To be is to be contingent: nothing of which it can be said that "it is" can be alone and independent. But being is a member of paticca-samuppada as arising which contains ignorance. Being is only invertible by ignorance.

Destruction of ignorance destroys the illusion of being. When ignorance is no more, than consciousness no longer can attribute being (pahoti) at all. But that is not all for when consciousness is predicated of one who has no ignorance than it is no more indicatable (as it was indicated in M Sutta 22)

Nanamoli Thera

Friday, March 1, 2024

Wiesel’s Existential Act Speaks Louder Than Words

 Wiesel Joins in Auschwitz Evacuation

On January 17, 1945, two days after his foot surgery, Wiesel tells us in La Nuit that he is hearing a rumor to the effect that the camp is about to be evacuated. As he discusses the rumor with others in the hospital who have just benefited from German medical care, he is told that the very same people who just saved his life will now kill him, and he expects the reader to believe such nonsense. He then has two of his characters mention possible ways in which all the detainees could be killed. One detainee speculates that “all the sick will be finished off at point-blank range,”265 while another states that “the camp is surely mined, and as soon as the evacuation is completed, it will all be blown up.”266 Wiesel goes to his father and asks what he would like to do:267He was lost in his meditations. The choice was in our hands. For once, we could decide for ourselves what our own fate would be. Both of us could stay at the hospital, where I could have him admitted either as a patient or a nurse, thanks to my doctor. Or we could go with the others.

But when his father remains silent and does not express a preference, it is Wiesel himself who takes the initiative and suggests one to him: “Let’s allow ourselves to be evacuated with the others,”268 he tells his father. Faced with this suggestion from his son, the father, who is supposedly very sick and quite weak, and who has not been able to work at Auschwitz for even one day, looks at the boy’s foot (and not his knee) and asks: “Do you think you can walk?”269 Wiesel responds: “Yes, I think so.”270 It is clear in this exchange that the father, first through his silence, and then by expressing his doubt about his son’s ability to engage in the forced march that would be part of the evacuation plan, does not want to go. He wants to stay, but his son wants to leave.

Without giving any explanation for his decision, and in contradiction to everything that has come before, Wiesel chooses to do just the opposite of what, logically, he should do: escape from the Germans at all cost! How can his act be defended? This decision is simply inexplicable within the context of the “autobiography” – or novel – up to this point, since it simply defies reason and turns our basic notions about cause and effect on their head. Thus, we must once again analyze the factors, mentioned above, that made the decision to remain behind seem like the obvious one. First, with regard to his father’s health, we must conclude that, by leaving with the Germans, Wiesel in fact hastened his father’s death instead of saving his life. Thus, in retrospect, Wiesel’s act was clearly irrational. Secondly, by leaving, he also needlessly risked his own life in the forced march. This was another irrational act that makes no sense in the context of the novel’s narrative to that point.

We now come to the third element that must of necessity be figured into his decision: German atrocities and overall brutality as part of an alleged extermination policy. The problem here is that Wiesel’s freely made decision to go with the Germans explicitly contradicts the anti-German rhetoric that characterizes La Nuit from its opening pages. This decision rocks the whole foundation on which the novel is based. The accusatory Jewish narrative voice, so stridently anti-German throughout, is completely contradicted by this act. In other words, this decision to voluntarily remain in German custody raises suspicions in the reader’s mind that the anti-German diatribes found in the preceding pages might not be true. If they were, Wiesel would have never agreed to go along with the Germans. Alternatively, his decision could be interpreted by a skeptical reader to mean that Wiesel knew that the anti-German rhetoric he had used in the preceding parts of the novel had no basis in fact.

Wiesel’s Existential Act Speaks Louder Than Words

This decision by Wiesel raises several serious questions about him as both a moral agent and a novelist. First, from a moral point of view, it is he, and not his father, who suggests this course of action. Even worse, he also insists on leaving with the Germans, even though such a choice represents the moral equivalent of signing his father’s death certificate. Given the detailed description of the father’s medical condition that is provided throughout the text of the novel, the son clearly understands that the decision to leave with the Germans involves serious risks for the father’s survival. What kind of a son is this?

Second, Wiesel, as the narrator and protagonist of this novel, seems to have already forgotten that his doctor had ordered two weeks of complete bed rest, that is, until January 29. By taking part of his own free will in a forced march and arduous travel by train when he supposedly could not even stand, Wiesel tests his reader’s ability to believe him. This is especially true when we recall that he was risking his father’s life as well as his own. It was also widely believed that anyone who fell out of the march for any reason was liable to be shot. This episode makes no sense, unless of course Wiesel was much healthier than he claims (if he was there in the first place). On the other hand, if he really was unable to walk, he simply invented, or plagiarized, the whole story.This basic inconsistency in Wiesel’s narrative offers a further explanation for why his camp medical records have been suppressed (if they exist at all). Sadly, the evidence in the text suggests that Wiesel, as narrator, never even considered such issues, hinting yet again that this episode is pure invention. In fact, Wiesel’s whole novel, up to the point of this pivotal discussion with the father, argues in favor of staying behind to be liberated. In doing so, he and his father would not only be escaping from the satanic Germans, Wiesel himself could have also gotten those two weeks of needed rest, and his father’s life would have been spared.

If Wiesel’s book is an autobiography, it must reflect life’s basic realities, including the relationship between cause and effect, as ordinary people understand that link. If not, his story cannot be taken seriously as a lived experience. Alternatively, if Wiesel’s book is a novel, which I believe to be the case, it should nonetheless contain the all-important quality of verisimilitude, that is, the quality of being in conformity, as a work of art, with that same understanding of cause and effect shared by ordinary folk.

In high-school and college literature classes, students hear the expression “willing suspension of disbelief,” which refers to the implicit bargain that any reader of a realistic work (excluded here are science fiction, fantasy literature and the like) strikes with an author. The reader will suspend disbelief, or skepticism, about the veracity and believability of the tale in exchange for entertainment or instruction. But should that reader conclude that the characters’ actions are arbitrary and do not make sense, then the pact is broken. The reader allows his skepticism to get the better of him and might even stop reading. In other words, suspension of disbelief implies a quid pro quo arrangement between author and reader. But skeptical school students who are forced to read this book cannot break the pact out of fear of reprisal from their teachers. After all, they are reading it “for credit,” and sometimes “for extra credit.”

Those who justify Wiesel’s decision to remain in German custody, including of course the teachers who administer Holocaust brainwashing at the grassroots level in the nation’s schools, are forced to justify Wiesel’s decision by citing the rumors mentioned in his discussion with the two other patients at the SS hospital. As shown above, one rumor had it that, if inmates remained behind, the Germans would shoot everyone at point-blank range, while the other predicted that the whole camp would be destroyed. Yet there are at least two reasons why it is difficult, if not impossible, to take these rumors seriously.

First, they were being circulated by people whose lives were being saved by fellow Jews working in a thoroughly normal and professional manner for the German government in a German military hospital. It would have made no sense for the Germans to save these patients, if they had intended to kill them the next day. Jewish proponents of the Holocaust faith have never been able to answer this massive contradiction at the heart of the master narrative of the Holocaust story, so they simply ignore it. Unfortunately, the collaborationist historians and literary scholars of academe give them a pass on the issue.

The second reason why these rumors cannot be taken seriously involves the sheer magnitude of the task they describe, killing thousands of people in a few hours!

Wiesel’s Decision Is Consistent with the Reality of Life in the Camps, Not the Holocaust

While there were no doubt individual instances of German brutality toward Jewish detainees in the camps, there was no German-government-ordered extermination plan at Birkenau. Thus, Wiesel’s decision to remain with the Germans makes sense only if he believed that the German program involved the ethnic relocation of Jews to work camps in Germany and farther to the east in order to force them to work on behalf of the German war effort, and not to kill them. His decision to remain in German custody makes no sense, however, within the context of the Holocaust.

In summary, Wiesel’s decision to evacuate the Auschwitz Camp with the retreating German “war criminals,” instead of remaining behind to be liberated by the Soviets, offers yet another insight into what was actually happening at Auschwitz. Many Jews were in fact deported from Germany and other European countries, spent time in camps, and were then transported farther to the east. In Wiesel’s case, he and his family were imported into the Reich to work in support of the German war effort, and if they were not always treated as humanely as in this episode, they were certainly not subjected to an industrial-scale extermination policy, as the Holocaust myth claims.

Thus, Wiesel’s decision to leave Auschwitz with the Germans is quite consistent with the reality of wartime Jewish suffering, but not with that of Holocaust fantasy. The latter is an exaggeration of the historical facts in order to justify, among other things, 1) German payment of restitution to Jews, 2) Jewish conquest and confiscation of Palestine, and 3) placement of guilt for war crimes solely on Germany. Thus, Wiesel’s decision, made within the horrible context of total war, signals his conviction at the time that the Germans had treated him relatively well. Not only had they provided him with medical care, they also offered the same level of care to his ailing father, even though the latter was never able to work.

Primo Levi and Lili Jacob Were Also Treated in the SS Hospital

One detainee who stayed behind was Lili Jacob. She later discovered the collection of photos that would come to be called The Auschwitz Album. By her own admission, she appears to have been treated well by the Germans before they left. According to the New York Times:273

On the day Auschwitz was liberated by Allied troops in December 1944 [sic], Lili Jacob was ill with typhus, lying in a camp hospital.

Primo Levi, who had worked as a lab assistant at the Buna synthetic rubber factory in the Monowitz complex, was also in the hospital with scarlet fever when the Germans left. Although sick and unable to work, he had not been sent to a gas chamber or killed by other means by the Germans either!274 Here again, the story peddled by Holocaust fundamentalists to the effect that sick people were routinely put to death in a gas chamber has proved to be false, for both Lili Jacob and Primo Levi, like Wiesel and his father, were well cared for.

[←265]Nuit, 129: “Tous les malades seront achevés à bout portant.” 

[←266]Ibid.: “Le camp est sûrement miné. Aussitôt après l’évacuation, tout sautera.” 

