To be is to be contingent: nothing of which it can be said that "it is" can be alone and independent. But being is a member of paticca-samuppada as arising which contains ignorance. Being is only invertible by ignorance.

Destruction of ignorance destroys the illusion of being. When ignorance is no more, than consciousness no longer can attribute being (pahoti) at all. But that is not all for when consciousness is predicated of one who has no ignorance than it is no more indicatable (as it was indicated in M Sutta 22)

Nanamoli Thera
Showing posts with label Segal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Segal. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 10, 2024

Spiritual depersonalization or mental disorder?

 

It's safe to say that the majority of people seeking help when they experience depersonalization simply want to resume life as they once knew it, or live the kind of well-adjusted, balanced, or "normal" life they instinctively know exists. This doesn't mean they have to ignore or deny the deeper meanings depersonalization may potentially hold.

Said one recovered depersonalized individual, a mother in her 40s,

"depersonalization changed my perspective forever, in an existential way. But when I first experienced it, all I wanted was a way out. It took me a long time to realize that I wasn't going insane. I'll always envy people who just live within the framework of normalcy. Yet sometimes, I feel a little sorry for them, especially when they're overly self-confident. They think they know who they really are."

Instances in which depersonalization can be channeled into creative or visionary outlets remain quite rare—so is true enlightenment, despite the fact that there are millions of practicing Buddhists. Fear, as Amiel noted, is certainly an inhibiting factor. And depersonalization is intensely isolating and fear provoking by its nature. Without the assistance of a knowledgeable "guru" to serve as a guide, a person must make their way through these fearful waters without a clue as to where they may be headed or when they may-sink.

With this in mind, is depersonalization akin to some kind spiritual enlightenment? Are mystical experiences, meditation, and depersonalization the same? Recently, compelling data has begun to emerge, providing these issues with more material for discussion.

In 2001 Andrew Newburg of the Department of Radiology at the University of Pennsylvania Medical Center published two single photon emission computerized tomography studies, one looking at Franciscan nuns and the other at Tibetan Buddhist meditators. In both groups, intense meditation was associated with increased brain activity in the prefrontal cortex, dorsolatera] and medial orbitofrontal, and the ciiigulate gyrus—areas involved in cognitive control and focused concentration on the self. Also of interest in both studies, the activity in the prefrontal cortex was inversely related to activity in the superior parietal lobe, possibly reflecting the altered sense of body and space experienced during meditation. As discussed in chapter 6, these are the areas involved in the experience of depersonalization. Does this new data tell us that spirituality, or depersonalization. is com-pletely in the brain, or is the brain letting in something else from outside?

There's no clear answer on this. As Newburg has pointed out, If we take a brain image of a person when she is looking at a picture, we will see various parts of the brain being activated, such as the visual cortex. But the brain image cannot tell us whether or not there actually is a picture "out there" or whether the person is creating the picture in her own mind. To a certain degree, we all create our own sense of reality. Getting at what is really real is the tricky part.2

As such studies continue, certainly more will be learned. But changes in brain activity that come about as the result of deliberate meditative practice seem to be experienced far differently from those that are neither desired nor voluntary. Once again, from a medical perspective, the DSM-makes its position clear here as well: "Voluntarily induced experiences of depersonalization or derealization form part of the meditative and trance practices that are prevalent in many religions and cultures and should not be confused with Depersonalization Disorder."2"

Much has been learned about the negative aspects of depersonalization, and, in time, more is likely to be learned about any positive attributes as well. Certainly, no matter how much they ruminate, suffer, or seek help, most depersonalized people are likely to learn firsthand what Frederic Amiel ob-served at the outset—we simply are not what we think ourselves to be.

Everything and Nothing

Perhaps the best way to leave this topic is with one of the greatest and most mysterious figures of the arts, William Shakespeare. What went through the mind of the man who wrote "to be or not to be?" Why does Richard ill say that inside himself he plays the part of many, and what prompts lago to curiously utter "I am not what I am"? The Argentine writer Jorge Luis Borges, whose poetry and prose is rich with esoteric meaning and intuitive perspectives on the nature of existence and nonexistence, a real self versus no self, provides his own speculation as to the mystery of Shakespeare, with thought-provoking relevance to the subject at hand.

In the short story, Everything and Nothing, which we excerpt here, Borges tells of a man 'who played many parts as an actor and assumed many roles primarily because he cannot realize his own identity.

