To be is to be contingent: nothing of which it can be said that "it is" can be alone and independent. But being is a member of paticca-samuppada as arising which contains ignorance. Being is only invertible by ignorance.

Destruction of ignorance destroys the illusion of being. When ignorance is no more, than consciousness no longer can attribute being (pahoti) at all. But that is not all for when consciousness is predicated of one who has no ignorance than it is no more indicatable (as it was indicated in M Sutta 22)

Nanamoli Thera
Showing posts with label Gober. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gober. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 9, 2026

Dark Metaphysical Forces


If Young’s framework is even directionally accurate, and if even a fraction of the perspectives shared in this book are true, they are hard to rationalize as mere incompetence. In other words, it’s hard to conceive that our drift into false paradigms is purely the result of innocent mistakes.

Perhaps false paradigms are being propagated intentionally. Not many people would be needed to enact such an agenda if they can use blackmail, bribery, threats, and mind control to manipulate key individuals in society.

But why would such social engineering be important? What would entice people to brainwash the public? And how could such an agenda remain over long periods of time if people have relatively short lifespans?

The answers might lie in the domain of consciousness—realms that transcend purely physical considerations. Perhaps there are nonphysical, spiritual forces that have much longer time horizons than humans do, and they work through humans in order to enact their goals. Why they might want to do so is open for speculation, but a common theory is that dark forces literally feed off of human energy—in particular, human suffering.

Within a consciousness-centric metaphysical framework, the existence of such forces is plausible. For instance, the famed computer scientist Alan Turing stated in 1950 that the statistical evidence for telepathy is “overwhelming,” which led him to then state: “It does not seem a very big step to believe in ghosts and bogies.”13 Put another way, once we accept that consciousness is not localized to, or dependent on, a brain, then it’s possible for forms of consciousness to exist that don’t have physical bodies. Broadly speaking, they’re often referred to as spirits. Maybe they even have an ability to take on different forms (known as shapeshifting).14

Along these lines, Helané Wabheh’s book The Science of Channeling (2021) compiles scientific evidence for the ability of humans to “tune in to” some of these nonphysical intelligences.15 Sometimes this can occur through voluntary invocations, but it also seems possible to tune in without being aware of it. If our brain has an antenna-like quality, then this is possible. After all, we don’t really know where our thoughts originate. It might be the case that an individual’s consciousness is constantly being influenced without the person’s explicit knowledge. Therefore, the ability to manage emotions and beliefs seems critical.

In my book An End to Upside Down Contact (2022), I document a wide variety of encounters with nonphysical forces, some seemingly benevolent and others not. The focus of the forthcoming discussion is on the darker forces. This focus is necessary because of the unquestionably deceptive nature of our reality. However, it’s important to acknowledge that benevolent forces seem to be real too. Practically speaking, if everything in the world were purely evil, it’s implausible that we’d even have the freedom to question  paradigms. Additionally, our world is filled with loving acts, which is suggestive of a benevolent spiritual force. Likewise, there are many otherworldly experiences, reported historically and in modern times, in which people have direct mystical encounters with seemingly benevolent beings—often reporting indescribable states of “unconditional love” and even being miraculously healed. Preston Dennett gives many examples in his 2019 book, The Healing Power of UFOs: 300 True Accounts of People Healed by Extraterrestrials.16Or consider Anita Moorjani’s case. She was healed after having a transformative near-death experience in 2006. She was in a coma during a bout with terminal cancer and has since tried to put into words the shift that her consciousness underwent: “What I can only describe as superb and glorious unconditional love surrounded me, wrapping me tight as I continued to let go. It didn’t feel as though I had physically gone somewhere else—it was more as though I’d awakened, perhaps finally being roused from a bad dream. My soul was finally realizing its true magnificence. And in doing so, it was expanding beyond my body and this physical world.”17 Her doctors were stunned when her tumors disappeared following the resuscitation.

Regarding darker forces, consider the work of Richard Gallagher, MD. He is a Princeton and Yale graduate and a professor of clinical psychiatry at New York Medical College who has personal experience with patients suffering from “demonic possession.” He details such accounts in his book, Demonic Foes: My Twenty-Five Years as a Psychiatrist Investigating Possessions, Diabolic Attacks, and the Paranormal (2020). He states his conclusion: “A segment of [the] invisible world seems to be mysteriously but remarkably hostile to human beings and seeks their physical and spiritual destruction. On rare occasions, like some kind of cosmic terrorist, that segment shows its true colors.”18 [emphasis added]

In fact, there are some instances in which individuals intentionally summon such dark forces. Earlier this was alluded to in the discussion of the “sex magick” ritual engaged by Jack Parsons (one of the early influences at NASA), with assistance from

 L. Ron Hubbard (the founder of the Church of Scientology). One has to wonder if this sort of ritual was just the tip of the iceberg. The Telegraph summarized the situation well in its 2017 article titled “Sex, rocket science, and Satanism: Meet Nasa’s real hidden figures.”19

There is, in fact, a long history of secretive, heinous, and sophisticated rituals that date back to biblical times. They have also been described in different forms by the Aztecs and Egyptians, among others. The intent of many such rituals is to call in dark spirits, likely for the purpose of obtaining power.20The rituals give vital insights into the psychology of evil and might help us understand the drive behind deception in our world. Only minor snippets will be covered here because the details are so unpleasant.

Although many instances of ritualistic abuse are hidden, some cases have been uncovered over time. In fact, they are discussed explicitly in state laws in Idaho and Illinois, and there are clear patterns to the activities. What follows is an excerpt from a law in Idaho (1990), and the law in Illinois is similar:

18-1506A. RITUALIZED ABUSE OF A CHILD — EXCLUSIONS —PENALTIES — DEFINITION.

(1) A person is guilty of a felony when he commits any of the following acts with, upon, or in the presence of a child as part of a ceremony, rite or any similar observance:

(a) Actually or in simulation, tortures, mutilates or sacrifices any warm-blooded animal or human being;

(b) Forces ingestion, injection or other application of any narcotic, drug, hallucinogen or anaesthetic for the purpose of dulling sensitivity, cognition, recollection of, or resistance to any criminal activity;

(c) Forces ingestion, or external application, of human or animal urine, feces, flesh, blood, bones, body secretions, nonprescribed drugs or chemical compounds;

( d) Involves the child in a mock, unauthorized or unlawful marriage ceremony with another person or representation of any force or deity, followed by sexual contact with the child;

(e) Places a living child into a coffin or open grave containing a human corpse or remains;

(f ) Threatens death or serious harm to a child, his parents, family, pets or friends which instills a well-founded fear in the child that the threat will be carried out; or

(g) Unlawfully dissects, mutilates, or incinerates a human corpse.21

Along these lines, Anne Johnson Davis’s autobiographical book Hell Minus One: My Story of Deliverance from Satanic Ritual Abuse and My Journey to Freedom (2008) describes her experiences as a victim as a young girl. The foreword of the book was written by a Utah detective from the state attorney general’s office who investigated that case. He confirmed that the perpetrators wrote confession letters detailing their crimes and added, “They confessed to us—in person. The allegations were confirmed.”22

This is significant because such allegations are often dismissed as products of “false memories.” Yet this is a validated case. In other instances, it’s indeed difficult to know what is real, particularly because the rituals often involve drugging and forms of torture designed to suppress memories. But in Davis’s case, her memories came flooding back later in life (which isn’t uncommon), and through unique circumstances, she was able to confront the perpetrators who decided to confess. Often the abused individual might just be considered crazy, with no way to validate the memories.

The bigger point here is this: If even some cases are real, then we can gain insights into the broader spiritual war that we all might be involved in (whether we know it or not).

In Davis’s case, she recalls seeing dark spirits entering into the ritual.23 Jay Parker endured similar abuse as a child, including incest, and he experienced dark energies directly. When interviewed by  filmmaker Sean Stone, he recalled that a dark intelligence seemed to possess his parents while they were engaging in nefarious acts. Parker says, “My father’s eyes would flash black, solid black,” as would his mother’s.24 [emphasis added]

Along similar lines, a 60 Minutes Australia episode that aired in 1989 featured a young British girl who was subjected to ritual abuse after being brought into the circle by her own grandmother. A psychiatrist validated her experiences as real and not the product of a psychotic or imaginative mind. Clearly traumatized (almost despondent and emotionless), she spoke about being brought to a place in the English countryside that looked like a “castle.” She said the route to get there was intentionally hidden from the victims. She also noted that the people there were “very rich” and had an ability to destroy evidence of murders with chemicals. They also referred to “Lucifer,” as she recalled. She detailed the horrors to which she was subjected, including being raped, being forced to have an abortion, and then being forced to eat the fetus.25Survivors of such abuse often describe links to powerful people—even governments. Anneke Lucas, for instance, was sold by her mother into a murderous pedophile ring in Belgium with “VIPs” and people “on the world stage.” Ritual abuse was involved as well.26 She documents her accounts in her 2022 book Quest for Love: Memoir of a Child Sex Slave. Another example is Serena Faith Masterson, author of I Am Serena (2020), who was born into a satanic cult and sold into the US government’s mind-control program. As a result of this torture, she developed dissociative identity disorder, including over 300 unique personalities. Only through a rare and miraculous series of events was she able to heal and tell her story. Her message is ultimately uplifting: she feels strongly that her soul grew from the experience and that she is able to contribute to the healing of others as a result. She seems to imply that suffering, while horrific in many ways, can paradoxically lead to healing and growth.

There are many cases that show a link between dark metaphysical forces and power structures in our world. Sean Stone’s documentary Best Kept Secret (2021), and John DeCamp’s book The  Franklin Cover-Up: Child Abuse, Satanism, and Murder in Nebraska (1992) provide additional insights, including links with child-sex trafficking and child pornography. Another important resource that validates the reality of ritual abuse is a more than 500-page compendium featuring essays from more than twenty-five contributors, titled Ritual Abuse in the Twenty-First Century: Psychological, Forensic, Social, and Political Considerations (2008).

The point of acknowledging this dark underbelly of our world is not to dwell on evil but rather to acknowledge reality. When we ask, Why is there so much deception in our world? What is driving this?, we’re forced to consider these deeper energies that might be behind it.

Parker sums it up by saying that “the suffering and dissatisfaction of the human soul is what feeds the [dark] spirits….It’s all an energy game….We are cattle for them, and we feed them.” Yet, in spite of the unspeakable abuse he endured, he still feels that the benevolent force is greater: “Divine love is much more powerful than anything else.”27 [emphasis added]

13As cited in Radin, Entangled Minds, 73.

14See Gober, An End to Upside Down Contact, 134–37.

15Wahbeh, The Science of Channeling. For a further discussion of Wahbeh’s work, see Gober, An End to Upside Down Contact.

16See Gober, An End to Upside Down Contact. Also see Dennett, The Healing Power of UFOs.

17Anita Moorjani, “The Day My Life Changed: February 2, 2006,” https://www.anitamoorjani.com/my-nde.

18Gallagher, Demonic Foes, 11.

19Vincent, “Sex, rocket science, and Satanism: Meet Nasa’s real hidden figures,” https://www.telegraph.co.uk/films/2017/02/17/sex-rocket-science-scientology-meet-hidden-figures-behind-nasas/.

20See, Gober, An End to Upside Down Contact, 57–66.

21Illinois Statutes Chapter 720. Criminal Offenses §-33. Ritualized abuse of a child, https://codes.findlaw.com/il/chapter-720-criminal-offenses/il-stsect-720-5-12-33.html; Idaho Statutes, https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title18/T18CH15/SECT18-1506A/.

22Davis, Hell Minus One, 85–93 (Kindle).

23Ibid., 1858–1863 (Kindle).

