouded in mystery. His body was cremated, and, according to Amy Wallace, author of a memoir of her time as one of Castaneda’s disciples, lovers and wives (he had several simultaneously), burning was a means of releasing the spirit into a higher form.39 Shortly after Castaneda’s death, at least three of the women in his intimate group, known as ‘the Witches’, disappeared. Florinda Donner-Grau, author of bestselling books based on Castaneda’s work, Taisha Abelar, and Patricia Partin, seemed to have simply vanished, and were never heard from again. In 2003, the wreck of a car was found in Death Valley, California, and had evidently been involved in a fire. DNA testing on human remains found in the wreck showed them to be those of Patricia Partin. Partin had a particular relation to Castaneda, as she was both his adopted daughter and his lover. To date the other women have yet to surface, and the assumption among some is that they may have taken the teachings of Don Carlos to a perhaps fatal extreme.

Against Suicide?

These, then, are some of the many types of literary suicide that deserve mention, but that fall outside of the main categories with which the rest of this book will be concerned. Needless to say, however, not all writers and poets are attracted to suicide. As several of the selections in the Suicidal Miscellany show, there were those who argued against it, those who made light of it, and those who, at first finding it attractive, were later purged of the idea. There is the question too of how sincere were the many writers who, writing darkly of the desirability of ending one’s life, did not, in actual practice, end their own. In his novel Manalive, G.K. Chesterton, whose “Ballade of Suicide” starts off the Miscellany, offers a sure-fire (no pun intended) test to determine one’s seriousness about the value of life. The only way to prove if someone who claims life isn’t worth living is serious, Chesterton argues, is to point a loaded pistol at his head and propose to pull the trigger. If he remains unmoved, then his nihilism is sincere, and you would probably be doing him a favour if you carried on. If he flinches, then it’s just a pose. Although poseurs are not hard to come by – and most of us have been one in our time – most of this book is concerned with those for whom, more or less, the question of suicide was deadly serious.

To end this introduction, let me add a personal note. In writing about suicide, more often than not, most writers devote some time to their own attitude toward it and describe, if such is the case, their own encounters with it. Like many people – writers or not – I have passed through difficult times, patches and even long stretches of my life when I was subject to much hardship and psychological and emotional suffering. But I have never attempted suicide, nor did I ever seriously consider it as an option, although the idea of ceasing the harangue of thoughts and anxieties that accompanies bad times at a single blow can be tempting. Why this is so probably depends on several factors, not the least of which is a recognition that, however bad my situation was, killing myself was certainly a shabby way of dealing with it. A sense of fastidiousness then, an awareness of the mess and complications and difficulties I would leave behind, ruled suicide out. I was also too aware of that piercing yet sadly useless consciousness, shared by Anna Karenina, Emma Bovary and others, that killing themselves was, in the end, a really bad idea and that in the face of that finality, life, as difficult as it is, is infinitely preferable. In more recent years, which have not been without their troubles, the fact that I am a father and that two young boys would, I think its safe to say, be severely upset at my absence, make it a definite non-issue. To avoid a long, slow, painful death through an incurable illness, to say farewell when it is still possible, before old age incapacitates one’s lucidity and grasp on life: I can appreciate these circumstances and understand ending one’s life in these cases, although how I will feel and react if I find myself in these situations remains to be seen. Everything else, however, strikes me as selfish and, realizing fully that most people bent on suicide will not be stayed by this, irresponsible, even egotistical. It is, I think, in some ways a kind of supreme egotism: the notion that my death will matter to the universe.

I will add one more thing. Reading these accounts of tragic and lost lives, it strikes me that it is never the major philosophical or religious arguments that convince people not to kill themselves – although in some cases, metaphysics does seem to have succeeded in prompting the opposite. What changes people’s minds are the little things: Goethe’s Easter bells, Chesterton’s “little cloud all pink and grey,” the glass of wine that Hesse’s suicidal Steppenwolf drinks, avoiding the razor back at home. Like Graham Greene’s experience of Russian Roulette, these things somehow trigger a sense of life’s “infinite possibilities,” the awareness of which makes suicide seem an absurd blunder. Why these everyday items, which we normally take for granted, can at times release a mystical sense of the absolute value of life, remains a mystery. Perhaps when we solve it, most reasons for suicide may become a thing of the past.

Notes

1  Unfortunately, space does not allow me to discuss the tragic deaths of all of these individuals. For more on the life and work of the occult historian James Webb, see my article “The Damned” at www.forteantimes.com/articles/150_webb.shtml

2  Kay Redfield Jamison, Touched by Fire: Manic-Depressive Illness and the Artistic Temperament (Free Press Paperbacks: New York, 1993) p. 46.

3  Ibid. p. 5.

4  Robert Lowell, quoted by Robert Giroux, Ibid. p. 250.

5  Bernard Shaw John Bull’s Other Island in The Complete Plays of Bernard Shaw (Odhams Press Ltd: London, 1934) p. 441.

6  Quoted in Jacques Barzun A Stroll with William James (Harper&-Row: New York, 1983) p. 15.

7  A. Alvarez The Savage God (Bloomsbury: London, 2002) p. 34.

8  Ibid. p. 12.

9  Christopher Woodward In Ruins (Vintage: London, 2002) p. 152.

10  For more on Jan Potocki and Gérard de Nerval, see my Dedalus Book of the Occult: A Dark Muse (Dedalus: Sawtry, 2003).

11For more of Gustav Meyrink and Guy de Maupassant, see my Dedalus Book of the Occult: A Dark Muse.