[←267]Ibid., 129f.: “Il était perdu dans ses méditations. Le choix était entre nos mains. Pour une fois, nous pouvions décider nous-mêmes de notre sort. Rester tous deux à l’hôpital où je pouvais le faire entrer comme malade ou comme infirmier, grâce à mon docteur. Ou bien suivre les autres.” 

[←268]Ibid., 130: “Laissons-nous évacuer avec les autres.” 

[←269]Ibid.: “Tu crois que tu pourras marcher?” 

[←270]Ibid., 30: “Oui, je crois.” 

[←271]https://furtherglory.files.wordpress.com/2012/05/auschwitzliberation.jpg.

[←272]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/51/Child_survivors_of_Auschwitz.jpeg

[←273] Jo Thomas, “‘Holy Document’ of Auschwitz Found: Closing the Past, Knew Her Tattoo Number,” New York Times, August 14, 1980, A16.

[←274] Primo Levi, If This Is a Man (New York: Orion, 1959); see also Illustration 17, gratefully received from Carlo Mattogno.


Warren B. Routledge:

Elie Wiesel, Saint of the Holocaust: A Critical Biography

Uckfield, East Sussex: Castle Hill Publishers

PO Box 243, Uckfield, TN22 9AW, UK

Fundamental Dishonesty of Night’s Conformist Critics


Since Night contains so many historical falsehoods, the conformist scholars and teachers who comment on the book must quickly learn to present it in a way that avoids discussion of its problematical pages and passages. Generally speaking, there are two major categories of deception in Night. First, there is the utterly mendacious, or implausible. Then there are the plausible claims that are weakened because they contradict the Holocaust’s master narrative. One or the other assertion can be true, but both cannot be true. As an example of what I call the mendacious and implausible, we have Wiesel’s burning trenches, their smoke visible outside the area of the camp compound and possibly for miles around, in which he claims to have seen children burnt alive. Conformist critics accept this eyewitness claim as true. But since the aerial photos, widely available on the Internet these days, show that this mass open-air burning of living multitudes of people never happened, such a belief is unfounded. Thus, the conformist critics simply avoid discussion of the subject.

An example of the second general category, in which a Wiesel claim contradicts the master narrative of the Holocaust, is offered by the episode involving his sore foot. In fact there are two contradictions here. In January 1945, Wiesel allegedly suffered from a case of frostbite, although the reader must construe this malady, since he does not use this word in his novel. Since his feet were sensitive to the cold, one of them began to swell. This event is quite plausible. In a word, it could have happened. Logically speaking, however, and in accordance with the vulgate version of the Holocaust, as it is repeated endlessly in the Zionist media, Wiesel ought to have been sent to the alleged gas chamber at Birkenau, or otherwise executed, for the simple reason that his sore foot should have prevented him from working. (The Holocaust vulgate also claims that an order had been issued in the fall of 1944 to stop the alleged extermination program, but no documentary proof has ever been offered in support of this claim176). But this did not happen. He was not killed. Yet another contradiction of the Holocaust master narrative in this episode is found in the fact that he was not only spared execution, he was operated on and restored to health by a Jewish surgeon at the camp hospital! This episode implies that German medical care, a very scarce commodity during the war years, was routinely given to sick or injured Jews. Yet the Holocaust master narrative states that medical care for inmates at Auschwitz was a sham, if not completely lacking.

There exists a multitude of books, articles and online resources that studiously evade such issues in order to deceive readers, especially young ones. Examples of this method can be found in the many manuals that are available in book form, such as the Student Companion to Elie Wiesel by Sanford Sternlicht or the Sparknotes Guide to Night. Then, of course, there are the Internet resources. They range from Oprah’s Book Club Guide to Night, in which Wiesel himself is featured as a narrator, to the study guide on Night in the series called Cliff Notes, which usually contain a plot summary, biographical information on the author, and critical commentary. Such books are intended for high-school students who must read the book in class as part of the state-mandated indoctrination program that is administered to them in support of our state religion, the Holocaust.

These and other Internet guides all have one thing in common: avoiding direct questioning of the passages in the book that contradict the basic tenets of our state religion. Students read Nightas part of their initiation into a state-imposed belief system, not into independent thinking. Thus, passages that provoke thought are avoided or passed over rapidly without comment. And since the Holocaust is our state religion, the instructors who actually teach this book to students on the high school level must engage in a self-imposed process of mental gymnastics even before they face a class. In so doing, they internalize the untenable belief that everything in Wiesel’s book is true and really happened, because the book is an autobiography. Thus, on encountering events in Night such as those mentioned above, whether plausible or implausible, they must first flip a mental switch, that of voluntary blindness, before setting to work brainwashing their charges.

In order to help such teachers, as well as other readers, who want to understand Night for what it is, a work of fiction, I have created the following list, not exhaustive by any means, of historical problems.

Problem #1: Botched Chronology and Possible Identity Theft

Date of Departure from Sighet

The traditional bildungsroman, or novel of initiation into adulthood, always involves travel away from home as an essential part of the young man’s journey to adulthood. Wiesel’s novel is consistent with this pattern. The hero’s travels will result in the creation of a new man, one who is ready to enter into the adult world. However, in his novel, Wiesel is extremely careless with regard to the basic question of a coherent chronology, and his carelessness extends even to the key issue of his departure from his hometown of Sighet and his arrival at Auschwitz. In an autobiography, in which everything is supposedly true, as Wiesel has claimed many times for Night, something as basic as an internally coherent chronology should be a given.

But that is not the case here. Wiesel seems to have invented dates as he went along, with the result that his story is a hodgepodge of events that take place in an internally contradictory time frame. I suspect that one reason for this problem is that Wiesel may have plagiarized other former detainees’ texts, probably written in Yiddish, for his own Yiddish account, Un di velt hot geshvign. When he published his Yiddish book, his principal intention was to attack Germans and other Gentiles, so he paid little or no attention to chronological detail. The main thrust of Un di velt hot geshvign involved Jewish racial hatred and the need to keep it alive. He had no idea at the time that the book would become the basis for one of the most sacred texts of the Holocaust. Thus Wiesel may well have never even bothered to stitch his various borrowings together into a coherent whole. Later, when Mauriac rewrote Un di velt on the basis of the bridge text that Wiesel had prepared for him, and, in the words of Holocaust theologian Naomi Seidman, “radically transformed” it into a French novel, he apparently concerned himself only with questions of language and style. He left everything else alone. As a result, Night is marred by a serious disconnect between the historical record and Wiesel’s alleged experiences within the context of that record.

When did Wiesel leave Sighet for Auschwitz? The basic textual reference for establishing the novel’s timeline is the Jewish Feast of Pentecost. Wiesel writes:177

On the Saturday before Pentecost (Shavuot), in the spring sunshine, people strolled, carefree and unheeding, through the swarming streets. They chatted happily.

In 1944, the first day of Shavuot fell on Sunday, May 28. Thus, the day described above was May 27. According to Wiesel, the first trainload of Jews bound from Sighet for Auschwitz left the next day, Sunday, May 28, on the Jewish feast day of Pentecost. Wiesel then speaks of Monday (“lundi,” Nuit, 37), then of dawn (“aube,” 38), and then of another dawn (“aube,” 41). He then writes:178Saturday, our day of rest, had been chosen for our departure.

The Jews of Sighet ate their ritual dinner on Friday evening, June 2, and then, the next morning (“le lendemain matin,” 43), that is, on Saturday, June 3, 1944, they left for Auschwitz. Since the trip usually took three to four days, they would have arrived on June 6 or June 7. Yet Wiesel writes as follows about his first full day in Poland:179

It was a beautiful April day. Springtime’s sweet perfume floated in the air. The sun was setting in the west.

This chronology is nonsensical, for if Wiesel left Sighet in June, he could not have arrived in April. It is this incoherence that leads me to suspect a botched job of plagiarism.

Marion Wiesel’s Deceptive “New” Translation of NightThis botched chronology, possibly resulting from Wiesel’s plagiarism of other Yiddish-language texts, helps to explain why a new translation of Night was deemed necessary by Wiesel and his Holocaust fundamentalist backers. With a breathtaking Orwellian stroke of the pen, Wiesel’s wife has attempted to cover over a number of glaring defects in Wiesel’s Night. Thus, the passage quoted above, and on which the chronology of the whole novel is based, “the Saturday before Pentecost (Shavuot)” (“le samedi précédant la Pentecôte”), has now been translated as “some two weeks before Shavuot.”180 By moving the whole chronology of the novel back two weeks, Wiesel and his wife are striving to have Wiesel leave Sighet on or about May 21, 1944, not June 3.

One of the reasons why Marion Wiesel has done this is to bring Wiesel’s arrival at Auschwitz into line with that of the man whose identity Wiesel appears to have stolen, Lazar Wiesel, also from Sighet, but born in 1913. In keeping with the use of retroactive continuity, Wiesel’s wife passes off this mendacious translation as if it were faithful to the original text from La Nuit, for there is no footnote alerting the reader that the original text has been altered through the use of this deliberate mistranslation.

Then, for consistency’s sake, Wiesel’s original description of his arrival in Auschwitz – “it was a beautiful day in April” (“c’était une belle journée d’avril”) – has also been doctored in the new translation to “it was a beautiful day in May.”181 Once again, this has been done without a note to alert the reader to this deliberate mistranslation. It is truly shocking that a widely respected publishing house like Farrar, Straus & Giroux would actually lend its name to such a travesty.

Unfortunately, Marion Wiesel is not the first person to have tampered abusively with her husband’s text in order to make it say what it most emphatically does not say. There is a precedent for what she has done, and the culprit, as far as is known, is the publishing house that brought out the original German translation of La Nuit in 1962.182

In both cases, the counterfeiters seem to have acted in an attempt to correct the strong impression given by Wiesel of never having actually been in either Auschwitz or Buchenwald. In his novel, Wiesel claimed to have seen outdoor burning operations of live victims, while the master narrative of the Holocaust story, by 1962, was centered on the mythical gas chambers. The German falsifiers seem to have been concerned about two things: Wiesel’s overall lack of verisimilitude in his description of killing operations, and his failure to even mention the gas chambers. Thus, the words crematory/ies and crematory oven(s) were simply translated as “gas chamber(s)” in 15 instances. This was done so systematically that the translator by accident even turned the Buchenwald crematory into a gas chamber, although everybody agrees that there was no homicidal gas chamber at the Buchenwald camp.183 In this way, by a simple swipe of the pen, the text of what Wiesel had supposedly seen became more compelling and, at the same time, was brought into conformity with the Holocaust master narrative. On the other hand, Mrs. Wiesel, preoccupied with other matters some 40 years later, concentrates on the narrative blunders relating to the novel’s botched chronology.

