To be is to be contingent: nothing of which it can be said that "it is" can be alone and independent. But being is a member of paticca-samuppada as arising which contains ignorance. Being is only invertible by ignorance.

Destruction of ignorance destroys the illusion of being. When ignorance is no more, than consciousness no longer can attribute being (pahoti) at all. But that is not all for when consciousness is predicated of one who has no ignorance than it is no more indicatable (as it was indicated in M Sutta 22)

Nanamoli Thera

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

A Stink of Zen

 Convinced that he has found the non-path to true insight - Zen, like Tao, is a way of non-doing - Smith follows Ryder’s advice and signs on as a fire lookout on a Northwest mountain top. In real life, Kerouac did the same. In a tiny forest service cabin on Desolation Peak, part of the North Cascade mountain range that cuts through California, Oregon, Washington and British Columbia, Kerouac lived alone for sixty-three days. The idea was to get enlightened or at least have visions. The universe had other plans. A kind of lunacy without the Zen descended on Kerouac. Peering at the cold, snowbound expanse of silent rock, mute forest and humbling peaks, Kerouac felt he was looking at a mirror. What he saw was a void, otherwise known as Jack Kerouac. No booze, no drugs, no sex, no cars, stone cold sober, Kerouac had an unexpected encounter with himself. The unreadable tracts of spontaneous prose that make up Desolation Angels (1960) is one result of Kerouac’s unsuccessful attempt to capture strange forces. The ‘anything goes’ ethic of his Beat Zen philosophy, mirrored in his life, deteriorated, like Dean Moriarity, into an uninteresting babble. Sadly, Kerouac would soon follow.

A STINK OF ZEN

Zen started in China in the sixth century AD. Its founding father, the fierce-faced Bodhidharma, was an Indian monk who combined snarling aggressiveness with Marx Brothers inanity. Once so angry at himself for falling asleep while meditating, legend has it that in a rage Bodhidharma sliced off his eyelids. These fell to the ground and became the seeds of the first tea plant.

By the early sixties, Zen and another kind of ‘tea’, marijuana, which had reached the Beats via the jazz scene, had become the intellectual flavour of the month, its serious study introduced to English speakers through the works of the Japanese scholar Daisetz Teitaro Suzuki.k Suzuki’s Essays in Zen Buddhism (1927) and other works lent an academic respectability to ideas about satori, koans, and zazen that was as far from Kerouac’s naive ‘anything goes’ approach as possible. Yet Suzuki’s works, applauded by Western orientalists, were nearly unreadable, and clearly lacked the common touch. Some Western thinkers saw in them little more than a philosophical ‘yellow peril’. The title of a section of Arthur Koestler’s The Lotus and the Robot (1961), a study of India and Japan, says as much: ‘A Stink of Zen’.

Koestler, who would find Timothy Leary’s brand of mysticism equally ersatz, and who would by the end of the decade follow Huxley as a mainstream proponent of parapsychology,12 saw little in Zen and Suzuki besides obfuscation and fudgy morality. Highlighting Zen’s ethical relativism, Koestler quotes Suzuki’s remark that ‘Zen is . . . extremely flexible’ and ‘may be found wedded to anarchism or fascism, communism or democracy, atheism or idealism’.13 Beyond good and evil - and any other categories of the rational mind - Zen made no distinction between ‘this’ or ‘that’. In the words of Seng-Ts’an, the third Zen Patriarch, who lived in the sixth century AD, ‘The conflict between right and wrong / Is the sickness of the mind’. Koestler rightly points out that with statements like this, context is everything. To a Taoist monk, bemused at the neurotic fastidiousness of Confucian decorum, it suggests a cheerful unconcern with pedantic conventions. To a sixties mystic-hedonist, it meant ‘do what thou wilt’ or ‘everything is permitted’ or ‘there’s no such thing as right and wrong’, convenient slogans condoning an assortment of appetites. Charlie Manson often appealed to their wisdom. In a later work Koestler pointed out that Eugen Herrigel, whose Zen in the Art of Archery (1953) would become a New Age classic, had been a member of the Nazi party.14 The Nazis, of course, were partial to their own brands of lunacy, and were less than hung up about right and wrong.

The lotus of Koestler’s title is the blissed-out Indian mystic, high on nirvana; the robot is the highly trained, unreflective automaton that the practice of Zen seemed geared to produce. Koestler’s mordant wit was paradigmatic of the tack late Enlightenment man would take as the threat from the East encroached more and more upon Western soil, and a masochistic mea culpa ensued from Western lips that continues in today’s politically correct witch hunts. Increasingly, as the appeal of taut reason lessened, that of an easy, immediate intuition increased. Koestler and other champions of the mind found themselves in less and less demand.

