To be is to be contingent: nothing of which it can be said that "it is" can be alone and independent. But being is a member of paticca-samuppada as arising which contains ignorance. Being is only invertible by ignorance.

Destruction of ignorance destroys the illusion of being. When ignorance is no more, than consciousness no longer can attribute being (pahoti) at all. But that is not all for when consciousness is predicated of one who has no ignorance than it is no more indicatable (as it was indicated in M Sutta 22)

Nanamoli Thera
Showing posts with label Donovan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Donovan. Show all posts

Saturday, November 7, 2026

Warren Farrell and Men Today

 

A founding father of the men’s movement speaks on the status and challenges of men today


No one can deny the importance of Dr Warren Farrell and his seminal book, The Myth of Male Power, to the movement for men’s equality. So it is an event when he is interviewed by Paul Elam, an eminent voice of that movement today.

Yet my response to this interview was, frankly, disappointment. In fact, I was flabbergasted. Does Dr Farrell really believe that the massive corruption of family law and the horrifying injustices it inflicts on men (confiscating their children, incarceration without trial, plunder, penury, homelessness, and more) can be ameliorated by more therapists or teaching men better “communication” skills? Does he really see #MeToo, a movement dedicated to violating constitutional rights by inflicting knowingly false criminal accusations against legally innocent people, is morally equivalent to men voicing their views and grievances on the internet? I was pleased to see Elam remind him that, in the age of MGTOW, exploding male incarceration, mass male suicide, and now Lindsay Clancy, something more serious threatens men and their families (and all of us) than hurt “feelings”.

I was equally troubled that few men responded in the chat by pointing out any of this. Instead they found his prescriptions appropriate and apparently adequate. I fear this reflects a credulous acceptance of therapy culture by too many men and failure to distinguish what is incidental from what is truly serious.

Dr Farrell has a PhD in political science, and yet Paul (a therapist) had to remind him of the political dimension to all this. In fact, for all his brilliance, Warren Farrell has never criticized the mass abuse of government power in family court and elsewhere in the law. This has helped him get a hearing from mainstream media and from opportunists like Jordon Peterson and other establishment figures. Yet it never translates into pushing the matter any further along, like exploring and exposing the most serious threats to men and children (and again, all of us). He also seems to have a lingering soft spot for the feminism he once served. (I would like to have heard his response to Janice Fiamengo’s new book, The Goddess That Failed, which documents her insistence that feminism did not go astray and cannot be reformed. It was hate-filled from the start and must be “destroyed root and branch”.) If I did not know better, I would also be tempted to suggest that Warren’s influence may play some role in why the state’s abuses of power against men and fathers never abates but only worsens.

Warren Farrell would be doing an enormous service, and perhaps earn a place in history, rather than disappearing into obscurity like so many others, if he were to use the profile and influence he has built up over the years to confront the political class and establishment media with the full force of what men must endure today and what may soon be the fate of all of us.

**
Jack Donovan, author of The Way of Men, joins “The Mansplainers” for a wide-ranging discussion about masculinity, fatherhood, male solidarity and the many forms it can take: friendship, sports, gangs, military service, churches, workplaces, men’s clubs, secret societies, revolutionary movements, and more.

Why are boys and young men so naturally drawn to gangs, crews, teams, clubs, and other male groups? Can the same impulses toward brotherhood, loyalty, strength, risk, and belonging be directed toward both constructive and destructive ends? And what happens when men lack meaningful relationships and associations with other men?

Donovan discusses: his famous idea that “the way of men is the way of the gang”; why men need other men to help establish standards and arbitrate honor; the importance of fathers modeling male friendship for their sons; physical strength and martial arts: and the difference between healthy male solidarity and online communities built around perpetual anger.

Bradley also reflects on his childhood fascination with New York City’s gang and graffiti culture and asks how society can provide boys and men with constructive alternatives that preserve brotherhood, identity, challenge, earned status, and the feeling of having someone at your back.