Carlo Mattogno’s Accusation of Identity Theft

Carlo Mattogno, in his claim regarding Wiesel’s possible theft of someone else’s identity, emphasizes that the ID number in question was assigned on May 24, 1944. Thus, the dates of June 6 or 7, which I have extrapolated from Wiesel’s chronology in the novel, are off by about two weeks. Furthermore, Mattogno, citing extant records, goes even further, stating that two thousand numbers, from A-5729 through A-7728, were distributed on that day, and suggests that Wiesel stole the identity of a man from Sighet named Lazar Wiesel, a person who might have been a distant relative and who might possibly have been known to Wiesel. Lazar Wiesel is listed in Buchenwald records as born in 1913, and was tattooed at Auschwitz with ID # A-7713 on May 24, 1944.

Such an impersonation would help to explain why Wiesel’s French-language biographer, Saint Cheron, tells us that Wiesel, whose name was Eliezer, or Elie, was actually called “Lazar,” a diminutive of Eliezer, through the end of the 1940s. Saint Cheron wrote of Wiesel that “for many years, until the end of the 1940s, [he] was called Lazar.”184 Thus, what seems like a gratuitous fact of no particular importance in Saint Cheron’s authorized biography of Wiesel could have actually been an attempt to provide a cover story for Wiesel’s theft of someone else’s identity.

Here is what Wiesel writes about his tattoo in La Nuit:185

The three veteran detainees, with needles in their hands, engraved a number on our left arm. I became A-7713. From this point on, I had no other name.

Yet, Wiesel’s tattoo cannot be discerned on any extant photograph or film of him.186 Nor have Elie Wiesel’s personal and medical records ever been made public – if they exist; are they being withheld by the various Holocaust museums and record centers? Thus, there is no way of knowing for sure where Wiesel spent the war years.187

[←176] The only evidence ever cited is the testimony by SS-Standartenführer Kurt Becher, IMT document PS-3762; IMT, Vol. 33, 68f. However, Becher clearly made it up to save his neck, as he confessed to an acquaintance; see Göran Holming, “Himmlers Befehl, die Vergasung der Juden zu stoppen,” Vierteljahreshefte für freie Geschichtsforschung, Vol. 1, No. 4, 1997, 258f.; www.vho.org/VffG/1997/4/HolHim4.html.

[←177] Nuit, 29: “Le samedi précédant la Pentecôte (Shavuot), sous un soleil printanier, les gens se promenaient insouciants à travers les rues grouillantes de monde. On bavardait gaîment.” 

[←178] Ibid., 42: “Samedi, le jour du repos, était le jour choisi pour notre expulsion.” 

[←179] Ibid., 69: “C’était une belle journée d’avril. Des parfums de printemps flottaient dans l’air. Le soleil baissait vers l’ouest.” 

[←180]Elie Wiesel, Night, tr. Marion Wiesel (N.Y.: Farrar, Straus & Giroux, 2006), 12.

[←181]Ibid., 40.

[←182]Die Nacht zu begraben, Elisha, tr. Kurt Meyer-Clason (Berlin: Ullstein, 1962).

[←183] See the comparison of the three language editions (French, English, German) by Jürgen Graf in: Robert Faurisson, “Witnesses to the Gas Chambers of Auschwitz,” in: Germar Rudolf (ed.), Dissecting the Holocaust: The Growing Critique of “Truth” and “Memory,” (Uckfield: Castle Hill Publishers, 2019), 139.

[←184]Saint Cheron, Elie Wiesel, 16: “[…] que l’on appela longtemps Lazar jusqu’à la fin des années 1940 […]” 

[←185] Wiesel, La Nuit, 72: “Les trois ‘anciens,’ des aiguilles à la main, nous gravaient un numéro sur le bras gauche. Je devins A-7713. Je n’eus plus désormais d’autre nom.”

[←186] As mentioned in my Introduction, there exists a website devoted to the question of Wiesel’s tattoo and identity: www.eliewieseltattoo.com.

Warren B. Routledge:

Elie Wiesel, Saint of the Holocaust: A Critical Biography

Uckfield, East Sussex: Castle Hill Publishers

PO Box 243, Uckfield, TN22 9AW, UK

[←187]Jean Robin, “Elie Wiesel n’a pas le tatouage qu’il prétend avoir.” Enquête et Débat, December 24, 2012. https://web.archive.org/web/*/http://www.enquete-debat.fr:80/archives/elie-wiesel-na-pas-le-tatouage-dauschwitz-quil-pretend-avoir-94416/; www.dailymotion.com/embed/video/xw5uoe. Robin presents the texts of an email exchange he engaged in with Wojciech Płosa, the head of archives at Auschwitz. In the exchange, the latter confirmed the truth of Mattogno’s reading of the Grüner and Wiesel ID cards.


The banking system was just a sophisticated system of slavery, that was marketed so well, that everyone was fighting to the death to become the noble alpha slave

 

This systematic dismantling of the society had to be part of some greater plan. Once you saw it, it was impossible to unsee it. The evidence was everywhere.
*
The banking system was just a sophisticated system of slavery, that was marketed so well, that everyone was fighting to the death to become the noble alpha slave.

It was so obvious to Ethan now. He sometimes wondered if the system had been subverted at some point in the past, or if it had always been a lie, but it didn't really matter. What mattered now was that he knew he was being exploited by people who had not earned and did not deserve, their positions; positions that were held together by imaginary frameworks. These were intangible structures that consisted of self-appointed royal bloodlines, oligarchs, and banking dynasties. Nearly every decision these sociopaths made was to secure their position of power within the architecture they had created, and eliminate any possibility of competition.

They were the divine few; always justified in their choices, no matter what the cost to people like him. It was people like him that the ruling class had been working diligently against for decades, if not longer; working to strip away any remaining residual power that might threaten their legacy. When these autocrats weren't developing new ways to devour their own countrymen, they were sending hundreds of thousands of these ignorant wretches, sometimes even millions, to their deaths.

Countless nobodies had died in wars so that the elites might enrich themselves or secure their legacy.

Nobody ever called them murderers, no matter how high the bodies were stacked. Countless men, still under the spell of the American delusion, had lined up for the slaughter generation, after generation. All of them vying for the chance to have their name carved into a war memorial. This was the closest a piñata could ever come to immortality or having a legacy. It was a bitter pill to swallow, but Ethan finally understood the truth. The truth that might have saved the lives of these men with engraved names had they experienced the same awakening.
*

Ethan was appalled that this tiny minority had managed to amass so much control over the rest of the species. That they had fooled so many into believing that murder, sanctioned by them, was no longer murder. That it only became murder, when it wasn't explicitly in the interests of their bloodlines. What made their interests so damn righteous, other than their place in the hierarchy?

"Nothing," he had decided. Rejecting their authority and their claim to their positions in this imaginary institution had been easy. He had never ceded power to them. He had never agreed to be their servant. He never consented to the murders they committed in his name. He rejected utterly the premise that when they kill, it is noble and good, but for him, and people like him, it was forbidden. He would not submit to this system. This system that was intangible, and existed only in the abstract, and only in the minds of those who did submit and obey.
*

Over, and over, and over, again, the ruling class had sent their agents into countries they wished to have under their rule. Every culture, every government, every population, all reacting precisely the same in reaction to taxpayer-funded methods developed by America's intelligence agencies. Starting civil wars, and toppling governments. Installing puppet-regime, after puppet-regime, so they could pillage the monetary systems of entire continents, and steal their natural resources. Expand their globalist corporations into new markets, and build a Starbucks on every corner.
*
It had been a similar process when he had first realized the extent of the lies that had been told to him. When the truths he had taken for granted were revealed as deception, with intent and design, he had felt a righteous indignation that evolved into to anger, then into despair.

How was it that such a small group of people could deceive the rest of humanity with ease? It wasn’t just the ease at which they had constructed the false reality or even the ease at which the public at large had accepted it. It was the complete lack of decency that these perpetrators of lies were demonstrating that astounded him. It was an inversion of nature. How long had the world been systematically rewarding and enabling its most depraved inhabitants?
*
Jacob was sitting at a large conference table on the sixty-third floor of the Silverman and Malone building, next to his mentor, and the owner of the Manhattan high rise, Eli Silverman. Jacob had worked for Silverman for over twenty-five years and had great respect for the man that had tripled the size of his empire over the last few decades. He had done it by being ruthless with his competition and having incredible instincts. Although, to be perfectly fair, many of his investments, which included everything from commodities to world leaders that had seemed to have been made by a man that could see the future, had in reality been the work of a man who dictated the future.

More precisely, Eli was allowed , b y families that really dictated the future, to manage the Americans. That said, they had been pleased with his efficiency and rewarded him with a large measure of autonomy when it came to operations in this part of the hemisphere. Jacob had learned at an early age how the world really worked, and right now it worked how ever Eli told it to work.
Or, at least, it had.
*
The internet had made many of their tried, and true, social engineering tactics ineffective. They owned Silicon Valley, just as surely as they owned Washington, but they’d been unable to wrangle and adequately suppress the free flow of information. Certainly, they had ways of suppressing the undesirable voices, but these undesirables were getting clever, and the old institutional media had been utterly incompetent. The people were playing outside of the sandbox, like unruly children trampling all over his delicate garden. The narrative had split into unmanageable fragments. People like this Wayne Thomas were beginning to have more influence than the approved thought leaders.

People like this Wayne Thomas had told the people to vote for the other candidate, and the people had listened.