24“RAW: Sean Stone with Jay Parker,” https://robertdavidsteele.com/sean-stone-with-jay-parker/.

25SATAN’S CHILDREN – SATANIC RITUAL ABUSE (60 MINUTES AUSTRALIA), https://www.bitchute.com/video/I1bHD2JyfmEg/.

26REALWOMEN/REALSTORIES, (UNCUT) Anneke Lucas: Sold by my mother into a pedophile network at six years of age, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RTxD6VUcxZ0. Also see 58 Tsakiris, Anneke Lucas, Recovering From Unimaginable Evil |441|, https://skeptiko.com/anneke-lucas-recovering-from-unimaginable-evil-441/.

27“RAW: Sean Stone with Jay Parker,” https://robertdavidsteele.com/sean-stone-wit

h-jay-parker/.


An End to theUpside Dow Cosmos

Rethinking the BigBang, Heliocentrism, the Lights in the Sky and Where We Live

Mark Gober

Tuesday, April 7, 2026

Seeing too far...

 The second line of evidence that Garcia references in the court case involves people seeing too far. In other words, they see things that should be blocked by Earth’s curve. For a believer in the Globe, one would think it would be straightforward to find something in the distance that should not be visible because it is below Earth’s curve. This simply requires having the appropriate camera or telescope. The physical curvature should block the object. Shouldn’t there be a great abundance of these cases, well documented and replicated, to put the Flat Earth debate to an end?

But the reverse seems to happen repeatedly, which is perhaps one of the reasons why more and more people are expressing skepticism of the Globe. People buy high-resolution cameras, telescopes, or binoculars and see distant objects that should be physically blocked by the curve. The counterargument from Globe  believers is that those things are only visible because the light refracts and creates a “mirage.” Or they claim that the curvature math was incorrect or that the viewer’s height was unclear (which would affect the viewable angle).

“Seeing too far” would inherently refute the radius value of Earth and thus debunk the Globe as it is currently conceived. But technically it would not totally debunk the concept of a spherical shape; it would simply debunk the idea that Earth is a sphere with a specific radius value. The shape could still be a sphere—just a sphere that has a much, much greater radius value than what the Globe model currently asserts. That would still reflect a radical departure from modern cosmological thinking because of the ripple effects on all other Globe assumptions discussed earlier.

Sometimes, however, no special equipment is needed, and people can still see too far (according to the Globe’s assumed radius value). Garcia references cases in which people can see New York’s Statue of Liberty on a clear day from up to sixty miles away, while it should be well below the curve. Similarly, he cites residents of Oahu, Hawaii, who can regularly see the island of Kauai from more than ninety miles away.

He also mentions one of the most famous cases that was picked up by South Bend, Indiana’s ABC57 local news in 2015. The article, titled “Mirage of Chicago skyline seen from Michigan shoreline,” reports: “A picture of the Chicago skyline taken almost 60 miles away, is actually a mirage. [Photographer] Joshua Nowicki snapped the pic Tuesday night from Grand Mere State Park in Stevensville. Under normal conditions, even when extremely clear, this should not be visible, due to the curvature of the earth. The Chicago skyline is physically below the horizon from that vantage point, but the image of the skyline can be seen above it.”15

Garcia remarks in the court document:

[The news report] was proven false, by two of my colleagues, Rob Skiba and Rick Hummer. These gentlemen went to Chicago and made a video documentary, confirming that one can…see the picturesque Chicago  cityscape from the side of lake Michigan where Joshua took his picture. They then rode across Lake Michigan in a boat, while filming the entire duration, the city growing in scope and size as one came nearer to it. This documentary affirmed without a doubt that one could, in fact, see the Chicago skyline from such distance and that it was not as the [news’] weatherman claimed a mirage.

He also interviewed several natives from that area, who all shared conclusively that seeing the Chicago skyline from such distance was a normal and daily possibility and that the only things which could skew in some slight manner such viewing, would be inclement weather, but that more or less it was…possible to see the entire cityscape even when in windy conditions and choppy waves from the opposite shores of Lake Michigan.16

Additional Instances of “Seeing Too Far”

Separate from Zen Garcia’s court victory, many other examples have been observed and cited.17 For instance, Austin Whitsitt has more recently referenced some striking examples in a 2024 presentation.

Before discussing the examples, however, it’s first important to understand the notion of “the horizon.” In the Globe worldview, the horizon is a physical location; it’s where Earth curves down and away from the viewer and literally blocks the viewer’s vision. What’s blocked from view can change with altitude, but that doesn’t change the fact that the Globe implies a physical horizon created by the curve. Since the Globe model assumes we’re on a spherical object, we are always perceiving ourselves to be at the “top” of the sphere from our perspective, meaning that the sphere is always moving down and away relative to us.

On a Flat Earth, the horizon is only apparent based on a vanishing point with respect to one’s visual “perspective” (as discussed in the previous chapter). The Flat Earth horizon actually moves around based on factors such as atmospheric conditions and  perspective. This can be seen in time-lapse videos of the horizon itself; it moves up and down.18

In his presentation, Whitsitt provides a video example in which the horizon is observed to be much farther than it should be based on the Globe’s assumed radius value. The video zooms in on oil rigs at sea, from the beach, and taken at a height of about a foot and a half off the ground. Whitsitt notes that the physical horizon should be under two miles from the camera at its height, based on the Globe’s assumptions. The farthest oil rig is about ten miles away…and the horizon can be seen clearly behind it. The horizon “should be” about two miles away, but it’s not. It is clearly behind something that’s roughly ten miles away. This means that the horizon is much, much more distant than it should be based on the Globe model’s math. And since the horizon is a physical location in the Globe model, this should not be possible—unless the Globe model’s radius value is simply incorrect. As Whitsitt says, “People will make all kinds of excuses, but it doesn’t matter. It’s basic geometry. The horizon [in the Globe model] has to be in front of the oil rigs. [There’s] no magical invocation of refraction [that Globe-Earth believers can point to]. This right here refutes the Globe….This is why Flat-Earthers exist: they went and looked at the Earth.”19 [emphasis added]

Whitsitt gives additional examples that he feels challenge the Globe’s radius value. The examples, and Whitsitt’s case as to why they’re important, are as follows:

❍Mountains 255 miles away from an observer at a height of 9,824 feet are seen, even though there should be 12,800 feet (more than two miles) of curvature blocking the view of the mountains. In other words, they should be far below the curve, and yet they are visible. The image is taken using infrared, which is significant because infrared mitigates the effect of refraction of light. Refraction is the standard Globe-based rebuttal. In other words, this observation is seemingly impossible on the Globe.20

 ❍The longest line of sight observation in the Guinness Book of World Records is 275 miles away (taken in 2019 by Gaspard Picard in Mallemort, France). “Line of sight” refers to observations that are directly from the observer’s eyes to the object that’s viewed without any obstructions. In this example, the observer views mountains from an altitude of 9,251 feet (roughly 1.75 miles). The mountains should be more than three miles below Earth’s curve, but they are visible.21

❍The Canigou mountain in the South of France is observed, two days every year, with the sunset behind the mountain. In the video that Whitsitt shows, the mountain is not visible until the Sun sets behind it, effectively backlighting it so the mountain is clearly visible from long distances. The mountain should be far below Earth’s curvature, according to the official Earth curve online calculator that Whitsitt used. The Globe advocate’s standard rebuttal is that refraction makes the mountain visible. However, because the Sun is behind the mountain, what is seen is a silhouette. Whitsitt alleges that this effective “shadow” is the absence of light, and since refraction is the bending of light, refraction should not explain this observation. Certainly refraction is a continued point of contention, but the observation of the mountain alone is noteworthy. Whitsitt remarks that Globe advocates claim this is just an “illusion,” and the mountain is not actually there. He calls this example “a direct falsification of the Globe.”22❍“Mirror flashes” have been done over twenty or twenty-five miles. This involves placing a mirror on, say, a beach, and the mirror reflects light. Then the observer moves far away from the beach where there is a direct line of sight. The mirror, and the light it reflects, should be under a substantial amount of curvature at far distances. But that’s not what is observed. The mirror flashes reach the observer at great distances. Whitsitt notes that the  military has used this method because it’s a silent form of communication.23

❍In a separate presentation, Whitsitt references long-distance laser tests of more than thirty miles, over a large body of water. The laser is also viewed from the side that shows it’s completely horizontal and parallel to the water—that is, the laser isn’t refracting and coincidentally “curving over the Globe.”24The beauty of examples like these is that anyone can try to replicate them, and that goes for government agencies as well. Hopefully, over time, more clarity will develop as additional trials are conducted and replicated with ample documentation.

Comedian Owen Benjamin brings some levity to the situation with his cartoon skit called “Globe Earth Sniper.” The sniper is hiding in the bushes, trying to shoot an enemy that he sees far away in the distance, but he constantly asks his compatriot in battle about adjusting for the Coriolis Effect (that is, Earth’s rotation on the Globe). He thinks that the enemy he sees far away is just a mirage because he should be below Earth’s curve.

His fellow sniper says: “We only have one shot at this guy [the enemy]. [Aim] a little left.”

Globe Earth Sniper replies: “Okay, now factor in the spin [of Earth]….What direction are we? East, west, north, south, northeast? Factor in everything! We need to know exactly the direction, the spin of the Earth and how to combat it or else….”

His colleague urges him to just take the shot, to which Globe Earth Sniper responds: “But that would mean Neil deGrasse Tyson is wrong.” His colleague urges him to shoot accurately because a miss would blow their cover on their covert location.

Globe Earth Sniper insists: “Tell me the spin of the Earth!” He then shoots and misses and says, “I guess [Earth] was spinning a little faster than I thought!”

 He then says: “I can see the mirage,” to which his colleague responds with urgency, “No, no, that’s the target [the enemy you’re supposed to shoot at]!”

Globe Earth Sniper insists: “It must be a mirage. I’ve done the calculation [of Earth’s curvature]; I wouldn’t be able to see him. It’s a mirage. I’m not taking the shot.” His colleague says: “It’s him!” and urges him to just shoot.25

The skit continues, but the point is well made that when thinking practically about some of the Globe advocates’ counterarguments, they seem like silly post hoc rationalizations. We experience the world one way and are told that it functions in another way.

Ships Disappearing “over the Horizon” but Brought Back into Sight with Cameras

One of Aristotle’s famous “proofs” of a Globe, which is still used often today, was that when looking out at a large body of water, ships would disappear, hull before masts.26Visual perspective can explain this without invoking the Globe model. Simply put, there is a vanishing point in our vision. But explaining why the hull (bottom) drops before masts (the tall part) requires a more technical analysis. The answer has to do with “angular resolution.” The angle of vision determines what “disappears”—and lower objects will disappear first due to the viewing angle. The viewing angle thus creates the obstruction. Using more technical terminology from the field of optics, at a certain distance, an object reaches the “Rayleigh criterion” (that is, the diffraction limit). This hinders the ability to resolve details, and it’s most apparent at low viewing angles. Thus, objects disappear “bottom up.”27

However, Aristotle didn’t have cameras like the Nikon 900, as we do today. So, many Globe Skeptics use these high-resolution cameras to zoom in when a boat “disappears” over the horizon. Thus, the camera alters the angular resolution, and the boat comes back into view. This implies that the boat is still on a level surface;  it’s simply beyond view from the naked eye. This is said to occur repeatedly, even when the distant object should be “beneath the curve.” Many such videos are available online. They show that the ship goes in and out of view with high-resolution cameras (see David Weiss’s Flat Earth Sun, Moon & Zodiac Clock app, under the Frequently Asked Questions “Ships over the Horizon” playlist).

