To be is to be contingent: nothing of which it can be said that "it is" can be alone and independent. But being is a member of paticca-samuppada as arising which contains ignorance. Being is only invertible by ignorance.

Destruction of ignorance destroys the illusion of being. When ignorance is no more, than consciousness no longer can attribute being (pahoti) at all. But that is not all for when consciousness is predicated of one who has no ignorance than it is no more indicatable (as it was indicated in M Sutta 22)

Nanamoli Thera
Showing posts with label paranormal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label paranormal. Show all posts

Monday, November 16, 2026

Russell Targ's Third Eye Spies

 FOREWORD

I was an Army psychic spy. Yes, really! For the military. A psychic spy. For nearly all of the seven years that I was a captain in the US Army, I was first trained and then used my extrasensory perceptual (ESP) abilities to project my consciousness to locations both foreign and domestic. These were abilities I never even knew I had before I was recruited to learn how to use them. Specifically, I am talking about what is known as “remote viewing,” or “RV” for short.

As Russell notes early in this book, the term “remote viewing” was coined by legendary New York artist and parapsychologist Ingo Swann. (Full disclosure: Swann taught me remote viewing, and I will be ever grateful, both to him and to the taxpayers who funded it.)

To be succinct: remote viewing is a skill that capitalizes on an aspect of consciousness we all possess. We have it simply by virtue of being human, and it allows us to experience, perceive, and describe people, places, and things that are hidden from us by distance, shielding, or even the past or (to some degree) the future. I often refer to this skill as a form of “disciplined clairvoyance.”

I was one of several military officers, enlisted soldiers, and government civilians who were taught to use this form of “disciplined clairvoyance” to spy out Soviet research facilities, advanced weapons, and scientific laboratories. We “looked” for hostages taken by Hezbollah in Lebanon, hunted narcotics traffickers off America's coasts, “observed” Chinese nuclear tests, “invaded” the Kremlin, and dug into emerging defense technology—both ours and the “other guy's.”

There were times, of course, when this psychic skill didn't work. On the other hand, there were many occasions when it absolutely worked—sometimes spectacularly. (Similar impressive results are presented in this book.) Given that skeptics laugh at the idea that ESP should ever work, the amount of concrete evidence we developed left us laughing last and best.

In large measure, I owe my career as a psychic spy to the author of this book, Russell Targ. Russ, along with his colleagues at the highly regarded California think tank SRI International had the courage to swim upstream against the tide of orthodox science. Their task was to fill a hole in our defenses that the US intelligence community could not itself plug. If they had not so successfully plugged that hole, I never would have had the opportunity to become a psychic spy.

In the 1960s and early 1970s, the Central Intelligence Agency fretted about massive Soviet military spending in fields that Western “experts” generally dismissed as “paranormal.” (To them, “paranormal” is a synonym for “fantasy.”) This worry led the CIA to physicist Hal Puthoff's laboratory door at SRI in the fall of 1972. The agents gave him a check for $50,000 as seed money and asked him to set up a program investigating the kinds of paranormal phenomena on which the Soviets already had a head start.

Russell, who had a long-standing interest in these topics, had recently become acquainted with Hal and, now that there was an actual “program” to join, he was invited to SRI to partner with Hal in creating what ultimately evolved into the Star Gate psychic spy program. Star Gate was run by the US government for the next twenty-three years, ending only with the conclusion of the Cold War. Thus history was made.

My task here is to briefly introduce you to this marvelous book, clarify the context, and set the stage for what follows.

When journalists write about the “CIA Star Gate Program,” they often start off confused, and it just gets worse from there. They think that because the Program has a singular name, it must have had a monolithic structure. But that is wrong. The first point to make is that the program only was called Star Gate late in its existence. Before that it was known under a variety of arcane titles, such as Scanate, Grill Flame, and Sun Streak, to name a few. The Star Gate moniker stuck because it was the last name by which the program was known.

It's best if you think of Star Gate as two parallel, yet connected efforts—two forking trunks of the same tree, if you will. The first trunk was Star Gate's research arm, created to investigate psychic phenomena, specifically remote viewing. Begun and home-based at SRI and helmed by Russell and Hal, this effort was funded under contract initially by the CIA and served as the foundation from which everything else developed.

After the CIA was forced to abandon the SRI program in 1975, the source of money and guidance switched to various Department of Defense (DoD) activities, starting with the Air Force, then the Army, and finally the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA). (Russell often mentions his great respect for Lieutenant General James Williams, under whom the longstanding relationship between DIA and remote viewing began.)

Ironically, the CIA never again “ran” the Star Gate Program. Though Star Gate is widely called the CIA's program, the agency's only additional role was to do away with it in June 1995. To those of us with ties to Star Gate, this was much like giving the beloved dog that you can no longer care for to a trusted neighbor, whose first act on taking ownership was to shoot it. Hard feelings? Yeah, maybe some.

Once established, the SRI effort (later moved to Science Applications International Corporation, or SAIC, under Dr. Ed May) was to make its findings available to its customer, the DoD, for use in the other branch of Star Gate, the military “psychic spy” unit. Some operational (that is, practical) work was done at SRI, but the majority of what Russell and his colleagues did there was scientific. It is largely those results and his experiences in helping generate them that Russ mines for our benefit in this book.

After a sojourn at Wright-Patterson Air Force Base under Air Force civilian analyst Dale Graff, the military branch of Star Gate came to rest at Fort George G. Meade, Maryland, in the late 1970s. It lived its life there through several incarnations (I won't bore you with the bureaucratic details).

First administered by the Army's Intelligence and Security Command, administrative ownership of the unit was passed to DIA headquarters at Bolling Air Force Base, District of Columbia, at the start of 1986, though the actual remote viewers stayed at Ft. Meade.

We Star Gate viewers performed over 2,500 intelligence collection missions for two dozen intelligence community and military agencies. Just some of the list includes the National Security Agency, the Joint Chiefs of Staff, the US Secret Service, the DEA, US Forces Korea, the Army's Intelligence Threat and Analysis Center, and the National Security Council. Our most prolific requestor, ironically, was the organization that in the end shut Star Gate down—the Central Intelligence Agency.

Until Congress transferred Star Gate to the CIA (leading, as mentioned, to the program's immediate demise), the DIA directed and funded the research at SRI (and later SAIC). This research significantly advanced remote viewing and other consciousness science. The world owes Russell and his colleagues a debt of gratitude for the profound insights from which we all may benefit.

Russell, though, had his own plans. Seeking a more relaxed climate for consciousness research than the often stifling classified security envelope government contracts demand, Russell left after ten years at SRI in 1982 and branched out into other activities. He has never looked back.

In my talks with him about this project, Russell often calls this a “remote viewing picture-book.” Director/producer Lance Mungia's successful documentary film Third Eye Spies, in which Russ plays the central role, gave Russ the idea for a companion book. And this book, itself now appropriately titled Third Eye Spies, serves as a canvass on which to assemble and add to the vignettes and interviews that emerged in the film.

Gathered here are remote viewing stories and images, some never before published, all brought together in a form more accessible than film can sometimes be. After all, even if the power is out, we can still pick up a book from the shelf anytime we want to refresh our memory or remind ourselves of something we loved in it. Try doing the same with a film.

Perhaps some of the most fascinating parts of Third Eye Spies (the book) are the chapters on precognition (in other words, “seeing” events or getting information from the future) and on how to actually launch a basic remote viewing experience for yourself. The latter is particularly helpful. Many folks want to try this skill, but have no idea where to begin. Russell provides friendly and—more importantly—easy guidance for people who have never tried remote viewing before and want to take their first steps. He gives you the basic secrets that he has successfully used over and over again in his many live workshops and appearances to help folks from Italian housewives to American businesspeople have their first empowering remote viewing experiences.

Russell now finds himself on the long end of life. One senses in him the urge many of us feel, once we realize we have unexpectedly become “chronologically challenged” by age, to document important things that didn't quite fit together in past tellings of our histories. This book is memorable for many reasons, and I invite you to give it the chance it deserves.

Paul H. Smith, PhD (Major, US Army, ret.)

Cedar City, Utah

April 2022

INTRODUCTION

I have been successfully teaching people how to get in touch with their psychic abilities for more than fifty years. This began in 1972 when I co-founded an extrasensory perception (ESP) research program at Stanford Research Institute. It was funded by the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA). We performed many fascinating double-blind experiments for the CIA, with very successful results. Among these, we described a hidden Russian weapons factory in Siberia and a failed Chinese atomic bomb test, located a downed Russian bomber in Africa, and located several kidnapped US officials. One was the ambassador to Iran during the Iran hostage crisis. Another was an American general kidnapped in Italy by the Red Brigades radical terrorist group. Early in the program, we even identified the ringleader of the Patty Hearst kidnapping, for which we received a commendation from the Berkeley Police Department.

This program was so successful that in 1978 the United States Army invited us to train six Army intelligence officers to create an Army psychic corps known as Project Star Gate. Star Gate provided useful secret and top-secret information to the military until 1995. One of my purposes here is to correct the misconception that psi, a more modern term for ESP, is weak and unreliable. On the contrary, in our laboratory experiments and classified operational tasks, psi was found to be surprisingly reliable, accurate, and useful. In this book, I will introduce you to the most successful and gifted remote viewers who participated in our program, many of whom had never done any psi-oriented work like this before.