There was no one inside him.. .behind his face . . . there was no more than a slight chill, a dream someone had failed to dream. . . .

At first he thought that everyone was like him. but the surprise and bewilderment of an acquaintance to whom he began to describe that hollowness showed him his error, and also let him know, forever after, that an individual ought not to differ from its species. . . .

At twenty-something he went off to London. Instinctively, he had already trained himself to the habit of feigning that he was somebody, so that his "nobodiness" might not be discovered. In London he found the calling he had been predestined to; he became an actor, that person who stands upon a stage and plays at being another person, for an audience of people who play at taking him for that person.

Borges explains 'how this man found happiness for a time in playing others on stage, but inevitably "when the last line was delivered and the last dead man applauded off the stage, the hated taste of unreality would assail him. He would cease being Ferrex or Tamerlane and return to being nobody."

For 20 years, Borges adds, the actor created characters to play on stage, and once in a while, hinted at his own particular selflessness through the words of one of his creations. But in time, the actor is overwhelmed by being so many different people on stage, while never really being himself. He stops writing and assumes the life of an English bourgeois, concerned only with money and daily maintenance of his affluent lifestyle. Even his last written item, his will, is commonplace, showing no sign of the literary genius that once flourished under its author's pen.
In the end, Borges provides an answer to this life of being no one, in a manner that reflects the enigmatic wonder of clepersonalization itself:

History adds that before or after he died, he discovered himself standing before God, and said to Him: I, who have been so many men in vain, wish to be one, to be myself.

God's voice answered him out of a whirlwind: I, too, am not I; I dreamed the world as you, Shakespeare, dreamed your own work, and among the forms of my dreams are you, who like me are many, yet no one.
***

Contrary to popular assumptions, the Christian tradition goes beyond phenomena like St. Paul's being "blinded by the light." It also includes centuries-old mystical experiences involving the elimination of the individual self.

This is somewhat different from the personal, conversant relationship with Christ that fundamentalists espouse today. In the 1860s, the writings of an obscure Jesuit priest, Jean-Pierre de Caussade. were published, more than a century after they were written. (He would certainly have been tried for heresy during his lifetime.) Commenting on the no-self experience, he wrote in 1731;

"Often indeed God places certain souls in this state, which is called emptiness of the spirit or of the intelligence; it is also called: being in nothingness (etre dans le rieri). This annihilation of our own spirit disposes wonderfully to receive that of Jesus Christ. This mystical death of the operations of our own activity renders our soul apt for the reception of divine operations"10

More recently, Bernadette Roberts's The Experience of No-Self reflects this type of being, and hearkens to Amiel's desire to be an ''empty vessel" filled with the presence of God. Roberts's writing describes her personal struggle with mysterious moments of deep, silent "stillness" that from early childhood she interpreted as the presence of God. To explore the source of this stillness, she entered a convent. But whenever she meditated in an effort to recapture it, she felt herself losing her identity, and suffered, intense fear because of it.

"It was a fear of being engulfed forever, of being lost, annihilated, or blacking out and possibly never returning. In such moments, to ward off the fear, I would make some movement of abandoning my fate to God—a ges-ture of the will, a thought, some type of projection. And everytime I did this I would gradually return to my usual self—and security. Then, one day,this was not to be the case."" Roberts writes of the no-self experience as a voyage, a "passageway" wherein panic reactions, emptiness, and depression are merely part of the trip to the final unity with God at the other end of a metaphoric tunnel. She was not unfamiliar with the psychological theories behind her strange feelings of emptiness, however, and recalled a book in which a psychologist described psychological "dissociation without compensation."

At the time I could not imagine what he was talking about, but felt sure it was something terrible and was glad I had never known any condition as dire as this sounded. But here, during the Passage, l recalled the statement because it seemed to epitomize my present situation. . . . I took it for my own condition of being completely cut off (dissociated) from the known, the self, without any compensating factor to take the place of the void so encoun-tered. It meant a state of no feelings, no energies, no movements, no insights, no seeing, no relationships with anything, nothing but absolute emptiness everywhere you turn. (p. 66)

After 9 years, she left the convent, married, and raised four children. The pervasive, periodic inner silences came and went, until, while visiting a monastery near her home, she experienced the stillness again and awaited "the onset of fear to break it up." But "instead of the usual unlocalized center of myself, there was nothing there, it was empty; and at that moment of seeing this there was a flood of quiet joy, and I knew, finally I knew what was missing—it was my self" (p. 23, emphasis in original).