They had overplayed their hand. They had been overconfident, and now their soft underbelly was exposed. They had to pacify the people and buy some time, so they could regroup, and then define a new monster to frighten the children back into their parent’s arms. Then, they must punish the children.
*

The story was about the murder of a former colleague of his. Randy Bishop. Randy had been fired from the campaign when he had been caught with child porn on his computer. Of course, they didn’t fire him for having kiddy porn. They fired him for being stupid and getting caught with kiddy porn. That had taken up the news cycle with accusations of pedophilia for about forty-eight hours, until his friends in the media could shut it down.

That was one subject that, at least for now, still outraged the cattle, but they would accept that too, eventually. As for now, if the cattle really knew what went on at the parties that Brad and these media people went to, they would have strung them all up, and hung them all from the Ellington Bridge.
*
The public had always watched the political theater and imagined what they saw was real. The gullible voting public believed the fiction that there was a never-ending battle raging between The Left and The Right. Indeed, there were power struggles within the establishment, but they were two sides of the same coin. One of the sides of the coin was always going to be on top, at any given moment, but to destroy one side, was to destroy the coin.
*

Devon Stack

The Day of the Rope 

Demonic Foes

 Foreword

As his past academic chairman for many years, I can attest that Dr. Richard Gallagher is a multitalented psychiatrist and a highly respected clinician who is also a valued teacher. He embarked on a serious scholarly study long ago concerning the fascinating, if controversial, subject of suspected demonic possession.

Contrary to a widespread belief, such phenomena not only continue to be reported in today’s world, but they still defy easy explanation as simplistically conceived medical or psychiatric disorders. Dr. Gallagher brings his trained intellect and unimpeachable integrity to bear on the investigation of such “states of possession” and has undoubtedly directly encountered more of these hard-to-explain and intriguing cases than any other physician.

Hence, his book may well be unique in history: the serious treatment of a long-disputed topic by a superbly credentialed academic physician—a full professor of psychiatry—who can accurately offer personally informed accounts in painstaking detail of modern-day examples.

                             Joseph T. English, MD

                             Sidney E. Frank Distinguished Professor of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences,

                             New York Medical College; Past President,

                             American Psychiatric Association

**

Demonic Foes is my attempt to enter into a meeting place between pop culture—which sensationalizes the paranormal and the supernatural—sound spiritual judgment, and serious psychiatric and scientific study. It is of necessity an interdisciplinary approach.

The best way to illustrate this, in my opinion, is to tell my own personal journey of transformation from skeptic to believer to expert. To ground the discussion in reality, I explore along the way some of my more complex and compelling cases, outlining my own investigative methods while explaining how each case relates to and informs modern culture, history, religion, and psychiatric theories.

Of the many cases I have seen, I highlight the following:

A young woman, a self-described Satanist, who levitated for half an hour during her exorcism in front of eight witnesses—a “once in a century” case, in the words of her two experienced exorcists.

A housewife whose hearing was blocked whenever anyone mentioned anything related to religion and who uttered vile blasphemies during recurring trancelike, possessed states.

A professional woman who suffered from unexplained bruises, spoke several languages completely unknown to her, and during her states of possession periodically ran amok, potentially wreaking havoc on herself and her reputation.

A petite woman who in her possessed state threw a two-hundred-pound Lutheran deacon across the room.

In such cases, I’ve worked hard to develop a system of investigation based on my psychiatric training and experience. To begin, I never officially “diagnose” someone as being “possessed.” I do this for several reasons. First, it is not a clinical diagnosis that can be shoehorned into a conventional and scientifically responsible psychiatric diagnostic category. Because possession is a spiritual problem—not a psychiatric one—no laboratory or cognitive or mental status tests exist to register that information using medically established categories. Instead, I ask one basic question: Do the patient’s symptoms have a natural or scientific explanation?

I may begin to answer this question, as need be, through a physical exam and standard rounds of medical tests, such as blood work to search for chemical abnormalities. I especially make sure the patient isn’t suffering from an odd seizure disorder or other undiscovered brain damage. To rule these out, I may schedule a brain scan or an EEG, if indicated. If appropriate testing is negative, I rely upon a full narrative assessment and symptom survey that I always conduct. I also generally interview friends and families to confirm all details reported by the patient.

To the untrained eye, many possessions may be thought to fall into the psychiatric categories of various psychoses and severe personality and dissociative disorders, or they may seem to happen to individuals who are prone to suggestibility. However, for well-trained psychiatrists and other health professionals, possession differs from such disorders in significant ways. I outline in detail these symptoms and signs throughout this book, along with both the medical and spiritual criteria involved.

In those rare instances when I cannot determine a natural or scientific explanation for a person’s condition, I refer the individual back to the priest, rabbi, pastor, imam, or other spiritual adviser who sent that person to me. The men and women of faith make the final official determination and arrange for spiritual help, if the patient is in need of such.

I take my responsibilities as a physician seriously, so I remind those who are mentally ill and who only think that they are being attacked by evil spirits to seek psychiatric help. The field of exorcism is littered with examples of careless deliverance groups and lay amateurs who may use questionable and sometimes outright hazardous forms of “liberation” on people who are struggling with depression or another mental illness.

A major attempt to moderate mistaken diagnoses and excesses came through the founding in the early 1990s of the International Association of Exorcists. I knew most of the founders personally and acted for a time as the association’s scientific adviser. In the United States, Catholic Bishops have appointed about one hundred or so exorcists to combat serious demonic conditions. They routinely expect psychiatric evaluations. Other denominations have mounted similar, if perhaps less prominent, efforts. None of these sensible developments, however, should blind us to the continuing scattered abuses among poorly led “teams” of the overeager, especially among fundamentalists of all faiths in both the developed and undeveloped worlds.

* * *

My having earned the trust of numerous possessed individuals, as well as my privileged position as a psychiatrist, allowed them to open up to me not only about the strange features of their presentations, but also about their backgrounds and many intimate aspects of their personal lives. All these factors are crucial in judging whether a person is undergoing a true demonic attack. Patients in their profound and varied suffering will often tell a physician, and especially a psychiatrist, matters that they wouldn’t reveal to anyone else. These details commonly include shameful behaviors, such as briefly turning to the occult or even satanic practices, that may make them reluctant to divulge their past indiscretions to clergy, let alone spouses and close friends. In some cultures possessed individuals are shunned and isolated; a few around the world are even physically punished or killed. As a consequence, these individuals often keep their stories hidden. In the United States, they usually fear institutionalization.

I work hard to distinguish carefully as a scientifically trained physician what “science” and good historical testimony can and cannot demonstrate about episodes of possession. And I take these individuals’ trust in me very seriously.

All the understandable demand for proof should not blind us to the inescapable reality that tortured individuals are at the center of these assessments. They are not looking to illustrate a theory or prove their credibility. They are in enormous pain and want relief. I’ve often looked into the eyes of those who are suffering and been moved by the terror that I see. Few of them fully understand what is going on or why they are in a constant state of torment. But they believe their whole body, mind, and soul are under attack. Should one just ignore their distress?

Yet surprisingly, most often their own behavior and attitude are also essential to their liberation. As the Catholic Church teaches (along with similar beliefs in other denominations and many religions), the Rite of Major Exorcism is not a magic formula that will cast out demons automatically and completely liberate suffering victims without effort from the afflicted individuals themselves. Exorcists are not wizards, and often a long, grueling, and terrible struggle ensues for victims to be free of what ails them, just as it would be in a normal psychiatric case with a typical severe mental illness.

Exorcisms are not magic bullets. In the end, that is why I’m placing my professional qualifications on the line to write Demonic Foes. I want to enlighten the public as to the import and reality of these admittedly rare phenomena and what must be done for someone to receive help. I want to see tormented people set free from all things that would oppress or destroy their lives. I’ve dedicated my life to fighting the ravages of mental illness, and I’ve put the same sort of passion into working with people who may suffer from demonic possessions or lesser attacks, however controversial such conclusions may seem to some of my peers.

While I know I can’t persuade the hard skeptic or critic, my hope is that Demonic Foes will reach out to the vast middle ground of people who are open to the ideas that we live in a world that is both seen and unseen and that these two realms can influence each other in unimaginable ways. A segment of that invisible world seems to be mysteriously but remarkably hostile to human beings and seeks their physical and spiritual destruction. On rare occasions, like some kind of cosmic terrorist, that segment shows its true colors. The public in recent decades has learned to its horror that vile humans may practice unspeakable acts of terrorism; perhaps the suggestion that spiritual entities of a similar brutality may also engage in acts of spiritually motivated savagery has thus become more believable.

I thank the many people who allowed me to share their compelling stories. I especially express my gratitude to the avowed Satanist presented in this book, who not only permitted but encouraged me and my colleagues to report her striking narrative. I well recognize the flamboyant, almost phantasmagorical nature of her strange story; however, it is not unprecedented in any of its individual details, and I provide parallels to even the most bizarre features of her situation from other historical cases.

Neither she nor any of these victims were patients of mine; I would not write about them if they were. Almost all of the cases found to be of an “extraordinary nature” (the traditional term) have instead been sent to me by educated and knowledgeable clergy of many faiths or other credentialed mental health professionals who have requested my opinion. In recent years, a few assaulted victims have found me on their own after learning of my experience online or from interviews I’ve given or articles I’ve written.

**

Around the time that I graduated as a resident and post-doc fellow from the Yale psychiatry program, a somewhat inaccessible literature about a modern possession was emerging within the mainstream. Various investigators, inspired by the commercial success of William Peter Blatty’s 1971 novel, The Exorcist, and the movie that followed, were digging up previously unreleased facts about the events that had inspired the fictionalized account.

I was fascinated to learn the real-life details of this sensationalized story, and, though I was already convinced that Blatty had borrowed features from various historical accounts of exorcisms, including the Loudun case, I was particularly struck that the movie had primarily fictionalized an account of a putative actual and present-day possession.

Blatty’s fictional story was said to have been modeled on the real-life possession of a young boy in Maryland, starting in 1949. Original sources pseudonymously called the boy Roland Doe, but in the age of investigative curiosity, the boy was later rechristened Robbie Mannheim. Raised Lutheran, Robbie was ministered to by his pastor, the Reverend Luther Miles Schulze. He had stints in hospitals, but doctors couldn’t explain the case features, and psychiatric treatment had no effect. Robbie remained possessed for a long time.

