To be is to be contingent: nothing of which it can be said that "it is" can be alone and independent. But being is a member of paticca-samuppada as arising which contains ignorance. Being is only invertible by ignorance.

Destruction of ignorance destroys the illusion of being. When ignorance is no more, than consciousness no longer can attribute being (pahoti) at all. But that is not all for when consciousness is predicated of one who has no ignorance than it is no more indicatable (as it was indicated in M Sutta 22)

Nanamoli Thera
Showing posts with label Ernst Jünger. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ernst Jünger. Show all posts

Monday, April 27, 2026

Cioran: The Optimistic Reflex of the Dying


Next, I would like to move on to a wonderful Romanian philosopher whom I really appreciate: Emil Cioran. He was close to Eugène Ionesco, Mircea Eliade, Lucian Blaga, later Paul Celan, Samuel Beckett, and Henri Michaux. When I read an entry on him today, I noted that he is generally regarded to have been heavily influenced by the culture of European pessimism. This is how Schopenhauer, Nietzsche, and Klages are categorized in one philosophical encyclopedia. I quite liked the expression “cultural pessimism.” Accordingly, Emil Cioran’s works are distinguished by their extreme hopelessness.

I became acquainted with Cioran’s works while in France. Until recently, many of his works were not translated into Russian. Emil Cioran was a consistent Romanian nihilist, an extremely pained one. The majority of his works are in the form of aphorisms.

All of them are quite melancholic. I’ll read you now verbatim one quote used in the announcement of my lecture: “On a gangrened planet, we should abstain from making plans, but we make them still, optimism being, as we know, a dying man’s reflex.”

Cioran had quite an interesting life. He was brought up in a religious environment, and at first undertook religious studies. His life then took a turn and he ended up being influenced by Schopenhauer, Nietzsche, and Klages. He gradually became a kind of “nihilist.” His experience of the First World War was brutal. From his pen appeared such works as A Short History of Decay, Syllogisms of Bitterness [known in English as All Gall Is Divided], The Trouble with Being Born, Anathemas and Admirations, The Evil Demiurge [known in English as The New Gods], etc.19 All of these are written in aphoristic style, consisting of heavy and painful fragments that are somewhat like the dark fragments of Vasily Rozanov.

There are two components in Cioran’s eschatological optimism. On the one hand, he recognizes the illusoriness of this world, its finitude, and how it is absolutely, impenetrably closed, with no way out. Cioran writes that he finds himself in a world that is condemned, that we are all obviously doomed, cursed victims of this condemnation. We have no way out in any direction — no way, up or down, because “we are condemned and crucified on the cross of interpretation.” Elsewhere, Cioran wrote: “We are born already crucified.” And elsewhere: “The soul is already a crucifixion.”

At the same time, Cioran says that “optimism is the reflex of the dying.” But even this convulsive reflex is necessary in order to somehow maintain the status of the universe, for optimism constitutes the world (in the same way that a spasm characterizes a dying person). Oddly enough, this is a healthy reaction to the meaninglessness of this world into which we are thrown. Despite the fact that Cioran’s works bear no religious element and no salvational doctrine that might change a person’s fate by opening up the call to leave this universe and take a leap of will towards the Absolute, which is to say that there is no positive transcendence, he nevertheless accurately captures the most important condition of this world: its illusory nature, the absolute meaninglessness permeating its exhaustion. This starting point of human existence constitutes the basis of optimism as the spasmodic reflex of the dying.

Therefore, in my view, Cioran is extremely important for understanding eschatological optimism. In fact, the very notion of “eschatological optimism” came to my mind after I read Cioran for the first time, in 2013 or 2012. That is when I started finding this hopelessness of the immanent world, the tragic experience of its finitude, in other works by other authors and schools, as well as, in spite of everything, a consciousness of the need to have an optimistic, volitional attitude towards it.

Jünger: Turning the Ship into the Forest

One important author whom I recently discovered to be a bearer of eschatological optimism is Ernst Jünger. Jünger’s life and works had many stages, but I have in mind first and foremost his work The Forest Passage. It was recently released in Russia by Ad Marginem with brilliant commentary by Alexander Mikhailovsky. In this text from 1951, Jünger speaks of “passing into the forest.” At some point, the time will come when a person has to break with the given reality of the hopelessness of the surrounding world. Jünger calls for resistance, for joining the fight against this world and for rising above the illusory reality to whose very illusoriness we testify through the very act of our abruption. In Jünger’s work, we find an interesting formulation which I will now quote:

The forest rebel is that individual who, isolated and uprooted from his homeland by the great process, sees himself finally delivered up for destruction. This could be the fate of many, indeed of all — another factor must therefore be added to the definition: this is the forest rebel’s determination to resist, and his intention to fight the battle, however hopeless.20
Jünger speaks of modern man being thrown into a space in which technology and matter essentially destroy him, in which he loses his axis of rebellion and sovereignty in the face of materiality and illusoriness. He writes of the necessity of committing to revolt against the modern world, saddling its reality, subduing it, and passing into the forest. What Jünger means by “forest” is very important.
He does not mean departing into a physical forest, nor guerrilla struggle against the system– he also does not mean slipping away into a space where there are no more illusions, because illusion is everywhere. The illusion is in the illusion itself. The forest is none other than something differentiated, something distinguished, something greater. The point is that, in the very center of this illusoriness, in the center of the deceptive, finite reality that devours man through technology, through Machenschaft as Martin Heidegger called it, man ought to cultivate a vertical axis within himself, a verticality which will be absolutely different from the surrounding illusion and the world as a whole. This axis of rebellion is what is meant by the “forest passage.”
Jünger chose the image of a ship to articulate the situation of the one who passes into the forest, an obvious reference to Dionysus. When Dionysus faced his enemies on the ship, the matter at hand was essentially a clash between two elements: the forest, the wooden, the ship-like, and the aquatic. The indomitable god causes the ship to become entangled in lush vegetation. The deck, masts, sides, and rigging are overwhelmed with wild ivy. The ship is turned into a forest. Dionysus thus vanquishes his enemies by way of a miracle. This metaphor serves Jünger as an illustration of the need to remain within the reality in which he found himself, in which he was manifest, into which he was born, while at the same time constituting some kind of transcendent volitional principle from the inside, within the immanent, something that will cut and break through the illusion until it collapses.

Evola: Differentiated Man’s Rupture of Levels

We encounter similar concepts among the Traditionalists. First and foremost, there is Julius Evola and his concepts of “riding the tiger” and the “differentiated man.”21 This is one and the same idea.

According to Evola, modern man finds himself under the destructive influence of matter, under the clichés of the consumer society, under the proliferating pressure of technology, which represses him and dictates to him the need to follow its intrusive, alienating algorithms. The majority surrender, shrug their shoulders, and merge with Modernity and its laws.

But, in spite of everything, there are certain individuals — “differentiated men” — who accomplish superhuman efforts to break this illusoriness, to subordinate it to their will, to overcome it, and to subject it to an act of radical transcendence.

The differentiated man continues to remain within the world, but, at the same time, his most important standpoint in his perception of this world is his piercing awareness of its finitude, its illusory nature, and the steadfast conviction that this illusion lacks an ontological status. Such a volitional tension results in the gesture of a sharp break, an experience of rupture. Evola calls this “la rottura del livello,” “rupture of level,” a puncture made in this illusion.

Summary
In the works of the philosophers I’ve spoken of today, we encounter indications of the experience of eschatological optimism. I would now like to summarize what I mean by eschatological optimism. We have considered various concepts and figures ranging from Plato to Julius Evola. Of course, each of these elements demands a separate lecture, but let us try to identify the basic criteria that can be traced throughout all these doctrines.

Firstly, eschatological optimism is the consciousness and recognition that the material world, the given world which we presently take to be pure reality, is illusory: it is an illusion that is about to dissipate and end. We are extremely, sharply conscious of its finitude. But, at the same time, we maintain a certain optimism; we do not put up with it, we talk about the need to overcome it.

Across different teachings, this finitude can be overcome in different ways. In theological Platonism, it can be overcome on the path of turning to the One that is to be found ἐπέκεινα τῆς οὐσίας, “beyond being,” and through the path of apophatic mystery. This optimism is also manifest in political Platonism, when the philosopher returns to the finite world not to serve the finite, but the infinite.

In Neoplatonism, the experience of eschatological optimism means gradually ascending up the hierarchy of virtues and along the ladder of the elements of the soul, through the soul’s selfimprovement from the lower to the higher virtues.
Once the higher levels are reached, the Neoplatonist’s path leads even higher, as he tries to escape the finitude of this world through the theurgical, mystical act.