The conversation also explores why independent associations of men have historically been viewed with suspicion, the role of virtue and honor in male groups, and Donovan’s warning against men becoming addicted to outrage and “practicing unhappiness.”

Finally, Jack offers practical advice for men looking for a tribe of their own: consider where a group is leading its members, whether its values correspond with the life you actually want, and whether loyalty and commitment are genuinely reciprocal.

We also discuss what happens when men need association with other men and are denied it.

https://substack.com/redirect/9800fed1-7aaa-4691-97b2-c0c11b7fac81?j=eyJ1IjoiMXBvcTY0In0.bpX_Ri4UrVVzEcwn2tPJZmntoRqzSx0aLRc9mOX6Iw8

StephenBaskerville.com

Thursday, October 13, 2022

On the Death of Gods and the Murder of Heroes


1

Nietzsche shouted that God was dead, and the whole world heard him.

The Zoroaster of Sils Maria is often mischaracterized as having attempted to kill god with his proclamations, but his statements were diagnostic. What he recognized in the world around him was a collapse of consensus about the religious narrative and, as a result, the disintegration of collective social values.

Nietzsche saw this mass disorientation as a great opportunity for a post-Christian revaluing of values — and it is. “Disappointment opens up a vista of chaos.”  1   In chaos there is both space and kindling for creation. He imagined that in this vacuum of divinity and direction, a new man, unbound by ancient orthodoxies — a man beyond man — could then create his own life-affirming values.

However, the collapse of religious consensus was never resolved or replaced by another consistent consensus. The outcome of disillusionment has not been a deep soul-searching, but a dynamic moral marketplace in which “trending” moralities are driven almost entirely by the madness of crowds and a culture of complaint.

Pious Christianity fell out of fashion among elites and influencers, but ressentiment remained in the masses, who replaced the divine promise of comeuppance and communion with a utopian vision that promised an equality of outcomes and esteem in the here-and-now — or at least in that unlikely moment when perfect equality is achieved.

Nietzsche’s diagnosis of deicide mutated into a malignant iconoclasm, not in the name of strength and life-affirming values as he had hoped, but in a “Harrison Bergeron”-style handicapping of all aspirational ideals.  2   The presumed absence of an afterlife or some divine authoritarian didn’t result in the widespread determination of individuals to work to realize their highest potential and make the most of finite existence — it resulted in the jealous damning of talent, of natural gifts, and of inherited privilege. It produced among the proletariat an indictment of all advantage and the exaltation of the mundane and the mediocre.

This horizontal culture of leveling has been replacing the vertical culture that preceded it — a culture that looked upward for inspiration to gods in the heavens and heroes on marble pedestals. Ancient and recent heroes of men have been posthumously diabolized by the thumbs of bored and bitchy social media mobs — accused of brand spanking new sins they never knew they were committing. This has not been the destruction that precedes all creation, the upending of one order to be replaced by a new order, but the destruction of order itself — because order itself is hierarchical. Weathered bronzes have not been toppled to be replaced by fresh idols of heroic stature. The pedestals have been left empty — or have been populated with pedestrians or sympathetic figures that can never haunt passersby with greatness.

2

It is not only a god or the gods who have been murdered, but also by extension ideals and heroes — the destruction of all hierarchies. The prevailing rationale for this leveling is that by raising up an ideal form — a perfect ideal of strength, beauty, goodness, intelligence, or competence — those who are least able or willing to strive to embody that form will feel inadequate or unhappy. A reasonable desire for fair and equal treatment under the law has been perverted into an egalitarianism of all values.

As the thinking goes, men should not try to be better, because too few will be truly great, and a lot of them will stumble and fall along the way. The safer route is to stay put and learn to love oneself exactly as one is, because the struggle to be better may result in disappointment, pain, or injury. It is better not to try to reach, because one might fall. One might fail at trying to be something, so it is better not to try to be anything. One should learn to accept one’s ugliness, because beauty is difficult to attain, and ultimately transient — as are all things.