As portrayed in the film, troubles began with poltergeist-like phenomena—inexplicable noises and “scratchings,” a vibrating bed, objects flying around, a tipped-over chair. Multiple accounts claimed that up to forty-eight people witnessed these strange happenings, including Reverend Schulze, who attested to such occurrences when Robbie stayed with him in his home for an extended observation. Robbie’s condition eventually progressed to symptoms more typically associated with possession: involuntary trance states; vitriolic expressions of hatred toward religion, delivered in a diabolic-sounding voice; and other paranormal abilities, including speaking in Latin, a language that young Robbie did not know. At one point, according to witnesses, Robbie’s room became frigid, a not-unprecedented occurrence during exorcisms, I later learned.

A variety of clergy performed multiple rituals of exorcisms, first according to Lutheran, then Episcopalian, and finally Catholic procedures. Several Jesuits in a St. Louis hospital eventually conducted the successful series of exorcisms years later. The priests related that a loud noise accompanied the actual moment of Robbie’s deliverance. The Jesuits compared the sound to a “thunderclap.” After his successful exorcism, Robbie went on to marry, have children, and lead a successful life.

Before his death in 2017, Blatty acknowledged that his fictional story was most prominently based on the Mannheim possession but was also a composite. For instance, Blatty modeled the character of the priest-psychiatrist in his book and screenplay in part upon Father Surin, who had similarly offered himself to the demon as ransom for the original victim.

At the same time, Blatty intended the two priests in his novel—Father Damien Karras and Father Lankester Merrin—to represent two contrasting points of view. With his heavily lined face and white hair, Father Merrin symbolized the old-school Catholic Church and its belief in literal evil spirits. He doesn’t waver from that belief even as he conducts the exorcism that will end his life. Father Karras, on the other hand, begins the story with the conviction that the young girl Regan MacNeil demonstrates signs of an unknown psychiatric disorder despite the evidence pointing to possession. Only after running every physical and psychological test possible does Father Karras change his mind, finally acknowledging that something inexplicable, something demonic, is going on.

The personal transformation of Father Karras proved especially fascinating to me. I probably only later realized how seminal it turned out to be to my much later academic pursuits and direction: a trained psychiatrist who investigates the matter from an analytic and scientific point of view and then—and only then—comes to believe firmly in the reality of demonic possession.

Like Father Karras, I have since walked in two worlds—the world of scientific psychiatric investigation and the world of exorcism. And I’ve spent much of my time over the years deepening my understanding of both, which to some seem incompatible, though in my opinion they are not so at all.

**

Julia, the Satanic Queen

Her Possession and Her Remarkable Abilities

The night before I met Julia, something unnerving happened. My family loves animals, and at that time, a French bulldog and two cats prowled around our house like longtime relatives. All three always got along well. The cats often curled up next to each other on our bed at night.

But one night around 3 a.m., loud screeching sounds startled me and my wife out of our sleep. Our two normally docile cats were going at it like champion prizefighters, smacking and clawing at each other, intent on inflicting some serious harm. My wife grabbed the female cat and I held on to the male. As we separated them into two different rooms, they continued to growl and bristle. My wife and I got back into bed, mystified, but wrote off the tiff as perhaps caused by some bad cat food or one too many sniffs of catnip.

The next morning, Father Jacques rang our doorbell. He was standing at our front door with “Julia.” She was dressed in black pants, with a dark purple blouse hanging loosely around her slight frame. I guessed she was in her late thirties or early forties. Her short hair was dyed jet black, and her black eyeliner extended to her temples—the style I later learned that was favored by her fellow cult members.

Dressed again, as always, in his clerics, Father Jacques had his hands in his pockets, avoiding eye contact.

“This is Julia,” he said. “She has something to confess.”

With a smirk Julia gazed at me.

“How’d you like those cats last night?” she asked.

I stared at her, taken aback as much by her manner as by her astonishing statement. She regarded me with that smug smile, evidently pleased with herself.

“What are you amused about?” I blurted out.

Her smile widened as she leaned against the doorframe.

“Look,” I finally thought to say. “I respect Father Jacques, and he asked me to see you. But let’s not have a repeat of last night, understand?”

My thoughts came fast and furious. What the hell am I saying? Could she really have had anything to do with the cats?

Unperturbed, Julia just stood there with the air of an honored houseguest, offering no apology.

For the rest of the day, I tried to collect my thoughts. What in God’s name have I gotten into? This was the first time I had ever doubted or even questioned my involvement with Father Jacques. To get a few things off my chest, I called him, throwing away common courtesy and asking, “What on earth were you thinking, bringing her here?”

He apologized profusely and told me she had arrived earlier than he had expected. He had wanted to make sure I was around so we could meet with her as soon as possible. Jacques was eager to get my input, though I already knew he was convinced that she was possessed.

“Striking while the iron was hot,” he put it, since he didn’t seem to trust that her motivation to get help would last long. He further astonished me by admitting that a similar thing had occurred in the house of another psychologist who had interviewed Julia. The man’s wife subsequently forbade him from having anything else to do with “that horrible woman” after their crazed cat tore up their living room couch.

“Now you tell me,” I said. I felt annoyed, invaded.

Father Jacques went on. “She can be provocative, but she does seem to want our help, at least for now. She needs our help, the sooner the better, I think. Her cult doesn’t want to let her go and will do anything to stop our continued exorcisms.”

According to Father Jacques, Julia was a truly exceptional case even for a serious possession. As a rare Satanist and the “high priestess” of a satanic cult, he further explained, Julia had been granted certain “special abilities.” Because her cult had threatened him directly, he said, Father Jacques was convinced her stories were credible.

I agreed to see her at my office the next day.

During the exorcisms of most full possessions, the evil spirit may on its own (or may be forced to) manifest itself and display its remarkable preternatural powers. Even outside the exorcisms, and critical to the diagnostic process, victims in their periodic possessed trances frequently display at least some of the classic signs of their state. Evil spirits may speak foreign languages; show supernormal strength; or reveal “hidden knowledge,” that is, display an awareness of matters they have no natural way of knowing—akin to what psychics claim to be able to do. Of course, it is the demon who has such powers, not the victim. In a possession, the demonstration of these paranormal abilities is precisely what proves that a foreign evil spirit is present and in control. Despite occasional protestations by so-called parapsychologists and spiritualists, human beings on their own have none of these powers.

But Father Jacques explained to me that a powerful diabolist like Julia who has explicitly committed herself to Satan, who worships him, may be granted some “privileges” of this sort “on their own.” That is, the contention that Satan grants his devotees the ability to demonstrate psychic powers not only outside an overt possessed state, but also in their normal conscious state. Under Satan’s power, they perform these paranormal feats through no inherent ability of their own but are able to draw upon demonic sources of power in a strange way.

Cases of individuals who have such a level of “favors” are, in my experience, very rare, even more uncommon than in a more typical possession. But Julia, I was soon to discover, was hardly typical. She openly exhibited these features and delighted in her “favors.”

* * *

When Jacques and Julia arrived the following day, I ushered her into my office. Instead of greeting me, she strolled over to my large windowsill, which was filled with small wicker baskets of forsythia, and without a word, started watering my plants. Again, I was struck by her effrontery, her almost complete disregard for formalities or everyday courtesies.

“I’m into the life of plants. We love plants and animals. Well, maybe not all animals, I suppose.” She chortled at her little joke. “But we’re unlike stupid Christians who hate nature, have you noticed?”

Through the months of our discussions, Julia always insisted that she desired to be in tune with the “natural world” and that was one reason she was a practicing Satanist. She interpreted traditional religion as unnatural and repressed. “My philosophy is this, doc,” she told me. “Indulgence instead of abstinence. Vital existence instead of spiritual pipe dreams. Vengeance instead of turning the other cheek.” It sounded like her cult’s formulaic motto of sorts, and she even wrote it out for me once.

She liked calling me “doc,” which I took as a good sign. She seemed to trust doctors more than priests. Having heard how she talked to priests, I expected her to treat me the same way. But I think she knew I would call her out on any discourtesy, and, as it turned out, she gave more respect and heed to my views as a physician than to the admonishments of priests, however obviously well-intentioned on their part. She wanted my perspective on, as she called it, this “possession business.”

“I know I’m possessed,” she said. “I space out and then don’t recall what happens. They tell me a voice comes out of me. I don’t know. I don’t remember anything. It’s a demon, I’m sure. It’s not Satan. He doesn’t bother himself with small things like that. But it comes from him. Everything is under his control. I have long followed the Master and done everything he wants for years.”

I was struck by the calm and rational way Julia talked about her condition. It wasn’t what I had expected. She stood in front of my office window, staring at the neighboring buildings and surrounding wooded area. I had chosen this office specifically for this view, and I regularly took in the scene, in much the same way Julia seemed to be enjoying it. If I hadn’t known what she was enduring within her spirit, I easily could have mistaken her for one of my usual patients. She struck me as intelligent and in firm control of her emotions. She did not seem to me the unbalanced or limited person I had been suspecting.

I decided to dig a little deeper, hoping she would reveal to me some crucial detail about her story that would allow me to gain a better understanding of her situation and her mental state.

“Why do you think you became possessed?” I asked.

She claimed not to have a clue, which I found odd. “Well, Satan is certainly in charge, so he must have his reasons. But I don’t understand why. And, no, I don’t like it. It’s always unwise to oppose the devil, but I decided to seek help. The cult would hate that, too, so I told them I would infiltrate the church and get any priests I met in trouble. I assume they believe me, but I’m leery and afraid they’ll turn on me. But I just sense I have to get rid of this possession. I heard only priests or ministers can help me. Can psychiatrists? I don’t think so. I’m not crazy, that I know.” I was impressed by her frankness, including about the priests.

She finally sat down in front of my desk, easing into our conversation. I decided to let her talk, which she seemed eager to do. I figured out quickly that she liked the fact that I just listened. In that, she didn’t prove immune to something I’ve observed in my years as a psychiatrist: if you say little, people often tell you everything. Plus, she knew that I was taking her seriously, not charging her a fee, and not automatically assuming she was mentally disturbed or pushing for a hospitalization.