In the political philosophy of Neoplatonism, which is, by the way, implicit in the late Platonists and more explicit in the early Neoplatonists (in Plotinus, for instance), this ascent is also associated with political virtues. In general, it is difficult to separate metaphysics from politics in Platonism. Take, for example, Plotinus’ project for a Platonopolis. This is something incredibly interesting: despite the fact that Plotinus seems to be repelled by the earthly world, he does not give up trying to build the ideal kingdom of philosophers. Proclus, despite all of his abstraction from the material world, participated in the political life of his native Athens, from which he was expelled for a while. Thus, in Neoplatonism, eschatological optimism can also manifest itself through political efforts, through the experience of political service. (...)

ESCHATOLOGICAL OPTIMISM
Daria Platonova Dugina

Thursday, April 2, 2026

On Ernst Jünger

 Conservative Revolutionary

Junger’s writings about the war quickly earned him the status of a celebrity during the Weimar period. Battle as Inner Experience contained the prescient suggestion that the young men who had

experienced the greatest war the world had yet to see at that point could never be successfully re-integrated into the old bourgeoisie order from which they came. For these fighters, the war had been a spiritual experience. Having endured so much only to see their side lose on such seemingly humiliating terms, the veterans of the war were aliens to the rationalistic, anti-militarist, liberal republic that emerged in 1918 at the close of the war. Junger was at his parents’ home recovering from war wounds during the time of the attempted coup by the leftist workers’ and soldiers’ councils and subsequent suppression of these by the Freikorps. He experimented with psychoactive drugs such as cocaine and opium during this time, something that he would continue to do much later in life. Upon recovery, he went back into active duty in the much diminished German army. Junger’s earliest works, such as In Storms of Steel, were published during this time and he also wrote for military journals on the more technical and specialized aspects of combat and military technology. Interestingly, Junger attributed Germany’s defeat in the war simply to poor leadership, both military and civilian, and rejected the “stab in the back” legend that consoled less keen veterans.

After leaving the army in 1923, Junger continued to write; producing a novella about a soldier during the war titled Sturm, and also began to study the philosophy of Oswald Spengler. His first work as a philosopher of nationalism appeared in the Nazi paper Volkischer Beobachter in September, 1923. Critiquing the failed Marxist revolution of 1918, Junger argued that the leftist coup failed because of its lacking of fresh ideas. It was simply a regurgitation of the egalitarian outlook of the French Revolution. The revolutionary left appealed only to the material wants of the German people in Junger’s views. A successful revolution would have to be much more than that. It would have to appeal to their spiritual or “folkish” instincts as well. Over the next few years Junger studied the natural sciences at the University of Leipzig and in 1925, at age thirty, he married nineteen-year-old Gretha von Jeinsen. Around this time, he also became a full-time political writer. Junger was hostile to Weimar democracy and its commercial bourgeoisie society. His emerging political ideal was one of an elite warrior caste that stood above petty partisan politics and the middle class obsession with material acquisition. Junger became involved with the the Stahlhelm, a right-wing veterans group, and was a contributor to its paper, Die Standardite.

He associated himself with the younger, more militant members of the organization who favored an uncompromised nationalist revolution and eschewed the parliamentary system. Junger’s weekly column in Die Standardite disseminated his nationalist ideology to his less educated readers. Junger’s views at this point were a mixture of Spengler, Social Darwinism, and the traditionalist philosophy of the French rightist Maurice Barrès, opposition to the internationalism of the left that had seemingly been discredited by the events of 1914, irrationalism and anti-parliamentarianism. He took a favorable view of the working class and praised the Nazis’ efforts to win proletarian sympathies. Junger also argued that a nationalist outlook need not be attached to one particular form of government, even suggesting that a liberal monarchy would be inferior to a nationalist republic.[37]

In an essay for Die Standardite titled “The Machine,” Junger argued that the principal struggle was not between social classes or political parties but between man and technology. He was not anti-technological in a Luddite sense, but regarded the technological apparatus of modernity to have achieved a position of superiority over mankind which needed to be reversed. He was concerned that the mechanized efficiency of modern life produced a corrosive effect on the human spirit. Junger considered the Nazis’ glorification of peasant life to be antiquated. Ever the realist, he believed the world of the rural people to be in a state of irreversible decline. Instead, Junger espoused a “metropolitan nationalism” centered on the urban working class. Nationalism was the antidote to the anti-particularist materialism of the Marxists who, in Junger’s views, simply mirrored the liberals in their efforts to reduce the individual to a component of a mechanized mass society. The humanitarian rhetoric of the left Junger dismissed as the hypocritical cant of power-seekers feigning benevolence. He began to pin his hopes for a nationalist revolution on the younger veterans who comprised much of the urban working class.

In 1926, Junger became editor of Arminius, which also featured the writings of Nazi leaders like Alfred Rosenberg and Joseph Goebbels. In 1927, he contributed his final article to the Nazi paper, calling for a new definition of the “worker,” one not rooted in Marxist ideology but the idea of the worker as a civilian counterpart to the soldier who struggles fervently for the nationalist ideal. Junger and Hitler had exchanged copies of their respective writings and a scheduled meeting between the two was canceled due to a change in Hitler’s itinerary. Junger respected Hitler’s abilities as an orator, but came to feel he lacked the ability to become a true leader. He also found Nazi ideology to be intellectually shallow, many of the Nazi movement’s leaders to be talentless and was displeased by the vulgarity, crassly opportunistic and overly theatrical aspects of Nazi public rallies. Always an elitist, Junger considered the Nazis’ pandering to the common people to be debased. As he became more skeptical of the Nazis, Junger began writing for a wider circle of readers beyond that of the militant nationalist right-wing. His works began to appear in the Jewish liberal Leopold Schwarzchild’s Das Tagebuch and the “national-Bolshevik” Ernst Niekisch’s Widerstand.Junger began to assemble around himself an elite corps of bohemian, eccentric intellectuals who would meet regularly on Friday evenings. This group included some of the most interesting personalities of the Weimar period. Among them were the Freikorps veteran Ernst von Salomon, Otto von Strasser, who with his brother Gregor led a leftist anti-Hitler faction of the Nazi movement, the national-Bolshevik Niekisch, the Jewish anarchist Erich Muhsam who had figured prominently in the early phase of the failed leftist revolution of 1918, the American writer Thomas Wolfe and the expressionist writer Arnolt Bronnen. Many among this group espoused a type of revolutionary socialism based on nationalism rather than class, disdaining the Nazis’ opportunistic outreach efforts to the middle class. Some, like Niekisch, favored an alliance between Germany and Soviet Russia against the liberal-capitalist powers of the West. Occasionally, Joseph Goebbels would turn up at these meetings hoping to convert the group, particularly Junger himself, whose war writings he had admired, to the Nazi cause. These efforts by the Nazi propaganda master proved unsuccessful. Junger regarded Goebbels as a shallow ideologue who spoke in platitudes even in private conversation.[38]

The final break between Ernst Junger and the NSDAP occurred in September 1929. Junger published an article in Schwarzchild’s Tagebuch attacking and ridiculing the Nazis as sell outs for having reinvented themselves as a parliamentary party. He also dismissed their racism and anti-Semitism as ridiculous, stating that according to the Nazis a nationalist is simply someone who “eats three Jews for breakfast.” He condemned the Nazis for pandering to the liberal middle class and reactionary traditional conservatives “with lengthy tirades against the decline in morals, against abortion, strikes, lockouts, and the reduction of police and military forces.” Goebbels responded by attacking Junger in the Nazi press, accusing him being motivated by personal literary ambition, and insisting this had caused him “to vilify the national socialist movement, probably so as to make himself popular in his new kosher surroundings” and dismissing Junger’s attacks by proclaiming the Nazis did not “debate with renegades who abuse us in the smutty press of Jewish traitors.”[39]Junger on the Jewish Question

Junger held complicated views on the question of German Jews. He considered anti-Semitism of the type espoused by Hitler to be crude and reactionary. Yet his own version of nationalism required a level of homogeneity that was difficult to reconcile with the sub national status of Germany Jewry. Junger suggested that Jews should assimilate and pledge their loyalty to Germany once and for all. Yet he expressed admiration for Orthodox Judaism and indifference to Zionism. Junger maintained personal friendships with Jews and wrote for a Jewish owned publication. During this time his Jewish publisher Schwarzchild published an article examining Junger’s views on the Jews of Germany. Schwarzchild insisted that Junger was nothing like his Nazi rivals on the far right. Junger’s nationalism was based on an aristocratic warrior ethos, while Hitler’s was more comparable to the criminal underworld. Hitler’s men were “plebian alley scum”. However, Schwarzchild also characterized Junger’s rendition of nationalism as motivated by little more than a fervent rejection of bourgeoisie society and lacking in attention to political realities and serious economic questions.[40]

The Worker

Other than In Storms of Steel, Junger’s The Worker: Mastery and Form was his most influential work from the Weimar era. Junger would later distance himself from this work, published in 1932, and it was reprinted in the 1950s only after Junger was prompted to do so by Martin Heidegger.