This phenomenon is another one that could use rigorous documentation and replication. But even if cases were published, one might wonder if any scientific journals would be willing to publish such heresy in a Globe-dominated world. As noted by geocentric physicist Robert Bennett, PhD: “Peer review is now peer censorship.”28The Horizon Rises to Eye Level

The Globe model would predict that as a person rises in altitude, the curve of the physical horizon should be more and more visible. So Earth would appear to be bending down and away, in all directions, and more so with increased elevation. This is simply a matter of geometry; the curvature of Earth determines all of this since the horizon is a physical location within the Globe model. However, that’s not what happens. The horizon remains at eye level as one rises in altitude. Anyone can experience this when ascending on an airplane, for example.

This phenomenon is supportive of the Globe Skeptics’ view, which suggests that the horizon isn’t a physical location but instead reflects the vanishing point based on perspective. In fact, a seminal book for artists published in 1939, titled Perspective Made Easy by Ernest Norling, gives the following instruction for artists: “If we ascend in an airplane we shall find that the distant horizon rises with our height. It appears to remain at eye-level. This accounts for the peculiar basin-like appearance of the earth when viewed from a great height.”29Norling calls this “peculiar” because he assumes the Globe model is correct. But if that model is false, then the observations make sense.

 Steven A. Young, PhD, summarizes the situation well:

All that would be needed to prove the globe would be to film the horizon while going straight up in a balloon; it would start flat at eye level, then as you ascended, it would bend at the sides and curve down and away as you got higher up. But nobody has been able to reproduce this; even SpaceX, with all the dozens of rocket launches they claim to do, never produced this simple footage of the flat horizon continuously bending into a sphere; their cameras always point down at the rocket. We learn nothing about the cosmos from these experiments….There are several amateur high-altitude rockets that have shown [that] the horizon remains totally flat at eye level, and even one that appeared to get stuck in the firmament. Globe sticklers will claim that continuous raw amateur footage is fake, while holding strong that NASA’s piece-wise TV footage is all legit.30 [emphasis added]

It’s also worth mentioning two pre-NASA anecdotes. In 1931, scientist Auguste Piccard ascended to an altitude of 51,775 feet (almost ten miles) in a hydrogen balloon. He and his assistant, who traveled with him, reached the highest point recorded at that time. Popular Science magazine reported: “In the first half hour, the balloon shot upward nine miles. Through portholes, the observers saw the earth through copper-colored, then bluish, haze. It seemed a flat disk with an upturned edge.”31 In other words, he didn’t report a “down and away” curve but rather the reverse. [emphasis added]

In 1933, the USSR broke Piccard’s record by launching a balloon to an altitude of 60,095 feet. Popular Science magazine wrote about this one too: “Soaring in their airtight balloon gondola to a record-breaking height of 11.8 miles above the earth, the other day, three Russian aeronauts brought back the first scientific observations ever made at so great an altitude. Above their heads, the sky provided a striking spectacle; its color had turned a soft, deep violet, and almost devoid of the light-reflecting haze found  at lower levels. Looking down, they tried in vain to detect any curvature of the earth’s horizon.”32 [emphasis added]

15Coomes, “Mirage of Chicago skyline seen from Michigan shoreline,” https://www.abc57.com/news/mirage-of-chicago-skyline-seen-from-michigan-shoreline.

16As quoted in a legal document for Zen Garcia’s case (“Case No.: 2019 MV-1104”), available at the following link: https://rodscontracts.com/docs/legal/ThompsonVersusGarcia.pdf. For more information on this case study, see Rob Skiba, “The Chicago Skyline Expanded Edition–Part 1: Refraction, Magnification or Curvature?” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I-Q-FuXJSTQ&t=1s.

17For instance, see Hamer, The Falsification of Science, 198-204; and Hendrie, The Greatest Lie on Earth, 25–50.

18Whitsitt X account, June 4, 2024, https://x.com/Witsitgetsit/status/1798165881429668322?s=46&t=ijTvU_628uOjAUiS9U8Hxw,2:51:00. Also partially available at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ssCZXJrDxiQ (so the time stamps do not perfectly match).

19Ibid., 2:52:00.

20Ibid., 2:57:00–2:53:00.

21Ibid., 2:54:00.

22Ibid., 2:57:00–2:58:00.

23Ibid., 2:57:00–2:59:00.

24Anti-Disinfo Leauge [sic], “True Earth 101: Curvature,” https://www.bitchute.com/video/6nbYsiGpwAH9/, 5:00-6:00.

25RobinsHoodlum, “Globe Earth SNIPER ~ from Mountainbear,” https://rumble.com/v1hlc50-globe-earth-sniper-from-mountainbear.html.

26Garwood, Flat Earth, 20.

27Mitchell fromAustralia, “Flat Earth School – Why Objects Disappear Bottom Up,” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aVVbsekJ9Sg. Also see Witsit Gets It, “Schooling Globers – Episode 26,” https://www.youtube.com/live/FBKrYJ0YvUY, 1:59:00-2:00:00.

28Witsit Gets It, “In The Field – Robert Bennett Ph.D. – Part 1,” https://www.youtube.com/live/5j0wCrkzfwk, 2:11:00-2:12:00.

29Norling, Perspective Made Easy, 9.

30Young, A Fool’s Wisdom, 79–80.

31Odle, Like Clay Under the Seal, 100. Odle includes the image from the magazine itself that includes the text. It’s worth noting that Sungenis cites an alternative view in his book Flat Earth/Flat Wrong, p. 12. He cites a 2008 article in Applied Optics in which the author, David K. Lynch, writes: “The first direct visual detection of the curvature of the horizon has been widely attributed to Auguste Piccard and Paul Kipfer on 27 May 1931.” Sungenis cites this as if it’s contradictory evidence to the Popular Science quote about Piccard. Piccard saw “upturn” edges, not the downturn edges that would be expected on a Globe. So perhaps that is what Lynch was referring to. Otherwise, Lynch does not cite a primary source suggesting that Piccard saw downward curvature, beyond noting the following: “Piccard is widely believed to be the first. There are many references to his achievement on the Internet, most of them certainly derivative. I contacted the Piccard family and they were aware of the claim but had no hard evidence or literature citation backing it up.” Thus, the claim that Piccard actually saw downward curvature suggestive of a Globe seems unsubstantiated.

32Odle, Like Clay Under the Seal, 102. Odle includes an image from the primary source, as well.

An End to the Upside Down Cosmos

Rethinking the BigBang, Heliocentrism, the Lights in the Sky…and Where We Live

Mark Gober

Monday, April 6, 2026

International Space Station (ISS) Video Anomalies

 

A final question about “space” that needs to be addressed is the ISS. For context, the ISS has been around since 1998 and is said to be roughly 260 miles above Earth. This places the ISS within the thermosphere but below the Van Allen Radiation Belts. Claims that still images or footage from the ISS prove that Earth is a sphere would need to be evaluated for the same reasons discussed earlier. Is photoshopping being used? What kind of lens are they using? Is the “curve” that they show consistent with the specific amount—and type—of spherical curvature that should be there, based on the Globe’s radius value, at the ISS’s altitude? Does imagery or continuous footage of the entire Earth exist, or are we continually shown snippets of little parts of Earth?

But even beyond all that, careful investigation of the ISS’s footage reveals repeated anomalies, according to NASA skeptics. For instance, in April 2023, activist and public speaker Justin Harvey brought forth evidence of what he calls “potential fraud of an enormous scale” to a Brevard County, Florida County Commission Board meeting. He urged the panel to investigate this, since NASA has a significant presence in that county. His recorded public comments went viral because he concisely synthesized the anomalies that are causing a growing number of people to question whether the official story about the ISS is truthful.98 (Note: Harvey’s comments also went viral in May of 2024 after he presented anomalies to the Brevard County commission related to the Challenger explosion in 1986.99)

With modern technology, it’s always difficult to know whether background scenery in a video is legitimate or if it’s computer generated. Even on simple Zoom (video) conference calls, this technology is employed, whereby people can look as if they’re in a totally foreign setting. One can only wonder what kind of sophisticated technologies government agencies have. In fact, the CBS sitcom The Big Bang Theory included a 2012 episode with a fake ISS scene, in which the actor is floating around in a realistic  ISS-looking set.100 Also, in 2018, a Tesla vehicle was allegedly sent into space and was shown floating above Earth. As Elon Musk said in a press conference, “You can tell it’s real because it looks so fake.”101

In one ISS video, a female astronaut is shown floating inside of the ISS, and says into the microphone, “I want people…to understand why the science on the ISS helps us out, here on Earth.” She said “here on Earth” when allegedly in the thermosphere.102 As Austin Whitsitt critically remarks, “I thought you were in space.” This raises questions about whether she was simply in a studio simulation on Earth but accidentally “slipped” with her words. However, if one wanted to be generous, one might conclude that she included the thermosphere as part of Earth.

The next ISS anomaly is harder to explain away, though. As an astronaut is shown floating on the ISS with two other astronauts, he told a story that concluded with: “And all of that happened in a little town called York, Maine, across the United States from where we’re talking to you right now.”103 Were the astronauts actually in, say, Houston, while pretending to be on the ISS? [emphasis added]

In another ISS video, it can be clearly seen that an astronaut is being held up by a harness as he swings around a corner in the background.104 The implication is that the “floating” we see in videos might not always be due to “low gravity.” Instead, apparent “floating” might be induced by physical harnesses that are used in a normal environment. And there are many video examples that skeptics feel are suggestive of harness use.105 In fact, there is a paper coauthored by a NASA employee titled “Practical Applications of Cables and Ropes in the ISS Countermeasures System.” Thus, it’s clear that such technology is used in at least some circumstances.106

There are also cases in which things inexplicably fall while in an allegedly “low gravity” environment on the ISS. In one video, the astronaut explicitly addresses the issue. As he’s floating, he mentions, “Sometimes you find a pocket of gravity.” He keeps one  hand next to a hammer that’s floating in the air, and simultaneously he lets go of a playing card in his other hand. The card falls straight down while the hammer is still floating. Austin Whitsitt analyzed the tape and asks a good question: “If you found a pocket of gravity, aren’t you currently moving 17,500 miles per hour—so how could you determine beforehand that you were going to actually be within that pocket of gravity?”107 The astronaut would have needed to know that this tiny pocket was specifically located where it was, and he would have also needed to know that the floating hammer by his other hand was not in that pocket of gravity.

But in most video anomalies, the astronauts don’t provide a “gravity pocket” caveat. And objects fall anyway, even though they “should be” floating. In one such video, the astronaut was signing papers, and he dropped the clipboard, which fell straight down.108 When he dropped it, he looked around as if to make sure no one saw what had happened. It was a clear look of guilt. Similarly, in another video, an astronaut unscrewed something on the wall, and the screw fell to the ground.109 There are many other similar examples as well.110

One such case is more subtle but very telling. An astronaut is shown floating while his microphone is floating too. On the wall, several feet away from him, is a plastic bag. In that bag an object can be seen to start slowly falling down. So it’s falling down while the astronaut and microphone are floating. Whitsitt speculates that the astronaut might be on a parabolic flight that had unavoidable turbulence, which caused the mishap on the wall.111 Parabolic flights can be used to bring about “zero gravity” environments.