Remote viewing is the ability to mentally experience and describe distant or unseen people, places, events, and objects from the past or present or future. The proof for ESP is so strong it would be statistically unreasonable to deny it. In data from laboratories all over the world, we see that the accuracy and reliability of remote viewing is not in any way degraded by distance. It is no more difficult to describe Soviet Siberia than it is to describe a park across the street. Similarly, it is no harder to describe an event hours or days in the future, than it is to describe a present-time event. For example, we were able to successfully forecast changes in the silver commodity market nine times in a row, earning us and our investor a quarter million dollars. So, the future can be known.

The world around us may look finite, but fifty years of research into psychic abilities and verified out-of-body experiences have convinced me that our awareness is limitless in space and time, and therefore we are also limitless. This is the basic finding from our two decades of remote viewing research at Stanford Research Institute (SRI). Through my work in this area, I have taught thousands of people all over the world how to get in touch with the part of themselves that is psychic. I hope this remote viewing “picture book” will help you do the same.

Remote viewing teaches that you are not just a physical body—not just meat and potatoes. Who we are is indestructible, timeless awareness and not what you see in the morning mirror. If you think that who you are is what you see in the mirror, then you are in for a lot of unnecessary suffering. I would say that the meaning of life is to experience our primordial timeless awareness and to teach that. I hope to give you an experience of that in this book.

Friday, November 13, 2026

The Brooklyn Enigma

 

My discovery of the Brooklyn Enigma was a mistake.

On one of my recent research trips to Green-Wood Cemetery, I was scouting graves and stories for my upcoming tour, Murder and Mayhem, Scandal and Spiritualism. I was using one of the cemetery-issued tourist maps, the kind you might be familiar with if you’ve ever visited on your own. I always try to steer clear of any points of interest listed on these — I call my tour “Green-Wood Off The Map” — but I rely on them while scouting, marking them up with notes and names and exes, like strange treasure maps. I have dozens of the little green things in my office, and on this particular day I must have grabbed one that was very old indeed, because I noticed something unusual on it, something I’d never seen on any of the more recent maps.* In one section of the cemetery was the grave of a person identified merely as “THE BROOKLYN ENIGMA.” And that’s how I stumbled on the story of Mollie Fancher, the fasting girl, also known as the Brooklyn Enigma:

“In 1864, sixteen-year-old Mollie Fancher was thrown from a horse while riding in Prospect Park, and her head struck against the pavement. Thereafter she was subject to fainting spells and violent headaches. A year later, on June 8th, 1865, she was dragged a block on the Fulton Street trolley car, which she had attempted to leave while it was still in motion. Her spine was injured, and her nervous system completely deranged. She was able to be about, though ill, until February 3rd, 1866. On the morning of that day… she suddenly shrieked, stood on her toes, and spun around like a top. Then she bent forward, clasped her feet in both hands, and began rolling about the kitchen floor like a hoop. She was carried to her bed, and didn’t leave it for fifty years and eight days, until she died, on February 11, 1916.” (Herbert Asbury, All Around The Town)

While spending fifty years in bed is an enviable enough feat in itself, Mollie’s story only gets even more interesting. While confined to her bed, Mollie developed highly sensitive psychical powers, and her “supernatural powers, clairvoyant gifts, and uncanny exploits” made her home on Gates Avenue a tourist attraction.

Baffling physicians, astounding spectators, and providing newspapermen with endless fodder, Mollie Fancher grew so famous that P.T. Barnum reportedly begged her to tour with him under his management (despite his offer of a swans-down mattress and gold plated bed, she refused). Some of her remarkable feats included finding mislaid articles, describing the “dress and doings” of friends and relatives fifty miles away, predicting thunderstorms several hours before they happened, and reading the contents and letters of unopened books merely by running her hands over them. She could also identify callers at the door before they entered the house. Some attributed her clairvoyant powers to repeated conversations with the dead, or with angels, and some claimed she had been to heaven and back several times.

Throughout her illness, Mollie went in and out of trances, some of which lasted only a few hours, some which continued for days, weeks, and even months. The longest trance lasted nine years:

“Throughout the nine years her eyes remained closed, and for six years her body was cold and rigid, there was no evidence of respiration, her physicians could detect only a slight pulse, and she never spoke. Occasionally she was fed by force, but for some months at a time she was given no nourishment except a little water. During the last three years of the long trance, Miss Fancher’s body relaxed to some extent, she spoke once in a while, and she was able to move her left arm with considerable freedom. In that time, she wrote 6,500 letters, a score of poems and lyric prayers [and] made a satin waist and pleated lining for her coffin,” among other feats, including crocheting and making wax flowers. (Herbert Asbury, All Around The Town)

So somehow, Mollie Fancher managed to be more productive during a prolonged trance than I have been… pretty much ever.

Three years after she woke up from her nine-year trance, she also developed five distinct personalities called Idol, Sunbeam, Ruby, Pearl, and Rosebud. My personal favorite of these is Ruby, who is described as being, “dashing and vivacious, even hoydenish, and very gifted in repartee.”

By 1894, her health was on the mend, and the public had moved on to newer and fresher sensations. She was thereafter, “nothing more than a bedridden old woman with a passion for fancy embroidery and crocheting.” (Herbert Asbury, All Around The Town)

One aspect of Mollie which Asbury’s somewhat hilarious account glosses over is the idea of “the fasting girl.” Fasting girls were a Victorian phenomena of girls who survived on little to no food and claimed to have spiritual or mystical powers. In Fasting Girls: The History of Anorexia Nervosa, Joan Jacobs Brumberg ascribes much of their claims to fraud, “hysteria” (in 19th century parlance) or anorexia. These girls may have seen themselves as spiritual mystics in the vein of Catholic saints like Catherine of Siena. In one case, that of Sarah Jacob of Wales, these girls literally starved themselves to death (her parents were later convicted of manslaughter). Others were exposed as frauds. While Mollie Fancher was never proven conclusively to be a fraud, neither were any of her claims of culinary abstinence ever proven definitively. 

Whether fraud, anorexic, or just plain crazy, there is no doubt that Mollie Fancher was a fascinating Brooklynite, one who reminds us of a time when people were keenly interested in the spiritual and mystical, and were ready to believe than an ordinary teenage girl from Gates Avenue may have visited heaven and returned several times over. I’ll be exploring the darker and stranger sides of life in Victorian New York in this Sunday’s Murder and Mayhem, Scandal and Spiritualism tour of Green-Wood Cemetery, where you too can see Mollie’s final resting place. You can buy tickets to the tour here, and if you can’t make it this Sunday, I’ll be running it the first Sunday of every month through November 2014.

* Incidentally, though I can’t tell you exactly when they updated this map, I can tell you that it didn’t have Basquiat labeled on it. I don’t ever remember visiting the cemetery in a pre-Basquiat era, nor do I recall how or when I got this map, or ever seeing it before. Which is all part, I suppose, of the enigma.

https://boroughsofthedead.com/

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Any scientific evidence for psychic phenomena?

 DAVID: A number of scientists that I’ve interviewed have told me that they didn’t think that there was any scientific evidence for psychic phenomena.


What would you say to these scientists about research in psychic phenomena?

DEAN: The usual reason for such comments is that these folks are simply telling the truth. They are not aware of the evidence. That’s an expression of ignorance, which is fine. We’re all ignorant about lots of things. But the fact is that there is an enormous amount of evidence for anyone who wishes to go looking for it.

Here’s one way of thinking about this. Rupert Sheldrake was visiting here [the Institute of Noetic Sciences] this week. Last week he was involved in a debate on the evidence for telepathy at the Royal Society of Arts in London.

His opponent was a biologist named Lewis Wolpert, who is a well-known skeptic and promoter of science in England. In the debate Rupert was presenting the experimental evidence for telepathy, and Wolpert acted as the devil’s advo-cate. Wolpert’s position was that telepathy doesn’t exist because we know it doesn’t exist, and anyway there’s no evidence that it exists. If you expand those words to twenty minutes of repetition around the same theme, then that was his position.
Rupert, on the other hand, presented one study after the other—showing here’s some evidence, here’s some more, and here’s some more, and so on.

The debate was cast in terms of a scientific court, where the members of the audience—about a hundred people—were the jury, and there was a judge that would rule on the case. Well, 80 percent of the people agreed with Rupert.

The overwhelming majority was such a shock to the reporters present that a few days later it appeared as a news item in the journal Nature  with the title, “Telepathic Charm Seduces Audience at Paranormal Debate.” The article reported that the debate had won hands down in favor of telepathy. So, this is just a microcosm of what goes on all the time. Many scientists are unaware of the evidence because they either wish to not pay attention to it or because it just isn’t visible in their orbit.

There’s another aspect to this, which occurs when you discuss taboo topics.