In The Worker, Junger outlines his vision of a future state ordered as a technocracy based on workers and soldiers led by warrior elite. Workers are no longer simply components of an industrial machine, whether capitalist or communist, but have become a kind of civilian-soldier operating as an economic warrior. Just as the soldier glories in his accomplishments in battle, so does the worker glory in the achievements expressed through his work. Junger predicted that continued technological advancements would render the worker/capitalist dichotomy obsolete. He also incorporated the political philosophy of his friend Carl Schmitt into his worldview. As Schmitt saw international relations as a Hobbesian battle between rival powers, Junger believed each state would eventually adopt a system not unlike what he described in The Worker. Each state would maintain its own technocratic order with the workers and soldiers of each country playing essentially the same role on behalf of their respective nations. International affairs would be a crucible where the will to power of the different nations would be tested.

Junger’s vision contains a certain amount of prescience. The general trend in politics at the time was a movement towards the kind of technocratic state Junger described. These took on many varied forms including German National Socialism, Italian Fascism, Soviet Communism, the growing welfare states of Western Europe and America’s New Deal. Coming on the eve of World War Two, Junger’s prediction of a global Hobbesian struggle between national collectives possessing previously unimagined levels of technological sophistication also seems rather prophetic. Junger once again attacked the bourgeoisie as anachronistic. Its values of material luxury and safety he regarded as unfit for the violent world of the future.[41]

The National Socialist Era

By the time Hitler came to power in 1933, Junger’s war writings had become commonly used in high schools and universities as examples of wartime literature, and Junger enjoyed success within the context of German popular culture as well. Excerpts of Junger’s works were featured in military journals. The Nazis tried to co-opt his semi-celebrity status, but he was uncooperative. Junger was appointed to the Nazified German Academy of Poetry, but declined the position. When the Nazi Party’s paper published some of his work in 1934, Junger wrote a letter of protest. The Nazi regime, despite its best efforts to capitalize on his reputation, viewed Junger with suspicion. His past association with the national-Bolshevik Ersnt Niekisch, the Jewish anarchist Erich Muhsam and the anti-Hitler Nazi Otto

von Strasser, all of whom were either eventually killed or exiled by the Third Reich, led the Nazis to regard Junger as a potential subversive. On several occasions, Junger received visits from the Gestapo in search of some of his former friends. During the early years of the Nazi regime, Junger was in the fortunate economic position of being able to afford to travel outside of Germany. He journeyed to Norway, Brazil, Greece and Morocco during this time, and published several works based on his travels.[42]

Junger’s most significant work from the Nazi period is the novel On the Marble Cliffs. The book is an allegorical attack on the Hitler regime. It was written in 1939, the same year that Junger re-entered the German army. The book describes a mysterious villain that threatens a community, a sinister warlord called the “Head Ranger”. This character is never featured in the plot of the novel, but maintains a foreboding presence that is universal (much like “Big Brother” in George Orwell’s 1984). Another character in the novel, “Braquemart”, is described as having physical characteristics remarkably similar to those of Goebbels. The book sold fourteen thousand copies during its first two weeks in publication. Swiss reviewers immediately recognized the allegorical references to the Nazi state in the novel. The Nazi Party’s organ, Volkische Beobachter, stated that Ernst Jünger was flirting with a bullet to the head. Goebbels urged Hitler to ban the book, but Hitler refused, probably not wanting to show his hand. Indeed, Hitler gave orders that Junger not be harmed.[43]Junger was stationed in France for most of the Second World War. Once again, he kept diaries of the experience. Once again, he expressed concern that he might not get to see any action before the war was over. While Junger did not have the opportunity to experience the level of danger and daredevil heroics he had during the Great War, he did receive yet another medal, the Iron Cross, for retrieving the body of a dead corporal while under heavy fire. Junger also published some of his war diaries during this time. However, the German government took a dim view of these, viewing them as too sympathetic to the occupied French. Junger’s duties included censorship of the mail coming into France from German civilians. He took a rather liberal approach to this responsibility and simply disposed of incriminating documents rather than turning them over for investigation. In doing so, he probably saved lives. He also encountered members of France’s literary and cultural elite, among them the actor Louis Ferdinand Celine, a raving anti-Semite and pro-Vichyite who suggested Hitler’s harsh measures against the Jews had not been heavy handed enough. As rumors of the Nazi extermination programs began to spread, Junger wrote in his diary that the mechanization of the human spirit of the type he had written about in the past had apparently generated a higher level of human depravity. When he saw three young French-Jewish girls wearing the yellow stars required by the Nazis, he wrote that he felt embarrassed to be in the Nazi army. In July of 1942, Junger observed the mass arrest of French Jews, the beginning of implementation of the “Final Solution.” He described the scene as follows:

“Parents were first separated from their children, so there was wailing to be heard in the streets. At no moment may I forget that I am surrounded by the unfortunate, by those suffering to the very depths, else what sort of person, what sort of officer would I be? The uniform obliges one to grant protection wherever it goes. Of course one has the impression that one must also, like Don Quixote, take on millions.”[44]An entry into Junger’s diary from October 16, 1943 suggests that an unnamed army officer had told Junger about the use of crematoria and poison gas to murder Jews en masse. Rumors of plots against Hitler circulated among the officers with whom Junger maintained contact. His son, Ernst, was arrested after an informant claimed he had spoken critically of Hitler. Ernst Junger was imprisoned for three months then placed in a penal battalion where he was killed in action in Italy. On July 20, 1944 an unsuccessful assassination attempt was carried out against Hitler. It is still disputed as to whether or not Junger knew of the plot or had a role in its planning. Among those arrested for their role in the attempt on Hitler’s life were members of Junger’s immediate circle of associates and superior officers within the German army. Junger was dishonorably discharged shortly afterward.[45]

Following the close of the Second World War, Junger came under suspicion from the Allied occupational authorities because of his far right-wing nationalist and militarist past. He refused to cooperate with the Allies De-Nazification programs and was barred from publishing for four years. He would go on to live another half century, producing many more literary works, becoming a close friend of Albert Hoffman, the inventor of the hallucinogen LSD, with which he experimented. In a 1977 novel, Eumeswil, he took his tendency towards viewing the world around him with detachment to a newer, more clearly articulated level with his invention of the concept of the “Anarch”. This idea, heavily influenced by the writings of the early nineteenth century German philosopher Max Stirner, championed the solitary individual who remains true to himself within the context of whatever external circumstances happen to be present.

Some sample quotations from this work illustrate the philosophy and worldview of the elderly Junger quite well:

“For the anarch, if he remains free of being ruled, whether by sovereign or society, this does not mean he refuses to serve in any way. In general, he serves no worse than anyone else, and sometimes even better, if he likes the game. He only holds back from the pledge, the sacrifice, the ultimate devotion ... I serve in the Casbah; if, while doing this, I die for the Condor, it would be an accident, perhaps even an obliging gesture, but nothing more.”

“The egalitarian mania of demagogues is even more dangerous than the brutality of men in gallooned coats. For the anarch, this remains theoretical, because he avoids both sides. Anyone who has been oppressed can get back on his feet if the oppression did not cost him his life. A man who has been equalized is physically and morally ruined. Anyone who is different is not equal; that is one of the reasons why the Jews are so often targeted.”

“The anarch, recognizing no government, but not indulging in paradisal dreams as the anarchist does, is, for that very reason, a neutral observer.”

“Opposition is collaboration.”

“A basic theme for the anarch is how man, left to his own devices, can defy superior force - whether state, society or the elements - by making use of their rules without submitting to them.”