There is also a video of an astronaut floating while brushing his teeth. The video footage is fast-forwarded so that viewers don’t need to watch him brush his teeth for such a long time. However, as this is happening, there is a bag floating nearby that doesn’t change its speed. If the whole video were fast-forwarded, then the entire scene should have moved at the same rate. But that’s not what happened. Perhaps this suggests that part of the visual “background” was not really where the astronaut was being filmed. This has led to speculation that augmented reality technology is  sometimes employed and visually deceives viewers.112 NASA did in fact publish an article in 2021 titled “Nine Ways We Use AR [Augmented Reality] and VR [Virtual Reality] on the International Space Station.”113In one seemingly egregious mistake, an astronaut magically appears in an empty ISS room. The background has continuity all the while, which suggests that this was the product of video imagery. In fact, his body can be seen to fade in, which suggests that it’s a visual effect. In other words, there could be a “green screen” with CGI layering technology that makes the astronaut look like he’s part of the scene.114

There are also videos in which potential “bubbles” can be seen floating in space while the astronaut is filmed allegedly working on something in space.115 Skeptics speculate that such instances were faked space scenes that were really filmed under water—because NASA astronauts admittedly train in the “Neutral Buoyancy Laboratory” underwater.116 Adding fuel to the skeptics’ fire, astronauts have had helmet “leaks” during “spacewalks” on the ISS. A 2022 New York Post article reads: “Panicked NASA cancels spacewalks after ISS astronaut’s helmet ‘fills with water,’”117 and a 2022 CNN article reads: “NASA review underway after water leaks into astronaut’s helmet.”118The video “Bloopers From Space—Top 25 All Time Favorites” on the YouTube channel Flat Earth and Coffee shows some of the examples discussed here. Beyond that, researchers have compiled an extensive body of documentation of similar cases.119 In any video or image analysis, there’s always the possibility of a technical glitch that’s misinterpreted as fraud. But when there are so many anomalies, skeptics contend that it’s hard to “explain away” all of them.

Any single example of fraud naturally puts everything into question. As the saying goes in US law: “Fraud vitiates everything it touches.”120 [emphasis added]

98Censored Important Videos, “April 2023: Justin Harvey calls out NASA at Brevard County,” https://rumble.com/v2kkkmu-calling-out-nasa-april-2023.html.

99Paul Davis UnCancelled, “Are the astronauts from the Challenger disaster still alive? Justin Harvey has the evidence,” https://rumble.com/v52mvyw-are-the-astronauts-from-the-challenger-disaster-still-alive-justin-harvey-h.html.

100Pearlman, “How did CBS’ Big Bang Theory send Howard Wolowitz to space?” https://www.space.com/17891-big-bang-theory-space-set-design.html.

101Witsit Gets It, “NASA Fraud,” https://www.youtube.com/live/CJnwl5aiBSk, 2:59:30.

102Ibid., 2:32:00.

103Flat Earth Dave Archive, “Houston, We Have Got a HUGE Problem! ISS HOAX,” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=la6ec1ay0II.

104Witsit Gets It, “NASA Fraud,” https://www.youtube.com/live/CJnwl5aiBSk, 2:47:00-2:48:00.

105A few examples shown in Witsit Gets It, “NASA Fraud,” https://www.youtube.com/live/CJnwl5aiBSk, 2:47:00-2:53:00.

106Moore et al., “Practical Applications of Cables and Ropes in the ISS Countermeasures System” https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20160012382/downloads/20160012382.pdf.

107Witsit Gets It, “NASA Fraud,” https://www.youtube.com/live/CJnwl5aiBSk, 2:29:00–2:30:00.

108Ibid., 3:15:20.

109Witsit Gets It, “NASA Fraud – Episode 3,” https://www.youtube.com/live/_gpM5lmRVW8, 2:13:00–2:16:00.

110Additional bloopers shown at Witsit Gets It, “NASA Fraud,” https://www.youtube.com/live/CJnwl5aiBSk, 3:19:00.

111Witsit Gets It, “NASA Fraud–Episode 3,” https://www.youtube.com/live/_gpM5lmRVW8.

112Witsit Gets It, “NASA Fraud,” https://www.youtube.com/live/CJnwl5aiBSk, 3:21:50.

113NASA, “Nine Ways We Use AR and VR on the International Space Station,” https://www.nasa.gov/missions/station/nine-ways-we-use-ar-and-vr-on-the-international-space-station/.

114Witsit Gets It, “NASA Fraud,” https://www.youtube.com/live/CJnwl5aiBSk, 3:36:50.

115See the YouTube channel “Flat Earth and Coffee,” https://www.youtube.com/@FlatEarthAndCoffee/videos.

116NASA, “Neutral Buoyancy Laboratory,” https://www.nasa.gov/johnson/neutral-buoyancy-laboratory/.

117Pettit, “Panicked NASA cancels spacewalks after ISS astronaut’s helmet ‘fills with water,’” https://nypost.com/2022/05/19/panicked-nasa-cancels-spacewalks-after-iss-astronauts-helmet-fills-with-water/.

118Erin Burnett Out Front, “NASA review underway after water leaks into astronaut’s helmet,” https://www.cnn.com/videos/business/2022/08/06/nasa-halts-spacewalks-spacesuit-problems-water-leak-astronaut-helmet-iss-fisher-pkg-ebof-vpx.cnn.

119Also available on Rumble at the channel Don’t Obey, “Bloopers From Space – Top 25 All Time Favorites,” https://rumble.com/v28x1v0-bloopers-from-space-top-25-all-time-favorites.html.

120Liverman v. McMurray, US Supreme Court, https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/20/20-5808/176392/20210422160651080_20210422-160534-95753440-00001842.pdf, 2.

An End to the Upside Down Cosmos

Rethinking the BigBang, Heliocentrism,

the Lights in the Sky…

and Where We Live

Mark Gober

Challenging Thought Processes

 

Before diving into the specifics, first it’s important to orient one’s thinking appropriately. The subjects in this book are scientific in nature, but the hard part isn’t as much the “science” as it is the thought processes that block rationality. What follows are cautions for you, the reader. Additionally, this will serve to prime you for paradigm-shifting concepts I discuss later that may cause cognitive dissonance (that is, psychological discomfort). Sometimes easing into jarring subject matter is most palatable to the mind.

1.Falsifying one model does not require having a viable or complete alternative model. When a claim is put forward, the burden of proof is on the party making the claim. If observations falsify the claim, then the claim must logically be discarded—regardless of whether a new, viable claim can be made to replace the old one.

In other words, it’s permissible to show that a model is incorrect without providing a new and comprehensive model to replace it. In such scenarios, we’re left in the uncomfortable but intellectually honest position of saying, We simply don’t know the answer.

Cosmology researcher Austin Whitsitt describes this principle using the phrase “falsification is independent of replacement”: the exercise of falsifying one model is independent of finding a definitive replacement model.20 This is a process of elimination that narrows down the possible truths.

Here is an example: You’re working with a team on a multiple-choice test in school that has options A, B, C, and D as possible answers. You’re required to submit an answer to your teacher, but the caveat is that your entire team must agree on the answer that you submit. Your teammates are convinced that the answer is option A. However, your analysis leads you to conclude that A cannot be correct. You tell your team the news, excited that you narrowed down the set of possibilities. But to your shock, your team dismisses your work. Although  they cannot deny that you’ve falsified option A, they ask with skepticism, But do you know, instead, what the correct answer is? If it’s not A, is it B, C, or D? You reply, I don’t know. That’s a separate analysis, and I haven’t gotten there yet. Your team replies, You don’t know the answer? Okay, then the real answer must be A. We’re sticking with that. This is irrational and illogical, but it can happen with rebuttals to scientific models.

Whitsitt gives another example that’s illustrative: Imagine that you go to your parents’ home and find in their closet official legal papers showing that you were adopted. All the paperwork is there: you were indeed legally adopted. Then you tell your friends, Hey, you won’t believe this: I was adopted! I found the paperwork! Your friends reply, Who are your real parents, then? You reply, I don’t know. That requires a separate line of inquiry. I’d have to look into that much further, but the truth is that I might never know who my real parents are. All I know with certainty is that I was adopted. Your friends reply, We refuse to believe that you were adopted until you tell us who your real parents are.21 This is the same sort of irrationality that can occur within science: even after one model is falsified, there’s a bias toward sticking with it if a comprehensive replacement model isn’t provided.

The psychological desire to have complete answers clouds logical thinking, as opposed to being able to sit in the unknown. There is often a tendency to feel more comfortable living with a lie than living with uncertainty.

This concept is essential to hold in mind while reading the coming chapters. In this book, I make no definitive claims about the true nature of the cosmos—and for reasons that I will discuss, there are limitations that make it impossible to promote a definitive model today. Instead, in this book I aim to expose flaws in the claims put forward by mainstream science. Hopefully by deflating confidence in the existing model, more attention will go toward new and better models.

 The approach is similar to the Vedic philosophy of neti neti (“not this, not that”).22 In other words, one arrives at the truth by continually finding what is not true, thereby leaving a narrower and narrower subset of possible candidates for the truth.

2.Black swans falsify a model. Imagine a model that claims: “All swans are white.” You travel around the world, and you find white swan after white swan. You conclude that the model works well and is highly predictive of reality. Then, one day, you come across a black swan. That black swan destroys your model because your model says that “all swans are white.”23All means all. A single anomaly makes your model unviable because your model is no longer able to accurately describe reality. This may sound obvious, but it needs to be stated explicitly. There is often a psychological tendency to excuse mistakes and defend the consensus model by using mental gymnastics, even if contradictory evidence is presented.

These mental gymnastics often include post hoc rationalizations: an idea is made up out of thin air to “explain away” the apparent anomaly, thereby allowing that model to seem like it still works.

Dark matter and dark energy might turn out to be examples of this rationalization. Observations in astrophysics failed to align with the mainstream model, so scientists effectively concluded: Dark matter and dark energy must be there. But what if they’re not there, and the fundamentals of modern cosmology—including gravity and general relativity theory—are simply wrong?

3.Double standards are everywhere in debates about cosmology. If an existing model explains reality “pretty well,” it’s easy to sweep under the rug seemingly minor errors, incomplete ideas, or unexplained phenomena.

However, when a new, competing model is proposed, there can be a tendency to quickly dismiss it if there  is even a single unexplained issue…while at the same time being willing to tolerate unexplained issues in the existing, mainstream model. This is, of course, irrational and intellectually inconsistent, yet it happens regularly. If one is willing to be so harsh toward a new model, one should be equally ready to let go of the existing model.

For instance, mainstream science seems willing to accept the problems with dark matter and dark energy, and the absence of a unifying theory of physics. Yet when the “nonmainstream” ideas I discuss in this book are proposed, there’s a knee-jerk reaction to dismiss them if there’s even a single concept that is difficult to conceptualize.

4.Observations do not, on their own, reveal the cause(s) of those observations. Imagine a situation in which people get sick with similar symptoms after attending a party. Then they conclude that they “caught” something contagious. This is certainly one reasonable hypothesis. But to stop there would be illogical. The fact that people got sick after being in the same place at the same time doesn’t necessarily mean that a contagious, microscopic germ caused the symptoms. People can get sick for many reasons that have nothing to do with germs. For instance, what if people at the party were exposed to the same toxin floating in the air, emanating from the materials in the building, or sitting in the food and drinks served at the party? What if the attendees were exposed to high levels of radiation or electric and magnetic fields (EMFs)? What if they were exposed to a similar psychological stressor that translated into sickness? What if there was a “bioresonance” between the “energy fields” of the people that mimicked germ-based contagion? Yawns seem to be “contagious,” but they don’t come from a germ. Women’s menstrual cycles sometimes synchronize when they share a living space, but that isn’t believed to come from a contagious germ. Furthermore,  what if there is some other cause that isn’t understood by modern science?

Rather than really digging for the truth, it’s easy to find ourselves in a place of intellectual laziness whereby a single explanation emerges, and we stop thinking any further. Once we’ve decided on the explanation, we erroneously use that as the basis for the model into which all future observations are forced.