There’s a big difference about whether something will be mentioned in private or in public. Rupert and I were comparing notes on this. We both found that, in private, most people—including the vast majority of scientists—will admit that, even though they may not know the literature very well, they’ve had personal experiences, or someone that they know and trust has reported things that do not seem like they can be accounted for by the usual explanations, like coincidence or wishful thinking. So, privately, many people are willing to admit that there’s something interesting going on, far more than publicly. As soon as you are going to commit something to paper, or to the press in some way, you become more circumspect about what you’re going to say. It’s a lot easier to then act the role of the skeptical scientist and say, Well, I don’t know of any evidence, which is portrayed as a dismissal of the topic rather than what it really is, an admission of ignorance.

Many of these scientists are not aware of my book, or any of the other books written on this topic, which as you know show in great gory detail that we do have ways of studying these things. We may not have very good theoretical explanations for them yet, but the fact is, for over a century, we’ve had empirical ways of studying psi. And if we believe in empiricism as reflecting something about what’s really going on out there, then there’s very little doubt that these phenomena do exist.

DAVID: It really is interesting how strangely taboo this particular research topic is. Most scientists that I talk to are either unaware of this research, or they immediately dismiss it.

DEAN: It’s partially because there’s kind of an understanding that if experiments of this type were really true, then they should have already appeared in Nature or Science  because it’s truly revolutionary. But what many scientists working in the mainstream don’t appreciate is that there are publication biases that prevent certain topics from appearing in the mainstream scientific press. Of course, anyone who’s been working in a controversial field knows this immediately, that certain things simply cannot make it to press. But if you haven’t worked in an area of high controversy you would never have any reason to suspect this.

You’d have no reason to guess that prejudice exists in science like it does anywhere else. So it’s frustrating, of course. Rupert and I have talked about this extensively, and we’re trying to crack this nut, but it’s a slow process. It’s like affirmative action: Prejudice carries enormous inertia, and it will not go away unless an affirmative stance is taken to counter it. Unfortunately, in science, there is no equivalent of affirmative action. So it can take a very very long time, as history has shown, for unpopular ideas to finally make it though. As Max Planck said, “Science progresses by funerals.”
. . .
DAVID: Why do you think the various psychic abilities that humans are capable of evolved to begin with?

DEAN: That’s a good question. It’s not clear to me at all that it evolved, because I think we’re dealing with something which is before evolution in a sense. It’s part of the fabric of the universe. It has to be, because if it was something that evolved, it would suggest that we have created ways of transcending space and time, which doesn’t make sense. How can we create something which, from a conventional point of view, would be a violation of “laws of science”? It can’t be that way.

So, another way of thinking of it is that we make the presumption—and one that most scientists have faith in—that the universe was here before people showed up, that we didn’t create it as a fact of thinking about it, and suddenly it all fell into place. In fact, we have to take that faith, otherwise science would stop, because it becomes a solipsistic universe, and anything we wish to be true would be true. So you start from the assumption that the world is given in some way and that we’re evolving in it. And if there’s any evolution at all, it’s the evolution of a realization that the fabric of the universe is not the way that Newton saw it. Or actually it is in his mystical sense, but not in the classical physics sense of the Newtonian-Cartesian world.

DAVID: So you see it as being an inherent part of the basic structure of the universe?

DEAN: Yes, there’s some aspects of the world for which we now have the term “nonlocality,” which nobody understands very well, but seems to be a fundamental, underlying aspect of the universe. If that is in fact the case, as it seems it must be, given theory and experiments, then in many ways psychic phenomena is something you would be compelled to predict. You would predict that occasionally people would have some sense or experience of this kind of interconnectedness.
. . .
DAVID: What are some of the practical applications of parapsychological research?

DEAN: Well, realistically we don’t know. Any time science stumbles across some new understanding of the world, it typically gets spun out into a few novel applications at the time when the invention or the discovery was made. But no one had any idea what would happen down the line.  (...)

From An Interview with Dean Radin

Dean Radin is a psychologist and engineer who has specialized in the study of anomaliesassociated with human consciousness, principally so-called psychic (psi) phenomena. He has investigated telepathy, psychokinesis, and precognition at Princeton University, theUniversity of Edinburgh, Bell Laboratories, SRI International, and as part of a classified program for the U.S. government, and he was president of the Parapsychological Association affiliated with the American Association for the Advancement of Science.

Dr. Radin earned his Ph.D. in psychology and M.S. in engineering, respectively, at theUniversity of Illinois, Champaign. His research awards include the Parapsychological Association’s 1996 Outstanding Achievement Award and the 1996 Rhine Research Center’s Alexander Imich Award for advances in experimental parapsychology. Dr. Radin is Senior Scientist at the Institute of Noetic Sciences. He is also the authoror coauthor of over two hundred scientific papers and popular articles as well as one of the most popular scientific books on psi research:  The Conscious Universe: The Scientific Truth of Psychic Phenomena.

Conversations on the Edge of the Apocalypse
Interviews by  David Jay Brown

Parrot Nkisi more clever than Clever Hans 😉


DAVID: How did you become interested in the unexplained powers of animals?

RUPERT: My interest in the unexplained powers of animals goes right back to my childhood . . . and my interest in homing pigeons. This was really the first area that I started investigating. When I was at Cambridge working on plants I was still very interested in animals, and I used to ask people about homing pigeons. I found that my colleagues in animal behavior really just didn’t know how pigeons found their way home. They didn’t know how navigation occurred in animals. Then, when I was thinking about it, I had the idea that maybe the pigeons were linked to their home in some way through a field, a kind of morphic field. That led me to think of an experiment which is the opposite of the normal experiments with pigeons. The normal experiments involve taking the pigeon from the home. My experiment was the opposite—taking the home from the pigeon. So even while I was at Cambridge doing work on plants, I actually started a project on homing pigeons. I set up a homing pigeon project with a mobile loft in 1973 on a friend’s estate in Ireland.
So I started working on this unexplained aspect of animal behavior right then. This got me into the whole subject of other unexplained aspects of animal behavior. The more I asked people, the more I thought about it, the more such examples came to mind—including the phenomenon of animals knowing when their owners are coming home. So that became the basis really for my investigations that I set forth in my book Seven Experiments That Could Changethe World, published in 1994, in which three unexplained areas of animal behavior are three of the seven experiments—dogs that know when their owners are come home, homing pigeons, and the social behavior of termites. That started me off on a whole new phase of research looking experimentally into these unexplained animal abilities.

DAVID: Why do you think studying the human–animal pet bond is particularly important?

RUPERT: Because there’s a lot we don’t understand about animal behavior, and the animals we know best are the pets that we keep in our houses. There’s a huge amount of information available on these pets from people who keep them. We know far more about them than we do about wild animals—which, after all, we don’t watch that much—or laboratory animals, which are kept under extremely artificial conditions. The behavior of laboratory animals is usually not really observed very closely, and their behavior is always very constrained by the cages they’re kept in and the artificial situations they live in.

Domestic animals are the animals we know best, and which have most to teach us I think.

They also form bonds with their owners, which mean that people are not just external observers, they interact with their animals. This interaction is very interesting to people. It’s one reason they keep pets. After all, they want to have interactions with their animals, and they’re interested in it. So this provides a huge amount of potential material for research. By working with pets, and the bonds between people and pets, we can find out a great deal just by asking people what they’ve noticed. I have a huge database with now more than five thousand cases of unexplained behavior in pets and other domestic animals, and this information really is the starting point for my natural history of unexplained abilities. In cases where it’s possible to test what people observe about their animals and their behavior, we then move on to do experiments.

DAVID: Can you talk a little bit about some of the latest developments in your research with the unexplained powers of animals?

RUPERT: I summarized the main phase of my research in my book Dogs That Know When Their Owners Are Coming Home  in 1999. Since then I’ve gone on working with animals, most particularly with parrots, and in particular with the parrot Nkisi, belonging to Aimee Morgona in New York. This parrot turns out to be one of the most remarkable animals in the world. He’s an African gray that now has a vocabulary of more than 950 words, which is a world record, and he speaks in sentences. He’s used at least 7,000 different sentences, and he uses language creatively. He also seems to have a concept of self; he uses the word “I.”

So this a completely astonishing situation, of an animal that talks and uses language in a meaningful way—better than chimps or gorillas that have been taught to use language through American Sign Language. He does it in English. You can hear what he says. All this is in itself totally amazing and mind-boggling, but most amazing of all is that he picks up what his owner’s thinking telepathically and comments on her thoughts and intentions—even on her dreams. Sometimes he wakes her up from her sleep by commenting on her dreams. She noticed this and got in touch with me in 2000, and of course I went to visit her as soon as I could in Manhattan to see for myself. And sure enough, what she told me seemed to be true.

We set up a whole series of controlled tests to see if he really could pick up what she was thinking. In these tests we filmed the parrot continuously in one room, and she was in another room—with all the doors closed, on another floor of the house, so there was no sound transmission possible. She looked at a series of photographs that she hadn’t seen before, which were in sealed randomized envelopes. In each trial, she was filmed as she opened an envelope and looked at the picture in it for two minutes. She didn’t say anything. Then we had independent transcription of what the parrot said. Three independent people transcribed it, blind, not knowing what was going on. We then saw whether the words the parrot said matched the picture she was looking at. In some tests the parrot didn’t say anything. But when he did, we could check and see if the words corresponded—and in an astonishingly significant way they did.