“... malcontents... prowl through the institutions eternally dissatisfied, always disappointed. Connected with this is their love of cellars and rooftops, exile and prisons, and also banishment, on which they actually pride themselves. When the structure finally caves in they are the first to be killed in the collapse. Why do they not know that the world remains inalterable in change? Because they never find their way down to its real depth, their own. That is the sole place of essence, safety. And so they do themselves in.”

“The anarch may not be spared prisons - as one fluke of existence among others. He will then find the fault in himself.”

“We are touching one a ... distinction between anarch and anarchist; the relation to authority, to legislative power. The anarchist is their mortal enemy, while the anarch refuses to acknowledge them. He seeks neither to gain hold of them, nor to topple them, nor to alter them - their impact bypasses him. He must resign himself only to the whirlwinds they generate.”

“The anarch is no individualist, either. He wishes to present himself neither as a Great Man nor as a Free Spirit. His own measure is enough for him; freedom is not his goal; it is his property. He does not come on as foe or reformer: one can get along nicely with him in shacks or in palaces. Life is too short and too beautiful to sacrifice for ideas, although contamination is not always avoidable. But hats off to the martyrs.”

“We can expect as little from society as from the state. Salvation lies in the individual.”[46]

Beyond the End of History: Rejecting the Washington Consensus

Keith Preston

Wednesday, August 13, 2025

If twins are born, the hunter kills one so that the second may live

 Returning from the far north, Attila had brought along a primordial delight in superfluousness. The latter, he said, represented the capital whose interest nourishes the world, harvest by harvest. That was how the hunter lived amidst tremendous herds, which kept multiplying without his interference, long before the earth was notched by the plowshare.

“The hunter has companions, but tillage brought slavery, killing became murder. Freedom ended; the game was driven away. In Cain a descendant of the primal hunter was resurrected, his avenger, perhaps. Genesis supplies only a rumor about all this. It hints at Yahweh's bad conscience regarding the slayer.”

I enjoyed hearing these things when I poured the refills long past midnight. Those were spoors that the anarch repeatedly tracks down – and the poet, too; no poet is without a touch of anarchy. Where else could poetry come from?

*

Attila felt that superfluousness requires its control. When the word comes surging, the poet has not yet formed it into a poem. Countless shapes slumber in marble – but who will bring forth even one? Hard by the rich pastures, Attila had run into nomads who arduously dug their food from the earth: worms and roots.

Oolibuk – that was the Inuit's name – was still a good hunter; he knew how to wield his bow. Once Attila asked him to shoot a black-throated diver swimming some eighty feet from their kayak. The bird eluded the first arrow by diving; the second pierced its head through both eyes when it resurfaced.

Otherwise the Inuits were thoroughly corrupted by dealing with the whalers, who, next to the sandalwood skippers, were notoriously the worst villains ever to plow the seas. From them, they had learned how to smoke, drink, and gamble. They gambled away their dogs, boats, weapons, and also their wives; a woman might change hands five times in a single night.

*

Yet Oolibuk also knew about the days before any ship had ever penetrated these climes. Grandmothers who had heard about the past from their grandmothers would tell their grandchildren.

The big day in an lnuit's life comes when, still a boy, he kills his first seal. The men gather around him and his booty; they hail his dexterity and praise the seal – never has anyone seen such a strong animal and such good meat.

Killing a seal is difficult; a man is not a hunter if he fails. He has to content himself with female food, with fish, seaweed, and crustaceans. Strange tales are told about such men; one of them, finding no wife, had to make do with a mussel, and he lost his member because the shell clamped shut.

The hunter, in contrast, is a free man, around whom the world arranges itself. He alone maintains the family, richly providing it with meat and hides, as well as blubber, which provides light and warmth in the simply endless winter night. The hunter is bold and cunning, and, like all early hunters, he is related to the game he tracks. His body is plump and brawny like a sea mammal's, it is rich in blood and fat and has the same smell as the animal. The hunter will brave even the whale and the polar bear.

*

But the winter is long. It can come early and wear on interminably. Nor is the hunter always lucky. Though the pantry and storeroom of his ice dwelling can be chock-full at the start of winter, the crossing of the Arctic night remains a unique venture.

Incidentally, prior to setting up my bunker on the Sus, I studied construction plans that Captain Ross had found among the Eskimos of New North Wales. A basic theme for the anarch is how man, left to his own devices, can defy superior forces – whether state, society, or the elements – by making use of their rules without submitting to them.

“It is strange,” Sir William Parry wrote when describing the igloos on Winter Island, “it is strange to think that all these measures are taken against the cold - and in houses of ice.”

*

If the prey is inadequate, then the family will not survive the winter. It will waste away with hunger and scurvy in its glass palace. Polar bears will break open the igloo and find their meals. They will be followed by foxes and gulls.

Frost is a harsh master. Even while the Greenlander is struggling with death, the others bend his legs under his loins to make the grave shorter. If twins are born, the hunter kills one so that the second may live. The food would not suffice for both. If a mother dies in childbirth, the newborn is buried with her, or a bit later, when the father, at the end of his rope, can no longer stand the baby's bawling. “The father's grief is, of course, unbearable, especially when it is a son” – so goes Parry's account. Sometimes infants are exposed on desert islands when winter comes.

*

Why did Attila stress such details in his reminiscences of the polar night? What was his “guiding thought”? (That is what the Domo always asks when checking instructions.)

Was Attila bent on offering examples of the “power of necessity”? When worse comes to worst, a man is forced to make decisions that are hard, cruel – yes, even deadly.

Naturally, the Arctic tribes, or whatever is left of them, have long since been perishing in comfort. This is a gradual dying, over generations. But the fateful question remains in its harshness, even if time gives it a different mask.

With the discovery of oil in northern Alaska, high rises shot up there as everywhere else in those days. A traveler walled in by fire on the twentieth floor of a hotel has to choose between burning up and leaping into space. He will jump; this is documented by photographs.

*

But this did not seem to be Attila's point. His guiding thought in that discussion (which, as we recall, concerned abortion ) was, more or less: It is reprehensible to delegate a misdeed. The hunter takes his son to the mother's grave and kills him. He does not assign the task to anyone else – not his brother, not the shaman; he carries it out himself.

If a man here in Eumeswil has “made a child,” he usually hands his wife or girlfriend a check and feels he is off the hook, certain that she will take care of it. Attila obviously means that if the man personally killed his son like the Inuit, then he would know what he was doing.

As an anarch, who acknowledges neither law nor custom, I owe it to myself to get at the very heart of things. I then probe them in terms of their contradictions, like image and mirror image. Either is imperfect – by seeking to unite them, which I practice every morning, I manage to catch a corner of reality.

Eumeswil

Ernst Jünger

Monday, August 11, 2025

The decay of language is not so much a disease as a symptom

 As a grammarian, Thofern sets great store by the verb “to nurture,” and it is here that I, as a historian, concur with him. The historian's task is a tragic one; ultimately it has to do with death and eternity. Hence his burrowing in rubble, his circling around graves, his insatiable thirst for sources, his anxious listening to the heartbeat of time.

What could lie hidden behind such disquiet? – I have often wondered. How understandable the terror of the savage who, upon seeing the sun disappear, fears it will never return. The man who stored the mummy in the rock hoped for the mummy's return, and we rob it of its bindings in order to confirm his – no, our – hope. When granting life to the past, we succeed in conquering time, and a subduing of death becomes apparent. Should the latter work out, then it is conceivable that a god will breathe new life into us.

13

“The decay of language is not so much a disease as a symptom. The water of life is dwindling. Words have meaning still, but not sense. They are being replaced largely by numbers. Words are becoming incapable of producing poetry and ineffective in prayer. The crude enjoyments are supplanting the spiritual ones.”

That was what Thofern said. In the seminar, he went into detail: “People have always delighted, more or less clandestinely, in the argots, the books sold under a coat or read with one hand. Then they are praised as models. The Third Tone dominates.”

By the “Third Tone” he meant the lowest level for naming things and activities. They are addressed in a lofty, a current, or a common manner; each manner is good in its place.

“If the common becomes normal in colloquial speech or even in poetry, then it involves an assault on the lofty. Anyone who likes to gobble and boast about it forestalls any suspicion of viewing bread as a miracle that is celebrated in the Supper.

“Profanation sets off lower forms of merriment. A head can ascend to a crown, a face to a countenance, or it can twist into a mug. Profanation can provoke merriment when it appears in Pandaemonium; the gods, too, laugh at Priapus. The merry-andrew has his place in the intermezzo. But if he rules the boards as a buffo assoluto, then the stage becomes a distorting mirror.