This work is, of course, not about medicine (I covered that topic in my book An End to Upside Down Medicine [2023]). But the fallacious reasoning observed throughout medicine often occurs in cosmology as well. Andrew Kaufman, MD, made this very observation in his 2023 lecture titled “Fallacies, Fraud & Pseudoscience: The Parallels Between Cosmology and Biology.” In his words: “You can observe a set of phenomena in nature and you can come up with a model or a hypothesis to explain it….But when you stick to circular reasoning, you feel that your explanation is the only possible solution….[It’s advisable to] always think: ‘If I can come up with another logical explanation for this set of phenomena, then we know that the proposed explanation or model is not necessarily correct because there are many other models that could also be correct.’”24

An example of this type of thinking arises in discussions about heliocentrism (the belief that Earth revolves around the Sun), versus geocentrism (the belief that the Sun revolves around Earth). Heliocentrism is fundamental to the consensus cosmological paradigm, yet physicists rarely acknowledge that observations attributed to heliocentrism could also fit into a geocentric cosmology. We’re simply so accustomed to presupposing the truth of heliocentrism that we struggle to envision Earth at the center—even though our experience is that the luminous bodies in the sky move around Earth, and Earth feels to us like it is stationary. Many prominent, mainstream physicists have discussed this, including  Stephen Hawking. In his book The Grand Design (2010), coauthored by Leonard Mlodinow, they stated: “Our observations of the heavens can be explained by assuming either the earth or the sun to be at rest.”25 Let that sink in. There is more to come on this topic. [emphasis added]

The broader problem here is related to a logical fallacy known as affirming the consequent. It goes like this:

If P, then Q.


 Q, therefore P.

An example:

If it rains, then the grass outside will be wet.


 The grass outside is wet; therefore, it rained.

This conclusion, of course, ignores many other possible causes of wet grass that have absolutely nothing to do with rain. The grass could have been wet because of sprinklers, for instance.

How often do we get stuck in a particular belief system without considering other possible explanations?

5.The way celestial bodies in the sky look and behave doesn’t necessarily imply that Earth looks and behaves in the same way. If you look at bodies in the sky through a telescope, it is not logical to conclude that Earth must share those same qualities. An alternative possibility—and one that must be considered among intellectually honest seekers—is that Earth is unique or distinct relative to those bodies observed in the sky. For instance, the assumption that Earth is just like “other planets” presupposes that Earth is a planet rather than something else. Alternatives need to be considered in fully comprehensive analyses.

6.Testing something on Earth alone, in the present moment, is insufficient to draw conclusions about the broader cosmos in the past and in the future. Scientists can run experiments on Earth today, but they often extrapolate and make  claims that ignore important presuppositions. As stated by physicist Robert Bennett, PhD:

When we design a test, the test has to match what the hypothesis claims. So, if you claim something that is going to apply throughout all space, you cannot test it only on Earth. If you say it’s in the Solar System, you have to be able to test it throughout the Solar System. This is what’s overlooked very often in the statements of laws—the scope of the laws—in space.

Same goes for time. Does the law only apply at a certain time? This is violated [frequently]….You cannot know what happened in ancient times if you make measurements on data in current time. You can only assume that nothing has changed between when the event occurred and when you actually did the measurement. And this is an assumption that is often incorrect.

[Also,] when you look at the stars in space, what you’re looking at are dots of light that are interpreted as being the same type of light production that is being done in the Sun. But there’s no proof of that. The spectrum of the stars—none of them are the same as the spectrum of the Sun. So we’re making assumptions that what we see in starlight is the same as we see in sunlight.…

[In summary,] when you look at a law, you must always ask, “What is the scope in space and time?” This is what I see most often violated in what I call “mainstream thinking.”26 [emphasis added]

7.The way our eyes see obscures reality, and many of us are unaware of this issue; thus, we fail to make the necessary mental adjustments. On the most fundamental level, our eyes only show us a tiny sliver of the electromagnetic spectrum: we don’t see radio waves, x-rays, microwaves, infrared light, and more (see the image that follows). Even though we can detect invisible light with  technology, we tend to be biased by what we can see with our eyes. Therefore, judging the cosmos by our eyes alone is problematic.

Visible light is only a tiny fraction of the electromagnetic spectrum. Most of the spectrum exists beyond what our ordinary vision can detect. Our eyes show us only a sliver of reality.27

Beyond that, it’s important to acknowledge that we cannot see forever. Light attenuates, meaning that its intensity fades as it moves through a medium (such as the air and atmosphere).28Similarly, a visual phenomenon known as perspective can lead us to erroneously interpret objects to be rising or falling as they become more distant from us, when in reality they’re not actually rising or falling. Put another way: our brains process visual information in a way that can skew perception. Ultimately, our visual space is curved and limited. It is neither linear nor infinite. More on this later.

8.Math is a tool; it is not direct evidence that a model is correct. Consider the following quotation from Arthur C. Clarke in his 1963 book Profiles of the Future:

The lesson to be learned…is one that can never be repeated too often, and is one that is seldom understood by laymen—who have an almost superstitious awe of mathematics. But mathematics is only a tool, though an immensely powerful one. No equations,  however impressive and complex, can arrive at the truth if the initial assumptions are incorrect. It is really quite amazing by what margins competent but conservative scientists and engineers can miss the mark, when they start with the preconceived idea that what they are investigating is impossible. When this happens, the most well-informed men become blinded by their prejudices and are unable to see what lies directly ahead of them. What is even more incredible, they refuse to learn from experience; they will continue to make the same mistake over and over again.

Some of my best friends are astronomers, and I am sorry to keep throwing stones at them—but they do seem to have an appalling record as prophets.”29 [emphasis added]

Physicist Nikola Tesla stated it another way in 1934: “Today’s scientists have substituted mathematics for experiments, and they wander off through equation after equation, and eventually build a structure which has no relation to reality.”30

In this book, I will not delve into math. But inevitably the question may arise in your mind: Wouldn’t equations have proven modern cosmology already? If the assumptions baked into the equations haven’t been correct, however, then the resulting math wouldn’t tell us what we need to know. And perhaps that’s what has been happening in cosmology.

9.Beware of the “appeal to personal incredulity” logical fallacy. When encountering paradigm-shifting concepts, there can be a tendency to think, I cannot conceive how this could possibly be true. I cannot, in my own mind, list all of the steps needed in order for it to have happened in the way that it is claimed. I don’t fully understand it. Therefore, I reject it.

 Truth doesn’t depend on our ability to fathom it. Just because one can’t comprehend something doesn’t mean that this thing is not true. Similarly, there might be ideas beyond our current knowledge that we haven’t even considered—“unknown unknowns.”31

20For example, see Austin Whitsitt’s content on his many social media channels, including his YouTube channel titled Witsit Gets It: https://www.youtube.com/@Whitsitt.

21Ibid.

22I first heard this comparison to Vedic philosophy made by Thomas Cowan, MD.

23Nassim Nicholas Taleb popularized the term black swan with his book The Black Swan: The Impact of the Highly Improbable (second edition, 2010).

24Andrew Kaufman, MD, “Fallacies, Fraud & Pseudoscience: The Parallels Between Cosmology and Biology,” https://rumble.com/v44kwso-fallacies-fraud-and-pseudoscience-the-parallels-between-cosmology-and-biolo.html. 3:00–5:20.

25Hawking and Mlodinow, The Grand Design, 56.

26Witsit Gets It, “In The Field – Robert Bennett Ph.D. – Part 1,” https://www.youtube.com/live/5j0wCrkzfwk, 12:45–15:10.

27Figure reconstructed from NASA introduction to electromagnetic spectrum, https://science.nasa.gov/ems/01_intro.

28Attenuation of light is a well-known phenomenon. For instance, “Fog attenuation in the visible and IR regions is reviewed from an empirical and theoretical point of view” is mentioned in Naboulsi et al., “Fog attenuation prediction for optical and infrared waves,” https://proceedings.spiedigitallibrary.org/journals/optical-engineering/volume-43/issue-2/0000/Fog-attenuation-prediction-for-optical-and-infrared-waves/10.1117/1.1637611.short.

29Clarke, Profiles of the Future: An Inquiry into the Limits of the Possible, 7.

30Tesla, “Radio Power Will Revolutionize the World,” https://teslauniverse.com/nikola-tesla/articles/radio-power-will-revolutionize-world.

31A phrase used by Donald Rumsfeld. See Graham, “Rumsfeld’s Knowns and Unknowns: The Intellectual History of a Quip,” https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2014/03/rumsfelds-knowns-and-unknowns-the-intellectual-history-of-a-quip/359719/.


An End to the Upside Down Cosmos 

Rethinking the BigBang, Heliocentrism,

the Lights in the Sky…

and Where We Live

Mark Gober



Monday, November 10, 2025

Research on children who remember previous lives began around 1960

 Beliefs about reincarnation

Before diving into the evidence, I should remind you that what is documented here is another example of simply following evidence. Reincarnation, for some, is an emotionally charged subject because of existing beliefs. This book aspires to be detached from preconceptions or wishful thinking. I certainly hadn’t heard much about reincarnation before I began my research. It was a completely foreign topic to me that  had no basis in reality, as far as I knew. It was an idea that I assumed people made up to comfort themselves about their mortality.

Lead reincarnation researcher Dr. Ian Stevenson of the University of Virginia reminded us: “Critics of the evidence for reincarnation have sometimes pointed to its element of hopefulness with the dismissing suggestion that such evidence as we have derives only from wishful thinking. This objection wrongly assumes that what we desire must be false. We might be more easily persuaded to believe what we wish to believe than the contrary; nevertheless, what we wish to believe may be true. Our inquiry into the truth or falseness of an idea should proceed without regard to whether it fortifies or undermines our wishes.”6Children who remember previous lives

Research on children who remember previous lives began around 1960. Then-department head of psychiatry at the University of Virginia (UVA) Medical School, Dr. Ian Stevenson, heard about such children and became intrigued. He then devoted the remainder of his life to this study, examining more than 2,500 cases around the world, until his death in 2007. Dr. Jim Tucker, also a professor at UVA, has continued Dr. Stevenson’s research.

Dr. Stevenson’s work is highly regarded. Dr. Larry Dossey remarks:

[Stevenson] reported thousands of cases of children who remembered past lives and whose descriptions of previous existences checked out on investigation.7…No one else has researched this area with the scholarship, thoroughness, and dogged devotion to detail as he has. Stevenson combed the planet, from back roads of Burma and the remote villages of India to the largest cities on Earth. He devoted decades to scouring every continent except Antarctica, investigating always the same quarry—children who appear to remember a past life. The scope of his work is breathtakingly universal, and even skeptics are generally awed by the thousands of cases he has amassed. The cases occur in every culture including our own and demonstrate strong internal consistency.8

Furthermore, Dr. Stevenson received praise from the well-respected Journal of the American Medical Association in 1975: “In regard to reincarnation [Stevenson] has painstakingly and unemotionally collected a detailed series of cases from India, cases in which the evidence is difficult to explain on any other grounds.”9 What did Dr. Stevenson find?

