While Dante was creating perhaps the greatest initiatory work of the medieval via positiva, a German contemporary of his was laying the groundwork for perhaps the greatest medieval expression of the opposite path, the via negativa. As mentioned earlier, the esoteric and the mystic paths, though related, are not identical. The esotericist seeks the experience and knowledge of the intermediary planes that lie between the material world and the One; he is interested in the Imaginal World, and in the different levels of reality and consciousness it encompasses. The mystic has little interest in anything but union with the divine. Both ways are rooted in the Neoplatonic ladder of being, but while one is interested in mapping out each step of the way, the other wants to reach the top by the shortest route possible.
While Dante projected an entire cosmos in order to contain his beatific vision, the theologian and philosopher Meister Eckhart (1260?–1327?) worked to empty his consciousness of everything but the immediate presence of God. Eckhart’s focus on the direct and unimpeded experience of the divine exemplified the great wave of lay mysticism and spirituality that swept through the Rhineland in the fourteenth century and troubled an unstable church already challenged by the Cathars and Knights Templar. As the Mysteries of antiquity provided a more powerful emotional experience than the routine worship of the gods, so too the grassroots spirituality fed by Eckhart’s vision offered a more transformative form of devotion than the increasingly legalistic strictures of the church.
This independent spirituality attracted many followers and took different forms, such as the contemplative Friends of God, led by Eckhart’s followers, John Tauler (1300–1361) and Henry Suso (1295–1365), and the more antinomian Brethren of the Free Spirit. The church has never taken kindly to amateur spirituality, believing that such matters should be left in the hands of professionals, and it took steps to dampen what it called “enthusiasm” whenever it appeared. In 1311, the Brethren of the Free Spirit were declared heretical by Pope Clement V—who ordered the arrest of the Templars—and accordingly persecuted. The less rambunctious Friends of God were not persecuted; they in fact remained within the church and were a kind of response to the Dionysian revels of the Brethren of the Free Spirit, although the fact that they died out after only two generations may have saved them from the Brethren’s fate. Along with the Black Death and the Hundred Years’ War (1337–1453), the inability of the church to accommodate a more living spirituality was a factor adding to the turbulence and chaos of the late Middle Ages. The time was rife with a sense of imminent disaster and apocalypse. The end of the world, many believed, was coming. A century earlier, the Calabrian monk and mystic Joachim of Fiore (1135–1202) had prophesized that a new age of the Holy Spirit was on its way, following the ages of the Father and the Son. Mankind, Joachim said, would then achieve direct contact with God, and no longer have need for the church, a prediction the Brethren of the Free Spirit, who were followers of Joachim, had tried to make true. Rome was not happy with this, but Dante put Joachim in Paradise, and the fact that the beginning of the age of the Holy Spirit coincided with the purported year of Meister Eckhart’s birth, 1260, may not have been entirely the work of chance.
Dante and Eckhart shared much in common; for one thing, the combination of mystical insight and intense intellectual hunger, although in each the expression of this union took different forms. Both also had trouble with the authorities. Dante, we know, was exiled. In his later life, Meister Eckhart was accused of heresy, tried, and was found guilty, although he died before receiving the verdict. He was accused of pantheistic tendencies; like Eriugena, he spoke of nature’s “manifest theophanies” and preached that there was no need to hear sermons, “for every creature is full of God and is a book” and that “God is present in a stone or a log; only they do not know it.”47 For such beliefs, he was posthumously found guilty of being “deceived by the father of lies,” and, like Socrates and Suhrawardi, of “sowing thorns and thistles among the faithful and even the simple folk” by the men who tried him.48 Yet Eckhart’s remarks are not strange or threatening to anyone with a sense of Schwaller de Lubicz’s “intelligence of the heart” or Bergson’s intuition or the “participatory” mode of consciousness associated with the right brain. Yet these subtle insights are invariably lost on those who view life literally.
In some sense we can say that the parallel positive and negative ways, rooted in Dionysius the Areopagite and embodied in Dante and Eckhart, reached a kind of culmination at this point, just as Europe was about to undergo the transformation that would eventually lead to the modern world. As Evelyn Underhill said in her classic work Mysticism, “These two giants stand side by side at the opening of the [fourteenth] century; perfect representations of the Teutonic and Latin instinct for transcendental reality.”49 For Teutonic and Latin, we can read via negativa and via positiva, a differentiation that would inform the Protestant Reformation in the sixteenth century and which would change the face of Europe.