One West Coast Zen lunatic, however, took argument with Kerouac’s brand of wild satori. One of the less loony characters to appear in The Dharma Bums is Arthur Whane. At a party at which people have decided to strip - one of Ginsberg’s less endearing antics-a smartly dressed Whane carries on a serious conversation about Buddhism without batting an eye at his two naked interlocutors. When asked what Buddhism meant to him he answered, ‘Buddhism is getting to know as many people as possible.’ Getting to know as many people as possible is something Alan Watts, on whom Kerouac based the prim Arthur Whane, certainly tried to do.

THE WISDOM OF IRRESPONSIBILITY

Born in Chislehurst, Kent, in 1915, Alan Watts (1915-1973) was, like Huxley, Heard and Isherwood, another British transplant to the Golden State. His journey to the East started early. In 1930, Edmond Holmes’s Creed of Buddha came into the fifteen-year-old Alan’s hands. In it was a pamphlet about Buddhism which mentioned a Buddhist Lodge in London. Alan wrote to the author, Christmas Humphreys, who turned out to be the director of the Lodge. An invitation was secured. Humphreys introduced him to the writings of D. T. Suzuki, and not long after Watts met the man himself.

When Watts met Suzuki, the Zen master was in his late sixties, a tiny man who wore pebble glasses and a bow tie. Suzuki exuded a air of Zen that was clear and unmistakable. His writing, however, was something else. Many readers found his books baffling, and orthodox Japanese scholars considered him a dilettante. Watts’s first act in his new life as Zen ambassador was to write a book, expounding Suzuki’s doctrine. In a month, the nineteen-year-old Alan produced the enthusiastic and highly derivative The Spirit of Zen (1935).

Over the years Watts fine-tuned his teaching. But all of his very popular and influential books share the same basic premise, the idea that there is no need to strive for enlightenment, because we are all already enlightened. This satori on the pointlessness of spiritual struggle seems to have guided Watts over several ethical hurdles with little strain.

One such was his marriage to the American Eleanor Everett, the first of three. They met at a meeting of the Buddhist Lodge in 1937, when Eleanor’s mother, the rich Chicago socialite Ruth Everett, gave a talk about her experiences in a Zen monastery in Kyoto. They had little in common, but Eleanor attracted Alan for several reasons, one of which was her eagerness to have a sexual adventure. But the real magnet was Ruth. Ruth Everett knew a great deal about Zen, and had great personal power, something Watts sensed as he talked with her at the lodge. She also had a lot of money. But she was unattainable as an erotic partner. That left Eleanor.

In 1938 Watts married an already pregnant eighteen-year-old Eleanor, and Ruth installed the couple in a huge Edwardian maisonette in Courtfield Gardens, decorated in opulent oriental style. Here Watts practised calligraphy, edited a Buddhist journal, prepared lectures on Zen, and thought about his next book. He also helped Eleanor spend her hefty allowance. Then a little man with a moustache threw a spanner in the works. In late 1938, as Eleanor approached term, she and Alan left Courtfield Gardens for Manhattan. A war with Hitler was inevitable, and Alan had no intention of fighting.

In New York, Alan took the next step on his path. Ruth had just begun studying with the Zen roshi Sokei-an-Sasaki at his small walk-up temple on 74th Street. After hearing his mother-in-law speak of the remarkable teacher, Watts went for a visit.

Watts referred to the practice of zazen scornfully as ‘sitting on your ass’. Now he was introduced to it by a master. Impressed by the older man’s style and simplicity of life, Watts asked to be his student. Sokei-an agreed. Sokei-an’s main method of teaching was sanzen, an interview during which the teacher would set the student a koan, rather as the Maharishi would dole out mantras later on.

Watts soon found his koans a bore. They produced no enlightenment, and after working away at one for several months, in a fit of frustration he shouted at his teacher that his interpretation was right. Sokei-an disagreed. That was the end of Watts’s stint as his student.

One koan, however, was becoming hard to ignore: how to make a living. Watts solved the problem by becoming an Episcopalian priest. Although his friends were stunned at this decision, the eloquent Watts argued that he wasn’t really abandoning Buddhism, as all paths led to the same goal, and what really mattered was that he celebrate the mystery that all religions embodied . . . The fact that by 1941 he was in danger of being drafted for the US armed service, and that as a minister he would be exempt, may have had something to do with it too. In 1944, Watts was ordained an Episcopalian priest in the Church of the Atonement, Evanston, Illinois.