He found common themes in the cases reported all over the world and in different cultures: A child between the ages of two and five begins to speak emotionally of a past life, including specific events (typically traumatic ones) that are clustered around the end of some previous life.10 When a child remembers his or her death, the account described is usually violent.11 Dr. Stevenson stated: “Too often the children are troubled by confusion regarding their identity and this becomes even more severe in those children who, conscious of being in a small body, can remember having been in an adult one, or who remember a life as a member of the opposite sex.”12Dr. Stevenson also noted that age plays a role in a child’s ability to describe and recall past-life memories:

I cannot emphasize too strongly that—with some exceptions—a child who is going to remember a previous life has little more than three years in which to communicate his memories of other persons, and he often has less. Before the age of two or three he lacks the vocabulary and verbal skill with which to express what he may wish to communicate. And from the age of about five on, heavy layers of verbal information cover the images in which his memories appear to be mainly conveyed; amnesia for the memories of a previous life sets in and stops further communication of them.13Often children’s traits can be linked to the previous lives they remember, such as fears, preferences, interests, and skills.14 These traits typically bear no resemblance to those of anyone in the child’s current family. In some cases, the traits make no sense for a young child, such as desiring certain foods that the family doesn’t eat, or desiring “clothes different from those customarily worn by the family members.” Stranger than that are cases in which the child has “cravings for addicting substances, such as tobacco, alcohol or other drugs that the previous personality was known to have used.”15

In some cases, the person allegedly being reincarnated had made a prediction of the next life before his or her death. In other cases, the child has birthmarks, birth defects, or other biological features that align with events of past lives (to be discussed further in the next section).  In a minority of cases, the child exhibits “xenoglossy”: speaking a foreign language he or she hasn’t been taught.16Where possible, Drs. Stevenson and Tucker have looked for historical facts demonstrating that the person the child remembered matches the child’s description. The degree of historical verifiability varies from case to case, but in some cases the accuracy is astounding. In such cases, it is difficult to imagine how a young child could possess such knowledge without access to some broader consciousness.

James 3

One such case is of James Leininger, a young boy in Lafayette, Louisiana.17 When James was 22 months old, his father took him to a museum, and he showed an affinity for the World War II exhibit. Prior to going to the museum, James had been pointing at planes flying overhead, but he became much more interested after the museum visit. So his parents bought him toy planes and a video of the Blue Angels, the Navy’s exhibition team (formed after World War II). James was obsessed and would crash the toy planes into the family’s coffee table, denting and scratching the table while saying, “Airplane crash on fire.” After his second birthday, he began having nightmares several times a week. He thrashed around the bed with his legs in the air, yelling, “Airplane crash on fire! Little man can’t get out!” When awake, he said, “Mama, before I was born, I was a pilot and my airplane got shot in the engine and it crashed in the water, and that’s how I died.” He told his dad the Japanese shot his plane as part of the Iwo Jima operation, that the plane was a Corsair (a plane not at the museum James had visited), which flew off of a boat called the Natoma. He also mentioned that Jack Larsen was there. An additional strange behavior: James was signing his name “James 3.”

James’s parents were confused, so they investigated some of James’s claims. Ultimately, they discovered that James’s description matched the historical facts of the life of James Huston Jr. (i.e., James the second), a pilot on Natoma Bay who had flown a Corsair and was shot down (in another plane) by the Japanese. Huston was the only pilot killed in the Iwo Jima operation, and eyewitnesses reported that the plane was “hit head-on right on the middle of the engine,” after which it crashed in the water and quickly sank. Jack Larsen was the pilot of the plane next to James Huston’s plane.

 The Hollywood extra

Another case is of a four-year-old boy, Ryan, who was born into an Oklahoma family that was traditionally Christian and did not believe in reincarnation.18 When Ryan played, he would often act as though he was directing imaginary movies by saying, “Action!” When he would see the Hollywood Hills on TV, he would say: “That’s my home. That’s where I belong…I just can’t live in these conditions. My last home was much better.”19 He also talked about having traveled the world and loved Chinatown, saying it had the best food. Ryan claimed that he chose his mother before he was born.

Eventually Ryan started having nightmares, waking up saying he was in Hollywood and his heart exploded. Confused, his mother bought Hollywood books to see if they would trigger any memories. In one book, Ryan saw a photograph of six men from a 1932 movie called Night After Night. He said, “Hey, Mama that’s George. We did a picture together. And Mama, that guy’s me. I found me.” Ryan’s mother researched and learned that the man Ryan had identified as George was a movie star in the 1930s/1940s named George Raft. However, Ryan’s parents could not identify the person who Ryan claimed was “him.”

After investigation with the help of Dr. Tucker, they discovered that the man Ryan pointed to was named Marty Martyn, an extra who had no lines in Night After Night. Dr. Tucker tracked down Marty’s daughter, and she and Ryan then met in person. Ryan’s reaction: “Same face, but she didn’t wait on me. She changed. Her energy changed.”20

Many of the claims Ryan had made lined up. For example, Ryan talked of taking girlfriends to the ocean; Marty had taken girlfriends to the ocean and had been married four times. Ryan had remembered an African American maid, and indeed, Marty had one. Ryan mentioned meeting “Senator Five” in New York; Marty’s daughter had a picture of Marty with Senator Ives of New York. Ryan said he was a smoker; Marty smoked cigars. Ryan recalled having a nice home and traveling; Marty had a big house with a swimming pool and traveled the world. Ryan talked about liking the food in Chinatown; Marty had enjoyed a Chinese restaurant in Hollywood. Marty died in a hospital room when he was alone, so it is not known whether a heart attack was the ultimate cause of his death, as Ryan’s nightmares would have suggested.

 As Dr. Tucker summarizes it: “Many of the details Ryan gave did fit the man he pointed to in the picture, who had a much more exciting life than anyone could have guessed a movie extra would have.”21

How could these children know such detailed facts at such a young age with no evidence of exposure to the details they report?

No wonder Carl Sagan thought this was an area deserving “serious study.”

Birthmarks and physical defects

Dr. Stevenson also found links between previous lives and birthmarks and physical defects. His body of work is robust—he wrote a two-volume book entitled Reincarnation and Biology, which is more than 2,000 pages long, with dense scientific text and fine print, covering 200 cases (with photographic evidence).

Amazingly, the birthmarks and physical defects he studied correlate to “previous lives” described by the children he examined. It’s one thing to read summaries of Dr. Stevenson’s work here in this book, but it’s another to see the pictures and detail contained in his literature. In an attempt to simply provide some flavor here, I present several examples out of many.

In some cases, birthmarks correspond to wounds verified by a child’s memories. For example, Dr. Stevenson described a Turkish boy who remembered a previous life in which he was stabbed through the liver area. In this life, the boy had a “large depressed birthmark, really a small cavity in the skin, over his liver.”22 In another example, a boy from Burma had “a small round birthmark in his right lower abdomen and a much larger birthmark on his right back. These correspond to wounds of entry and exit on the bandit whose life he remembered.”23In the strongest cases, medical records verify that the location of a birthmark matches where a trauma occurred in a deceased person. A Lebanese boy recalled a previous life in which he was drinking coffee before leaving for work one day and was shot in the face. The story was verified by an actual shooting that took place. According to medical records related to the shooting, the bullet entered one cheek, damaged the man’s tongue, exited through the other cheek, and the man later died in the hospital. The boy, who claims to be the next incarnation of the murdered man, had birthmarks on each check and had difficulty articulating words that required him to elevate his tongue. Dr. Stevenson reported: “I was able  to study the hospital record in this case. It showed that the birthmark on [the boy’s] left cheek, which was the smaller of the two, corresponded to the wound of entry, and the larger birthmark on the right cheek corresponded to the wound of exit.”24In another case, a Turkish boy was believed to be the next incarnation of a recently deceased relative who died after being shot. The bullet did not exit his head, but the pathologist made an incision to extract the bullet. The Turkish boy was born with a birthmark that corresponded with the location of the incision. Dr. Stevenson commented: “Like many other children of these cases, [the boy] showed powerful attitudes of vengefulness toward the man who had shot [him in the previous life]. He once tried to take his father’s gun and shoot this person, but was fortunately restrained.”25 The boy came to his parents in their dreams, before he was born, saying he would be the next incarnation of this same deceased relative.

It gets even weirder.

Dr. Stevenson examined “experimental” birthmarks: cases in which a mark was left on the body of a deceased person in the hopes that the mark would show on the person who later reincarnates. In a case in Thailand in 1969, a boy’s dead body was marked with charcoal before he was cremated. He had died from drowning. The next boy that the same mother birthed was born with a birthmark near the location of the charcoal marking. Once the boy was able to speak, he began describing details of the life his deceased brother lived. He also had a fear of water.26In another case in Burma, a girl died after unsuccessful open-heart surgery. Her classmates put a mark in red lipstick on the back of her neck before she was buried, in the hopes that the mark would show in the deceased girl’s next incarnation. Thirteen months after the girl’s death, her sister gave birth to a girl who had a “prominent red birthmark at the back of her neck in the same location where [the deceased girl’s] schoolmates marked her with lipstick” [emphasis in original]. Dr. Stevenson commented that she also had a birthmark that appeared as a thin line with “diminished pigmentation that ran vertically from her lower chest to her upper abdomen. This corresponded to the surgical incision for the cardiac surgery during which [the girl] had died.”27

In other cases, more extreme physical deformities can be linked to traumas experienced by the previous life remembered by the child. A Burmese girl was born with birthmarks near her heart and on her head; she was missing  the fifth finger on her left hand, and she had “constriction rings” on her legs, the most dramatic of which was on her left thigh.28 In the disturbing picture provided by Dr. Stevenson in Where Reincarnation and Biology Intersect (shown below), her leg looks as though it had been constricted by something like a rope. But her leg is naturally shaped that way, without anything constricting it. It is by no means the typical shape of a leg. When the girl was able to speak, she identified herself as a man who had been tortured (fingers cut, tied in ropes). Dr. Stevenson was eventually able to verify this man’s identity. There was indeed a person tortured and killed in the precise manner described by the little girl. Distressed by her birthmarks and deformities, the little girl said, “Grandpa. Look at what they did to me. How cruel they were.”29How could she have known such specific details? Why would a young child be saying these things? Why did her body reflect such distinctive deformities that matched the way the man had died?

Dr. Ian Stevenson investigated the case of a young girl who had specific, distinctive deformities that match how she described dying in a past life (shown above). In fact, there was a person who died in the precise manner described by the little girl. She described being tied in ropes and tortured in her past life. The shape of her legs seems to match that description. The figure above is from Dr. Stevenson’s bookWhere Reincarnation and Biology Intersect(1997).

 Dr. Stevenson noted that the girl’s mother happened to have walked past the tortured man’s dead body when she was two and a half months pregnant. She saw the police handling the situation. She believes the same man came to her in a dream before her daughter was born.30 Was this little girl the next incarnation of the man who was tortured—even though this man had no biological relationship to the little girl?

Maternal impressions

Dr. Stevenson conceded that in some cases it is not fully clear that birth defects can be tied directly to a previous life. Instead, “maternal impressions” sometimes could have been the cause. Maternal impressions refer to frightening mental images that the mother of a baby has during pregnancy, which result in the baby’s having a deformity that closely matches the mental image. Dr. Stevenson referenced an 1890 study at the University of Virginia written by a pediatrician who reviewed 90 maternal-impression cases. In these cases, the mother experienced something particularly frightening during pregnancy. And in 77 percent of the cases, there was “‘quite a close correspondence’ between the impression upon the mother during pregnancy and her baby’s defect.”31

Dr. Stevenson researched this topic further and focused on 300 cases from around the world, of which he studied 50 in detail. The example that Dr. Stevenson pointed to is disturbing, but makes the point. He recalled the case of a woman whose brother’s penis was amputated for medical reasons. While pregnant, “her curiosity impelled her to have a look at the site of her brother’s amputation.”32 She then gave birth to a male baby without a penis. Dr. Stevenson researched medical records of the general population and found the odds of a male baby being born with this birth defect is one in 30 million.

Dr. Stevenson’s analysis of the cases revealed that maternal impressions most likely impacted the baby when the impression occurred during the first trimester of pregnancy and when the traumatic incident occurred to the mother or someone close to her.33 Examples such as this caused Dr. Stevenson to question whether every case of physical deformity was induced by reincarnation. Instead, it is possible that some cases could be attributed to maternal impressions (which on its own deserves investigation!).