She mentioned that Father Jacques had taken her to a couple of psychologists first. Jacques had told her that in their view no psychological explanation came close to explaining her strange condition. As believers, both agreed she was possessed. She went on to say that Jacques wanted the opinion of a physician, however. She took some glee in telling me that the original “shrinks” were a little scared of her.

“Then he put me on the phone with a Jesuit priest he knew. He seems to know a lot of people, big shots. This priest was also a psychiatrist. I couldn’t stand the guy. He was a real smartass. He said he couldn’t tell me his full opinion over the phone, but he went out of his way to tell me he thought my thinking was ‘off.’ Can you believe the nerve of the guy? Here he was giving me some dim-witted opinion even though he never met me and didn’t know all the facts. Him and his stupid, heavy red curtains.”

“How do you know he has red curtains?” I asked. “You told me you spoke to him over the phone.”

Julia laughed and lit up, visibly excited. With a glimmer in her eyes, she explained that she had some “powers.” One of them, she claimed, was what students of the paranormal call “remote viewing.”

“I can also wreak havoc whenever I want.”

I was learning fast here. My characteristic incredulity faded by the minute, with every new piece of information Julia presented me.

“But I don’t want to get into that now,” she said. “You’ll see soon enough.” She promised to tell me the truth, but she wasn’t ready to tell me everything about her devotion to Satan, or anything about the cult or its leader and participants. “It might be better for you not to know anyway, if you get my drift, doc.”

In my previous conversations with Father Jacques he had assured me that he was positive Julia was involved with a committed group of avowed devil worshippers. I also knew she claimed to be a kind of satanic witch—a claim that still seemed fantastic to me, despite her continued candor. Still, I was starting to believe her story, or rather I wasn’t ruling out its veracity on the basis of this conversation. At least she didn’t give me the impression that she was deluded or simply trying to cause a stir with sensational stories.

She told me she was not some pathetic “loony bird,” as the Jesuit had implied. “He told Father Jacques I should probably be observed in a hospital.” For the first time, Julia got annoyed. “I have never had any need for psychiatric help in my life.”

Despite her growing anger, she said all this with such conviction that I again was surprised by the coherence of her vehement reasoning.

“You won’t do that, will you? Put me in the hospital against my will? Father said you’re more open-minded than most shrinks and have some experience with people like me.”

I told her that I wasn’t in the habit of putting people in the hospital unless they are a danger to themselves or to others. Julia visibly relaxed. (...)

***

Still, if you assume that the best historian of the spiritual states of oppressions and possessions was an exorcist or a theologian, or even a traditional Christian believer, you would be wrong. The classic work of states of oppression and possession throughout world history was written almost a hundred years ago by Traugott K. Oesterreich, a professor from the German town of Tübingen. An agnostic German polymath, Oesterreich became an early believer in parapsychology, a field that also secretly fascinated Freud. The wealth of detail in the voluminous 1966 translation of his work from 1921, Possession: Demoniacal and Other, Among Primitive Races, in Antiquity, the Middle Ages, and Modern Times, is unmatched. (Author William Peter Blatty read it before writing The Exorcist, deriving a lot of his background material for his fictitious account.)

Like Freud, who wrote in 1923 a famous short monograph on the subject of possession, which he called a “demonological neurosis,” and like many other secular intellectuals of that period, Oesterreich originally considered parapsychological states as emotional disturbances or illnesses, interpreting such conditions as psychiatric in nature. He categorized the trances and aggressive behaviors of possessions as resulting from dissociative states related to inner hostility projected outward as a personification of evil, or as compulsions. Like Freud, he originally interpreted possession cases diagnostically as hysteria, severe neurosis, and psychosis. However, Oesterreich never could explain how such mentally disordered individuals could levitate, possess arcane knowledge, speak or understand foreign languages, or experience many of the other features he cited in the myriad historical cases. Mystified by such observations, he changed his mind. He came to feel the mysterious phenomena to be so inexplicable that he concluded that states of possession must go beyond the natural and material world to reflect “spiritist” (his word) or paranormal realities.

And so, in his magnum opus, Oesterreich concedes that his earlier, more exclusive focus on mental pathology was mistaken and noted that “researchers of scientific standing consider such explanations as unsatisfactory . . . and regard the ‘spiritistic’ hypothesis as valid.” Oesterreich included thousands of accounts of and references to such cases, showing over and over how both anthropologists and historical chroniclers have found ample evidence that these odd states have always existed. Not surprisingly, Oesterreich again and again gives historical citations of many of the phenomena described in this book. For instance, he chronicles voluntary and involuntary possessions and how pagan rituals over the ages typically solicited spirits, thought to be benign, as spirit guides and helpers. But these episodes often turned out badly. Sometimes—as we witnessed in the case of Speedy, the MS-13 member who was expected to solicit hidden knowledge from the spirit world to achieve the group’s evil purposes—these “voluntary” requests backfire and supplicants conclude they were the true victims.

Oesterreich cites hundreds of examples of involuntary possessions across cultures that are remarkably similar to many of the cases for which I have consulted. These include cases involving animist beliefs in Africa, where spirit forces possessed humans, who were then reported to speak various unknown languages or reveal pieces of hidden knowledge. He describes historical Hindu possessions, presumed to occur by the activity of gods and “lesser powers,” but that this thoroughly agnostic scholar remarks bring us “perilously close to belief in demons.” He also gives examples from multiple pagan and non-Western sources of recent history, as well as reports of possession cases that are broadly similar to cases presented in the Christian and Jewish sources he cites, too. He includes accounts within texts from all of the world’s religions.

Some poorly informed modern critics of the reality of states of possession and oppression claim that only credulous members of traditional religious subcultures experience such states. Nothing could be further from the truth, as historical and contemporary accounts regularly attest. In my experience, people with no real religious background who turn to occult practices are among the most frequently attacked by spirits. And because they lack solid spiritual foundations, or “spiritual armor,” they are more mystified about what is happening to them, which makes their liberation from demonic oppressors that much more difficult to achieve. In their desire to have paranormal experiences, they are among those most naïve about a spirit world.

Regardless of time or place, throughout history and diverse secular as well as religious cultures people continue to document the existence of a rich and active spirit world and the very real predatory activity of evil spirits and demons. I witness this continuous and complex diversity of demonic or spirit-related expressions today in people who seek my advice from all over the world.

About the Author

RICHARD E. GALLAGHER, MD, a board-certified psychiatrist, is Professor of Clinical Psychiatry at New York Medical College and a faculty member of the Psychoanalytic Institute of Columbia University. He is a Phi Beta Kappa, magna cum laude graduate of Princeton University and winner of the Stinnecke Class Prize, a scholarship award in classical Latin and Greek. He trained as resident in psychiatry at the Yale University School of Medicine and is in private practice in Valhalla, New York.

Dr. Gallagher is the longest-standing American member of the International Association of Exorcists since its founding in the early 1990s. For a number of years, he served as scientific adviser on its governing council as the only layman and sole psychiatrist. He has also helped train major groups of exorcists in the United States in distinguishing possession cases and other diabolic attacks from medical and psychiatric pathology.

Over the past twenty-five years Dr. Gallagher has consulted for hundreds of ministers, priests, and rabbis (and clergy of other faiths, too) as well as numerous mental health professionals on the subject area of this book. He has published and lectures widely on the topic of diabolic possession from the medical perspective and the critical need to differentiate such very rare cases from the much more common instances of people with mental or medical illness.

None of the above organizations or any other academic or religious institution bears any responsibility for the views expressed or tales recounted in this book. Then again, they haven’t witnessed what he has as a doctor who has seen more such cases than any other physician, and perhaps any other person, in the world.

Discover great authors, exclusive offers, and more at hc.com.

Wednesday, February 28, 2024

What’s at stake

 

The reductionistic, allopathic model of medicine is deeply flawed and based on outdated assumptions. And it has turned modern health care into an establishment that all too often endangers the very patients it’s supposed to help.

Medicine should be devoted to caring for people. It should be about a human-to-human connection in the process of healing. While some noble practitioners embody these ideals, the overall system has become a “medical-industrial complex”: an intricate web of financial interests involving pharmaceutical companies, doctors, nurses, medical device/equipment suppliers, diagnostics companies, hospitals, medical schools, insurance companies, media companies, politicians, technology companies, scientific journals, and others.1

Those who pull the strings of this web have managed to control society’s belief systems about health and disease; and about germs, infections, contagion, and vaccines. Modern medicine’s core beliefs are often blindly accepted—and even defended—when there is great reason to challenge them. And yet they persist.

The medical-industrial complex not only steers society’s belief systems but also the practice of medicine itself. Making money  often takes precedence over healing, while a deeper spiritual orientation is lacking.

From a financial perspective, healing a person means losing a customer. Having people stay on long-term pharmaceutical medications is a much better outcome than identifying and solving the underlying problem that’s causing symptoms. Thus, for the pharmaceutical industry, it makes sense to fund research on drugs and vaccines rather than uncovering how to empower people to stay healthy on their own. Certainly, the medical system has saved people from life-threatening conditions, but at the same time, it hasn’t focused as much on how it could have prevented those people from becoming deathly ill in the first place. Overall, a chronically sick society is a better economic outcome for the medical-industrial complex than a healthy society is. This dangerous mentality can persist if participants within “the system” act from a physicalist perspective that has lost sight of the greater “cosmic system” that connects us all. As such, a consciousness shift is essential.

In the absence of this shift, hospitals have become factory-like; and doctors and nurses, often unknowingly, have transformed into cogs in a wheel. Perhaps they enter the system with good intentions and genuinely want to help people. But indoctrination takes hold quickly, and the prospect of going against the grain is harrowing and outright intimidating. Speaking out carries great risk, so it’s easier to just play it safe, not make a fuss, and unquestioningly follow the protocols. Patients who have experienced this dynamic can attest without hesitation: compassion in the mainstream medical system is sometimes conspicuously absent. In part, this might be due to a flawed philosophical outlook, but it’s also a symptom of an unhealthy society. Given how many sick people are flooding the system, it’s often a practical challenge for health-care providers to treat each patient with appropriate care and attention.