Watts took to his ministry with gusto, and their home at Canterbury House became a location for wild parties. Watts once attached a petrol-soaked sanitary napkin to a helium balloon, lit it and sent it across Lake Michigan. The police and local radio stations received reports of a flying saucer. But Watts’s determination to fit into his suburban environment was doomed from the start. The reason was something that would occupy Watts from then on: sex.

In June, 1950, Eleanor wrote to her friend, Bishop Conk-ling, who had secured Watts’s entry into the church. Eleanor had fled to New York, taking the children to her mother, and had put herself under the care of a psychiatrist. She was also seeing a priest. Her reason, she told the Bishop, was that Alan was a sex maniac.

He masturbated daily, drew pornographic pictures, read pornography, and had a taste for ‘various tortures’ which he inflicted upon himself in order to achieve orgasm.15 But that wasn’t all. Watts, having confessed his appetites, asked Eleanor to beat him. She refused. He found himself looking to other women for satisfaction. In typical suburban fashion, this led to an affair with the babysitter, Dorothy de Witt, who would eventually become Watts’s second wife.

But Eleanor herself was no saint. When it became clear that Watts and Dorothy were sleeping together, Eleanor sought solace in a younger man, with whom she would have a son. When Eleanor announced that now she too had a lover, she expected Watts to act the jealous husband. But Watts was pleased with the development and suggested they live together in a ménage à quatre. By 1947, their daughter Joan was moved out of her room to make way for the new arrangement. When the affair blew up, Watts wrote one of his most famous books, the aptly named The Wisdom of Insecurity (1954).

In San Francisco Watts met an old London acquaintance, Frederic Spiegelberg. He asked Watts to join his American Academy of Asian Studies, whose aim, at least in Watts’s mind, became ‘the practical transformation of human consciousness’.16 Michael Murphy and Richard Price, the founders of Esalen, attended lectures, as did Gary Snyder. Another student, Lock McCorkle, went on to be a major figure in EST. Around this time Watts started broadcasting on a local Berkeley radio station, KPFA, and appeared on the educational television station KQED. He also took to wearing a kimono and fooling around with other women. Dorothy, meanwhile, expected another child.

In 1957 the Academy’s backer withdrew support and, at forty-two, Watts once again found himself jobless. Nevertheless, his reputation was growing. In the spring of 1958 he lectured at the C. G. Jung Institute in Zurich; during the trip he met Jung himself. One result was Watts’s influential Psychotherapy East and West (1961), in which he argues that the Hindu doctrine of maya did not refer to the illusory character of the sensual world - the traditional understanding - but pointed instead to the false constraints of society. Even if his argument didn’t hold water where Hinduism was concerned - its caste system was one of the most conservative social structures in history - it fitted in well with the anti-authoritarianism rising up among sixties youth.

But by this time the marriage to Dorothy was going down, and his relationship with his children - of whom there were now six - was practically non-existent. The comforts of Mill Valley, a suburb of San Francisco, where he now lived, began to grate. Goodly quantities of vodka helped; he was succumbing to the alcoholism that would eventually kill him in 1973. But as with so many other changes in his life, Watts needed a woman to act both as magnet and comforter. In 1959, while teaching in New York, he met one.

Mary Jane Yates - ‘Jano’, in Watts’s autobiography - was a student; they got to know one another over meals in Greenwich Village. Following the line of least resistance, they became lovers. Soon after Watts left Dorothy - who was again pregnant - his six children, and the hells of suburbia for his new lover. One of Watts’s books is entitled This is It. Maybe it was.

The seeds of the counterculture, planted by Huxley, Miller, the Beats, and Watts himself, were sprouting, and Watts for once found himself in an environment for which he was absolutely suited. Escaping the middle-class suburban trap, in 1961 he and Jano moved into an old ferry boat moored at Sausalito, across the Bay from San Francisco. It was a floating sixties version of Henry Miller’s Villa Seurat. In fact, Watts shared it with the artist Jean Varda, one of Miller’s pals from Big Sur. Other friends were around too: Gary Snyder, Kerouac, and new friends like Timothy Leary, who Watts visited in Harvard. By this time Alan had taken LSD, and would even write a book about it next year, The Joyous Cosmology (1962). Although he liked Leary, Watts shook his head at the mess he found in Leary’s household, amazed that any one who had experienced the mystical consciousness stimulated by LSD could live in such squalor. Oh well. Live and let live. Things were looking up. It was early yet - the summer of love was still a few years away. But the party was definitely getting started.

Turn Off Your Mind 

Gary Lachman


No comments:

Post a Comment