 But Dr. Stevenson noted that sometimes the mother had no knowledge of a deformity during pregnancy. In those cases, the maternal-impressions explanation doesn’t hold, and something else (reincarnation?) is needed as an explanation.34

Where does this leave us?

The totality of Drs. Stevenson’s and Tucker’s work points in the following direction, as summarized by Dr. Stevenson: “Some persons have unique attributes that we cannot now explain satisfactorily as due solely to a combination of genetic variation and environmental influences. Reincarnation deserves consideration as a third factor in play.”35 If this is true, the implications are immense for science, medicine, and beyond (as we’ll explore in chapter 13).

Under the materialist view that the brain produces consciousness, reincarnation is “nonsense.” However, if consciousness is more fundamental than matter and does not arise from brain activity, then the evidence discussed in this chapter is truly plausible.

Chapter Summary

❍Drs. Ian Stevenson and Jim Tucker of the University of Virginia have studied more than 2,500 children over 50-plus years who claim to remember previous lives.

❍Sometimes the stories these young children tell match historical records of the individuals they claim they were in past lives. In other cases, the children speak foreign languages that they had no way of knowing.

❍In some cases, the child has distinctive birthmarks or physical deformities that match the way in which the child describes having died in a previous life. Sometimes, medical records verified the accuracy of the child’s claims.

An End to Upside Down Thinking

Dispelling the Myth That the Brain ProducesC onsciousness, and the Implications for Everyday Life

Mark Gober

Sunday, May 18, 2025

The One Mind theory, or we are sense organs of the Infinite

 An underlying reason for the movement toward panpsychism is perhaps due to Thomas Nagel’s popular definition of consciousness from the 1970s: “Consciousness is what it’s like to be something.” In other words, consciousness is what it’s like to be a human or a dog or anything that has consciousness.

At first glance, this seems reasonable. But as noted by philosophers such as Rupert Spira, embedded in Nagel’s definition is a big, unwarranted assumption. It assumes that there exists a human that could be conscious—that there is a human from which consciousness arises. See the issue there? He’s assuming physicalism in his definition.

On the contrary, the One Mind model suggests that all reality is just one universal consciousness. There is no human or dog or insect or plant or stone that could be conscious. Rather, as Spira says, “Only consciousness is conscious.”8 And that one consciousness—the One Mind—experiences an apparently physical world through the vehicle of humans and other physical vessels.

The One Mind is the infinite, silent context underlying all experience—the field of reality and the ground of all being. Spira often compares it to an infinite screen. The screen’s pixels are colored when a movie is playing and various characters appear (for example, humans). But no matter what happens to the characters on the screen and no matter what colors light up the pixels, the screen is untouched.

The One Mind is the substrate of all experience. The apparent diversity in the world is a reflection of “modulations” of consciousness9—like waves appearing in an ocean.

Our Ultimate Identity Is Not Our Body

What are we? This answer seems obvious. Our everyday experience suggests to us that our identity is our body. That’s what our perceptions show us. It's also how our mind interprets reality and certainly what modern society teaches us. I’m a human being named Mark Gober. Easy.

But based on the One Mind model, our identity at the Absolute level is not our body or our personality; rather, it’s our consciousness—the one consciousness at the core of all existence. Our identity is the full “stream” itself, the One Mind. The body is just something that consciousness experiences. We inhabit the body, but we aren’t identified as the body.

That said, at the Relative level of reality, it sure feels as if we are a body and a personality. That’s the way we live day to day. So in order to buy into the One Mind model, we have to hold the paradox of feeling like an individual in the context of being the totality of existence. We are both a whirlpool and the stream simultaneously.

That is one of the most earth-shattering implications of the One Mind model: we’ve been thinking about our very own identity incorrectly! As is often stated: “We aren’t human beings having a spiritual experience; we are spiritual beings having a human experience.” Or alternatively, as author Suzanne Segal phrased it: “We are sense organs of the Infinite.”10The shift away from physicalism toward the One Mind is likely a bigger revolution in thinking than any other in human history. The realizations that Earth isn’t flat and that Earth isn’t at the center of the solar system were enormous paradigm shifts, but they pertained to how we viewed the external world around us while preserving our identity. What I’m talking about here is shifting how we think about who and what we fundamentally are.

The One Mind Could Be Likened to “God”

God is a term with lots of baggage. The Judeo-Christian cultural view anthropomorphizes God. God is often depicted as a white, bearded male in the sky who exists separately from us; and who often exhibits vengeful, judgmental, and bellicose behavior. We are here, and God is “up there” in the heavens. Obey “him”... or else. People throughout history have justified murder and mayhem in “his” name.

Debates rage on as to whether or not God exists. However, a first step that people often skip is to make certain we’re using a  consistent definition. Let’s be sure we’re talking about the same guy before we argue!

The model in this book is not claiming that there exists a separate God having the characteristics just described. Rather, I’m arguing that the One Mind—a genderless, impersonal, infinite field of consciousness—is the basis of reality. There is one infinite stream in which we are localized whirlpools. If one wanted, one might call the One Mind—the entire stream—“God.” Rick Archer has often stated as a rebuttal to atheistic views: “I don’t believe in the same God you don’t believe in.” Or as I like to say, “They got the wrong guy.”

If we were to employ this One Mind definition of God, there are some important implications. Since each us is made of the same water in the same stream, then it would logically follow that each of us is an aspect of God. This aligns with the spiritual notion that God is both immanent (within) and transcendent (beyond). There is no separation between God and us. And yet there is separation because we don’t access the full stream in daily living. Both are true. Another paradox.

Returning to our discussion about identity, we could reframe my previous comments using God-centric terminology. We could say that we are “tentacles of God” or “instruments of the Divine.” This is why spiritual author Ram Dass advised: “Treat everyone you meet like God in drag.”

Certainly in Eastern religions we see ideas like this. But they also appear in the West if we look closely. For example, consider Jesus Christ’s quote: “I and the father are one.” Translation: Jesus, as an individual whirlpool, is one with the stream. And consider his quote: “The kingdom of God is within you.” Translation: Even though you are an individual whirlpool, you are comprised of the same water that makes up the full stream of reality. Words such as father and God have become so culturally off-putting that we can overlook what’s actually being said.

In my life, the term God has been a turn-off. I used to immediately shut down when I heard it. Even when I began my explorations  several years ago, I would become viscerally disturbed anytime someone used the word, even if I knew they weren’t talking about a personal God. Now, I’ve come to terms with it as long as it’s being defined properly. Too often people use it without specifying what they mean.

So why not just do away with the term God to avoid possible confusion? Some claim that the “Ah” sound in the word God creates a frequency that keeps us in alignment with the greater stream of consciousness. Why that would be the case, I’m not sure. Interestingly, when we look at religions around the world, we find that the very same “Ah” sound is found in words that represent divinity: Allah (Islam), Brahman (Hinduism), Hashem ( Judaism), and so on.

As spiritual teacher Dr. Wayne Dyer said, “I was taught that the expression of the word or sound, which means God, brings us into contact with God. God is the basic fact of the universe, symbolized with this most natural and comprehensive of all sounds. It’s no accident that the words omnipotent, omniscience, and omnipresent contain the sound of God”11 [emphasis added].

However, regardless of whether or not that idea is true, I will generally use the term One Mind in this book—unless I’m making an explicit tie to religion.

The One Mind Is Intelligent

A basic fact of our individual existence as humans is that we are intelligent. The degree of intelligence can vary from person to person, but each of us has some intelligence.

If each of us is intelligent, and if we are individually part of the One Mind, it seems to follow logically that the One Mind is intelligent. Stated another way, if the whirlpools are intelligent, and the whirlpools are part of the stream, then by definition the stream has intelligence.

Let’s take a further logical step. If all reality is just the One Mind, then all reality—ourselves and everything around us—is  conceivably embedded with intelligence as well.

Everywhere we look in the universe—whether it’s a flower, a human being, mathematics, the greater cosmos, or anything—we find immense complexity. And in light of this unthinkable complexity, it seems reasonable to assume that the One Mind has unthinkable intelligence.

So perhaps this is what religious traditions mean when they make statements such as “God is omniscient” and that we should “see God in everything.” When we depersonalize “God,” it all starts to make more sense.

Randomness Is an Illusion

The universe

As previously discussed, the physicalist view of reality tends to view the universe as random. However, if the universe is embedded with unthinkable intelligence, should we question the “randomness” hypothesis? I think so.

We have to ask ourselves: Why is the universe exactly balanced for life? Robert Lanza, MD (a stem-cell researcher who was named one of TIME magazine’s top 100 most influential people in 2014), and physicist Bob Berman examine this question in their book Biocentrism (2009). In a chapter titled “Goldilocks’s Universe,” they state:

By the late sixties, it had become clear that if the Big Bang had been just one part in a million more powerful, the cosmos would have blown outward too fast to allow stars and worlds to form. Result: no us. Even more coincidentally, the universe’s four forces and all of its constants [tables follow] are just perfectly set up for atomic interactions, the existence of atoms and elements, planets, liquid water, and life. Tweak any of them and you never existed.12

List of Constants (as shown in Biocentrism)13

(...)

The universe is configured “just right” for life to exist. Somehow, life emerged from nonlife. Given what we’ve discussed about the One Mind, do we think the universe’s fine-tuned structure is a function of the One Mind’s inherent intelligence? Or do we think it’s a “jackpot” event that emerged from pure randomness?

Physicalists say it’s just chance. Lanza and Berman summarize what the physicalist perspective is asking us to believe:

The entire universe, exquisitely tailored for our existence, popped into existence out of absolute nothingness. Who in their right mind would accept such a thing? Has anyone offered any credible suggestion for how, some 14 billion years ago, we suddenly got a hundred trillion times more than a trillion trillion trillion tons of matter from—zilch? Has anyone explained how dumb  carbon, hydrogen, and oxygen molecules could have, by combining accidentally, become sentient—aware!—then utilized this sentience to acquire a taste for hot dogs and the blues? How any possible natural random process could mix those molecules in a blender for a few billion years so that out would pop woodpeckers and George Clooney? Can anyone conceive of any edges to the cosmos? Infinity? Or how particles still spring out of nothingness? Or conceive of any of the many supposed extra dimensions that must exist everywhere in order for the cosmos to consist fundamentally of interlocking strings and loops? Or explain how ordinary elements can ever rearrange themselves so that they continue to acquire self-awareness and a loathing for macaroni salad? Or, again, how every one of dozens of forces and constants are precisely fine-tuned for the existence of life? Is it not obvious that science only pretends to explain the cosmos on its fundamental level?14 [emphasis in original]

It seems much simpler, to me, to explain the precision of the universe as a manifestation of the intelligent One Mind. While previously I was sympathetic to the randomness argument, I now see it as its own form of religion. It’s like a Hail Mary. Sure, it could be right. But it seems very, very unlikely.

An End to Upside Down Living

Mark Gober

Wednesday, February 28, 2024

What’s at stake

 

The reductionistic, allopathic model of medicine is deeply flawed and based on outdated assumptions. And it has turned modern health care into an establishment that all too often endangers the very patients it’s supposed to help.

Medicine should be devoted to caring for people. It should be about a human-to-human connection in the process of healing. While some noble practitioners embody these ideals, the overall system has become a “medical-industrial complex”: an intricate web of financial interests involving pharmaceutical companies, doctors, nurses, medical device/equipment suppliers, diagnostics companies, hospitals, medical schools, insurance companies, media companies, politicians, technology companies, scientific journals, and others.1

Those who pull the strings of this web have managed to control society’s belief systems about health and disease; and about germs, infections, contagion, and vaccines. Modern medicine’s core beliefs are often blindly accepted—and even defended—when there is great reason to challenge them. And yet they persist.