In some trials, for example, she was looking at a picture of a man on a phone, and the parrot said, “What’cha doing on the phone?” In other trials she was looking at pictures of flowers, and the parrot said, “Those are flowers. It’s a pic of flies,” and went on talking about flowers. In other trials she was looking at water, and he said the word “water.” When you see the videos it’s pretty obvious that something really astonishing is happening, but of course we had to have them evaluated in an objective way. All the statistics were evaluated independently by a professor of statistics in Amsterdam, and, sure enough, the whole thing is a hugely significant statistically. A paper on this research was published in January 2004 in the Journal of Scientific Exploration, and the text is available on my Web site for anyone interested in the details.

From An Interview with Rupert Sheldrake in the book

Conversations on the Edge of the Apocalypse
Interviews by  David Jay Brown 

Monday, November 9, 2026

Spirit Release Therapy

 A REVISED EPISTEMOLOGY FOR AN UNDERSTANDING OF SPIRIT RELEASE THERAPY DEVELOPED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK OF F.W.H. MYERS


By  Terence James Palmer

Abstract

In this thesis I argue the case for a revised epistemology that will enable medical practice to understand more fully the relevance and validity of Spirit Release Therapy (SRT), as a clinical approach to releasing alleged discarnate spirits from the living, in its application for the treatment of a wide range of psychological and physiological disorders.

SRT is a modern clinical alternative to religious exorcism for the release of spirit entities from patients that has been emerging in psychiatry and clinical psychology since the early part of the twentieth century, especially in North and South America and in Western Europe. In contrast to positivist scientific assumptions that spirits are created in the minds of the superstitious or the mentally ill, SRT finds earthbound spirits of the deceased that are found to be attached in some way to the living. It treats these spirits with equal compassion to those presenting patients who are unwilling hosts to them. This compassionate approach of SRT contrasts with that of the Roman Catholic tradition which casts out spirits deemed to be ‘evil’ using its Rite of Exorcism. The general reaction from modern medicine to the proposition that spirits exist, is to reject it because there is no scientific framework that can accommodate it. Although there is no consensus within the Christian tradition that affirms the existence of autonomous spirits (with many believing in the reality of spirits and evil as symbolic and not metaphysical truths), the Catholic tradition relies on faith and non-rational beliefs in its justification for the eradication of what it consequently regards as inherently diabolical entities.

There is therefore a dichotomy between modern medicine and religious belief, but I shall argue that the gulf between these opposing positions can be bridged through an epistemological approach that is both grounded in subjective experience and validated by scientific enquiry. In this thesis I examine the relevance of this epistemological approach to the reality of spirit possession (and the practical procedures adopted in SRT for the possible dispossession of spirits) through an analysis of the conceptual framework and scientific methods of Frederic Myers (1843-1901), the 19th century researcher and co-founder of the Society for Psychical Research.

In Part I of this thesis I place spirit possession in a Western social and cultural context where I discuss the contemporary attitudes to spirit possession, which are themselves expressed and reinforced by an epistemology that is grounded in the empiricism of the social sciences, anthropology, psychiatry and the scientific study of beliefs.
Part II explains Myers’ 19th century methods and theories that challenge positivistic empiricism and Part III seeks to update these methods and theories within a 21st century context where they are applied to various enigmatic case studies that challenge modern psychiatry and clinical psychology. I have adopted this structure in order first to highlight some of the deficiencies of current scientific methods in making sense of spirit possession and second to raise important questions that remain unanswered by mainstream psychology, thereby further illuminating the limitations of the epistemological grounding of this discipline.
**
Treatment Approaches to Spirit Possession

Broadly speaking, there are three basic methods that have been traditionally used for treatment of the possessed. The first consists of trying to expel the spirit physically, by such means as bleeding, beating, or whipping the patient (Ellenberger, 1970, p. 13). It is this first method that was adopted by the caregivers in those cases cited by La Fontaine et al (2009).

The second method is to transfer the offending spirit to another body, usually an animal. 6 The third form, and arguably the ‘most frequently applied’ (Ellenberger, 1970, p. 13) is religious exorcism, which is driving the spirit out by conjurations, prayer and ritual. It was this third method that Cuneo sought to examine.

‘Exorcism’ 7 is no less an imprecise term than ‘possession’. It has been used for any prayerful act by a priest with the intention of releasing a demonic entity from a person or place (Baglio, 2009, p. 35). The same word has been used for a procedure lasting minutes and for one lasting weeks in which priests and others are involved in intense interaction with a person or place thought to be possessed or harassed by evil spirits. 8

Modern Christian ministry recognises the problems created by inappropriate beliefs in possession or suspicions that someone is experiencing some kind of paranormal activity and in England there is a national information infrastructure in place that is administered at diocesan level (Perry, 1987). According to Perry, the term ‘deliverance’ is adopted by the Anglican Church in preference to exorcism, and those who are experiencing disturbing psychic or spiritual phenomena are advised by Perry to contact their local parish priest, who will present their case to the specialist spiritual investigation team, which comprises deliverance ministers, psychiatrists and psychic investigators who will be able to advise a course of action depending on whether the disturbance is deemed to be caused by mental illness, paranormal activity or genuine spirit manifestation. 9

In addition to the above mentioned church initiatives, SRT is emerging as a collection of methods and techniques used by an increasing number of practitioners in a variety of professional therapeutic disciplines.

What is Spirit Release Therapy (SRT)? 10

Spirit Release Therapy is a term that is used by some practitioners, but not all, to describe a treatment modality that has evolved from the pioneering clinical experience of medical practitioners, psychiatrists and clinical psychologists who have encountered patients with illnesses that have not responded to traditional psychotherapy or psychiatric methods.

Such pioneers have treated them successfully using their own intuition (described below) and by responding to the expressed needs of the patient and those spirit entities that are encountered in dialogue, rather than treating them according to predetermined theories and the beliefs and assumptions of the therapist. SRT could therefore be described as a person centred, or perhaps a ‘soul’ centred therapy (Zinser, 2010).

Each practitioner of SRT has his or her own definition of their practice, but in order to introduce Spirit Release Therapy here I shall quote the definition offered by William Baldwin who writes:

Spirit Releasement Therapy comes under the broad category of Transpersonal Psychology methods, and is so named because it aims to release from the client / patient / host, any disembodied consciousness of any sort (Baldwin, 1995, p. 207).

Baldwin coined the term ‘releasement’ instead of ‘release’ to differentiate the releasing of spirits from other forms of release, but the term has not generally been adopted by other practitioners because it is seen as an unnecessary complication in the meaning of the term.

Baldwin’s definition is a simple one, but it incorporates a very wide diversity of spirit entities with the term ‘disembodied consciousness of any sort’, and it is part of the SRT practitioner’s art and skill to uncover the type of spirit (or spirits) that are affecting the patient.11 In Baldwin’s definition he uses the word ‘consciousness’ that implies a direct relationship between spirit and consciousness. A spirit can therefore be referred to as a ‘disembodied consciousness’. It is within the conceptual framework of Myers that the relationship between consciousness and spirit is explored in more detail in Parts II and III of this thesis.

Definitions of Autonomous Spirit Entities

SRT practitioners who define spirit entities according to their orientation can be divided loosely into three main groups: those practitioners who release spirit entities from places, such as Archie Lawrie (2003; 2005) of the Scottish Society for Psychical Research (SSPR), and Linda Williamson (2006), and those who release spirits from people such as Carl Wickland (1924), Hans Naegeli-Osjord (1988) and William Baldwin (1995). Others, represented by the man-and-wife team of T & N O’Sullivan (1999), refer to themselves as ‘soul rescuers’ who have learned to tread the path of the shaman where they ‘communicate with the spirits and understand the rules of co-existence with the other world’ (O'Sullivan and O'Sullivan, 1999, xix). Archie Lawrie could be regarded by many as a ‘ghost’ hunter, but in contrast to other investigators of the ‘paranormal’ he enlists the aid of a medium to locate and communicate with those restless spirits that may be referred to as ghosts. Linda Williamson, in her book Ghosts and Earthbound Spirits (2006) remarks that mediums who are either aware of, or communicate with spirits are not able to arrive at a consensus on how ghosts or spirits are defined. Ghosts are generally deemed to be those spirits that inhabit houses, whilst others prefer to call them ‘earthbound spirits’ (Williamson, 2006, 11), and Spiritualists 12 refer to those they communicate with as ‘spirits’ (ibid). Williamson makes the distinction between spirits that exist in a spiritual domain, or spirit-world such as ‘guides’ and the spirits of the deceased and those who remain ‘earthbound’ for a variety of reasons. Williamson asserts that ‘evil’ spirits do exist, but in her own experience poltergeists are not evil but ‘lost and frustrated’ earthbound souls that are trying to attract attention to themselves (ibid. p.11).