Although supressed after his death and forgotten for centuries, Meister Eckhart’s work was rediscovered in the nineteenth century, mostly through the work of the German Romantic philosopher and Christian theosopher Franz von Baader (1765–1841), and he has since become a central figure in modern western mysticism. Some recent scholars suggest that Eckhart’s true lineage is within the German philosophical tradition, and wish to save him from the dubious world of New Age mysticism. Yet the German philosophical tradition itself contains many who were fellow travelers with mystics, so the differentiation is perhaps more academic than useful. In recent times, Eckhart has been enormously influential, and figures as disparate as the philosopher Martin Heidegger, the Zen scholar D. T. Suzuki, the contemporary spiritual teacher Eckhart Tolle, and the Christian priest and theologian Matthew Fox find common ground in their inheritance from Meister Eckhart.
A FAITHFUL HERETIC
Eckhart von Hochheim was born around 1260 in Tambach, a Thuringian village in northeast Germany near the town of Erfurt. Little is known of his childhood and family life; some accounts say he was the son of a knight, yet others dismiss this. It is possible he may have studied in Paris as a youth under the Aristotelian philosopher Siger of Brabant.50 What we do know is that at around sixteen, Eckhart entered the Dominican novitiate at Erfurt. In 1280, he was sent to the famous Dominican House of Studies, the Studium Generale, at Cologne, which was founded by Albertus Magnus. Eckhart was there for only a short time before Albertus Magnus died, but accounts say he met the great philosopher and theologian and was taught by some of his students, one of whom was Thomas Aquinas. Albertus Magnus brought the ideas of Plato, Aristotle, and Plotinus and the theology of Christianity, Islam, and Judaism into a creative synthesis, a version of the perennial philosophy; he was also, as mentioned, one of the first in the West to study alchemy. Eckhart absorbed this heady curriculum, which also included the work of Porphyry, Proclus, Augustine, Origen, Dionysius, and Eriugena. Although Albertus Magnus’s Neoplatonism was soon eclipsed by the scholasticism of his pupil Aquinas, the mystic spirituality he fostered had a powerful influence on the Christians of the Rhineland.
Eckhart proved a brilliant student and able administrator, and following his ordination as a priest in 1293, he went on to have a remarkable career in the church. In Paris, he worked as a lecturer and studied for his degree as master of theology. Between 1293 and 1302, when he was granted the degree, which was the highest academic honor at the time—and from which his title of “meister” comes—he was made prior of Erfurt and also vicar of Thuringia. Other titles came, including being made regent master at the St. Jacques Dominican House of Study, the First Provincial of Saxony, the vicar of Bohemia, as well as professor of theology. Eckhart is generally considered a mystic; if he was one, he was in the tradition of Emanuel Swedenborg and Rudolf Steiner, two other men deemed mystics who were also highly efficient organizers.
Eckhart was put in charge of reforming several of the Dominican Houses and he was also made responsible for the spiritual guidance of Dominican nuns and several women’s lay spiritual groups, such as the Beguines. These popular women’s groups reflect both the turn toward the feminine and the interest in independent spirituality common to the time; as one commentator remarked, they contributed to “one of the most spectacular upsurges of mystical spirituality in the history of Europe.”51 Not surprisingly, Clement V, who had suppressed the Templars and declared the Brethren of the Free Spirit heretical, suppressed the Beguines, and in 1310, the mystic Marguerite of Porete was burned at the stake for heresy in Paris. Among other things, she was accused of promoting the “heresy of the free spirit,” a charge laid against Eckhart as well. Marguerite, along with other women mystics, such as Hildegard of Bingen (1098–1179) and Mechthild of Magdeburg (1207–1294), a Beguine, was an influence on Meister Eckhart’s beliefs. Eckhart believed in an equality of the sexes and promoted a casual friendship between men and women, in contrast to the more sharply segregated policy of the church. He was also, as Albertus Magnus was, open to insights from other faiths, and was conversant with Jewish thinkers like Moses Maimonides and the Sufi saint Ibn ‘Arabi, among others. Much of what we know of Eckhart’s teachings comes to us from the many nuns and Beguines who memorized his sermons and wrote them down, although in their efforts to erase Eckhart’s work, the Inquisitors seized many of these accounts and destroyed them. Were it not for the efforts of these spiritual women, the little we have of Eckhart’s writings might have been even less.
