Wish You Were . . . Connected
To be alienated is to be cut off, or estranged, from something or someone with which one should be connected. One can be alienated from other people, as when one fails to relate intimately to one’s family or friends, or when one cannot deal cordially and co-operatively with colleagues, or interact civilly with, or respond empathetically toward, other people in general. It can be a harmful failure to make contact, a troublesome inability to achieve closeness, a frustrating breakdown in communication. Since art is an attempt to communicate one’s ideas and feelings deeply and intensely, artists are often especially sensitive to this problem. Artists of all kinds must confront the danger that this special communication might at any point be thwarted by their alienation from their audience.
But not all alienation is social. Workers can become alienated from their work if they must perform boring, uncreative tasks at the direction of others. They can become alienated from the products of their work, as might assembly-line workers who install one tiny part of a car, in accordance with someone else’s design and production plans. Such workers are unlikely to see the finished product as having resulted from their personal creative effort. They may feel disconnected from the fruits of their labors (which they also, incidentally, do not own).
It’s plausible that modern life leads increasingly to our alienation from nature, as well. We spend more and more of our time in artificial environments (for example, in the car, at the office, on city streets, or locked up in our homes); and we are likely, wherever we are, to remain glued to television or computer screens, iPods, or to other electronic media or devices. If the rhythms of nature are drowned out by these distractions, it’s not a stretch to see that we can also become alienated from ourselves.
One who is alienated in this way may passively defer to others (such as parents, religious leaders, one’s peers, or society at large) on the fundamental questions of life that each of us, if we are to be autonomous, must decide for ourselves: What do I stand for? What are my values? How should I treat other people? What do I think is important? What are my priorities? What do I want to accomplish with my life? Confronting these questions allows one to emerge as a person, an individual with distinct talents, interests, and sensibilities—and not just an anonymous and interchangeable member of the public. Insofar as one submerges or never develops these distinctive traits, one loses sight of oneself, and becomes alienated from it.
Indeed, in a broader sense all forms of alienation might be thought of as forms of self-estrangement. The reason is that I can only be truly “alienated” from something that is (or should be) part of me. I am not alienated from the cobwebs in the corner of my basement, even though I feel no connection to them, for I can only be alienated from that to which I want to be connected, or should be connected. That’s why alienation involves disequilibrium, disturbance, and anxiety. It makes the world feel strange in ways that can sometimes be effectively expressed in music.
**
Time, Finitude, and Death
Time” on The Dark Side of the Moon begins quietly. But we suddenly hear the very loud chiming of clocks. The effect is startling and jarring, much like the first point that “Time” makes. Young people, especially, have no clue about how precious and scarce time is. They “fritter and waste the hours in an offhand way,” reasoning that they “are young and life is long and there is time to kill today.” Then life’s alarm clock sounds: “then one day you find ten years have got behind you / No one told you when to run, you missed the starting gun.” It also underscores the existentialists’ ideas about our “thrown” condition. We simply find ourselves already right up to our necks in the midst of a world that we did not create. Everyone, in that sense, has “missed the starting gun.”
Waters says that, following his mother’s advice, he spent his youth preparing for a life that he regarded as having not yet started—a life that was to start at some unspecified time in the future. The point was to get a good education so that he might be prepared, later, to have a family and a career, at which time his life would begin. He reports: “It came as a great shock to discover that I wasn’t preparing for anything—I was right in the middle of it, and always had been.”49Both lyrics and recollection suggest that part of the problem is our overly passive reliance on others, our refusal to think and act for ourselves. Just because “no one told [us] when to run,” that’s not a valid excuse for not embracing life authentically. Everyone, especially those that are “kicking around on a piece of ground in [their] home town” and “waiting for someone or something to show [them] the way,” should take a deep breath and “choose [their] own ground.” Waters confirms that a fundamental message of The Dark Side of the Moon is that “[i]t’s OK to engage in the difficult task of discovering your own identity[, a]nd it’s OK to think things out for yourself’.”50
The point is underscored in a familiar way for Pink Floyd—immediately after a provocative lyric, David Gilmour’s guitar soloing takes over. It gives listeners time, literally, to think about the ideas just presented and joins those ideas to richly emotive music. Gilmour begins this solo by sustaining its first note for seven beats, as if he were saying “listen to me; I have something important to say; I won’t be changing notes until I have your attention.” Once he does, the listener is likely to hear in Gilmour’s dark, moody, minor-key playing a restatement and intensification of the ideas conveyed by Waters’s lyrics. He gradually increases his speed and moves to the upper register of his instrument until the mood suddenly relaxes into the major seventh chords of the chorus. Now, Gilmour’s solo sounds no longer dark and menacing, but open, hopeful, even consoling (as if he were saying, “don’t feel bad; I missed the starting gun, too; everybody did”), an effect that is underscored by the soothing female voices that accompany it in the background.