The term ‘disembodied consciousness of any sort’, used by Baldwin, can include the spirits of deceased persons, non-human destructive entities that may commonly be referred to in religious language as ‘demons’ (often referred to as Dark Force Entities or ‘DFE’s), negative thought forms created by the host or other living persons, intergenerational curses, elementals, alien life forms and others less clearly defined (Baldwin 1995). Even the discarnate spirits of foetuses that have been terminated can be encountered, and Winafred Lucas (2000) describes techniques for communicating with the spirit of the unborn child and negotiating its return to the spirit world in preference to being forced out with physical abortion, which is traumatic for the spirit of the foetus and may cause it to remain earthbound and attached to the mother (ibid, pp.257-316).

Whether these disembodied conscious forms actually exist in material or metaphysical form or whether they are created from the imagination is a subject of debate even between SRT practitioners (Hunter 2005, pp.156-157). However, the aim of this thesis is to encourage the academic study SRT and its contribution as a therapeutic modality in the alleviation of psychological or physiological distress and to situate it within transpersonal psychology according to the conceptual framework of Frederic Myers. It is from the scientific methods and framework of Myers that the ontological status of discarnate spirit entities may ultimately be determined. Having gained an idea of some of the different uses and definitions of the word ‘spirit’, it remains for me to determine how the word is applied to clinical interventions.

(...)

Differences between SRT and Exorcism

Spirits, whether they be earthbound or co-existing in another dimension or ‘spirit-realm’ are often referred to as ‘attachments’ if they are interacting in some way with a person rather than referring to them as ‘possessing’ spirits. According to Williamson, earthbound spirits are in a confused mental state and many of them do not even realise that they are dead (Williamson, 2006, xi). Possessing spirits on the other hand tend to be deliberate in their intentions and may enter into the subject’s physical and spiritual space and take control over the thoughts and behaviours of the unwilling host, as we shall see in Chapter 3.

SRT can, depending on the belief system or world-view of the patient, be applied in a purely secular, spiritual or religious therapeutic context. Spirit Release Therapy does not impose any theory, concept, philosophy or belief system onto the patient, or try to shoe-horn the patient into a theoretical model of health or sickness. SRT aims to facilitate the healthy well-being of the patient and the ‘attached’ entities through the patient’s and the ‘attachment’s’ own understanding of their experiences and perceptual world-views. This is achieved by allowing the therapist to enter into the integrated world of the patient and the attached spirits through the gateway that we shall identify as a state of consciousness that is different from what is commonly acknowledged as the normal waking state or ‘normal conscious awareness’. The process of accessing mental phenomena that exist beyond the limitations of normal conscious awareness is fundamental in linking SRT practice with the concepts and methods of Myers who identified the Subliminal Self as the greater part of the total mind, and the Supraliminal as the much limited normal waking state (see Chapter 6). SRT is fundamentally different from religious exorcism where spirits are assumed to be ‘evil’ and cast out. William Baldwin’s approach is sympathetic and therapeutic, and in complete contrast to the popular conception of exorcism. Baldwin writes: The widely accepted method of exorcism seemed violent and without compassion, thus I rejected the traditional religious approach (Baldwin, 1995, p. xviii).

Baldwin is one of many professionals including Fiore (1987), Modi (2000) and Naegeli-Osjord (1988), who have had their own belief systems challenged, and have discovered hidden entities of various forms with their patients. A careful examination of all the literature on SRT reveals that all practitioners have had both their scientific and religious beliefs challenged and are essentially guided by their own clients; and depending on the nature of the intrusive spirit, it is dealt with appropriately, and not as a form of exorcism. As a diagnostic system, SRT has been found to be a far more efficient method of identifying the aetiology of a very wide range of illnesses, including mental, emotional and psychosomatic, than traditional medical diagnostics (Modi 1997; 2000), and these claims need to be substantiated by rigorous empirical studies.
(...)
Discovering an Earthbound

Wickland describes his experience of discovering his first discarnate earthbound soul when he was a medical student practising dissection on the corpse of a sixty year old man. On his return home, his wife spontaneously entered into a state of somnambulism, and as Wickland reached out to assist her into a chair a commanding voice issued from her voice box and demanded to know, ‘What do you mean by cutting me?’ (ibid, p.18).

It transpired that the earthbound spirit of the man to whom the body had belonged had followed him home and had taken advantage of Mrs. Wickland’s gift of mediumship18 to communicate his displeasure at being molested without realising that he was dead. Following this incident Wickland and his wife, aided with the guidance of discarnate beings who, Wickland claims, were of a superior intelligence from other realms in our universe, proceeded on a career lasting thirty years to help earthbound spirits of deceased individuals move on to where they were supposed to be on their path of spiritual development. The result of Wickland’s experience is an archive of documented cases of spirit possession and his method of removing them, supported by stenographically recorded sessions of psychical research with his wife acting as the medium of communication between the two worlds of the living and the deceased (ibid, p.21).

Psychosis or Spirit Attachment?

Among Wickland’s recorded cases are several where a patient who had been diagnosed with psychosis was cured following a successful spirit release session. These cases are of particular interest because they represent a group of patients whose suffering is at the extreme end of the scale of diagnosed mental illnesses and are the most difficult to treat using traditional medical and psychotherapeutic methods. They are therefore essential examples to illustrate the efficacy of SRT in treating illness that is automatically assumed to be mental illness by medical science. As an example, Wickland cites his case of ‘Mrs. M’:

One summer evening we were called to the home of ‘Mrs. M’, a lady of culture and refinement; she was a musician of high rank and when the social demands made upon her proved too great she suffered a nervous breakdown. She had become intractable and for six weeks had been in such a raving condition that her physicians had been unable to relieve her, and day and night nurses were in constant attendance.

We found the patient sitting up in bed, crying one minute like a forlorn child, and again screaming in fear: “Matilla! Matilla!” Then suddenly fighting and struggling, she would talk a wild gibberish of English and Spanish, (the latter a language of which she had no knowledge).

Mrs Wickland immediately gave her psychic diagnosis, saying the case was unquestionably one of obsession, 19 and this was unexpectedly confirmed when Mrs Wickland, who was standing at the foot of the bed, with wraps on ready to leave, was found to be suddenly entranced. We placed her on a davenport in the music room, where for two hours I talked in turn with several spirits who had just been attracted from the patient.

There were three spirits – a girl named Mary, her suitor, an American, and his Mexican rival, Matilla. Both of the men had vehemently loved the girl and just as fiercely hated each other. In a jealous rage one had killed the girl, and then in a desperate fight the two rivals had killed each other.
All were unaware of being ‘dead’, although Mary said, weeping wretchedly, “I thought they were going to kill each other, but here they are, still fighting.”

This tragedy of love hatred and jealousy had not ended with physical death; the group had unconsciously been drawn into the psychic atmosphere of the patient, and the violent fighting had continued within her aura.20 Since her nervous resistance was exceedingly low at this time, one after the other had usurped her physical body, with a resulting disturbance that was unexplainable by her attendants (Wickland, 1924, 25-26).

Dissociative Disorders and SRT

On the arguments put forward by psychologists with regard to dissociative disorders Wickland writes:

In the study of cases of multiple personalities, dissociated personalities or disintegrated states of consciousness, modern psychologists disclaim the possibility of foreign intelligences on the ground that these personalities give neither evidence of supernormal knowledge, nor of being of spiritistic origin.

Our experience, to the contrary, has proven that the majority of these intelligences are oblivious of their transition and hence it does not enter their minds that they are spirits, and they are loathe to recognise the fact (ibid, p. 29).

Carl Wickland’s records from his thirty years of clinical experience and organised psychical research are a valuable contribution to scientific knowledge and testimony to the reality of non-corporeal existence. Together with the documented scientific evidence provided by earlier mystics and scientists such as Emmanuel Swedenborg (1758), Allan Kardec (1857), Edgar Cayce (1970), William James (1902), Frederic Myers (1903) and James Hyslop (1919), Wickland provides validated scientific evidence to support the hypothesis of spirit attachment as a reality to modern medicine that is difficult to ignore or refute. More recent research into the validity of the hypothesis that there is an afterlife has the valuable resource of Wickland’s records to provide a foundation for exploring this avenue of human experience (Fontana 2005). It is to Wickland, therefore, as a pioneer in Spirit Release Therapy that we turn to in the first instance for medical descriptions of the phenomenology of spirit attachment and methods of releasing them from their unwilling hosts.

Dissociation and Paranoia

In support and validation of his own experiences of dealing with cases of dissociation and paranoia, Wickland quotes James Hyslop, professor of logic and ethics at Columbia University from 1889 to 1902, and editor of the American Journal of Psychical Research:

The term obsession is employed by psychic researchers to denote the abnormal influence of spirits on the living.... The cures affected have required much time and patience, the use of psychotherapeutics of an unusual kind, and the employment of psychics to get into contact with the obsessing agents and thus to release the hold which such agents have, or to educate them to voluntary abandonment of their persecutions.... Every single case of dissociation and paranoia to which I have applied cross-reference has yielded to the method and proved the existence of foreign agencies complicated with the symptoms of mental or physical deterioration. It is high time to prosecute experiments on a large scale in a field that promises to have as much practical value as any application of the scalpel or the microscope (Wickland 1924:8-9).