With these dynamics at play, many health-care providers do not focus on providing holistic solutions. Stale and simplistic narratives about why people get sick have transformed into invincible dogmas such that the only solution to illness is a magical pharmaceutical  bullet. In other words, an external source must be the savior, and the patient is a mere victim.

Uncovering the true determinants of health and disease has become secondary, whereas it should be the primary objective in a system truly focused on well-being. That’s where health-care providers, in theory, should be directing their attention. In essence, allopathy often focuses on what’s under the microscope, rather than what’s within the “macroscope.”2

New Zealand surgeon-turned-naturopath Ulrich Williams saw this clearly back in 1937. He suggested basic principles that can redirect our current paradigm—and the thinking that underlies it—into something much better:

The orthodox healing system has failed for reasons that easily can be defined….We have failed because from our too narrow and materialistic outlook we have conceived of disease as something attacking us from without, due to germs; whereas disease whether of body, mind, soul, or estate, is mostly a gradual degenerative process going on within, due to failure to comply with the requirements of well-being. We fail because in the zones of physical limit we look outside ourselves for cause and cure of troubles arising within. We have failed because the whole complicated system of orthodox modern diagnosis and treatment is based upon a misconception that mistakes the symptom for the disease; and tinkering with effects while the cause is ignored and allowed to continue always has been and will be followed by deplorable consequences.3Furthermore, moving toward a better system of medicine might require looking back at ancient methods from a variety of cultures all over the world. Dr. Shamini Jain mentions Indian Ayurvedic, classical Chinese, and Tibetan teachings in particular, summarizing their approach and the implications thereof:

The body has an innate ability to heal itself, and this process can be encouraged by fostering proper flow of  life force energy, which serves as a conduit between consciousness and physicality.

These Eastern teachings provide an underlying model to help us better understand and explore communications between the spirit, the body, and our environment. Disease is considered disharmony that might exist within one’s self or between one’s self and his or her surrounding environment. Thus, healing is not about curing yourself from something that is “not you” but understanding the patterns that might be causing you disharmony and therefore illness. The vital life force is a bridge that allows the healer—ultimately you—to better understand the nature of that disharmony and bring harmony back to your system.4

While we may not yet know exactly what a new paradigm of medicine will look like, at least we know what it won’t look like.5 Armed with a general compass for rethinking heath care, we have an opportunity to create a brighter future—both on an individual and collective level.

From the perspective of an individual, if we want to be healthy, it’s simply not wise to rely exclusively on the mainstream allopathic system and its health-care providers (perhaps outside of emergency situations). Finding real health solutions requires reconsidering the basic nature of disease.

In their book What Really Makes You Ill?, Dawn Lester and David Parker lay out what they consider to be the four determinants of illness:61. Nutrition

2. Toxic exposures

3. Electromagnetic radiation

4. Stress

 Notice that they don’t focus on germs. Thus, from this perspective, “symptoms” reflect the body’s attempt to heal or detoxify from an underlying ailment in one of those categories. Modern labels of discrete diseases are in many ways arbitrary distinctions for varying symptoms. Those labels often tell us nothing about the real causes of those symptoms.

An even broader way to think about it, in my view, is that ill health comes from:

1. Physical injury and/or

2. Psychospiritual injury

The first category can be a physical ailment (from, say, sports), but it also can relate to other aspects of physicality such as poor diet, environmental toxicity, electromagnetic toxicity, and so on. The second category relates to one’s mental state, unresolved trauma, belief systems, emotions, “spiritual” connection, a sense of purpose in life, and even multidimensional matters that we don’t fully understand.

What, then, should we do to stay healthy? Holistic practitioners might vary in their specific recommendations—such as detoxification protocols, dietary recommendations, herb and/or supplement recommendations, electromagnetic-protection solutions, body-alignment and somatic modalities, spiritual-practice suggestions, and so forth. But there seem to be some basic lifestyle recommendations, that they suggest across the board, which anyone can implement, such as eating nutritious and clean food; drinking clean water; avoiding toxins; sleeping well; exercising; getting sunlight and fresh air; avoiding excessive electromagnetic radiation; minimizing toxic forms of light (such as blue light from electronic screens); spending time in nature; having positive relationships; working on processing and clearing trauma; practicing forgiveness; feeling emotions rather than suppressing them; setting appropriate boundaries in relationships; laughing; following passions and joy; experiencing gratitude; being authentic; engaging in centering practices like meditation or breathing exercises; feeling a strong spiritual connection; discovering and following one’s “soul  purpose”; giving, receiving, and embodying love; and so on.7 Maintaining good health might be much simpler than we’ve been led to believe by a pharmaceutical-dominated paradigm. These basic practices, which are empowering and largely inexpensive, enable independence from the overarching societal power structure. Personal sovereignty isn’t possible without taking the reins over one’s own health.

On a collective level, this is an essential point. We saw during the COVID-19 era that a “crisis” can be used as a pretext for taking citizens’ rights away. What better way to control the global population than to bring about massive amounts of health-related fear—even for imaginary causes—wherein the only solution is the remedy provided by the authorities. The weaponization of fear around climate change has been taking on a similar quality.8

In fact, both are central pieces of the World Economic Forum’s “Great Reset”—which was formally announced in June 2020 by Klaus Schwab and then–Prince Charles, and was described, in detail, in Schwab and Thierry Malleret’s July 2020 book COVID-19: The Great Reset. As discussed in my book An End to the Upside Down Reset (2023), COVID-19 presented an opportunity to reset all aspects of society in a manner that a small number of people consider to be ideal. Perhaps the most significant point about the Great Reset is that it’s not an agenda that emphasizes liberty or human flourishing; rather, it’s much more focused on limiting freedom under the guise of “compassion.” Thus, we are currently living through an attempted reshaping of society, and medicine is one of the key levers that’s being used to usher it in.

As I’ve often contended, these matters extend beyond physical concerns; they are part of what appears to be a “spiritual war.” One might wonder if the corrupt dynamics of the medical-industrial complex trace their roots to nonphysical forces of evil—the ultimate “string-pullers,” invisible to our ordinary perceptual abilities. Such forces are drawn to power, and they seem to thrive off of the suffering of others; perhaps they even feed off of negative energy. Thus, the notions of eugenics and depopulation—in other words, culling the population like cattle—doesn’t seem like a stretch. A  medical system that’s ostensibly supposed to save people, but in fact ends up harming them, is the perfect instrument for such an objective. And furthermore, a weakened and unhealthy populace is much easier to control than a strong and healthy one.

Even transhumanism—merging humans with artificial intelligence and altering our natural form—is often being promoted. The spiritual impact of such activities on the bodily vessel might be more hazardous than scientists currently acknowledge.

On a related note, in 1917 the mystic Rudolf Steiner foresaw the following:

The time will come—and it may not be far off—when…people will say: It is pathological for people to even think in terms of spirit and soul. “Sound” people will speak of nothing but the body. It will be considered a sign of illness for anyone to arrive at the idea of any such thing as a spirit or a soul….The soul will be made nonexistent with the aid of a drug. Taking a “sound point of view,” people will invent a vaccine to influence the organism as early as possible, preferably as soon as it is born, so that this human body never even gets the idea that there is a soul and a spirit….

I have told you that the spirits of darkness are going to inspire their human hosts, in whom they will be dwelling, to find a vaccine that will drive all inclination towards spirituality out of people’s souls when they are very young.9 [emphasis added]

The dystopian books Brave New World and 1984 no longer seem like fictional possibilities for our future—and from a metaphysical perspective, such enslavement could have even greater consequences than we know.

Dr. Anthony Fauci has openly discussed a “next pandemic.”10 Future global health scares seem inevitable, and COVID-19 showed us that the world can be shut down in an instant if the authority figures choose to do so. People’s livelihoods can be determined on  the basis of whether they take an experimental injection or not. A “positive” result on an unreliable test can lead to a mandatory quarantine sentence. Quarantine camps were even built as a result of COVID-19.11

Therefore, with such high stakes, discernment is essential; our ability to identify “wolves in sheep’s clothing” needs to be sharp. A big piece of that is seeing through the dangers and falsities of the allopathic system, upon which many control mechanisms in society are based. That entails breaking out of the hypnotic spell of conditioned belief systems and engaging in independent, critical thinking rather than parroting the opinions of “experts.” From a higher perspective, this process could be viewed as “evolutionary”: in order for us to transcend the darkness of our world, we must be able to accurately perceive deception and navigate accordingly. We must learn to see through “false light.” Therefore, the evil forces within the spiritual war either stimulate our growth and make us stronger (if we are able to catch on); or, if we don’t, they’ll consume us.

During his near-death experiences decades ago, Dannion Brinkley, the author of Saved by the Light (1994), was shown hints about our society’s future. As he summarizes the message in a 2023 interview: “I’ve been saying this for forty-eight years: the battle of humanity will be fought in health care.”12 [emphasis added]

The question then arises: How should we approach this battle? Thomas Friese provides sound guidance in his 2013 preface to Ernst Jünger’s The Forest Passage (1951). May these words echo in our consciousness as we navigate the treacherous waters ahead:

The forces seeking to exploit man today are but the latest incarnations of forces that have threatened individual freedom throughout history….

While [an individual’s journey to freedom] may bring collateral benefits for society, in particular for other individuals, it does not aim primarily at world-improvement: the collective, as a whole, is essentially beyond redemption, a priori a lost cause. It is only individuals,…rebels  within society, that can hope, as exceptions, to escape the coercion, to “save their own souls.” The…rebel[s] [battle] the Leviathan not in the hopes of defeating it—for it eventually collapses under its own enormous weight—though [they] may promote this inevitable demise by inflicting strategic damage on it, and [they] can already help define and introduce the seeds of new freedoms for a post-Leviathan world. Rather, the… rebel[s] [have] two other immediate motivations in the here and now: first, to save [themselves]…and second, and not unrelated, to obey [their] conscience…which feels natural concern for its fellow human beings.13

An End to UpsideDown Medicine

Contagion, Viruses, and Vaccines—and Why Consciousness Is Needed for a New Paradigm of Health

Mark Gober

Psychological Hurdles


In addition to headwinds posed by the medical establishment, the general public’s psychology serves as a barrier to a new medical paradigm. More specifically, the way people think often anchors them toward the prevailing and engrained belief systems.