What troubled the church was that Eckhart preached the same sort of union with God that the Sufi mystics sang of under the cover of a mysticism of the erotic. “God and I are one,” Eckhart told his congregation. “Through knowledge I take God into myself, through love I enter into God.”52 Other sayings make the same point. “The eye through which I see God is the same eye through which God sees me; my eye and God’s eye are one eye, one seeing, one knowing, one love.” “Our Lord says to every living soul ‘I became man for you. If you do not become God for me, you do me wrong.’”53 Probably the most well-known, as well as the most threatening from the church’s perspective, is “God needs me as much as I need him,” an insight that achieves the dual heresy of diminishing God’s omnipotence while emphasizing man’s importance.54 This sort of union with the divine has always been frowned upon by the church—understandably, as it subverts its authority, although Eckhart made a spirited defense of his faithfulness and orthodoxy and, as in the case of other heretics, much of what he says can be found in scripture.55 Yet as we’ve seen throughout this book, “dynamic” religion, meaning personal and experiential, does not get along well with the “static” variety, and it is usually the dynamic individuals who suffer from this dissonance.
According to Eckhart, the fundamental ground of all being is God—or, in Neoplatonic terms, the One—and through a process of letting go, of emptying ourselves of everything that stands in the way of recognizing and experiencing this—the via negativa—we can come to know God and to be One with Him. Or to be more precise, not to know God, which we cannot, as he is beyond knowledge, but to love him and to feel his love. This process of inner emptying is at the heart of the anonymous fourteenth-century mystical work The Cloud of Unknowing, whose title encapsulates the essence of the via negativa, and whose aptly unknown author was, like Eckhart, influenced by Dionysius the Areopagite. The aim of this work was to instruct a novice on the essentials of the contemplative life. Physical withdrawal, in the clichéd sense of retiring to a cave, is not essential. This work can and should be done in the midst of life. Eckhart himself said that if it was a choice between mystical rapture and giving a sick person soup, one should forget the rapture and get the soup. What was important, both for Eckhart and the unknown author of The Cloud of Unknowing, was “psychological withdrawal,” a letting go of attachments, possessions, relationships, and personal concerns. As the old Sufi saying has it, one should be in the world, but not of it. As the psychologist Ira Progoff remarked, “the aim of the work is to lead beyond all theological conceptions and doctrines, and beyond all attachments to religious objects and observances.”56 We should, the anonymous author tells us, learn to love God without his characteristics; love him not because he is good, loving, or merciful, but simply because he is (the similarity to the Neoplatonic conception seems fairly clear here). “It is good to think about the kindness of God, and to love Him and to praise Him for it, [but] it is far better to think about his naked being and to praise Him and love Him for Himself.”57As with Eckhart, this “ground” of “naked being” is the same as our own, and by losing one’s self in order to find it, one finds one’s “true self,” as it is. This is best achieved by getting rid of everything that can take our minds away from this. As Progoff writes, “Attachment to the symbolic forms and sacred figures of man’s religions can easily become an impediment in the ultimate quest of the spirit.”58 The philosopher Alfred North Whitehead said, “Religion is what the individual does with his solitariness,” an insight with which Eckhart and those that followed him would agree.59
Eckhart had different names for this process of getting rid of whatever comes between oneself and God, but probably the most well-known is Gelassenheit, a German word that does not have an exact English equivalent but can be understood as “detachment,” “releasement,” or simply “letting go.” It plays a central role in the philosophy of Martin Heidegger, whose concern with our “forgetfulness of being” is close to Eckhart’s own vision, with his attention to Istigkeit, or the sheer “is-ness” of things, and it is also used by Iain McGilchrist to characterize the right brain’s mode of letting things be as they are, as opposed to the left brain’s tendency to manipulate them into how it thinks they should be. The “dispassionate equanimity” related to the Greek notion of ataraxia (Chapter Three) comes close, but is too negative. We can see it as a positive letting-go in order to let things be as they are. “When a man’s heart grieves for nothing, then a man has the essence and the nature and the substance and the wisdom and the joy and all that God has,” Eckhart tells us. “Then the very being of the son of God is ours and in us we attain to the very essence of God,” he says of this kind of detachment.60 One cannot help but think of the Buddhist quieting of desire and of countless “dropouts” who quit the rat race in order to find a better life. “I have no money, no resources, no hopes; I am the happiest man alive,” Henry Miller declared at the start of his most famous work, Tropic of Cancer, an account of la vie bohème in the Paris of the 1930s.61 Eckhart might not have appreciated the book, but he would have agreed with Miller’s joy.
Yet while Eckhart and those who followed him continued on their solitary path toward the “dark brilliance” and “empty fullness” of the divine, the western mind was gearing up for a trip down the via positiva unlike any it had seen for some time.
Gary Lachman
The Secret Teachers of the Western World
No comments:
Post a Comment