The observation by Hyslop that ‘every single case of dissociation and paranoia ... are complicated by the presence of foreign agencies’ provides initial support for the hypothesis that dissociative disorders can be confused with spirit interference. Furthermore, Hyslop’s reference to ‘the use of psychotherapeutics of a very unusual kind, and the employment of psychics to get into contact with the possessing agents’ is arguably the first mention of a treatment method that has subsequently become known as Spirit Release Therapy.

Carl Wickland was one of the earliest in a series of twentieth century professionals who discovered discarnate entities affecting their own patients and published their findings. These professionals include (in chronological order of publishing) Adam Crabtree (1985), Edith Fiore (1987), Hans Naegeli-Osjord (1988), Irene Hickman (1994), William Baldwin (1995), Shakuntala Modi (1997), and others since. It is impractical to examine the wealth of individual contributions of all of these authors due to the need for brevity. However, I shall present below some of the contributions of Adam Crabtree, Edith Fiore and Irene Hickman.

Multiple Personality or Spirit Possession?

Adam Crabtree has taken the time to research the development of psychotherapy in the treatment of those who are diagnosed either correctly or incorrectly as mentally ill from his own clinical experiences with patients (Crabtree 1985). Crabtree’s work is important for two reasons. Firstly, because he has developed an interest in these anomalous phenomena from a scientific research perspective, and secondly from a personal one where, as a psychotherapist, he has experienced the phenomena that are relevant to the practice of SRT. Crabtree was a Benedictine monk and ordained in the Catholic Church as a priest in 1964. As a serious student of the human psyche he became a psychotherapist. He has also been a lecturer in philosophy and the psychology of religion. In the introduction to Crabtree’s first book Multiple Man (1985), Colin Wilson has this to say:

...he is first and foremost a scientist, and his first response to the mystery of multiple personality was to study its medical history in detail. The first part of the present book is as balanced an introduction to this bewildering topic as I have ever come across. But the most important section of the book is the one that begins with chapter 10, describing Crabtree’s own experiences of such cases. It was, I think, just as well for Crabtree to offer his credentials as a scientific historian in the first part of the book, otherwise some of these cases – and I draw particular attention to those of ‘The Confused Father’ and ‘The Complaining Mother’ – would give rise to the suspicion that he is stretching the facts. While some psychologists will, no doubt, prefer to ignore Crabtree’s findings, those who are open-minded enough to consider them without bias will find that they open strange and exciting perspectives (Wilson 1985).

The first part of Crabtree’s book provides an in-depth overview of the conceptual frameworks that accommodate multiple personality and spirit possession phenomena; the same concepts that Wickland identified regarding the spirit world and life after death, but with the addition of the collective phenomena of altered states of consciousness, which is a significant component of Myers’ work, and therefore of prime importance in my argument to support Myers’ framework in this thesis.

SRT, Hypnosis and Secondary Selves

On a foundation of the discoveries of the early mesmerists from Franz Anton Mesmer (1734-1815) to the present day, Crabtree identifies various methods of inducing magnetic sleep (hypnotic trance, or the dissociated state) and the observable phenomena of the induced trance state. According to Crabtree, it became apparent to the early magnetisers that the subject entered into a trance-like state that facilitated at least two distinct groupings of phenomena that were different from the normal waking state. One group of characteristics are described as ‘lower phenomena’ and the other are described as ‘higher phenomena’ (Crabtree 1985, pp.2-20).

Characteristics of the lower consciousness included:
a) A sleepwalking kind of consciousness
b) Double consciousness and double memory
c) Loss of sense of identity
d) Suggestibility
e) Heightened memory
f) Deadening of the senses
g) Insensibility to pain
h) Intense rapport with the magnetiser

The higher consciousness characteristics included four special groupings:

1. Physical or sensorial rapport [perceptions of the physical senses of the other]
2. Mental rapport [mind reading - telepathy]
3. Clairvoyance [clear seeing in spirit realms]
4. Ecstasy [mystical experience]

Crabtree reports that the early magnetisers attributed these phenomena to a second self, or double-consciousness, and this discovery was accepted as an observable scientific fact.
In 1842, the English surgeon James Braid, introduced the term ‘hypnosis’ and took the scientific investigation into trance phenomena into a new direction. He discovered that the hypnotic state had a number of different stages or depth. A subject could move through different stages from light trance to somnambulism to unconscious. Opinions differed between investigators as to how many distinct levels of consciousness could be accessed as the trance deepened. Experiments conducted by Myers’ colleague Edmund Gurney in the 1880’s at the British Society for Psychical Research (Gurney 1884) revealed that each different level of consciousness produced a different memory chain. Each memory chain characterised a different personality that was separate from the others. Later researchers discovered as many as eight different memory chains in subjects which indicated that there may be no limit to the number of distinctly separate sections of consciousness into which the hypnotised subject could divide or have access to.

Moving deeper into an altered state could be regarded as moving along a continuum of depth that is similar to moving down a series of steps where each step is a discrete state of consciousness or ‘personality’ with a discrete memory chain that differentiates one from another. Hence the concept of the continuity of dissociation and the concept of discontinuity can both be accommodated.

According to Crabtree, this on-going research was revealing what was referred to by the early magnetisers as the second self was more probably a much more divided or multiple self (ibid, p.21).

The Hidden Observer or Higher Self

A problem revealed itself in experiments to try to discover the nature of these separated personalities or discrete states of consciousness. According to Crabtree, it was known by early researchers into hypnotic phenomena that the somnambulist was highly suggestible and could be influenced to experience positive hallucinations, i.e. to see something that wasn’t there, or negative hallucinations, i.e. to not see something that was there. Crabtree describes the experiment that confounded observers, (but in retrospect has significant meaning to SRT practitioners):

The hypnotised subject is at one end of the room and the hypnotists at the other. There is a table between them. The hypnotist gives the subject the post-hypnotic suggestion; on awakening he will perceive the room as devoid of furniture – a negative hallucination with regard to the table. When the subject is awakened, careful questioning reveals that he really believes there is no furniture in the room. The hypnotist then asks the subject to walk over to him and he does so, but instead of walking in a straight line, he moves in an arc to avoid the table. When the hypnotist asks why, the subject does not know why, or makes some weak excuse, but when asked whether he was trying to avoid something, he will reply, “Of course not.” When further questioned about whether there is any furniture in the room, the subject will again answer no.

But in order that the subject not see something and act in the manner suggested by the hypnotist, something within him had to see the object and act upon that perception (Crabtree 1985, p.30).

Alfred Binet describes the problem:

...in order to cease to see an object – to have that alone excluded from sight – a person must begin by perceiving and recognising it, however that may be done, and the rejection of the perception can only take place after it has been established ... Now, who does this supervising? What is the intelligence that always decides that the subject shall perceive this and not that? It is not the normal ego, for that is not conscious of anything. It only accepts what it gets. It must be therefore, a personality capable of seeing the object ... As to what this personality may be; I for one am completely in the dark... (Binet 1886, cited in Crabtree 1985, p.30).

To clarify the nature of the problem further; the waking consciousness is hallucinating and is not aware of the table but avoids it without knowing why. The hypnotised personality is hallucinating and is unaware of the table and is therefore unable to guide the waking consciousness around it. Who then is aware of the table?

This problem has been tackled by the contemporary researcher Ernest Hilgard (1977), who identified what he called ‘the hidden observer’. This behind-the-scenes hidden observer is a part of consciousness that observes everything that is going on between all other parts of the personality or states of consciousness and the hypnotiser and all other persons that interact with the subject. According to Crabtree it was Hilgard’s intention to use the term hidden-observer as a metaphor. He didn’t intend for the hidden observer to be considered as a secondary personality with an autonomous consciousness of its own.

As we make use of the detailed literature reviews of Crabtree in gaining some understanding of the concepts surrounding the phenomenon of altered states of consciousness, multiple personality and spirit possession, we are obliged to take very special note of the scientific discovery of the hidden observer. One of Hilgard’s subjects makes a clear statement of the phenomenology of her experience of her hidden observer:

The hidden observer is analytical, unemotional, and business-like. The part of me that was hypnotised was off on a tropical island. The hidden observer is a portion of ME. There’s ME 1, ME 2 and ME 3. Me 1 is hypnotised, ME 2 is hypnotised and observing, and ME 3 is when I’m awake. The hidden observer is cognizant of everything that is going on; it’s a little more narrow in its field of vision than ME 3, like being awake in a dream and fully aware of your actions. The hidden observer sees more, he questions more, he’s aware of what’s going on all the time but getting in touch is totally unnecessary. The first time [ice, water, pain] I thought it was an artefact of the situation, but after the second time, with hearing, I don’t think that’s the case. He’s like a guardian angel that guards you from doing anything that will mess you up. The hidden observer is looking through the tunnel and sees everything in the tunnel. It’s focused, doesn’t pay attention to extraneous things. It’s aware that the tones are coming through, aware that I was saying, “zero”, that the ME 1 was also busy floating. ME 2 is watching all of this. Unless
someone tells me to get in touch with the hidden observer I’m not in contact. It’s just there (Crabtree 1985, p.32).