Roberts's "passage" ultimately led her to a complete perceptual shift.

"When I visually focused in on a flower, an animal, another person, or any particular object, slowly the particularity would recede into a nebulous Oneness, so that the object's distinctness was lost to my mind. . . . it became impossible for the mind to perceive or retain any individuality when all visual objects either faded from the mind, gave way to something else, or were 'seen through'" (p. 36).

Strikingly similar to Roquentin's awakening by the chestnut tree, this type of changed perception is hard to manage. For Roberts, terror returned intermittently, but with a vengeance: "The silence within was not seen as freedom from self, rather, it was seen as an imprisoned self, a frozen, immovable self that was all part of the scene, part of the insidious nothingness choking the life out of everything. Even now it had frozen my body on the spot. How-could I survive another moment?" (p. 48).

Then, while on a retreat, she made an effort to face it once and for all. Seeking to eliminate this demon through her usual meditative practices, the final experience is described much like an exorcism, or an orgasm.

My head grew hot, and all I could see were stars. My feet began to freeze. Finally I fell back against the hill in a convulsive condition with my heart beating wildly. . . . It took me a while to realize my body was lying still on the hill, because initially, I seemed not to have one. I knew a great change had taken place. . . .God is neither the see-eror the seen, but the ''seeing." . . .

After a long passage, the mind had finally come to rest, and rejoice in its own understanding. . . . Now it was ready to take its rightful place in the immediacy and practicality of the now-moment.
(p. 92)

The View from the East

Ultimately, the stage was set for Roberts's depersonalization by a specific religious upbringing, intentional meditative practices, and reinforcement from clerics who were familiar with the traditions of Christian mysticism. This raises the issue of whether the depersonalization experience can be influenced by existing cultural biases. What happens when an atheist or non-Christian experiences essentially the same thing? Roquentin's encounter with the chestnut tree provides one answer. Suzanne Segal's Collision with the Infinite provides another.12

For many DPD sufferers, Segal's experiences hit closer to home than Roberts's perplexing spirituality. Segal's book centers on an event that occurred while boarding a bus in Paris in 1982. She was 27 years old and pregnant. As a young woman Segal had been involved with the transcendental meditation movement, which was trendy in the 1970s. After several years, however, she became disillusioned and left the organization entirely.

She then studied at the University of California-Berkeley, where after 2 years she gained a degree in English literature. She moved to Paris where she married and gave birth to a daughter. As she waited in line to get on the Paris bus, a life-altering event occurred. Suddenly she felt her ears pop, and was at once "enclosed in a kind of bubble" which cut her off from the rest of the scene, and left her acting and moving in the most mechanical way. In Collision, she describes that moment in detail:

I lifted my right foot to step up into the bus and collided head-on with an invisible force that entered my awareness like a silently exploding stick of dynamite, blowing the door of my usual consciousness open and off its hinges, splitting me in two. In the gaping space that appeared, what I had previously called ''me" was forcefully pushed out of its usual location inside me into a new location that was approximately a foot behind and to the left of my head. "I" was now behind my body looking out at the world without using the body's eyes. (p. 49) Walking home from that bus ride, she felt like a "cloud of awareness" was following her body. The cloud was a "witness" located behind her and completely separate from body, mind, and emotions. The witness was constant and so was fear, the fear of complete physical dissolution. The next morning, when nothing had changed, she wondered if she was going insane, and if she would ever be herself again.

What Segal then refers to as the "witnessing" continued for months, and her only relief came in sleep, into which she "plunged for as long and as often as possible." She explains, "In sleep, the mind finally stopped pumping out its unceasing litany of terror, and the witness was left to "witness an unconscious mind" (p. 53).

Recalling her earlier experiences with transcendental meditation, it occurred to her that this might be some kind of "cosmic consciousness," something her guru had described to her as the first stage of "awakened awareness." But it seemed impossible to her that this hellish realm could have anything to do with an enlightened state.

After months of the presence of this mystifying witness, it disappeared. Segal writes, leaving her in a new state that was far more baffling, and consequently more terrifying, than the experience of the preceding months. "The disappearance of the witness meant the disappearance of the last vestiges of the experience of personal identity. The witness had at least held a location for a 'me,' albeit a distant one. In the dissolution of the witness, there was literally no more experience of a 'me' at all. The experience of personal identity switched off and was never to appear again" (p.54).