The refusal to elevate an ideal of perfection because perfection is unattainable and near perfection is exceptional, is the product of a nihilistic ethos characterized by cowardice and self-loathing. And, it misses the point of idealism completely. It makes the perfect the enemy of the good. This is like saying that a man shouldn’t work to become stronger because he will probably never become the strongest. That you shouldn’t try to be better because you’ll never be the best.

An ideal is not a destination, it is a direction. Without direction, there is only chaos and dissolution.

3

Psychologist Carl Jung is often credited, at least by many of his adherents, with a gift of prophecy. In his Red Book , an exploratory project that remained private until decades after his death, he recorded a vision of himself ambushing and murdering Siegfried, the archetypal Germanic hero, “through trickery and cunning.”  3   After committing this cowardly crime he felt tormented by it and searched his soul for his underlying motivation. Jung concluded that, “The hero must fall for the sake of our redemption, since he is the model and demands imitation.”  4  

In this allegorical riff on a Nietzschean theme, Jung seemed to suggest that men must murder their heroes, or refuse to have heroes in the first place, because heroes are the enemies of the true individual. That until we stop copying others, we will be nothing more than pale imitations.

This is another common reason that has been given for doing away with heroes and high ideals — that we are somehow inauthentic or derivative when we aim to reproduce greatness. But, as perfection is impossible, so is perfect reproduction. All of the variables will always be different. A man is only capable of being himself. No matter how hard he tries to be like another man, he will never be the same. He will always be a unique variation on a theme.

No matter how independent you think you are, you learn through imitation. We all do. It’s how we learn everything from language to martial arts. Monkey see, monkey do. And then, when you have some idea what you are doing, you can innovate. That’s where the art is.

To choose qualities in another man that you wish to imitate or emulate means that you are choosing qualities that you value and wish to reproduce in yourself. I haven’t met a man of substantial accomplishment who never had a mentor or a model or an ideal or someone he looked up to at some point. Caesar wept in front of a statue of Alexander the Great.

They say that “imitation is the sincerest form of flattery,” but the word flattery itself implies excessive or insincere praise. A better word is “honor.” By imitating another man, you are acknowledging that he is better than you at something — whether it is a skill or a virtuous quality — and that you want to become better at it, or as good as he is, or possibly even better. By imitating him, you are honoring him based on his reputation or his demonstrated expertise or simply by the way he conducts himself.

Imitation is also a consequence of inspiration. Gods, heroes, and ideals inspire us. The forms and the stories point the way — they give us direction and show us what is possible or admirable. Exemplars and paradigms push us to overcome ourselves and maximize our potential.

4

I once attended a defensive handgun class taught by my friend Greg Hamilton, who is a former Green Beret. He told his students that one of the things they could do to cultivate the right mindset to handle an emergency that may require lethal force was to read stories about other people who have survived and overcome extreme situations. His point was that in times of stress, we remember powerful stories of courage and those stories inspire us to face our own challenges with courage. When you know that men have done extraordinary things, it expands your perception of what is possible and suggests the possibility of doing the extraordinary yourself.

5

Men don’t need to hear stories about men who learned to love themselves “just the way they were.” Those stories don’t make men better. Hollow affectations of self-affirmation can only make men superficially content, because they will always know deep down they could have been better than “good enough.”

Men need to hear stories about men who are the best, because it drives them to be better.

Why elevate and affirm what is merely acceptable when you can tell stories about the exemplary and imagine what is perfect?

Men need gods and heroes and ideals — not to beg and wallow before, but to inspire them to reach higher and lift themselves up in imitation of paragons, and in imitation of righteousness itself.

Men need gods and heroes and ideals because our conception of what is best — of what is the highest good — orients our entire value system and helps us to order our external and internal worlds.

If we cannot determine what is sacred to us, then everything is profane by default. I believe that many men today feel lost and are looking for some sense of what is sacred to give their lives meaning, order, and direction.

from Fire in the Dark by by Jack Donovan