“At the opera comica, I always saw a few spectators departing once the laughter began to roar. This is more than a question of taste. There is such a thing as a collective gusto, also a jubilation, announcing imminent danger. The good spirits leave the house. In the Roman circus, the effigies of the gods were draped before blood flowed.”

*

Now and then, I, as a student of history, was permitted to help Thofern prepare his lectures. Thus, when dealing with the decay of language, he asked me to gather material about the contributions of the Eumenists.

Those things go back quite a way, and it may be said that no one cares two hoots about them anymore. At the luminar, however, the number of titles that I tallied up was enormous, even for the limited area of our city. As in any work on a scholarly apparatus, the main issue was to survey the cardinal points. Whatever has moved the Zeitgeist cascades in a chaotic flood; one has to catch the historical meaning concealed behind opinions and events.

The linguistic decay that the professor was talking about occurred during the final period of the wars between nations, a time that heralded great coalitions. First, the regional gods had to be disempowered worldwide; the fact that the father was also affected indicated a planetary agitation.

The disempowering of the father endangers the heavens and the great forests; when Aphrodite bids farewell, the ocean goes dim; once Ares is no longer in charge of wars, the shacks of flayers multiply, the sword becomes a slaughterer's knife.

In a period of decline, when it was considered glorious to have helped destroy one's own nation, the roots of language were, not surprisingly, likewise pruned, above all in Eumeswil. Loss of history and decay of language are mutual determinants; the Eumenists championed both. They felt called upon to defoliate language on the one hand and to gain prestige for slang on the other hand. Thus, down below they robbed the populace of language and, with it, poetry, on the pretext that they were facilitating speech; while on the heights they presented their “mugs.”

The assault on evolved language and on grammar, on script and signs, is part of the simplification that has gone down in history as a cultural revolution. The first world-state cast its shadow.

*

Well, that lies behind us now. In this area, we have been released from wanting and wishing and can render unbiased judgment to the extent of our abilities. In Eumeswil, this applies, I feel, to Vigo, Bruno, and Thofern. Different as they are, these three are able to have a conversation without promptly serving up the trendy claptrap. One often has the impression in Eumeswil that it is not the person but the swarm that answers. Of course, there are raised platforms, as with my dear father, and also flounders of the deep, which unite in schools.

Eumeswil

Ernest Jünger 

Saturday, August 9, 2025

The brass city

 How had he hit on Damascus and then the leap to Spain, through which Abd-ur Rahman had escaped being murdered? For almost three centuries, a branch of the Omayyads, who had been exterminated in Syria, flourished in Cordoba. Along with mosques, the faïences testified to this branch of Arabic civilization, a branch long since withered. And then there were the castles of the Beni Taher in Yemen. A seed fell into the desert sand, managing to yield four harvests.

The fifth Omayyad, an ancestor of Abd-ur Rahman, had dispatched Emir Musa to the brass city. The caravan traveled from Damascus through Cairo and the great desert, into the western lands, and all the way to the coast of Mauritania. The goal was the copper flasks in which King Solomon had jailed rebellious demons. Now and again, the fishermen who cast their nets in the EI-Karkar Sea would haul up one of these flasks in their catches. They were closed with the seal of Solomon; when they were opened, the demon spurted forth as smoke that darkened the sky.

Emirs named Musa also recur subsequently in Granada and other residences of Moorish Spain. This emir, the conqueror of Northwest Africa, may be regarded as their prototype. His Western features are unmistakable; of course, we must bear in mind that the distinctions between races and regions vanish on the peaks. Just as people resemble one another ethically, indeed become almost identical, when approaching perfection, so too spiritually. The distance from the world and from the object increases; curiosity grows and with it the desire to get closer to the ultimate secrets, even amid great danger. This is an Aristotelian trait. One that makes use of arithmetic.

It has not come down to us whether the emir felt any qualms about opening the flasks. From other accounts, we know that his step was risky. For instance, one of the imprisoned demons had sworn to himself that he would make the man who freed him the most powerful of mortals; he had spent hundreds of years thinking about how to make him happy. But then the demon's mood had soured; gall and venom had concentrated in his dungeon. When a fisherman finally opened the flask centuries later, he would have suffered the fate of being ripped to shreds by the demon had he not resorted to a trick. Evil becomes all the more dreadful the longer it is deprived of air.

In any case, Musa, needless to say, could not have recoiled from the unsealing. This is already evidenced by the uncommon boldness of his expedition through the wastelands. The aged Abd-es Samad, who possessed The Book of Hidden Treasures and could read the stars, guided the caravan to the brass city within fourteen months. They rested in deserted castles and amid the graves in decaying cemeteries. At times, they found water in wells that Iskander had dug while trekking westward.

The brass city was likewise dead and was enclosed by a ring wall; it took another two moons for blacksmiths and carpenters to build a ladder all the way to the battlements. Anyone who climbed up was blinded by a spell, so that he clapped his hands, and crying “Thou art beautiful!” plunged down. Twelve of Musa's companions perished, one after another, until at last Abd-es Samad succeeded in resisting the witchcraft by incessantly calling out Allah's name while clambering up and, after he reached the top, reciting the verses of salvation. Under the mirage as under a watery surface, he saw the shattered bodies of his predecessors. Said Musa: “If that's how a rational man acts, what will a madman do?”

The sheik then descended through one of the turrets and, from the inside, opened the gates of the necropolis. However, it was not these adventures - although they have their secret meaning - that prompts the mention of Emir Musa; rather it was his encounter with the historical world, which becomes a phantasm vis-a-vis the reality of the fairy tale.

The emir had the poet Thalib read aloud the inscriptions on the monuments and on the walls of the deserted palaces:

Ah, where are they whose strength has built all these

With unbelievably lofty balconies?

Where are the Persian shahs in castles tall?

They left their land - it did forget them all!

Where are the men who ruled the vast countries,

Sind and Hind, the proud hosts of dynasties?

To whom Sendge and Habesh did bend their will

And Nubia when it was rebellious still?

Await no tiding now from any tomb,

No knowledge is forthcoming from its womb.

The times changed, weaving death from every loom; 

The citadels they built brought naught but doom.

These verses filled Musa with such profound sorrow that life became a burden for him. As they wandered through the rooms, they came to a table carved out of yellow marble or, according to other reports, cast in Chinese steel. There, the following words were notched in Arabic letters:

At this table, a thousand kings have dined whose right eyes were blind and a thousand others whose left eyes were blind: they have all passed on and now they populate the graves and catacombs.

When Thalib read these words aloud to him, everything went dark before Musa's eyes; he shrieked and rent his garment. Then he had the verses and inscriptions copied down.

Eumeswil

By Ernest Jünger

Monday, May 26, 2025

Books and Cities

 

76

The listless, nocturnal circling and wandering of drunken masses through sprawling, bleak quarters is a frightening scene, similar to those depicted by De Quincey and Jack London in their memoirs. A cheap bar beckons on every corner; people drink on their feet, and the strong potions have an almost violent effect on the weakened constitutions. Swarms of streetwalkers, among them children, drift along in the current with drunk women and homeless people. Lurking between them are the types whose livelihoods depend on the intoxicated and the will-less: pimps, smugglers, pickpockets, and villains of every kind.

They do not drink for nostalgia or to get closer to others here; they drink to escape and to forget, and the awakenings are terrifying. The demon is ever present; with his unsurpassable nose, Dostoyevsky sensed this almost physically. His travel journals are veritable demonologies, the wanderings of a ghost-seer through the world. With the same certainty that a Tocqueville captured the political structures, he captured their boundless backgrounds—as if the one had occupied himself with the musculature, the other with the pneuma of a being. In Paris, Dostoyevsky found a great “stillness of order, so to speak! . . . a colossal, internal, spiritual regimentation having its source in the very soul . . . ,” it could have been a “Heidelberg on a colossal scale.”22London seemed to him the titanic negative image of civilized Parisian humanity, reposing in itself despite all the outward movement. A “fear of something or other” began to seize him during his walks through London, a city in which “on Saturday nights half a million working men and women and their children spread like the ocean all over town, clustering particularly in certain districts, and celebrate their sabbath all night long until five o’clock in the morning, in other words, guzzle and drink like beasts to make up for a whole week. They bring with them their weekly savings, all that was earned by hard work and with many a curse. Great jets of gas burn in meat and food shops, brightly lighting up the streets. It is as if a grand reception were being held for these white negroes. Crowds throng the open taverns and streets. There they eat and drink. The beer houses are decorated like palaces. Everyone is drunk, but drunk joylessly, gloomily and heavily, and everyone is somehow strangely mute. Only curses and bloody brawls occasionally break that suspicious and oppressively sad silence. . . . Everyone is in a hurry to drink himself into insensibility . . . wives in no way lag behind their husbands and all get drunk together, while children crawl and run about among them.”23He then describes a walk through a glowing hellhole of lust. Léon Bloy expresses a similar aversion to London, vented in his extreme manner to the point of wishing for a cannon that could finish off the “capitale infâme” with one shot. Bloy comes at it from a different angle: that of a Spanish-flavored Catholicism observing Protestantism, analogous to the relationship between a cat and a dog.