The medical-industrial complex not only steers society’s belief systems but also the practice of medicine itself. Making money  often takes precedence over healing, while a deeper spiritual orientation is lacking.

From a financial perspective, healing a person means losing a customer. Having people stay on long-term pharmaceutical medications is a much better outcome than identifying and solving the underlying problem that’s causing symptoms. Thus, for the pharmaceutical industry, it makes sense to fund research on drugs and vaccines rather than uncovering how to empower people to stay healthy on their own. Certainly, the medical system has saved people from life-threatening conditions, but at the same time, it hasn’t focused as much on how it could have prevented those people from becoming deathly ill in the first place. Overall, a chronically sick society is a better economic outcome for the medical-industrial complex than a healthy society is. This dangerous mentality can persist if participants within “the system” act from a physicalist perspective that has lost sight of the greater “cosmic system” that connects us all. As such, a consciousness shift is essential.

In the absence of this shift, hospitals have become factory-like; and doctors and nurses, often unknowingly, have transformed into cogs in a wheel. Perhaps they enter the system with good intentions and genuinely want to help people. But indoctrination takes hold quickly, and the prospect of going against the grain is harrowing and outright intimidating. Speaking out carries great risk, so it’s easier to just play it safe, not make a fuss, and unquestioningly follow the protocols. Patients who have experienced this dynamic can attest without hesitation: compassion in the mainstream medical system is sometimes conspicuously absent. In part, this might be due to a flawed philosophical outlook, but it’s also a symptom of an unhealthy society. Given how many sick people are flooding the system, it’s often a practical challenge for health-care providers to treat each patient with appropriate care and attention.

With these dynamics at play, many health-care providers do not focus on providing holistic solutions. Stale and simplistic narratives about why people get sick have transformed into invincible dogmas such that the only solution to illness is a magical pharmaceutical  bullet. In other words, an external source must be the savior, and the patient is a mere victim.

Uncovering the true determinants of health and disease has become secondary, whereas it should be the primary objective in a system truly focused on well-being. That’s where health-care providers, in theory, should be directing their attention. In essence, allopathy often focuses on what’s under the microscope, rather than what’s within the “macroscope.”2

New Zealand surgeon-turned-naturopath Ulrich Williams saw this clearly back in 1937. He suggested basic principles that can redirect our current paradigm—and the thinking that underlies it—into something much better:

The orthodox healing system has failed for reasons that easily can be defined….We have failed because from our too narrow and materialistic outlook we have conceived of disease as something attacking us from without, due to germs; whereas disease whether of body, mind, soul, or estate, is mostly a gradual degenerative process going on within, due to failure to comply with the requirements of well-being. We fail because in the zones of physical limit we look outside ourselves for cause and cure of troubles arising within. We have failed because the whole complicated system of orthodox modern diagnosis and treatment is based upon a misconception that mistakes the symptom for the disease; and tinkering with effects while the cause is ignored and allowed to continue always has been and will be followed by deplorable consequences.3Furthermore, moving toward a better system of medicine might require looking back at ancient methods from a variety of cultures all over the world. Dr. Shamini Jain mentions Indian Ayurvedic, classical Chinese, and Tibetan teachings in particular, summarizing their approach and the implications thereof:

The body has an innate ability to heal itself, and this process can be encouraged by fostering proper flow of  life force energy, which serves as a conduit between consciousness and physicality.

These Eastern teachings provide an underlying model to help us better understand and explore communications between the spirit, the body, and our environment. Disease is considered disharmony that might exist within one’s self or between one’s self and his or her surrounding environment. Thus, healing is not about curing yourself from something that is “not you” but understanding the patterns that might be causing you disharmony and therefore illness. The vital life force is a bridge that allows the healer—ultimately you—to better understand the nature of that disharmony and bring harmony back to your system.4

While we may not yet know exactly what a new paradigm of medicine will look like, at least we know what it won’t look like.5 Armed with a general compass for rethinking heath care, we have an opportunity to create a brighter future—both on an individual and collective level.

From the perspective of an individual, if we want to be healthy, it’s simply not wise to rely exclusively on the mainstream allopathic system and its health-care providers (perhaps outside of emergency situations). Finding real health solutions requires reconsidering the basic nature of disease.

In their book What Really Makes You Ill?, Dawn Lester and David Parker lay out what they consider to be the four determinants of illness:61. Nutrition

2. Toxic exposures

3. Electromagnetic radiation

4. Stress

 Notice that they don’t focus on germs. Thus, from this perspective, “symptoms” reflect the body’s attempt to heal or detoxify from an underlying ailment in one of those categories. Modern labels of discrete diseases are in many ways arbitrary distinctions for varying symptoms. Those labels often tell us nothing about the real causes of those symptoms.

An even broader way to think about it, in my view, is that ill health comes from:

1. Physical injury and/or

2. Psychospiritual injury

The first category can be a physical ailment (from, say, sports), but it also can relate to other aspects of physicality such as poor diet, environmental toxicity, electromagnetic toxicity, and so on. The second category relates to one’s mental state, unresolved trauma, belief systems, emotions, “spiritual” connection, a sense of purpose in life, and even multidimensional matters that we don’t fully understand.

What, then, should we do to stay healthy? Holistic practitioners might vary in their specific recommendations—such as detoxification protocols, dietary recommendations, herb and/or supplement recommendations, electromagnetic-protection solutions, body-alignment and somatic modalities, spiritual-practice suggestions, and so forth. But there seem to be some basic lifestyle recommendations, that they suggest across the board, which anyone can implement, such as eating nutritious and clean food; drinking clean water; avoiding toxins; sleeping well; exercising; getting sunlight and fresh air; avoiding excessive electromagnetic radiation; minimizing toxic forms of light (such as blue light from electronic screens); spending time in nature; having positive relationships; working on processing and clearing trauma; practicing forgiveness; feeling emotions rather than suppressing them; setting appropriate boundaries in relationships; laughing; following passions and joy; experiencing gratitude; being authentic; engaging in centering practices like meditation or breathing exercises; feeling a strong spiritual connection; discovering and following one’s “soul  purpose”; giving, receiving, and embodying love; and so on.7 Maintaining good health might be much simpler than we’ve been led to believe by a pharmaceutical-dominated paradigm. These basic practices, which are empowering and largely inexpensive, enable independence from the overarching societal power structure. Personal sovereignty isn’t possible without taking the reins over one’s own health.

On a collective level, this is an essential point. We saw during the COVID-19 era that a “crisis” can be used as a pretext for taking citizens’ rights away. What better way to control the global population than to bring about massive amounts of health-related fear—even for imaginary causes—wherein the only solution is the remedy provided by the authorities. The weaponization of fear around climate change has been taking on a similar quality.8

In fact, both are central pieces of the World Economic Forum’s “Great Reset”—which was formally announced in June 2020 by Klaus Schwab and then–Prince Charles, and was described, in detail, in Schwab and Thierry Malleret’s July 2020 book COVID-19: The Great Reset. As discussed in my book An End to the Upside Down Reset (2023), COVID-19 presented an opportunity to reset all aspects of society in a manner that a small number of people consider to be ideal. Perhaps the most significant point about the Great Reset is that it’s not an agenda that emphasizes liberty or human flourishing; rather, it’s much more focused on limiting freedom under the guise of “compassion.” Thus, we are currently living through an attempted reshaping of society, and medicine is one of the key levers that’s being used to usher it in.

As I’ve often contended, these matters extend beyond physical concerns; they are part of what appears to be a “spiritual war.” One might wonder if the corrupt dynamics of the medical-industrial complex trace their roots to nonphysical forces of evil—the ultimate “string-pullers,” invisible to our ordinary perceptual abilities. Such forces are drawn to power, and they seem to thrive off of the suffering of others; perhaps they even feed off of negative energy. Thus, the notions of eugenics and depopulation—in other words, culling the population like cattle—doesn’t seem like a stretch. A  medical system that’s ostensibly supposed to save people, but in fact ends up harming them, is the perfect instrument for such an objective. And furthermore, a weakened and unhealthy populace is much easier to control than a strong and healthy one.

Even transhumanism—merging humans with artificial intelligence and altering our natural form—is often being promoted. The spiritual impact of such activities on the bodily vessel might be more hazardous than scientists currently acknowledge.

On a related note, in 1917 the mystic Rudolf Steiner foresaw the following:

The time will come—and it may not be far off—when…people will say: It is pathological for people to even think in terms of spirit and soul. “Sound” people will speak of nothing but the body. It will be considered a sign of illness for anyone to arrive at the idea of any such thing as a spirit or a soul….The soul will be made nonexistent with the aid of a drug. Taking a “sound point of view,” people will invent a vaccine to influence the organism as early as possible, preferably as soon as it is born, so that this human body never even gets the idea that there is a soul and a spirit….

I have told you that the spirits of darkness are going to inspire their human hosts, in whom they will be dwelling, to find a vaccine that will drive all inclination towards spirituality out of people’s souls when they are very young.9 [emphasis added]

The dystopian books Brave New World and 1984 no longer seem like fictional possibilities for our future—and from a metaphysical perspective, such enslavement could have even greater consequences than we know.

Dr. Anthony Fauci has openly discussed a “next pandemic.”10 Future global health scares seem inevitable, and COVID-19 showed us that the world can be shut down in an instant if the authority figures choose to do so. People’s livelihoods can be determined on  the basis of whether they take an experimental injection or not. A “positive” result on an unreliable test can lead to a mandatory quarantine sentence. Quarantine camps were even built as a result of COVID-19.11

Therefore, with such high stakes, discernment is essential; our ability to identify “wolves in sheep’s clothing” needs to be sharp. A big piece of that is seeing through the dangers and falsities of the allopathic system, upon which many control mechanisms in society are based. That entails breaking out of the hypnotic spell of conditioned belief systems and engaging in independent, critical thinking rather than parroting the opinions of “experts.” From a higher perspective, this process could be viewed as “evolutionary”: in order for us to transcend the darkness of our world, we must be able to accurately perceive deception and navigate accordingly. We must learn to see through “false light.” Therefore, the evil forces within the spiritual war either stimulate our growth and make us stronger (if we are able to catch on); or, if we don’t, they’ll consume us.

During his near-death experiences decades ago, Dannion Brinkley, the author of Saved by the Light (1994), was shown hints about our society’s future. As he summarizes the message in a 2023 interview: “I’ve been saying this for forty-eight years: the battle of humanity will be fought in health care.”12 [emphasis added]

The question then arises: How should we approach this battle? Thomas Friese provides sound guidance in his 2013 preface to Ernst Jünger’s The Forest Passage (1951). May these words echo in our consciousness as we navigate the treacherous waters ahead:

The forces seeking to exploit man today are but the latest incarnations of forces that have threatened individual freedom throughout history….

While [an individual’s journey to freedom] may bring collateral benefits for society, in particular for other individuals, it does not aim primarily at world-improvement: the collective, as a whole, is essentially beyond redemption, a priori a lost cause. It is only individuals,…rebels  within society, that can hope, as exceptions, to escape the coercion, to “save their own souls.” The…rebel[s] [battle] the Leviathan not in the hopes of defeating it—for it eventually collapses under its own enormous weight—though [they] may promote this inevitable demise by inflicting strategic damage on it, and [they] can already help define and introduce the seeds of new freedoms for a post-Leviathan world. Rather, the… rebel[s] [have] two other immediate motivations in the here and now: first, to save [themselves]…and second, and not unrelated, to obey [their] conscience…which feels natural concern for its fellow human beings.13

An End to UpsideDown Medicine

Contagion, Viruses, and Vaccines—and Why Consciousness Is Needed for a New Paradigm of Health

Mark Gober