The subject of the above quotation was involved in experiments to control pain using iced water and numbing suggestions. The context under which the experiment was conducted is not important with regard to SRT, but the importance of the concept of the hidden observer is realised when the techniques of SRT are applied and acknowledged. Hilgard, being a positivistic scientist is not considering the hypothesis that the hidden observer is anything other than psychogenic in the makeup of the multiple personality, and like the majority of researchers into the phenomena of hypnosis he disregards the possibility that the essential nature of the psyche is spiritual. In the practical application of Spirit Release techniques the hidden observer is of paramount importance. In SRT protocol there is a spiritual component of the individual that is regarded respectfully as the ‘higher-self’, and it is from the higher-self that permission to proceed with a therapeutic intervention is always sought.21 In spiritual language, the higher-self is that part of the personality that is furthest away from the earth-plane and closest to God. It may be hypothesised that if Hilgard and other scientists’ investigations into hypnotic phenomena were able to broaden their conceptual framework then they may find sympathy with the notion of the spiritual higher-self rather than trying to understand the hidden-observer as a purely psychogenic phenomenon.

If the assumptions made regarding the higher-self by SRT are true then much of the scientific research that has been conducted into the phenomena of magnetic sleep, somnambulism, hypnosis and altered states of consciousness can be considered as blindly groping in the dark. The need for scientific explanations for extraordinary subjective experiences such as multiple personality and spirit possession have been side-tracked down a blind alley by rejection of the earlier concept that was identified by Carl Wickland and earlier researchers, including Frederic Myers; namely that a spirit world exists in parallel with the physical.
Crabtree cites several examples from the literature that have been assigned by psychological rationalists as double or multiple personality. He makes no comment on the phenomenology of each case until collectively at the end of the chapter where he makes this comment: When examining the data of multiple personality, one cannot overlook a phenomenon which exhibits certain striking similarities: “possession.” Here, too, the subject exhibits a duality or even multiplicity of personalities which disclaim any identity with each other. Also in both the multiple personality and the possession experience, amnesias of various kinds may be present (Crabtree 1985, p. 60).

We shall see later in this thesis that Frederic Myers made precisely the same assertion more than 100 years ago.








Sunday, November 8, 2026

The Infinite Boundary

 

PREFACE

Can mental illness be complicated by purely psychic or paranormal factors? For years, many psychiatrists and parapsychologists have felt that within the bizarre hallucinations and delusions of the mentally disturbed there might lurk some level of paranormal perception—some way of apprehending reality that goes far beyond the normal perception of the five senses. For instance, what if a mental patient’s delusions that he is being persecuted by the spirit of a dead person contained verifiable information about that individual? Can “insanity” result in some cases because these patients really are being victimized by the dead?

This is the topic of The Infinite Boundary. This book will include cases of several people who have been seemingly influenced by the dead to develop remarkable skills or artistic talents. These talents corresponded to the skills and talents possessed by the donor personalities during their terrestrial lives. But these people also exhibited pathological behavior as a result of these interactions. This book also describes remarkable experiments in which psychics were brought in to help diagnose such patients and even cure them!

The Infinite Boundary is essentially a history book. The story begins in the early 1900s, when well-known philosopher and psychic investigator Prof. James H. Hyslop confronted the strange case of Frederic Thompson of New Bedford, Massachussets. Thompson was a craftsman who suddenly began painting oils and drawing sketches in the style of a recently deceased artist, even though he claimed he had no formal artistic training. Hyslop gradually came across similar cases while still fighting belief in the obsession hypothesis. Finally, shortly before his death in 1920, he realized that obsession by the dead could indeed pass for insanity and that it constituted a hitherto unrecognized factor in mental illness. After his death, his views were elaborated and researched by the eminent New York neurologist Dr. Titus Bull; by the famous psychical investigator Dr. W. Franklin Prince; by noted clergyman Dr. Elwood Worcester (who founded the Emmanuel Movement in Boston); and by the highly unorthodox Dr. Carl Wickland. All their work is chronologized for the first time in this volume.

To bring the information up to date, reports from other researchers engaged in similar work today are included, such as the work of Dr. Ralph Allison, one of this country’s leading authorities on the strange phenomenon of multiple personality. Dr. Allison believes that many cases of this rare disorder are actually genuine cases of spirit obsession.

The current status of this continuing search for evidence will keep the historical chapters relevant to the interests of the contemporary reader.

Although no responsible psychologist or parapsychologist would suggest that all—or even many—cases of insanity are cases of “psychic control,” the evidence suggests that sometimes what is diagnosed as mental illness is really possession—some sort of invasion from without, not from within.

It makes little difference just how you approach this book. It can be read as a study in parapsychology, as a report on the evidence for life after death, or simply as a curious chapter in the history of American psychiatry. My goal in writing this book has been solely to remind today’s public of the essentials of a forgotten search—a search undertaken by some genuinely brilliant minds who implicitly believed in the important work they were doing. It is more than revealing that several explorers of the unknown are still engaged in this work today. It seems that the spiritistic theory of mental illness is a concept that will not die; and perhaps in these confused times it is time to look at the lives and work of those researchers who championed it and those who still support it.

D. Scott Rogo
**
So it seems to me that there is plenty of reason to consider all sorts of seemingly bizarre theories about the nature of human behavior. The rest of this book will consider the possibility that some cases of deviant behavior are not due simply to the dysfunction of the brain or mind, but that certain unseen influences might be a complicating factor. Since John’s cure by exorcism was psychiatrically inexplicable, would it be too outrageous to suggest that perhaps some sort of foreign influence had been responsible for the youth’s feminine behavior? We can at least explain his cure by adopting this provisional view.

For several years, some enlightened psychiatrists and psychologists have believed that within the bizarre hallucinations and delusions of the mentally disturbed, there might lurk some level of paranormal perception. For instance, take a patient who believes he is being persecuted by spirits of the dead. What if that patient started coming up with obscure and verifiable information about real people whom he never knew and who died years before—the very people he claimed were persecuting him? Such a case would suggest that the patient’s delusions were based on some glimmer of reality. In fact, there are several such cases buried within the literature on the paranormal. During the course of the next several chapters, we will take a detailed look at these cases— and at what they have to teach us about the nature of the mind and life itself.
**

But even though Frank Stockton didn’t manifest that morning, Miss De Camp seemed to receive a psychic message from him the following evening. While resting in her room at the hotel, she felt some sott of presence trying to reach her. She mentally requested the entity to leave her alone, and she especially didn’t want to produce any psychic writing. But she suddenly received an extrasensory message from the presence that instructed her to sit less closely behind the psychic. Miss De Camp instantly realized that her physical proximity to the psychic was probably interfering with Mrs. Soule’s receptions from the spirit world, thereby causing the earlier failure.

Miss De Camp told this strange story to Hyslop while they drove to Mrs. Soule’s residence the following morning. Hyslop felt that the suggestion was reasonable enough, and so they followed the advice.

This sitting (which was held on the morning of February 28) began with a surprise. When Prof. Hyslop first entered the séance room, Mrs. Soule was already picking up the purported communicator’s presence. She told the professor that the name “Frank” had been popping into her mind that morning, and she felt that the name was being sent to her by her spirit guides. It certainly looked as if the session would be promising, but when the psychic finally entered trance, the subliminal stage was exceedingly long. By voice the Boston psychic referred to the communicator as a story writer who wore a ring—which was true enough, as Hyslop was to learn later. Luckily, though, it didn’t take long before the Stockton personality commenced writing directly through Mrs. Soule’s pencil—and he offered a message directly pertinent to De Camp, who was sitting silently behind the psychic.

“We are working for more than the present effect,” the communicator began. “We are working for posterity and for the joy of working.

It is great and wholesome as well. Do not let any one say I am overdoing it or that I will hurt her [the sitter]. I will not and I will supply whatever energy I use. I mean the one through whom I write my manuscripts . . . not the hand I am using now.” The communicator then proceeded to discuss the circumstances under which he had come to work through Etta De Camp, directly saying that he had been “brought” to her by other discarnate entities.

This was certainly correct and corresponded with the report Miss De Camp had previously given to Hyslop in 1909. (See page 77.)

“I could have come before,” the presence explained further, “but I was not sure that you wanted me and there are others around who helped me to do the work. I did not make her a medium, she was one and the people were already there and it was easy for me to work because the organized plan for work was already established.” The communicator then expounded in great detail concerning the procedures he was using to write his stories through his psychic scribe. He then chided Hyslop for making him write through a different channel!

“I know that I am able to write through my little friend’s hand,” the communicator wrote through Mrs. Soule’s pencil, “and she knows it and that is quite enough for me at present. I hope you will not think I am not cordial to your work or that I do not appreciate your courtesy but this is so much more difficult for me than my work with her.” Hyslop politely responded by explaining that he was trying to help the communicator prove his identity to the world, but the communicator wasn’t impressed by the professor’s speech. He replied cordially that such evidence had previously been channeled through his regular scribe.

When Hyslop restated his argument, explaining that the skeptics would probably be unimpressed by his post-mortem writings, the communicator responded in a truly Stocktonesque manner.

“What do I care about the skeptics?” wrote the purported Stockton.

“Probably nothing,” concurred Hyslop.