12  O.V. de L. Milosz The Noble Traveller: The Life and Writings of O.V. de L. Milosz ed. Christopher Bamford (Lindisfarne: West Stockport, MA, 1985) p. 438. See also The Dedalus Book of the Occult: A Dark Muse.

13  Ibid. p. 439.

14  For more on Baudelaire see The Dedalus Book of the Occult: A Dark Muse.

15  Graham Greene The Lost Childhood and Other Essays (Penguin: Harmondsworth, 1962) p. 202.

16  Richard Holmes Coleridge: Early Visions (Penguin: London, 1989) pp. 49–52.

17  Graham Greene The Lost Childhood and Other Essays p. 204.

18  Kay Redfield Jamison Touched With Fire p. 43.

19  Graham Greene The Lost Childhood and Other Essays p. 205. Greene’s attempts to shock himself out of a spiritual lethargy are an example of “living dangerously,” an ideal which Colin Wilson associates with many of his Outsiders. Wilson argues that there is a kind of “indifference threshold” in human consciousness. “There is, “he writes, “a certain margin of boredom or indifference when the human mind ceases to be stimulated by pleasure, but can still be stimulated by pain or discomfort.” (Encyclopedia of Murder with Pat Pitman [Arthur Baker: London, 1961] p.22) Greene (and Coleridge), who could see but not feel beauty, had reached this threshold, and the prospect of blowing his brains out, and then discovering he hadn’t, for a brief time galvanised his consciousness. In her account of Greene’s experience, however, Kay Redfield Jamison fails to mention that his motive in playing Russian Roulette was to achieve a feeling of greater life, not to end his own.

      This is one of the problems with Jamison’s book, which, as a study of manic-depression among writers and artists, is excellent, as far as it goes. But being a clinical psychologist, Jamison tends to see everything in terms of either mania or depression. One example she gives of ‘manic’ behaviour is Poe’s short story “The Man of the Crowd.” She quotes Poe’s narrator remarking how, convalescing after months of illness, he finds himself in a London coffee house “in one of those happy moods which are so precisely the converse of ennui – moods of keenest appetency, when the film from the mental vision departs … and the intellect, electrified, surpasses … its everyday condition.” For Jamison this is an expression or confession of Poe’s manic states, but it is clear that Poe is simply speaking of the poetic condition itself, the kind of clarity and acute sensual and psychic appreciation which reveals to the poet the poetic object. Psychologically speaking, Poe’s narrator is having what the psychologist Abraham Maslow called a ‘peak experience’. This isn’t ‘manic’ at all, and is something, Maslow argued, experienced by most healthy people. This kind of ‘peak’ is shared by many of the depressives Jamison writes about, people like Coleridge, William James and others. But she fails to recognize it as such, and erroneously speaks of it as an indication of a pathology.

20  Charles Nicholl “The Wind Comes Up Out of Nowhere,” London Review of Booksvol. 28 no. 59 March 2006.

21  Andrew Hussey The Game of War: The Life and Death of Guy Debord (Pimlico: London, 2002) p. 2.

22  Again, for more on Lowry, see The Dedalus Book of the Occult: A Dark Muse.

23  Quoted in Alex Kershaw Jack London: A Life (Flamingo: London, 1997) pp. 5–6.

24  Ibid. p. 153.

25  Ibid. p. 25.

26  Martin Booth Cannabis (Bantam Books: London, 2004) p. 155.

27  Another possible category is the strictly literary suicide. One candidate for this is the horror fiction writer H.P. Lovecraft, who two years before his death by cancer, had effectively given up writing. It is possible that Lovecraft’s reluctance to ‘sell’ himself – he would rarely submit his work to another editor once it had been rejected – and general passivity to life, created the psychological conditions for his illness to establish itself.

28  Fernando Pessoa The Selected Prose of Fernando Pessoa ed. Richard Zenith (Grove Press: New York, 2001) p. 301.

29  Ibid. p. 304.

30  Ibid. p. 310.

31  Ibid. p. 287.

32  For more on Aleister Crowley, see The Dedalus Book of the Occult: A Dark Muse.

33  For more on Pessoa see The Dedalus Book of the Occult: A Dark Muse.

34  Colin Wilson The Quest for Wilhelm Reich (Doubleday: New York, 1981) p. 65

35  Ibid. p. 72.

36For more on Silberer and hypnagogia, see my article “Waking Sleep” www.forteantimes.com/articles/163_hypnagogia.shtml

37  For more on Briusov and Bely and the Russian occult revival, see The Dedalus Book of the Occult: A Dark Muse and also my afterword, “Valery Briusov: Paradoxical Decadent,” in The Fiery Angel (Dedalus: Sawtry, 2005).

38  In spring 1997 the comet Hale-Bopp became visible in our sky. Convinced a UFO accompanying the comet had come to take them away, thirty-nine members of the Heaven’s Gate cult in Oregon committed suicide. In 1994, after their leader murdered a couple and their three-month-old baby (whom he believed to be the Antichrist), fifty-three members of the Order of the Solar Temple incinerated themselves in Quebec and Switzerland. And of course the Jonestown massacre in Guyana, 1978, in which almost 1000 people drank cyanide at the command of their leader Jim Jones remains one of the most gruesome group suicides on record.

39  Amy Wallace The Sorcerer’s Apprentice: My Life with Carlos Castaneda (North Atlantic Books: 2004)

Gary Lachman 

The Dedalus Book of Literary Suicide