Although internally Segal knew that she had changed radically, no one else noticed. She functioned as smoothly as ever, "as if there were an unseen doer who acted perfectly" (p. 65). She even managed to earn a doctorate in psychology in the years to follow. And yet, she writes, "The oddest moments occurred when any reference was made to my name. If I had to write it on a check or sign it on a letter, I would stare at the letters on the paper and the mind would drown in perplexity. The name referred to no one. There was no Suzanne Segal anymore; perhaps there never had been" (p. 55).

She consulted psychiatrists in an attempt to understand what had happened to her. Some diagnosed her with depersonalization disorder. Others had no clear explanation. As she lived in this mysterious state day after day, she became increasingly filled with fear. "Everything seemed to be dissolving right in front of my eyes, constantly. Emptiness was everywhere, seeping through the pores of every face I gazed upon, flowing through the crevices of seemingly solid objects. The body, mind, speech, thoughts, and emotions were all empty; they had no ownership, no person behind them. I was utterly bereft of all my previous notions of reality" (p. 63).

She later reasoned that the fear that pervaded her life forever after the "bus hit" came from the mind's attempts to make sense of what had happened to her. She reasoned that the mind created fear because it had lost control of the illusion of the person Suzanne Segal.

In time, a further shift occurred. Driving though a wintry landscape, she observed, "everything seemed more fluid. The mountains, trees, rocks, birds, sky, were all losing their differences. As I gazed about, what I saw first was how they were one; then, as a second wave of perception, I saw the distinctions. From that day forth I have had the constant experience of both moving through and being made of the 'substance' of everything" (p. f 30).

She got in touch with spiritual teachers within the California Buddhist community and gained additional reassurance, which helped ease the non-stop fear she had previously endured. They also provided explanations in the form of Buddhist teachings regarding anatta (no-self) and shunyata (emptiness). Her kind of no-self experience was not only understood, something like it was actually being cultivated, through daily regimens of rituals and meditations by those wanting to follow certain spiritual paths.

Buddhism, she felt, provided a plausible explanation for it all. In simplistic terms, the Buddhist interpretation states that "personality functions" remain even when one's self has disappeared. These are known as skandhas or "aggregates," and include form, feelings, perceptions, thoughts, and consciousness. Their interaction creates the illusion of self. They do not actually make up the self. There is no self, Buddhism claims*. When the truth of the skandhas is revealed, as suddenly happened to Segal at the bus stop, it is seen that there is no self, only the skandhas still functioning as they function; the truth is that they are empty, they don't constitute a self, but their interaction creates the illusion of self. In Tibetan Buddhism this is known as "realization of emptiness," in Zen Buddhism it is known as realizing "no mind." (There have been Western explanations through the years, notably the philosopher Alan Watts's Wisdom of Insecurity and The Book, in which he explains ancient Vedantic traditions of "oneness" and no-self through metaphors and in simple English.) Buddhism stresses that changes of consciousness be met in stages; devotion (saddha), discipline (sila), detachment (cagd), and depersonaiization (.panna). The rituals and self-preparation are essential lifelong processes, with depersonalization as the final goal. Understandably, an unplanned, unexpected fast-track to panna could be quite terrifying, even with some knowledge of Buddhism.

When Segal's "collision with the infinite" became widely known, she received numerous "congratulations" from spiritual teachers, both East and West. From India, the well-known guru Poonjaji wrote, "In between the ar-rival of the bus and your waiting to board, there was the Void where there was no past or future. This Void revealed itself to itself. This is a wonderful experience. It has to stay eternally with you. This is perfect freedom. You have become (moksha) of the realized sages" (p. 122).

Closer to home, one of Poonjaji's American-born disciples (who took the name Gangaji) reassured her: "This realization of the inherent emptiness— which is pure consciousness—of all phenomena is true fulfillment. In the face of conditioned existence, much fear can be initially felt. Ultimately, the fear is also revealed to be only that same empty consciousness" (p. 122).

Unfortunately for Segal, the fear which had disappeared eventually returned with renewed intensity. (Recall that this happened to Bernadette Roberts as well.) She stopped all public appearances and withdrew into virtual seclusion. She continued meeting with fellow therapists and, in time, revealed that she had suffered a long history of migraine headaches, and, to the sur-prise of many, she began to recover memories of abuse during her childhood.