Protestantism, without which our technological new world is unthinkable, finds it more difficult to spread into the wine-producing countries than into the northern ones. Transition zones often bring unexpected manifestations. Think of Geneva.

77

Dostoyevsky’s vision, which could penetrate into even the Parisian “stillness,” was nevertheless not confused by the storm of images that frightened and unsettled him in London. He might have called the chapter in which he describes these impressions something like “Splendor and Misery of the Machine World.” He chose a different title: “Baal.” Evidently, he had perceived something more there: a power enthroned in the midst of the crowd.

A person looking for a way out never exits into a void; something is waiting at every possible egress. Fleeing is a fatal movement in itself. We can include suicide in this, with the exception of its stoic forms, which should not be regarded as evasion. “In certain circumstances, exiting life may become a duty for the brave.”24

78

From the perspective of intoxication, scenes like those described by Dostoyevsky represent a meeting of narcotic and stimulating effects. Something gets forgotten, like a curtain with graying images painted on it being rolled up and away. Then another world appears behind it where a new master has been busy. The lights become harsher, the colors more vivid. Naked desires step forth. There were glowing embers deep under the ashes—now flames shoot up, as if stoked by bellows. The heart and lungs respond.

The senses also sharpen, for the smell of blood too. The masses scent blood on the wide streets and squares like ravenous predatory fish in a bend on the Amazon. There the river begins to boil; here it is the foaming of yeast. Twenty years before Dostoyevsky, Dickens had witnessed a similar scene: at the execution of the Manning couple who had been sentenced to death for a carefully planned murder and robbery. He presented his impressions in a letter to the Times:

“Sir, I was a witness of the execution at Horsemonger Lane this morning. I went there with the intention of observing the crowd gathered to behold it, and I had excellent opportunities of doing so. . . .

“When I came upon the scene at midnight, the shrillness of the cries and howls that were raised from time to time, denoting that they came from a concourse of boys and girls already assembled in the best places, made my blood run cold. As the night went on, screeching, and laughing, and yelling in strong chorus of parodies on negro melodies, with substitutions of ‘Mrs. Manning’ for ‘Susannah’ and the like, were added to these. When the day dawned, thieves, low prostitutes, ruffians, and vagabonds of every kind, flocked on to the ground, with every variety of offensive and foul behaviour. Fightings, faintings, whistlings, imitations of Punch, brutal jokes, tumultuous demonstrations of indecent delight when swooning women were dragged out of the crowd by the police, with their dresses disordered, gave a new zest to the general entertainment. When the sun rose brightly—as it did—it gilded thousands upon thousands of upturned faces, so inexpressibly odious in their brutal mirth or callousness, that a man had cause to feel ashamed of the shape he wore and to shrink from himself, as fashioned in the image of the Devil.”2579

Nothing good emerges in this spectacle. Yet it cannot be attributed to intoxication, for the altered state only reveals, as if a curtain were lifted or the door to a deep crypt opened. It is one key among others.

In seeking out this event and spending the night there, Dickens obeyed a higher curiosity to which the author is not only entitled but even obliged. When, as he says, he felt shame, that also is part of the course and especially important in an era like the Victorian, during which everything always came up smelling of roses.

Such cannibalism is after all innate in man, and it does not need an execution to express itself. Cruelty is almost anatomically inborn in man, like the blind spot in our eyes, and it is just as little noticed. In every epoch, there is an ostracized element on which the general aversion concentrates. These elements are branded as heretics, it is considered commendable to persecute them, and when something bad happens to them people feel gratified. This kind of gratification is also present in good people, even in Pickwickians.26 It begins as early as kindergarten or first grade.

80

Here I need to resist the temptation of a long literary digression. Its theme would be the manner in which the attention of different writers focuses on these ostracized elements. It is significant whether this attention originates from outside—be it sympathetic or even benevolent—or from within. In this regard, the light that Dostoyevsky brings to bear on evil is fundamentally different from that of Dickens, Victor Hugo, or, to name an extreme case, Eugène Sue.

Dostoyevsky enters into Raskolnikov’s inner universe; he thinks, feels, and suffers with the murderer, and he is resurrected with him. He follows the great “Thou art that.”27 This is enlightening in the highest sense since the reader is included in the process of identification; but it does make the reading a purgatory for entire chapters—for instance, in Marmeladov’s confession or Raskolnikov’s plea of guilty.

This book, often described as a crime novel, is actually the opposite. The crime novel is fascinating because a human being is hunted in it; the chase, the clever tricks, the manhunt in the big city jungle: elements of a Great Hunt. Dostoyevsky takes us a floor deeper; the murderer appears as his own persecutor, but also his own self-conqueror. This touches us more intimately.

I also have to restrain myself here from bringing in Joseph Conrad: as a phenomenon of transition not only in East–West relations but also in the moral sphere, where his illumination of the ruined existence is unsurpassable. One might say that the roses begin to lose their sweet smell here. A ruined existence is an ambiguous case—a person no longer belongs to society, but he still recognizes its laws.

81

I don’t think we have strayed too far from the theme with this; at worst, it has been a circumscribing of it. The pure observation of man, also when accompanied by sympathy or even compassion, only ever nears its subject imperfectly.

Something entirely different occurs when the author begins to enter into his subjects, to identify with them. Lavater once said that to truly understand someone else one has to imitate their face28—we can agree, assuming that this does not stop at the mask. This is the touchstone that separates the authentic from the simulated—it can also be applied to actors. Blood will always be called for, and the most faithful imitation, the finest character study, will never achieve what passion can. Then art becomes identical with nature, the mask melts into the primordial substance. The distinction can be found in all the arts, including the healing arts, and it always involves what no school or technique can teach.

Raphael said, “Understanding means becoming one.” We should include the animal in this relation; the ancient hunters always knew this. It applies not only to blood forms of hunting but also to the higher hunt with its spiritual, deathless capture of the prey. Here again the religions of the Far East distinguish themselves from those of the Middle East. Many other eras, including the most ancient, were closer to and understood the animal more profoundly than our own, despite all the sophistications of modern-day zoology. And never have there been such shameful ways of treating animals as in our day.

The poet, too, knows the mystery of the Great Hunt. As the ancient hunters invoked the animal with masks and dances, so he invokes it with words that do not stop at impressions of movement and patches of color. Brothers should generally not sing each other’s praise; nevertheless, I cannot ignore Friedrich Georg’s success in this domain—with the peacock, the owl, the snake, the hare, and others.

We return here to early, pre-mythical times, to the transformative powers of the Great Mother. Her dress may have many patterns and pleats, but it is made of a single fabric. This unity becomes clear in fairy tales; poets and artists in general remind us of this. More important than what they make us see and hear is what they help us forget. If they succeed with this One, all else is left behind: the fragmentary, the disputable, the separate—that is, time and its shadings.

82

Dostoyevsky apparently saw something reassuring in the looser constitution of Paris and something frightening in the order of London. This attests to his penetrating but humane look. He saw Baal enthroned behind the spectacle on the Thames, and it frightened and fascinated him as it had inspired the portrayals of many others before and after him.

Dostoyevsky was likely thinking of the Bal or Bel who also appeared as a dragon and whom King Cyrus demanded of Daniel that he worship: “Thinkest thou not that Bel is a living God? Seest thou not how much he eats and drinks every day? . . . thou canst not say that he is no living god; therefore worship him.”29 Blake saw a green dragon manifesting in the form of the London Treasury Building.

The enduring reputation of this god Bel is of a hard and merciless master. The name Babylon, its principal seat, became synonymous with the metropolis as such, especially in its night side. Beyond this, Dostoyevsky also saw something specific: the stamp of puritanism in which enormous deployments of energy were coupled with an unwavering conscience. Hence, it is no coincidence that it was precisely in those puritanical zones that machine technology and its related forms of exploitation brought forth the precedents and model cases for critical reflection on these same phenomena.