One likely reason for why this and other of Gilmour’s solos work this way is that they are usually improvised, on the spot, in the studio. (This is true, for example, of all of his solos from The Dark Side of the Moon, including the one from “Time.”) One can hear this. These solos don’t sound canned or calculated, but rather strike the listener as free, spontaneous creations. He plays them “in the moment,” and allows his emotional response to the music over which he is soloing to come through.51
“Time” ends with the frightening line, “the time is gone, the song is over / Thought I’d something more to say.” You might think the song is speaking about itself as it winds down, but it’s speaking about you and all of us who, when we reach old age and recognize that we have little time left, will be disappointed at our meager accomplishments. We will recall with dismay and disappointment all of the things that we had hoped and dreamed and planned to do, but had never done, perhaps because we had foolishly assumed that “life is long and there is time to kill today.” We might instead recognize and confront our finitude, and take full advantage of the limited time available to us to make our lives meaningful and to ameliorate the hardships and the suffering that we share with others.
These thoughts harmonize with the famous argument of twentieth-century German existentialist philosopher Martin Heidegger that our refusal to face up to our own mortality—not just to acknowledge it in a vague, abstract, intellectual way, but rather to look it straight in the eye and feel it in one’s bones—creates the inauthenticity and triviality of our lives. With Heidegger, the two problems raised in “Time”—relying on others to “show you the way” and failing to recognize mortality—have the same solution. For if we were to come to grips with our finitude, we would not willingly and uncritically go along with norms of thought and behavior simply because they are widely accepted by others. If I genuinely face the fact that I have but one short life to live, I will want to make sure that it is indeed my life that I live, and not that of the public at large. I will not simply do as “one” does, or think as “they” do, but rather I will think for myself, and do what I think (in the light of my best critical judgment, and on the basis of careful thought, and with full cognizance of my own unique interests and talents) is best. Nor will I squander my precious time, which could be spent in significant conversation with others, or in the development of significant personal projects or interpersonal relationships, on idle gossip or sensationalistic trivia. For I could only do so if I suffered from the delusion that “life is long and there is time to kill today.”
**
We Don’t Need No Indoctrination
The Wall also contains Pink Floyd’s only #1 single, “Another Brick in the Wall (Part 2),” with its disturbing, but catchy refrain, sung by a children’s chorus: “We don’t need no education.” It’s not so much an attack on education per se as an attack (according to “The Happiest Days of Our Lives”) on “certain teachers” who torment their students with “derision” and ridicule. And it is an attack on education when it becomes indistinguishable from “thought control.” This occurs then students are simply told what to think, as opposed to being helped to learn how to think for themselves. (The fact that the children sing in unison, rather than in harmony, adds to the perception that they, as victims of thought control, all think alike.) Teachers whose main concern is simply to keep order, maintain a schedule, and get through the day, are well served by passive, docile students who, like the “Sheep” from Animals (“Meek and obedient you follow the leader”) are content to take orders, let others think for them, and grow into modern, alienated citizens who overpay for concert tickets because their local radio station tells them to.Another reason why indoctrination is widespread in education is the fact, well-known by those who wield power, that independent, critical thought is dangerous to their interests. People who think for themselves can’t be counted on to do your bidding, especially if your bidding is indefensible. Consider the difference between the teaching of arithmetic, on the one hand, and history or social studies, on the other. In arithmetic, it’s not enough for students merely to memorize the correct answers; rather, they must understand the logic of arithmetic for themselves, so that they can calculate answers for themselves to problems that have never been posed to them by their teachers.
But in history and social studies, teachers face enormous pressure to produce students who hold the “right” opinions, to adopt “patriotic” positions which justify, if not celebrate, they very status quo that Pink Floyd indicts in these albums, in which the alienating powers, privileges, and wealth enjoyed by society’s contemporary rulers (or chart-topping rock stars) are seen as important, legitimate and well-deserved.
The ugliness that results from this thwarting of independent critical thought and the substitution of indoctrination for it is well captured by Franz Kafka’s memorable aphorism: “Probably all education is but two things: first, parrying of the ignorant child’s impetuous assault on the truth; and second, gentle, imperceptible initiation of the humiliated children into the lie.”56
That’s why Pink Floyd’s message is one of resistance—resistance to the forces of indoctrination and conformity, as well as resistance to the artificial barriers that separate “us” from “them.” More specifically, the band urges us to resist those who would persuade us that money is more precious than time, that commerce is more important than creativity, that spectacle is more valuable than communication, and that competition is more important than empathy. Indeed, according to Pink Floyd one of the keys to coping successfully with the alienating pressures of modern life is the reversing of these value judgments.
But the most important key is simply to think for oneself. Don’t let others (even your favorite rock band!) decide for you what is true, valuable, and important. For if you think for yourself (and are not afraid to care), you have a chance to lead a richly meaningful life as an autonomous person. But if you don’t, you run the risk of ending up, like so many others, as just another brick in the wall, dragged down by the stone.
Dragged Down by the Stone: Pink Floyd, Alienation, and the Pressures of Life
DAVID DETMER
In
Pink Floyd and Philosophy
No comments:
Post a Comment