She died in 1997 of a brain tumor.

Feeling Unreal Depersonalization Disorder and the Loss of the Self
Daphne Simeon, Jeffrey Abugel

* Idea "There is no self" - Buddhism claims to be a wrong view
see ATTĀ →

The Blow of the Void 


Friday, April 19, 2024

Ligotti on ego-death & Suzanne Segal

 Another statistic of long-term ego-death was Suzanne Segal, who one day found she had become bereft of herself. After years of seeking a cure to the unease this experience had set off in her—it would seem that not everybody is at peace with being nobody—she wrote Collision with the Infinite: A Life Beyond the Personal Self (1996). The following year she died of a brain tumor at the age of forty-two. Although no link was established between her diseased brain and the disappearance of her ego, cerebral tumors causing altered states of consciousness and changes in personality are not unknown.5

Unlike U. G. but similar to Wren-Lewis, Segal sought answers to her transformation in spiritual traditions that addressed egoless experience. Unlike Wren-Lewis but similar to U. G., Segal had pursued a spiritual practice, Transcendental Meditation, before she became the beneficiary of enlightenment by accident. Segal lost her ego two years after discontinuing TM, which she performed for eight years. In an interview, she stated that she did not feel meditation played a role in the loss of her self-identity. U. G. was in agreement with Segal. After years of pursuing ego-death through meditation, he railed against this procedure as pointless and perhaps harmful.

—For most of humanity, including that part which studies consciousness, the phenomenon of ego-death is not enthralling, or even well marked as a human experience. Ordinary folk have all their big questions answered to their satisfaction by some big book. And cognitive psychologists, philosophers of mind, and neuroscientists have their reputations to consider as high priests of the noosphere. Quite naturally, then, almost no one figures their time to be ill spent in bickering about some point of scripture or a psycho-philosophical poser rather than in sizing up some superlative individuals who have called into question what we are or what we might be aside from slaves of our egos. Regardless of the life stories of U. G., Wren-Lewis, and Suzanne Segal, ego-death is a state that has nothing but anecdotal evidence to support it, which groups this phenomenon with mystical experiences and revealed religions. As one might imagine, though, ego-death is laden with about as much mass appeal as physical death. It has been eyeballed as an ideal only by a minuscule number of our species who feel there is something wrong with ego-life, which they conceive as an uncanny masquerade where things they would rather not see are behind every false face. To everyone else, life is life and death is death. We are not sold on impersonal survival. It would negate all that we are, or think we are, for what are we but egos itching to survive? And once our egos have been deposed, what would be left of us? By all recorded accounts, everything would be left except what Horwitz called “a vanity, an elaborate delusion, a ruse.”

Some would say that if human beings must exist, the condition in which U. G., Wren-Lewis, and Segal found themselves is the optimum model, one in which everyone’s ego has been overthrown and our consciousness of ourselves as persons goes up in smoke. As Segal tried to explain what had happened to her:

The experience of living without a personal identity, without an experience of being somebody, an “I” or a “me,” is exceedingly difficult to describe, but it is absolutely unmistakable. It can’t be confused with having a bad day or coming down with the flu or feeling upset or angry or spaced out. When the personal self disappears, there is no one inside who can be located as being you. The body is only an outline, empty of everything of which it had previously felt so full.

The mind, body, and emotions no longer referred to anyone—there was no one who thought, no one who felt, no one who perceived. Yet the mind, body, and emotions continued to function unimpaired; apparently they did not need an “I” to keep doing what they always did. Thinking, feeling, perceiving, speaking, all continued as before, functioning with a smoothness that gave no indication of the emptiness behind them. No one suspected that such a radical change had occurred. All conversations were carried on as before; language was employed in the same manner. Questions could be asked and answered, cars driven, meals cooked, books read, phones answered, and letters written. (Collision with the Infinite)

As the ego-dead, so we might imagine, we would continue to know pain in its various forms—that is the essence of existence—but we would not be cozened by our egos to take it personally, an attitude that converts an individual’s pain into conscious suffering. Naturally, we would still have to feed, but we would not be omnivorous gourmands who eat for amusement, gorging down everything in nature and turning to the laboratory for more. As for reproduction, who can say? Animals are driven to copulate, and even as the ego-dead we would not be severed from biology, although we would not be unintelligently ruled by it, as we are now. As a corollary of not being unintelligently ruled by biology, neither would we sulk over our extinction, as we do now. Why raise another generation destined to climb aboard the evolutionary treadmill? But then, why not raise another generation of the ego-dead? For those who do not perceive either their pleasures or their pains as belonging to them, neither life nor death would be objectionable or not objectionable, desirable or not desirable, all right or not all right. We would be the ego-dead, the self-less, and, dare we say, the enlightened.