If we look closely at this picture of London, the night side that is present in every metropolis and even in every small city is particularly bleak here. Like everything on offer in big cities, the varieties of vice are also more specialized and openly marketed. While the streets and quarters used for the purpose are similar in their essence everywhere, there are variations according to time and place: they are different in the capitals than in harbor or garrison towns, different where Hogarth studied them than where Toulouse-Lautrec did. There are cities with the age-old reputation of a Capua, and others that were founded expressly as centers of intoxication, gambling, and the sex trade.

In his Paris days, Dostoyevsky was undoubtedly also in Montmartre, but it was not there that Baal appeared to him to reign. He saw an orderly fabric in the Parisian ambience, in London an obscene disorder. We might have suspected the opposite impression, yet it is precisely here that his artistic incorruptibility is demonstrated—the artist whose gaze penetrates through the social veneer, through the varnish on a masterpiece, to its ground.

83

Again, the question arises: why do the altered states produce sadder, gloomier images in northern countries than in the south? There is no wine of course, but that also has its reasons. The same is true for the sun and for the climate in general. Poe is from a southern state, but he is nonetheless the perfect example for all the horrors of the Anglo-Saxon “blackout.” Poe’s hells are different from Baudelaire’s because in Poe the machine appears no longer in its economic but in its demonic power. The enemy of the artist, indeed of man, is mechanical movement; Bosch had already seen that.

In the north, the separation from all that the altered state is supposed to provide is greater; much of the natural, innate cheerfulness is lacking. On the other hand, northerners have a greater talent to reflect this into skepticism; masters of irony, satire, and the grotesque thrive more naturally in the north.

The separation entails greater effort. To forget something, to flee from something, or, conversely, to want to achieve or gain something—the whole problem of intoxication moves between these two poles. The poorer the substance, the wider the gap to be bridged. The way home from a Victorian family dinner passed directly by a brothel. Works and doctrines become “edifying” when the foundations of the edifice have become too weak. What should be is reflected into the mere appearance of it.

The comparison with the desert keeps coming to mind. Nietzsche pondered the matter thoroughly and roamed the oases and mirages himself. His evaluation of crime is part of this picture, along with the historical projection into the Renaissance. But caution is called for here; optical illusions had already crept in with Jacob Burckhardt, a confounding of strengths and weaknesses the consequences of which are difficult to judge. This leads back to Gobineau. “Nostalgia for racial purity is a distinguishing trait of the half-breed”—another of those maxims by which I did myself no favors.

Nietzsche’s relationship with altered states is that of a hyper-sensitive; the sun, the air, even the barometric pressure can have euphoric effects on such constitutions. He shares this with his readers above all in The Dawn of Day. In its preface he speaks of the person who “desires a long period of darkness, an unintelligible, hidden, enigmatic something, knowing as he does that he will in time have his own morning, his own redemption, his own rosy dawn.”30

Here again we are in an approach.

84

When the separation has become very great and the supervening element that we depend on very rare, then the intermediary zones and underworlds become more alluring—because things do not become absolutely barren. Now demons inhabit the crumbling altars.

The desolation must be grasped in the depths and not in the symptoms, for our visible world has no lack of outward variety. But this variety is bound to time and place, is dynamic in nature. We fly to the poles and even to the moon, and we bring our wastelands with us. So long as we stay in motion, the flood of images presses upon us. Why is it so insatiable, this hunger for images? It is a sign that the images are ultimately not satisfying. A real deficiency drives us to get beyond time and space.

Only where this hunger is no longer perceived as such can the mere images suffice; there they will seem complete in themselves, lacking nothing over, under, or behind them. They will no longer reveal their secrets to us. At this stage, people enjoy the contentment of the “Last Man” described by Nietzsche and after him by Huxley.

85

Where life becomes very impoverished, intoxication is one of the last remaining resources. This is one reason why alcoholism also cannot be dealt with by priests. The alcoholic can be helped neither economically nor morally; it is a problem of being, something theology has become increasingly incapable of resolving.

The alcoholic drinks not only to escape his own misery. Above all, he yearns to approach a place in which not only hisneeds but need as such has been removed, where grief itself does not exist. His euphoria conceals more than comfort and the absence of pain. Dostoyevsky grasped this too with brilliant insight. How else could he have put this sentence in the mouth of his unhappy hero, Marmeladow: “I drink so that I may suffer twice as much.”31

86

Natural cycles with their ebbs and flows are opposed to technical monotony: here the beat of the heart, there the cadence of the motor; here the poem, there the machine. The impulse to celebratory self-dissolution operates on both base and sublime levels—as much in those who drink away their weekly salary in the tavern as in the person who wants to say, “Once I lived like the gods!”

The cyclical rhythms are perceived more strongly where people still know the meaning of festivals and their joys; they are thus felt more strongly in untouched, archaic regions than in urbanized ones, more strongly in the country than in the city. The city is a single continuous fairground, it is light day and night. For this reason, the return—the real mystery of periodic cycles—is limited to only very big occasions. A return happens when the unmoving appears in the moving, the invisible in the visible—that is, when it is intimated in them.

There are thus more addicts in the city than in the country. One characteristic of addiction is that it tries to reduce the periodicity of the pleasure to a minimum, or even better, to a continuum. This flattens the peaks.

Cities also conceal addicts better than the countryside. They can live more anonymously, find shelter, change territories; the drugs are also easier to find.

In a small town, the village drunkard or the morphine addict are quickly identified and known to most, even when they try to hide their condition. This succeeds only when the transition from a strong habit to an unconditional addiction is not yet manifest. This is simultaneously the passage from open and approved consumption to a secret and suspect one.

Soon enough there is nothing left to hide; an inevitable loss of reputation and respect follows, apart from the economic, social, and health costs. The degeneration in the subject’s usual social manifestation, observed and suffered by family and friends, is perceived by the sufferer himself in the irrevocability of his demon. This is one of the saddest spectacles, described perhaps nowhere better than in some of E. A. Poe’s short stories.

Approaches : drugs and altered states / Ernst Jünger

what is the real in this case?—a number of marks in black printer’s ink on a few white sheets of paper

 Books and Readers

An essential monument of any city of dreams is that dedicated by the unknown reader to the nameless author in gratitude for the inspiration that has helped him attain a second, brighter existence. For myself, in any case, it appears that for long stretches I lived more intensely in books than in the intervals between them. I was not moving from Leipzig to Halle but from one chapter to the next. Between them lay the synchronized cadence of rails and ties, punctuated by the passing telegraph poles—the emptiness of the technical world. This had been the case even at school and then as a soldier—a life “to be continued.”

The palace of readers is the most enduring of all. It survives peoples, cultures, religions, and even the languages themselves. Earthquakes and wars do not shake it, nor even the burning of libraries, like the one in Alexandria. Markets, fellah towns, colosseums, skyscrapers, islands, and countries grow up in it and disappear, as though washed away by rain. Reality is charmed; the dream becomes real. A door is opened to a magical world.

I think that I have somewhere already mentioned the mandarin waiting for his execution in a line of wrongdoers, engrossed in a book as the beheadings proceed ahead of him. A reader is generally distracted, not because he could not cope with the world but because he simply takes it less seriously. This happens even more when a world is cheapened and its offerings devalued.

The Trials and Tribulations of Fontane has a firm place in my memory. I can relate details from it more precisely than what happened on the day I came to know the book. It was the day the Otago Rifles, fresh arrivals from New Zealand, were sent in at us, and we shot and blew each other up. During the breaks in the battle, I returned to the Brandenburg lake district of the Wilhelminian times.

In June 1904, as a nine-year-old, I first began reading One Thousand and One Nights, that immortal gift of the magical world to the West. I had found the book that month among the gifts on my mother’s birthday table. It was Gustave Weil’s four-volume translation, to which I repeatedly fled as to an oasis in the desert—that is, until I moved on to Littmann’s twelve-volume edition. The fables engraved themselves profoundly in my memory, as did the pictures in the richly illustrated edition. I sensed them again now in Taroudant, a Moroccan city with a strong oriental character despite its proximity to the coast.

One Thousand and One Nights: the ideal model of an at once collective and anonymous authorship. The work could have been created by a demon—fashioned overnight like one of its phantom castles. We could also think of the mother-of-pearl in a seashell—of cerebral traces that hardened into iridescence.