So, before embarking on a journey to poke holes in the allopathic model, it’s first important to appropriately orient one’s mindset. This exercise aims to reduce the cognitive dissonance—emotional discomfort—that might accompany forthcoming discussions in this book.

1. Anomalies matter. An anomaly is something that doesn’t fit a worldview. It is an exception to the rule.36 Encountering even a single anomaly is problematic because it implies that the “rule” is incorrect, and a new one is needed. For instance, in 1900, one of the leading authorities in science, Lord Kelvin, declared that physics had largely figured things out, but there were two pesky “clouds”—unsolved mysteries—that remained. Upon further study, those clouds emerged into what are now known as relativity theory and quantum mechanics. Two anomalies resulted in drastic changes in scientific thinking.372. Correlation does not imply causation. If someone observes firefighters at the scene of a fire, there are multiple possible explanations. Without having any background knowledge, one might assume that the firefighters caused the fire. Alternatively, one might believe that the fire has a mystical ability to manifest humans out of thin air, so the firefighters are a by-product of the fire itself.38 Of course, these explanations miss the correct reason, which is that firefighters appeared on the scene in response to the fire. The point here is that when two things are related to one another, or if they appear at the same place and at the same time, the relationship between those things needs to be explored carefully. That is, the correlation of  those things doesn’t automatically imply that one caused the other. All possibilities need to be considered in order to accurately explain the relationship.

This point is critical in the exercise of uncovering the causes of illness. For instance, if people get sick in the same place around the same time, one can’t automatically conclude that a contagious virus or bacteria caused it. Maybe the sick people were exposed to a common environmental toxin; or consumed food or water that contained toxins; or were exposed to a similar form of radiation or a dangerous electromagnetic field; or were affected by a change in seasons, humidity, temperature, or barometric pressure; or they were under similar emotional distress; or they were exposed to some other factor, or factors, that could collectively contribute to illness. Critical thinking and open-mindedness are thus essential in the process of exploring causation.

3. Presuppositions often go unacknowledged. A presupposition is an assumption that underlies a belief system. If presuppositions aren’t examined, people end up believing things without knowing why they believe those things—other than “someone told me this was true.” Consider the six-feet-social-distancing requirement that dominated policy around the world during the COVID-19 era. In 2021, former FDA commissioner Scott Gottlieb revealed to CBS that the rule was “arbitrary.”39 Yet, how many people religiously followed the rule, trusting that it would save lives because people on television said so? The belief that “it must be true because an expert said it” is a logical fallacy known as “appeal to authority.” Cultlike superstitions are the result.

4. Science is an approach, not a religion. These days, the term science has come to refer to “anything that a mainstream scientist or doctor says.” Anthony Fauci, MD, a leading public medical figure in the United States, even declared in 2021 that attacks on him are “attacks on  science.”40 In reality, the scientific method is supposed to be an approach that welcomes endless challenges, whereas religious dogma is not allowed to be questioned. The institution of “science,” ironically, has become its own religion.

5. Consensus does not always mean “truth.” There is often a belief that if the majority of authority figures believe something, then it must be true—as if it’s not possible that so many prominent people could be wrong. Author Michael Crichton explained why this is such a problematic approach:

I regard consensus science as an extremely pernicious development that ought to be stopped cold in its tracks. Historically, the claim of consensus has been the first refuge of scoundrels; it is a way to avoid debate by claiming that the matter is already settled. Whenever you hear the consensus of scientists agrees on something or other, reach for your wallet, because you’re being had….Let’s be clear: the work of science has nothing whatever to do with consensus. Consensus is the business of politics. Science, on the contrary, requires only one investigator who happens to be right, which means that he or she has results that are verifiable by reference to the real world. In science, consensus is irrelevant. What is relevant is reproducible results. The greatest scientists in history are great precisely because they broke with the consensus. There is no such thing as consensus science. If it’s consensus, it isn’t science. If it’s science, it isn’t consensus. Period.41What’s to Come in This Book

With this contextual backdrop, I will move into an examination of flawed allopathic assumptions. Although I will discuss potential alternatives, they are presented in a hypothetical manner, and they need to be studied further.

 Said another way, the ideas I discuss in this book should not be taken as definitive proof of anything. But, taken together, the pieces of evidence suggest that the allopathic approach is misguided—not just a little bit misguided, but severely misguided. That means we need to be looking for new models if we want to achieve better health. Therefore, it’s necessary to consider ideas that are far outside of conventional thinking. And given how unhealthy modern society is, such a radical exercise is warranted.

Thus, the examination of the medical system in this book aspires to “start from scratch”—as if we know nothing about medicine and are exploring health and disease for the very first time. That entails asking the question: “How is it that we know the things we think we know? And how certain are we of those things?”

Keeping that approach in mind, in part I of this book I explore why allopathic assumptions need to be challenged. The first exploration, in chapter 1, takes a fresh look at HIV/AIDS. This serves as a template for later discussions about other diseases. Viruses—and how they are identified and “isolated”—are explored in chapter 2. The discussion walks through potential flaws built into the field of virology itself. Chapter 3 then sets the stage for a reevaluation of all allegedly infectious diseases by examining the logic needed to establish a cause of disease. That framework provides a backdrop with which to examine a variety of conditions commonly believed to be infectious, including polio, SARS, Spanish flu, avian flu, smallpox, chicken pox, hepatitis, rabies, and the Black Death (chapter 4). In the process of reviewing these illnesses, many questions about vaccines arise, which leads to a deeper analysis of their safety in chapter 5.

An End to UpsideDown Medicine

Contagion, Viruses, and Vaccines—and Why Consciousness Is Needed for a New Paradigm of Health

Mark Gober

In part II, I explore consciousness and why it’s a necessary component of a comprehensive medical model. In chapter 6, I dive into the nature of reality—and the human body’s place in it—which presents a fundamental challenge to allopathic beliefs. The resulting framework makes way for a discussion about consciousness, health, and disease in chapter 7. The topics covered are so far outside of traditional thinking that they make modern medicine seem highly primitive.

I conclude this book with a discussion of what’s at stake for all of us, in terms of our individual and collective freedom. The implications are immense.

Dr. Sheldrake and Wikipedia "credibility"

 Why are so many articles on these phenomena (such as Wikipedia articles) so negative?

A number of organizations are openly hostile to claims of the paranormal. One has to wonder if their sentiments have played a role on Wikipedia and elsewhere.

One such organization is the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry (CSI). CSI’s Lee Nisbet, who holds a PhD in philosophy, said of paranormal phenomena: “We feel it is the duty of the scientific community to show that these beliefs are utterly screwball.” One of CSI’s former co-chairs of its “Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal” resigned because he felt that “they sought to debunk rather than scientifically examine.”18

Dr. Rupert Sheldrake has been a target of criticism from skeptics and speculates that a group called “Guerilla Skepticism” is contributing to negativity around the paranormal on Wikipedia. As Dr. Sheldrake states in his blog post Wikipedia Under Threat:

Wikipedia is a wonderful invention. But precisely because it’s so trusted and convenient, people with their own agendas keep  trying to take it over. Editing wars are common.…Everyone knows that there are opposing views on politics and religion, and many people recognise a biased account when they see it. But in the realm of science, things are different. Most people have no scientific expertise and believe that science is objective. Their trust is now being abused systematically by a highly motivated group of activists called Guerrilla Skepticism on Wikipedia.

Skepticism is a normal, healthy attitude of doubt. Unfortunately it can also be used as a weapon to attack opponents. In scientific and medical contexts, organized skepticism is a crusade to propagate scientific materialism.…Most materialists believe that the mind is nothing more than the physical activity of the brain, psychic phenomena are illusory, and complementary and alternative medical systems are fraudulent, or at best produce placebo effects. . . . Several advocacy organizations promote this materialist ideology in the media and in educational institutions. The largest and best-funded is the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry (CSI), which publishes The Skeptical Inquirer magazine. The Guerrilla Skeptics have carried the crusading zeal of organized skepticism into the realm of Wikipedia, and use it as a soapbox to propagate their beliefs.

This summer…a commando squad of skeptics captured the Wikipedia page about me. They have occupied and controlled it ever since, rewriting my biography with as much negative bias as possible, to the point of defamation.…The Guerrilla Skeptics are well trained, highly motivated, have an ideological agenda, and operate in teams, contrary to Wikipedia rules. The mastermind behind this organization is Susan Gerbik. She explains how her teams work in a training video. She now has over 90 guerrillas operating in 17 different languages. The teams are coordinated through secret Facebook pages. They check the credentials of new recruits to avoid infiltration. Their aim is to control information, and Ms. Gerbik glories in the power that she and her warriors wield. They have already seized control of many Wikipedia pages, deleted entries on subjects they disapprove of, and boosted the biographies of atheists.

 As the Guerrilla Skeptics have demonstrated, Wikipedia can easily be subverted by determined groups of activists, despite its well-intentioned policies and mediation procedures. Perhaps one solution would be for experienced editors to visit the talk pages of sites where editing wars are taking place, rather like UN Peacekeeping Forces, and try to re-establish a neutral point of view. But this would not help in cases where there are no editors to oppose the Guerrilla Skeptics, or where they have been silenced.

If nothing is done, Wikipedia will lose its credibility, and its financial backers will withdraw their support. I hope the noble aims of Wikipedia will prevail.19

If what Dr. Sheldrake describes is truly happening, then we might (in part) understand why the reality of the “paranormal” has struggled to gain momentum. The casual researcher doesn’t have time to dig into the details. If you Google a topic and the first thing that comes up is a Wikipedia article saying it’s fraudulent, you might stop your search then and there.


An End to Upside Down Thinking

Dispelling the Myth That the Brain Produces Consciousness, and the Implications for Everyday Life

Mark Gober