A depiction of what our lives might be like in such a state would seem to have been recorded in the eightieth section of the Tao Te Ching, perhaps to show up humankind’s modus vivendi by daydreaming about one not of this earth.

Let all lands be small

And their people few,

So they have no need

For time-saving machines.

Let them keep their minds

On the coming of death

And never stray far

From where they were born.

Should they have boats

Or carts to go traveling,

Let there be nothing

They would want to see.

Should they have weapons,

Let them be put someplace

Out of everyone’s sight

To rust and grow useless.

Let each person’s duties

Be no more than may be

Kept track of by tying knots

On a short piece of string.

Let their food be enough

And their clothes drab,

Their homes decent shelter

And their lives unremarkable.

If the next land is so close

That they can hear its

Dogs barking at night and its

Roosters crowing at dawn . . .

Let them get old and die

Rather than be troubled

By the least curiosity

To have a look over there.

One might think of this not as a description of an ego-dead society but of one that is dead all the way. But one would be wrong. Wherever there are those who “get old and die,” there are also those who live in wait for age and for death—youths and infants and infants-to-be. And because none of them should take his fate personally in the Taoist scripture quoted above, why not take it as it comes? Of course, this would not occur to the ego-dead, just as it does not occur to species of a lower order that recycle themselves as nature bids them. The ego-dead would be back to where our race began—surviving, reproducing, dying. Nature’s way would be restored in all its mindlessness and puppetry.

But even if ego-death is regarded as the optimum model for human existence, one of liberation from ourselves, it still remains a compromise with being, a concession to the blunder of creation itself. We should be able to do better, and we can. To have our egos killed off is second-best to killing off death and all the squalid byplay that flitters around it. So let all lands be small, and let them grow smaller and smaller until no lands are left where any human footstep need press itself upon the earth.

—At the height of her ego-death, Segal was ecstatic twenty-four hours a day. She also began to speak of what she called the “vastness,” a term that sounds as if it belongs in one of Lovecraft’s tales of cosmic horror. To Segal, the vastness was a unitary phenomenon that comprised all existence. As she wrote, “The purpose of human life has been revealed. The vastness created these human circuitries in order to have an experience of itself out of itself that it couldn’t have without them.” Living in the vastness as she did, nothing was useless to Segal because it served the purposes of the vastness. For her, it also felt good once she had gotten over her initial fear of being a tool of the vastness rather than a person. However, toward the end of her life, as American psychotherapist and Buddhist Stephan Bodian recounts in his afterword to Collision with the Infinite, Segal began to have more intense experiences in which “the vastness became even vaster for itself.” This new phase of the vastness both distressed her emotionally and sapped her physical energy until she died from her unsuspected brain tumor not long afterward.

Like Segal’s vastness, Schopenhauer’s Will has the same purpose in mind for human beings—to use our “circuitries” to acquire some kind of knowledge of its mindless self. For Schopenhauer, though, the self-seeking Will does not feel good to human beings except during moments when we temporarily satisfy its universal ravening as it emerges within us. Why the vastness or the Will should want to use us in this way is a mystery. Both of these meta-realities do serve the purpose of making sense of human life in their own way. But whether they make us feel good does not seem to matter to either of them. We are just vehicles; they are the drivers. And wherever we are going, as Segal and Schopenhauer have assured us, along with every other individual whose consciousness has been opened to the vastness by whatever name or nature, we must keep in mind that we are not what we think we are. Taking things a step further, Professor Nobody would teach us that neither is our world what we think it is, lecturing with a flamboyant dispassion on the omnipresence of the infernal in “The Eyes That Never Blink.”

Mist on a lake, fog in thick woods, a golden light shining on wet stones—such sights make it all very easy. Something lives in the lake, rustles through the woods, inhabits the stones or the earth beneath them. Whatever it may be, this something lies just out of sight, but not out of vision for the eyes that never blink. In the right surroundings our entire being is made of eyes that dilate to witness the haunting of the universe. But really, do the right surroundings have to be so obvious in their spectral atmosphere?