“They are a bad lot and I am not trying to save them. . . . I do my work in my own way and I know and she knows and that is enough.” The communicator kept up this humorous train of thought as the sitting progressed.

“It [is] a funny thing,” the writing through Mrs. Soule continued, “if a man can have no rest in heaven but must go on repeating for the sake of a lot of idiots that his name is John Smith or whatsoever it may be. I really have a desire to do a certain kind of work but deliver me from the class who cut up their relatives to see how their corpuscles match up.”

The discarnate entity then referred back to his dissatisfaction with the experiments Hyslop was conducting through Minnie Soule.
“I think I won’t do for your business, but personally I have no fight with you,” the entity explained. “You can go on and save all the critics you can but don’t send them to me when they die.” The communicator then began reminiscing about his previous life and work and started to fade, but not before signing his name to the preceding scripts. Mrs. Soule’s hand fumbled through several false starts but ended by writing “Frank” and then “Stockton.” Once these calling cards were written, Mrs. Soule’s hand began to falter again and the pencil finally fell from her grasp. The Stockton personality had obviously left the sitting, and the séance came to a rapid conclusion.

Reading the transcript of this experiment today, what should the reader think?

This séance was in my opinion truly extraordinary for a number of reasons. Although it is true that the Stockton personality offered no verifiable information about himself, the scripts channeled through Mrs. Soule were filled with evidential information. Remember that the Boston psychic knew nothing about her sitter, who lived 235 miles away in New York. Even though every precaution had been taken to ensure the secrecy of Miss De Camp’s identity, the spirit presence writing through Mrs. Soule seemed to know and realized why the sitting was being conducted. The purported discarnate explained in detail the reason for and manner in which he was creating stories through the sitter, and he even claimed to be the exact person Hyslop was secretly hoping to contact.

But another aspect of this sitting should strike the reader as even more evidential. Reading the transcripts of this séance even today, some seventy years later, Stockton’s presence seems to literally jump right from the pages. His presence comes by virtue of the communicator’s wit, cynical humor, and contemptuous flippancy.

This personal blueprint pervades the Soule/Stockton sittings, and its impact becomes even more obvious to anybody who has read Frank Stockton’s books and short stories. His stories especially were filled with a specific style of humor. Capping the humor was the writer’s wonderfully grotesque attitude toward his characters and their plights. Note that the same characteristics permeate the Soule sittings, during which the Stockton personality is often capricious and delightfully obnoxious. His total disdain for the situation in which he found himself while communicating with Hyslop would have been characteristic of the real Frank Stockton.
It is also remarkable how personally distinct the Stockton personality seems to be. The persona seems to be a living (!) personality, a personality totally independent of the psychic’s own mind.

This was an important phenomenon that Hyslop liked to emphasize in his writings on the phenomenon of post-mortem contact. Each of the personalities that he contacted during his dozens of experiments with Minnie Soule seemed to be different. For example, just compare the Stockton personality with that of Robert Swain Gifford, who regularly communicated through Soule during the summer of 1908. The Gifford presence was serious and somber. Not even a suggestion of leyity pervaded the sittings Hyslop undertook to establish contact with the painter. The Gifford personality seemed to pursue his work with Thompson and his communications through Mrs. Soule with a religious zeal. This sense of importance and urgency virtually infected each and every message communicated from him to the researchers. But this was certainly not the case with the Stockton personality, who was perpetually filled with whimsy and cynicism. His literal “go f— yourself” demeanor toward Hyslop and Minnie Soule stands in stark contrast to the (excuse the pun) deadly seriousness of Robert Swain Gifford.

It is therefore easy to sympathize with Hyslop’s refusal to believe that such distinct personalities could be springing from the psychic’s subconscious.

Hyslop conducted three more sittings with Mrs. Soule in order to establish contact with the departed Frank Stockton. These sittings weren’t quite so lively, although considerable evidential information was imparted by the Stockton personality. The only surprise came during the last sitting, on the morning of March 6, when the deceased George Duysters placed a final vraisamblance by writing his full name through Soule. The personality seemed to be laboring to write, and the information he communicated wasn’t extremely evidential.

But the fact that a name so significant to James Hyslop and Etta De Camp was correctly communicated by the Boston sensitive was impressive enough.

Hyslop’s investigation of the De Camp/Stockton case ended with this sitting, and whatever became of Miss De Camp and her mediumship isn’t a matter of public record. The stories she wrote with the purported guidance of the deceased Frank Stockton were eventually published in 1913 when Miss De Camp’s own book on the case was issued.

The Return of Frank R. Stockton includes most of the stories written through her hand. The original records were filed with the American Society for Psychical Research. Miss De Camp later married and lived the rest of her life in relative obscurity.
**
Despite the relatively benign outcome of these complex incidents, however, another important issue began to preoccupy Hyslop’s mind.

Each of his previous cases looked like instances of psychopathology— either simple dissociation, secondary personality, or dementia praecox (the 19th-century term for what we call schizophrenia today). Frederic Thompson, Etta De Camp, and Ida Rogers seemed to be going insane, and only Hyslop’s intervention and experiments may have saved them from a complete loss of reason.

Frederic Thompson had even been formally diagnosed as a case of incipient paranoia or dementia, but Hyslop’s psychic diagnosis of his problem through the mediumship of Minnie Soule had thrown new light on his inner world.

Because of these studies, Hyslop began formulating a radical theory in order to explain some cases of insanity. The Spiritualists in the United States, England, and France had long maintained that possession and spirit influence were the true causes of some psychotic states and phobias. Of course, this interesting theory predated the rise of the Spiritualist movement by several centuries. Similar theories had been popular during the Enlightenment. They had been most vocally supported by the theological writer Johann Weyer (1515-88) in his famous book De Praestigiis Daemonum. Weyer championed the demonic theory of insanity even though he was the most enlightened and vocal critic of the European witch craze, which was rife during his lifetime.

The Spiritualists were, however, going beyond theory and theology and were trying to cure cases of insanity by conducting exorcisms as part of their seances. By the turn of the century, such “rescue work” was being conducted by both private and public Spiritualist groups and churches throughout the country.

Even though Hyslop never considered himself a Spiritualist, he grew increasingly sympathetic to their views on insanity during the 1910s.

He was not positing that each and every case of insanity was due to spirit influence or possession, but he felt that the possibility should be kept in mind. He also realized that his era’s medical community was in no position to evaluate whether psychic factors were playing a role in their patients’ illnesses.

This theoretical framework might strike the reader as nothing short of far-fetched, but Hyslop was not proposing a radically novel conceptual model for the problem of insanity. Many psychical researchers had come to believe in life after death by this time, and some of them were probably silently sympathetic to the theories Hyslop was promoting. Even during the months when he was grappling with the Thompson/Gifford case, William James was seeing the implications of his own research into the phenomenon of mediumship. As early as 1909, James was willing to write in a report to the SPR:

The refusal of modern “enlightenment” to treat “possession” as a hypothesis to be spoken of as even possible, in spite of the massive human tradition based on concrete experience in its favour, has always seemed to me a curious example of fashion in things scientific. That the demon theory (not necessarily a devil-theory) will have its innings again is to my mind absolutely certain. One has to be “scientific” indeed to be blind and ignorant enough to suspect no such possibility.
6

Hyslop’s research between 1907 and 1914 was leading in the same direction, but there was an important difference between their views. William James had been speaking purely theoretically, while Hyslop was speaking more and more from personal experience. He was pleased to see that Frederic Thompson’s and Etta De Camp’s psychological dispositions had improved after their sittings with Minnie Soule.

He would later write of his investigations and discoveries in his book Life after Death that

“the chief interest in such cases is their revolutionary effect in the field of medicine. It is probable that thousands of cases diagnosed as ‘paranoia’ would yield to this sort of [psychic] investigation and treatment: It is high time for the medical world to wake up and learn some- thing.”

It is important again to note that Hyslop was not suggesting possession and spirit obsession as the sole causes of insanity. He felt either that the syndrome explained some such cases or that the general process of psychological disintegration might somehow attract misguided or obsessing discarnates. He pointed to this possibility several times in his writings and would later state this concept in his Contact with the Other World.

It is important to remark at the onset of the exploration of obsession that I do not mean this idea to be a substitute for hysteria, dementia praecox, paranoia or other maladies, nor is it a rival explanation. . . hence that we are not to set aside organic and functional trouble in body and mind when acknowledging that obsession by spirits is an accompaniment of the trouble. It is quite conceivable that any disturbance to healthy functions, bodily or mental, might create conditions in which accidental connections with the discarnate would be established and would open the way to all sorts of voluntary and involuntary invasions.

It must be thoroughly understood that we are not controverting psychological or psychiatric explanation. The only revolution that we wish to introduce into medicine is the denial of the limits ordinarily assigned to causes of disease and methods of treatment. The terms hysteria, dementia praecox, paranoia, manic depressive insanity, and epilepsy are largely descriptive; the causes are revealed only by autopsy and other such methods. Obsession does not displace other causes, but adds to them another factor.

By acknowledging such a possibility, exciting new avenues for future experimentation opened for the researcher. Could some people suffering from insanity be cured by going to gifted psychics? Does exorcism really work? Hyslop believed that these issues should be explored.