From: Approaches : drugs and altered states / Ernst Jünger

**


(I know, for my own part, that I am far more strongly moved by episodes in books than by those in real life, which usually leave me cold. This, of course, is what the author of the book is aiming at when he uses what Kierkegaard calls ‘the foreshortened perspective of the aesthetic’, which leaves out unromantic details—the hero’s interview with his bank manager about his overdraft; the heroine’s visit to the dentist to have two decayed teeth stopped—in order to heighten the reader’s emotional tension. My emotional reaction is entirely in the sphere of the imaginary; for what is the real in this case?—a number of marks in black printer’s ink on a few white sheets of paper.)

Nanavira Thera


Thursday, May 8, 2025

Internal Exile

 

It was by chance that the writer Julien Gracq discovered On the Marble Cliffs at the newsagent’s of Angers station,133  at the darkest time of the Occupation. He opened it while waiting for a train and could not tear himself away from it. He would later state that the novel was ‘Jünger’s masterpiece’. In La Littérature à l’estomac,134  a famous 1950 pamphlet that targeted the commercialisation of literature, he would add the following:

I would readily give up on almost all the literature of the past ten years for Ernst Jünger’s On the Marble Cliffs.135 

At a later time, he would expand further and write:

This book, which saw the light of day at one of the turning points of history [1939], tells us not only about Jünger himself, but, through him, also about ourselves and our era […]. I believe that one should read On the Marble Cliffs as a quintessential book. It is filled with great imagery, with images that have been, and still are, those of our lives as men of the mid-twentieth century, of our joys and disasters. […] Those are the different faces of our very situation: whether moving or terrible, they are the framework under which the cards of destiny were dealt to us.136 

The Warrior Who Withdrew from the World  

These thoughts, expressed by Julien Gracq, summarise to a certain extent the purpose of our current book. Ernst Jünger is indeed the witness of the successive faces of European destiny throughout the cruellest of centuries. However, On the Marble Cliffs only relates this fate in a fleeting manner. This coded novel cannot be separated from the era that witnessed its birth, independently of any artistic judgment.

In the text that we have just quoted, Julien Gracq briefly points out the highlights of Jünger’s career as both an author and a soldier, a career whose successive stages we are well-aware of: the endless reading endeavours during his childhood and adolescence, punctuated by adventurous outings into an untouched sort of nature; the founding ordeal of the Great War; the insolent heroism of a young assault troop officer covered in scars and forever marked by the exhilaration of the military attacks and the unrelenting harshness of the trenches; and the birth of the writer from the very moment that he removed his helmet. And what a writer he was! He would first become an author of war books and then a writer of political works that would turn him into the intellectual beacon of new radical thoughts that would be collected in his sensational manifesto entitled The Worker. And it was then that the one that people sometimes considered a herald of the victorious movement of 1933 suddenly turned away from it all in the most abrupt and unbridled manner. In response to the pleas made to him, he would dryly reply, ‘There is no room for me in an army where Göring is a general.’

Jünger thus becomes a sort of inner emigrant. He travels and meditates before penning his breakthrough novel, On the Marble Cliffs, in 1939, a novel whose meaning was immediately understood in Germany. As the first copies come out of the printing house, a new war breaks out. Although Jünger is mobilised, the enthusiasm of the past has given way to resignation. The opportunities to wage battle would be rare and he would not complain about it very much. Having ordered his men to always respect the vanquished in the aftermath of the French campaign, he is appointed to the headquarters of the occupying forces. Apart from being on leave a few times and a three-month mission in the Caucasus, he spent the rest of the war in Paris, establishing friendly relations with all that the French capital had to offer in terms of talent. Indirectly involved in the plot of 20 July 1944, he evades the fate of a great many other officers. During a long life in which he would also experience other, less dramatic developments, he had overcome many a mortal peril while enjoying a strange privilege of invulnerability.

Summarising Jünger’s life in his own words, Julien Gracq compares him to ‘those mediaeval warriors who had one day chosen to hang their sword on the walls of a cloister’. Although the image itself is beautiful, the fact remains that Jünger’s long existence was punctuated by a greater number of transmutations than this single change. It is, of course, true that On the Marble Cliffs did mark a clear break in the middle of his life, heralding the immense rift that would soon befall the mind and destiny of Europeans. We shall return to this later.137 

This break in Ernst Jünger’s life and work is a source of more than one enigma. The warrior, tempted by the dreams of a violent revolution, suddenly withdraws from the world and transforms into a humanitarian and pacifistic hermit, collecting plants on the heights of the Marble Cliffs. And it is the unexpected that drives even the least curious onlooker to ask questions.

Ernst Jünger

A Different European Destiny 

Domminque Venner

Tuesday, May 6, 2025

Carl Schmitt, Jünger’s Unlikely Friend

 

Unlike Jünger, Spengler and Ernst von Salomon, several renowned intellectuals belonging to the same hard-to-define movement of the Conservative Revolution had initially hoped that the new chancellor would be the providential actor that would bring about their country’s national recovery. I am thinking of the jurist Carl Schmitt, the writer Gottfried Benn and the philosopher Martin Heidegger.

Carl Schmitt (1888–1985) was, for a long time, part of the circle of Jünger’s close friends. They had met at the beginning of 1930 and the mutual appeal exerted by these two superior yet different minds had been so great that Jünger would often speak of his ‘unfathomable friend’ and his ‘invigorating’158  company. What had also brought them closer before 1933 was their shared distrust of Western democracies. On the other hand, the two men would have divergent standpoints as soon as Hitler had risen to power.

The great jurist had published his major works at the time of the Weimar Republic: his criticism of political romanticism (1919); his book on dictatorship (1921); and his studies on political theology (1922), on the political form of the Roman Catholic Church (1923), on the notion of the political (1928), and on the concepts of legality and legitimacy (1932). Remaining rather on the fringes of the Conservative Revolution, he was hostile to any and all organismic thought and even rejected an entire part of the German political tradition in order to draw inspiration from Italian (Machiavelli), French (Joseph de Maistre), Spanish (Donoso Cortès) and English (Thomas Hobbes) authors. His Christian faith, which Jünger did not share, and his counter-revolutionary Roman Catholicism served as a basis for his philosophy of the State. He criticised liberalism, as well as the economic and moral doctrine of individualism, which he deemed incompatible with genuine democracy owing to the fact that the latter presupposes a political homogeneity of citizens and a similarity of views between the governing and the governed. In July 1932, he called for a vote against the NSDAP headed by Hitler, whom he considered dangerous due to his ideological and political immaturity. Supporting Chancellor von Papen, he even spoke out in favour of the Reichswehr-based national dictatorship project, arguing for a ban on both the Nazi Party and the Communist Party for being in breach of the Weimar Constitution159  .

Following in von Papen’s footsteps, however, he would align himself with the new power from the beginning of 1933. On 1 May 1933, he would even join the NSDAP, whose ban he had called for shortly before. With regard to this reversal, the question remains open as to the role of Schmitt’s opportunism and career concerns, which may or may not account for this. Appointed to the Prussian State Council in 1933, he also became the head of the National Socialist Association of German Jurists. His ambition was, in fact, to become the official jurist of the new Reich. Philosophically, he hoped to promote the idea of the State (the ‘total’ State, as he himself wrote) at the expense of the notion of Party. His theory was that there is no totalitarian state as such, only a totalitarian party whose ambitions are to be limited by the State.160  At the same time, he firmly upheld the distinction, a fundamental one in his eyes, between what is political and what is not; between the public sphere and the private sphere.

These conceptions would be rejected by the Nazis, who would regard them as a surrendering of the prerogatives enjoyed by the Party and its leader in favour of the State, all the more so since Schmitt was also opposed to any biological racism that contradicted his own philosophy of history. For this reason, he would be targeted by ever-increasing criticism from 1934 onwards. In 1936, he is forced to resign from his official functions, before being subjected to a public trial by the SS newspaper Das Schwarze Korps,161  in two front-page articles published in December 1936.162  Realising that he had deceived himself, he confines himself to his academic work, adding to the number of those who had embraced ‘internal emigration’, to which Ernst Jünger had long preceded him. This would not stop him, however, from being arrested by the American police in 1945. He would thereafter be imprisoned in Nuremberg until May 1947. In the meantime, he had been expelled from university and was without pension, depending on a few friends to survive. Plummeting into the blackest bitterness, he would thus indulge, on the pages of his own Journal (Glossarium), in venomous attacks against his friend Jünger, reproaching him for his apparent detachment and his gradual return to grace.

Dominique Venner

Ernst Jünger - A Different European Destiny