Take a cramped waiting room, for instance. Everything there seems so well anchored in normalcy. Others around you talk ever so quietly; the old clock on the wall is sweeping aside the seconds with its thin red finger; the window blinds deliver slices of light from the outside world and shuffle them with shadows. Yet at any time and in any place, our bunkers of banality may begin to rumble. You see, even in a stronghold of our fellow beings we may be subject to abnormal fears that would land us in an asylum if we voiced them to another. Did we just feel some presence that does not belong among us? Do our eyes see something in a corner of that room in which we wait for we know not what?

Just a little doubt slipped into the mind, a little trickle of suspicion in the bloodstream, and all those eyes of ours, one by one, open up to the world and see its horror. Then: no belief or body of laws will guard you; no friend, no counselor, no appointed personage will save you; no locked door will protect you; no private office will hide you. Not even the solar brilliance of a summer day will harbor you from horror. For horror eats the light and digests it into darkness.

From: The Conspiracy against the Human Race

***

Short exchange with certain lady on Goodreads who didn't like review posted by V.B

message:

1. This book is not about pathological 'depersonalization'. That is the beginning of the book and even Ms. Siegel says it was not pathological and it was not about 'depersonalization'. It is quite clearly about the process of enlightenment and the truth of knowing that everything and everyone is you and you are everyone and everything. The ecstasy and the joy of it. Perhaps you didn't read the last few chapters?

2. Just because tumours can cause altered states doesn't mean that was what was happening to her. In addition, the first part of the process of enlightenment happened 12 years before she came down with a brain tumor.

2. You are a bombastic idiot,

Dear Madam!

I think my fault is that I did not make clear what I mean using word depersonalisation. In the Dhamma and Nisargadatta's [NM] teaching it means highest enlightenment or awakening. Nibbāna is cessation of the person.

[NM: You, as the person, imagine that the Guru is interested in you as a person. Not at all. To him you are a nuisance and a hindrance to be done away with. He actually aims at your elimination as a factor in consciousness. ... Liberation is never of the person, it is always from the person.]

Enlightenment can be stated as a discovery of what one truly is, but since it is a timeless and eternal reality, imagining oneself to be a person so-and-so, is already step into darkness (at least according to the Buddha and NM).

I hope I made  this point more clear: on spiritual level there is nothing pathological in  depersonalisation, contrary,  the existence of the person is pathological.

Another point, total enlightenment -cessation of a concept "I am"* - happens  very rarely all at once, and there are gradual stages of awakening

*[ NM Immortality is freedom from the feeling: 'I am'. Yet it is not extinction. On the contrary, it is a state infinitely more real, aware and happy than you can possibly think of. Only self-consciousness is no more.]

Before such realisation one must first abandon any positive self-identifiication "I am this or that". In practical terms it means the attitude of detached observer where only "I am" is present, but no personal self-identifiication. This is already a certain stage of awakening, and I do grant her such attainment. I suppose this is the state of Eckhart Tolle, his teaching is quite good, but he emphasis only pure being - "I am".

What I indeed deny is that the author attained the final realisation, and I base my judgement on the fact that such state is totally without fear and any mental confusion.

[Q: How shall I recognise this state when I reach it?
NM: There will be no fear.]

As I understood,  you totally reject idea that brain tumour had anything in common with her enlightenment. Of course there is such possibility, I simply do not know. I try to do my judgement according my present understanding of things as they are, and since my understanding is not perfect you may be right I I may be wrong.

However as I understand things: enlightenment is the result of very intense practice or very rarely - like in the case of Eckhart Tolle - tremendous personal suffering. Since it was not so in her case, I believe there was connection between her brain problem and her experience of vastness.

What I am not sure: was her experience only initiated by the brain tumour, in the case it survived the death of the body,  or it was just temporal experience totally determined by the state of neurological system.

Much of human misunderstandings comes from the fact that people use the same words, but prescribe to them different meanings. I hope that at least I clarified the meaning of "depersonalisation", in spiritual tradition to which I belong.

May You be well and happy

Varapanyo Bhikkhu

PS
In my spiritual tradition harsh speech is a serious obstacle to enlightenment, but since you seem to believe in kind of spontaneous enlightenment which doesn't depend on how we act, you do not try to restrain your own speech.  No doubt there is a consistency between your views and your practice 🙂